School Committee
Regular MeetingSalem, MA · October 6, 2025
Minutes
Minutes of the Regular Session
of the Salem School Committee
Monday, October 6, 2025
Rm. 227, 29 Highland Ave.
Hybrid Meeting
Members Present: Mayor Pangallo, Vice Chair Cruz, AJ Hoffman, Beth Anne
Cornell, Mary Manning and Veronica Miranda
Others in Attendance: Superintendent Stephen Zrike, Deputy Superintendent Carbone
and Assistant Superintendent Pauley
Members Absent: Amanda Campbell
Call of Meeting to Order
Mayor Pangallo called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm and informed the public that the docket
contains the public participation procedure and how to access Spanish interpretation.
Approval of Agenda
Member Miranda made a motion to approve the agenda. Member Cornell seconded. A roll call
vote was taken.
Member Campbell ABSENT
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman voted YES
Member Manning ABSENT
Member Miranda voted YES
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Public Comment
There was no public comment.
Approval of Consent Agenda
1. Approval of Minutes of Regular School Committee Meeting held on September 24, 2025
2. Approval of Field Trip to Hershey and Philadelphia, PA for Salem High School Music
students on May 15-18, 2026
3. Approval of Field Trip to Cape Cod Fairgrounds for Salem High School Varsity Boys
Cross Country Team on October 12-13, 2025
4. Approval of FY26 Warrants:
1. 09/25/2025 - $732,520.30
Page 1
Member Cornell made a motion to approve the consent agenda. Member Miranda seconded. A
roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell ABSENT
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman voted YES
Member Manning ABSENT
Member Miranda voted YES
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Student Representative Report
Student Representative Sula mentioned some of the SAT and Preliminary SAT dates at the Salem
High School. Student Representative Sula informed the School Committee that she joined the
State Student Advisory Council to the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE).
Student Representative Sula said that the Advisory Council heard about projects for seniors,
assessments and tests that might be implemented, portfolios for work, competency
determinations in high schools as well as classes, internships and activities that neighboring
school districts are conducting.
Superintendent’s Report
Superintendent Zrike spoke about the MCAS achievement and accountability which was divided
into two parts. The first part for Grades 3-8 was presented at the meeting and the second part
for high school grades will be presented at the next meeting.
1. Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) Update
Superintendent Zrike presented the update. In response to Member Miranda,
Superintendent Zrike said dual language schools are not compared to other dual
language schools but rather, they are compared to all other schools.
Deputy Superintendent Carbone and Executive Director of Academics, Sonia Lowe,
continued the presentation. Member Cornell asked to compare the district’s
disproportionality with other gateway cities.
In response to Member Cornell, Deputy Superintendent Carbone said that the schools
are using the same materials except for some schools such as the innovation schools.
Deputy Superintendent Carbone continued that there are probably differences as to the
degree in which these materials are used in different classrooms. In response to Vice
Chair Cruz, Superintendent Zrike said that the district is looking to learn from other
schools who have the same demographics and good results.
In response to Member Hoffman, Deputy Superintendent Carbone said civics is being
taught in schools from elementary to middle school. In response to Member Miranda,
Deputy Superintendent Carbone said that all MCAS assessments are computer based.
Page 2
Superintendent Zrike announced that there are two consultants working on the
elementary school reconfiguration to gather data from stakeholders. They will present
their findings to the School Committee in November. Superintendent Zrike also said that
this is the last year of the strategic plan as it ends in 2026. There are funds to work on a
new strategic plan with the same consultant who helped with the current plan. There
are also stipends available for those who engage in this effort with the goal of delivering
an updated strategic plan by the end of this school year for the start of the 2026-2027
school year. Superintendent Zrike added that a safety webinar was scheduled for the
community on the following day in collaboration with the Salem Police Department.
Another matter highlighted by Superintendent Zrike is that the district is in preliminary
discussions with Salem State College about potentially relocating the New Liberty
Innovation School to the Salem State campus. Mayor Pangallo added that it would be a
great opportunity for the students. Member Cornell suggested that the November
School Committee meeting should be advertised so that the community is aware.
Member Manning joined the meeting at 7:40 pm.
2. Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) Update
Superintendent Zrike provided the update. Superintendent Zrike added that the design
for the new high school building is on display at the schools and Central Office.
In response to Member Hoffman, Mayor Pangallo said that the High School Building
Committee is currently discussing the types of fields, turf, grass, lights, scoreboard,
bleacher storage as well as bathroom access.
3. Finance and Operations Report
Assistant Superintendent Pauley presented an update on operations.
1. Budget Transfer Request
Assistant Superintendent Pauley explained that the transfer is from a personnel
line to a non-personnel line for $6,000.
Superintendent Zrike announced that Operations Hero, the facilities application,
is going to be made available for high school students through the ClassLink site
so that they can report on anything that might need to be fixed. Assistant
Superintendent Pauley added that this initiative will be rolled out in October
once the guidance for the high school students is finalized.
Subcommittee Reports
1. Finance Subcommittee
No report at this time.
Page 3
2. Personnel Subcommittee
No report at this time.
3. Building and Grounds Subcommittee
No report at this time.
4. Curriculum Subcommittee
No report at this time.
5. Policy Subcommittee
Member Cornell reminded everyone that the Massachusetts Association of School
Committees (MASC) is working with the subcommittee to review the policy manual. The
liaison from MASC provided the subcommittee with the first update at the most recent
meeting. MASC is working on reconfiguring the numbering system as well as suggestions
to adopt Massachusetts General Law language. Member Cornell added that the MASC
liaison will be at a future School Committee meeting to explain a new approach to
reviewing and updating policies because it will not happen one policy at a time but
rather in sections unless there are policies which are of particular concern or interest to
the School Committee or the public.
Motions and Resolutions
1. Budget Transfer Request
Member Cornell made a motion to approve the budget transfer request. Member
Miranda seconded. A roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell ABSENT
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman voted YES
Member Manning voted YES
Member Miranda voted YES
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 6 votes in favor and 1 absent.
Announcements
Mayor Pangallo said that the City Council had approved the bond order of $3.6 million for the
Bates Elementary School’s roof repair project and it now awaits a second vote which is
scheduled to take place later in the week. This project is in the accelerated repair program with
the MSBA. Mayor Pangallo also thanked everyone who participated in the recent haunted
happenings parade. Member Cornell said that the air conditioning is always on in the Bertram
locker room and bathrooms.
Adjournment
Page 4
Member Miranda made a motion to adjourn at 8:09 pm. Member Cornell seconded. A roll call
vote was taken. A roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell ABSENT
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman voted YES
Member Manning voted YES
Member Miranda voted YES
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 6 votes in favor and 1 absent.
Respectfully submitted by,
Shirley Dorai
Executive Assistant to the School Committee & Superintendent
Page 5
Agenda
Salem Public Schools
School Committee
Amanda Campbell AJ Hoffman
Beth Anne Cornell Mary A. Manning
Manny Cruz, Vice Chair Veronica Miranda
Mayor Dominick Pangallo, Chair
“Know Your Rights Under the Open Meeting Law, M.G.L. c.30A § 18-25 and
City Ordinance Sections 2-2028 through 2-2033”
REVISED
REGULAR SCHOOL COMMITTEE MEETING
Notice is hereby given that the Salem School Committee will hold a Regular School
Committee meeting on October 6, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. This meeting will take place in
person at 29 Highland Ave., Rm. 227, Salem, MA. You can also join via Zoom using the
link below.
Zoom Link to participate:
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/83664704182?pwd=ws03WOG1hKfuL3dl8VPkrQqLrOVIgA.1
Passcode: 518984
1. Call of Meeting to Order
1. Summary of Public Participation Policy (School Committee Policy #6409).
Read aloud: The Salem School Committee would like to hear from the public on
issues that affect the school district and are within the scope of the Committee’s
responsibilities. Spanish interpretation is available for anyone who needs it. The
members of the School Committee would like to remind the public that Salem
Public School students regularly attend School Committee meetings. We
encourage all meeting participants to model respectful and productive public
discourse for our young learners.
2. Live Spanish Interpretation.
Spanish language interpretation is now provided for all regular School
Committee meetings. To listen to this meeting with Spanish language
interpretation, please see instructions below:
1. Click Interpretation
2. Click Spanish
3. (Optional) To hear the interpreted language only, click Mute Original Audio.
2. Approval of Agenda
29 Highland Ave, Salem, MA 01970 Phone: 978-740-1212 Email: sdorai@salemk12.org
3. Public Comment
If you wish to participate in the public comment portion of the meeting, you may come up to the
podium to speak during this section of the meeting. If you wish to provide a comment via Zoom,
you may do so by entering the Zoom meeting and clicking the raise hand feature. When it is your
turn to speak, a host will announce your name and will unmute your line and allow you to speak.
4. Approval of Consent Agenda
1. Approval of Minutes of Regular School Committee Meeting held on September 24, 2025
2. Approval of Field Trip to Hershey and Philadelphia, PA for Salem High School Music
students on May 15-18, 2026
3. Approval of Field Trip to Cape Cod Fairgrounds for Salem High School Varsity Boys
Cross Country Team on October 12-13, 2025
4. Approval of FY26 Warrants:
1. 09/25/2025 - $732,520.30
5. Student Representative Report
6. Superintendent’s Report
1. Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) Update
2. Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) Update
3. Finance and Operations Report
1. Budget Transfer Requests
7. Subcommittee Reports
1. Finance Subcommittee
2. Personnel Subcommittee
3. Building & Grounds Subcommittee
4. Curriculum Subcommittee
5. Policy Subcommittee
8. Motions and Resolutions
1. Budget Transfer Requests
9. Announcements
10. Adjournment
Respectfully submitted by,
Shirley Dorai
Executive Assistant to the School Committee and Superintendent
“Persons requiring auxiliary aids and services for effective communication such as sign language interpreter, an
assistive listening device, or print material in digital format or a reasonable modification in programs, services,
policies, or activities, may contact the City of Salem ADA Coordinator at (978) 619-5630 as soon as possible and
not less than 2 business days before the meeting, program, or event.”
Page 2
Escuelas Públicas de Salem
Comité Escolar
Amanda Campbell AJ Hoffman
Beth Anne Cornell Mary A. Manning
Manny Cruz, Vicepresidente Veronica Miranda
Alcalde Dominick Pangallo, Preside
“Conozca sus derechos bajo la Ley de Sesiones Públicas, M.G.L. c.30A § 18-25 y
Secciones 2-2028 a 2-2033 de la normativa municipal”
REVISADA
REUNIÓN REGULAR DEL COMITÉ ESCOLAR
Por la presente se notifica que el Comité Escolar de Salem celebrará una Reunión regular del
Comité Escolar el 6 de octubre, 2025 a las 7:00 p.m. Esta reunión tendrá lugar en persona en 29
Highland Ave., Rm. 227, Salem, MA. También puede unirse a través de Zoom utilizando el enlace
de a continuación.
Enlace Zoom para participar:
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/83664704182?pwd=ws03WOG1hKfuL3dl8VPkrQqLrOVIgA.1
Contraseña: 518984
1. Orden del día
1. Resumen de la Política de Participación Pública (Política del Comité Escolar nº 6409).
Lectura en voz alta: Al Comité Escolar de Salem le gustaría escuchar al público sobre
temas que afectan al distrito escolar y que están dentro del ámbito de las
responsabilidades del Comité. Habrá interpretación al español para quien lo necesite. Los
miembros del Comité Escolar desean recordar al público que los estudiantes de las
Escuelas Públicas de Salem asisten regularmente a las reuniones del Comité Escolar.
Animamos a todos los participantes de la reunión a modelar un discurso público
respetuoso y productivo para nuestros jóvenes estudiantes.
2. Interpretación en directo al español.
Ahora se ofrece interpretación en español para todas las reuniones regulares del
Comité Escolar. Para escuchar esta reunión con interpretación al español, por
favor vea las instrucciones a continuación:
1. Haga clic en Interpretation .
2. Haga clic en Spanish
3. (Opcional) Para escuchar sólo el idioma interpretado, haga clic en Mute
Original Audio.
2. Aprobación del orden del día
29 Highland Ave, Salem, MA 01970 Phone: 978-740-1212 Email: sdorai@salemk12.org
3. Comentarios del público
Consulte las instrucciones anteriores para participar en los comentarios públicos.
4. Aprobación del orden del día
1. Aprobación del acta de la reunión regular del Comité Escolar celebrada el 24 de septiembre de 2025
2. Aprobación de la excursión a Hershey y Filadelfia, Pensilvania, para el departamento de música de la
escuela secundaria Salem, estudiantes del 15 al 18 de mayo de 2026
3. Aprobación de la excursión al recinto ferial de Cape Cod para el equipo de campo a través masculino
de la escuela secundaria Salem, del 12 al 13 de octubre de 2025
4. Aprobación de las órdenes de pago del año fiscal 2026:
1. 25-sep-2025 - 732 520,30 $
5. Informe del representante estudiantil
6. Informe del Superintendente
1. Actualización del Sistema de Evaluación Integral de Massachusetts (MCAS)
2. Actualización de la Autoridad de Edificios Escolares de Massachusetts (MSBA)
3. Informe financiero y operativo
1. Solicitudes de transferencia presupuestaria
7. Informes de los subcomités
1. Subcomité de Finanzas
2. Subcomité de Personal
3. Subcomité de Edificios y Terrenos
4. Subcomité de Planes de Estudios
5. Subcomité de Política
8. Mociones y resoluciones
1. Solicitudes de transferencia presupuestaria
9. Anuncios
10. Clausura
Respetuosamente presentado por,
Shirley Dorai
Asistente Ejecutiva del Comité Escolar y del Superintendente
“Las personas que necesiten ayudas y servicios auxiliares para una comunicación eficaz, como un intérprete de lenguaje de
señas, un dispositivo de ayuda auditiva o material impreso en formato digital, o una modificación razonable en los
programas, servicios, políticas o actividades, pueden ponerse en contacto con el Coordinador de la ADA de la Ciudad de
Salem en el (978) 619-5630 lo antes posible y no menos de 2 días hábiles antes de la reunión, programa o evento..”
Minutes of the Regular Session
of the Salem School Committee
Wednesday, September 24, 2025
Rm. 227, 29 Highland Ave.
Hybrid Meeting
Members Present: Mayor Pangallo, Vice Chair Cruz, Amanda Campbell, Beth Anne
Cornell, and Mary Manning
Others in Attendance: Superintendent Stephen Zrike, Deputy Superintendent Carbone
and Assistant Superintendent Pauley
Members Absent: AJ Hoffman and Veronica Miranda
Call of Meeting to Order
T
Mayor Pangallo called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm and informed the public that the docket
contains the public participation procedure and how to access Spanish interpretation.
Approval of Agenda
AF
Vice Chair Cruz made a motion to approve the agenda. Member Cornell seconded. A roll call
vote was taken.
Member Campbell voted YES
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman ABSENT
Member Manning voted YES
R
Member Miranda ABSENT
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Public Comment
D
There was no public comment.
Approval of Consent Agenda
1.
2.
3.
4.
Approval of Minutes of Regular School Committee Meeting held on August 18, 2025
Approval of Minutes of Regular School Committee Meeting held on September 8, 2025
Approval of Field Trip to Cardigan Mountain and Lodge, Alexandria, New Hampshire
for New Liberty Innovation School students on October 21-22, 2025
Approval of FY25 Warrants:
1. 08/20/2025 - $5,716.28
2. 08/27/2025 - $2,229.74
3. 09/03/3035 - $13,509.38
4. 09/17/2025 - $8,000.00
Page 1
Approval of FY26 Warrants:
1. 08/21/2025 - $395,708.35
2. 08/28/2025 - $776,878.96
3. 09/04/2025 - $1,041,650.39
4. 09/11/1015 - $576,209.07
5. 09/18/2025 - $588,899.74
Vice Chair Cruz made a motion to approve the consent agenda. Member Cornell seconded. A
roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell voted YES
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman ABSENT
Member Manning voted YES
Member Miranda ABSENT
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Student Representative Report
T
AF
Student Representative Sula was unable to be in attendance. Superintendent Zrike said that the
Student Advisory Group had a meeting recently where 20 students attended. The students
wanted to find a way to support newcomer students in Year 2 for Salem High School and New
Liberty Innovation School. The students also wanted more gluten free options in the cafeteria,
clarification regarding bathroom access procedures, and raised the matter of foul odors in the
high school. Two of the students expressed interest in being in the State Student Advisory
Council to the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE). Superintendent Zrike sent
the names of the students and is waiting to hear from BESE. Superintendent Zrike added that he
was going to work with the students to enhance their leadership skills.
R
Vice Chair Cruz highlighted the need for the Student Advisory Group to engage with the School
Committee directly. Vice Chair Cruz and Member Campbell had done training with the Student
Advisory Group in the past. Superintendent Zrike said that scheduling is a challenge and that a
virtual meeting might be better.
D
Superintendent’s Report
Superintendent Zrike said that the current enrollment numbers is about 80-90 students more
than last year at the same time. However, there are fewer newcomers to the district.
Superintendent Zrike added that the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS)
test results embargo will be lifted on the following Monday. A letter will be sent to the
community regarding the district performance and a presentation to the School Committee will
take place on October 6th. Superintendent Zrike added that families will also receive a letter
regarding the reconfiguration process at the elementary school level. There would be a
presentation to the School Committee for consideration in November regarding this matter.
1. College and Career Counseling Update
Page 2
Salem High School (SHS) Principal Burns and Director of College and Career Counseling,
Meghan Sousa provided a presentation.
Member Cornell said that there has been a lot of measurable progress and ensuring the
students understand the process. Vice Chair Cruz said that some districts are having
conversations about using My Career and Academic Plan (MyCAP) at the middle school
level. Principal Burns and Ms. Sousa said that there have been discussions with the
Collins Middle School about incorporating MYCAP lessons into crew and advisory
periods. The 8th graders have access to Naviance (college and career readiness software
platform).
In response to Vice Chair Cruz, Ms. Sousa said Naviance has been expanded to the
alumni tracker which allows more data gathering to provide alumni support as they are
move to college. Ms. Sousa added that surveys are also used to gather data. Member
T
Cornell spoke about the importance of having age appropriate conversations with
younger learners about college. Member Cornell asked for an update in the near future
about how this is being implemented into the curriculum for younger students. Member
Cornell mentioned that middle school students should be prepared to do more
homework so that they are prepared for the amount of work required in high school.
AF
Principal Burns mentioned that more academic conversations are happening at the 9th
grade level especially around Advanced Placement (AP) courses. Superintendent Zrike
commented that students are getting more access to AP courses. Superintendent Zrike
said that the graduation rate alone is not enough, what students do beyond graduation
in order to be competitive is also important. Superintendent Zrike added that the
expanded partnership with OneGoal and others increases tracking and support for
students’ post secondary endeavours. Vice Chair Cruz asked if staff from OneGoal can
speak at the School Committee in the future.
2.
R
Playground Committee Update
Superintendent Zrike introduced Ms. Kathryn Mattern, a Parent Teacher Association
member from the Bentley Academy Innovation School, who also led the Superintendent
Advisory Playground Committee. Ms. Mattern along with Ms. Erika Clifford, Parent
Teacher Committee President at Horace Mann Laboratory School, and Melinda
D Baker-Buzdygon, Parent Teacher Organization Co-President at Carlton Innovation School,
presented the Playground Committee update.
Vice Chair Cruz asked the parents to share their research into playgrounds so that the
conversation and advocacy on this matter can continue. Member Cornell said that for
the past three years, about $1.6 million has been spent on playgrounds and this was
based on the most urgent needs in terms of the legal perspective or safety perspective.
Member Cornell said that communication on how this process happens is needed so
that the community can be aware. Member Cornell suggested using natural materials for
playgrounds and getting input from landscape designers.
Page 3
Ms. Mattern said that it is unrealistic to expect parents to raise a million dollars for
playgrounds and added that using natural materials as well as involving a landscape
designer still comes with a high price tag. Member Cornell commented that the current
playgrounds are not sustainable financially or environmentally. Ms. Mattern highlighted
that a landscaped playground might have accessibility issues and that the upfront cost
would be high. Ms. Mattern added that a playground especially for an early childhood
school is basic infrastructure. Ms. Baker-Buzdygon commented that hiring someone to
look for grants will be more productive than having parents drive the effort.
In response to Vice Chair Cruz, Ms. Mattern said that the Early Childhood Center and the
Salem Park, Recreation and Community Services collaborated and received a $60,000
grant for a shade structure but it has not yet been installed. Superintendent Zrike
provided information about the plans regarding playgrounds at some of the schools and
added that mats are one alternative to eliminate having woodchips on the playgrounds.
T
Assistant Superintendent Pauley provided information about playground improvements
that occurred in the last five years including the installation of the Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA) accessible mats at the Saltonstall School, installation of outdoor
classrooms, repairing playgrounds, undertaking of a comprehensive playground study,
addressing safety issues, doing work on the Witchcraft Heights Elementary School and
3. AF
Bates Elementary School playgrounds. Ms. Mattern commented that the playground
study did not include the Carlton Innovation School playground. Member Campbell said
more clear communication is needed regarding long-term and short-term plans.
Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) Update
Superintendent Zrike provided an update on the high school building project. Mayor
Pangallo added that community events where information about the project has already
been taking place. Vice Chair Cruz thanked everyone involved with the building
committee for their work.
4.
R
Finance and Operations Report
There was no report.
Subcommittee Reports
D
1.
2.
3.
Finance Subcommittee
No report at this time.
Personnel Subcommittee
No report at this time.
Building and Grounds Subcommittee
No report at this time.
4. Curriculum Subcommittee
Page 4
No report at this time.
5. Policy Subcommittee
No report at this time.
Motions and Resolutions
1. Authorization for the Disposal of Surplus Materials
Member Campbell said these materials are outdated or broken. Superintendent Zrike
said there is some urgency to remove these materials from Salem High School and the
Collins Middle School so that the space can be used.
Member Cornell made a motion to dispose the surplus materials. Member Campbell
seconded. A roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell voted YES
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman ABSENT
Member Manning voted YES
T
AF
Member Miranda ABSENT
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Announcements
There were not any announcements.
Adjournment
R
Vice Chair Cruz made a motion to adjourn at 8:35 pm. Member Cornell seconded. A roll call
vote was taken. A roll call vote was taken.
Member Campbell voted YES
Member Cornell voted YES
Vice Chair Cruz voted YES
Member Hoffman ABSENT
D
Member Manning voted YES
Member Miranda ABSENT
Mayor Pangallo voted YES
Motion passed with 5 votes in favor and 2 absent.
Respectfully submitted by,
Shirley Dorai
Executive Assistant to the School Committee & Superintendent
Page 5
Salem Public Schools
2025 MCAS, ACCESS &
Accountability Results
School Committee Meeting
October 6, 2025
Salem Public Schools 1
Our achievement gaps with all high school content areas
State Performance and Grades 3-8 ELA is smaller than it was in 2019.
In Grades 3-8, Salem Public
State SPS Schools improved the percentage
% M or E change % M or E change of students meeting/exceeding
compared to 2024 compared to 2024
expectations between 2024 and
2025 at a rate higher than the state
ELA Grades 3-8 +3 +8
average in all 3 content areas
ELA Grade 10 -4 -7 tested.
Math Grades 3-8 0 +2 At the high school level, the rate
of improvement of Salem Public
Math Grade 10 -3 -1 School students
meeting/exceeding expectations
Science Grades 5 & 8 0 +3 between 2024 and 2025 as
compared to the state average was
Science Grade 10 -3 -3 variable. Some evidence of
impact from Question 2.
MA Accountability System
Over two years, Salem Public Schools has made
2025 Accountability Percentile Ranks significant progress toward meeting targets (66%).
2023 2024 2025
Percentile Percentile Percentile Progress Toward Target
School
Rank Rank Rank (over 2 years)
Bates 38 49 56 Substantial Progress (71%)
BAIS 16 21 25 Moderate Progress (49%)
Carlton 37 41 36 Limited or No Progress (24%)
CMS 9 11 21 Substantial Progress (68%)
HMLS 18 23 14 Moderate Progress (47%)
Salts 24 33 34 Substantial Progress (67%)
WHES 25 34 38 Substantial Progress (65%)
SHS 20 33 43 Substantial Progress (54%)
Accountability Reflections
● During the last two years, Salem has met or exceeded more accountability targets
than any Gateway City in the Commonwealth.
● Over half of Salem schools (5 out of 8) made substantial progress toward their targets
in 2025 (Bates, Collins, Saltonstall, Witchcraft and Salem High School).
● 6 out of 8 schools improved their percentile rank in two consecutive years (Bates,
Bentley, Collins, Saltonstall, Witchcraft and Salem High School).
● All schools but 1 have a designation of “Not requiring assistance or intervention”.
○ Salem High School is listed as “Requiring assistance or intervention” due to low
participation of English Learners (ELs) or Former English Learners (FELs).
Every subgroup must have a 95% participation rate, and ELs/FELs at Salem High
School participated at 94%. If one more student in this group had tested, the
school would have had a designation of “not requiring assistance”.
● The Salem Public Schools as a District met or exceeded 66% of the established targets
which is considered making “Substantial progress toward targets”.
Accountability Reflections
● Chronic absenteeism rates continue to improve such that we had the third lowest rate of
absenteeism out of 26 Gateway City school districts.
● 73% of our students passed an advanced coursework class in 11th or 12th grade (3rd among
Gateways).
● Our achievement gaps with the state in all high school content areas and Grades 3-8 ELA
are smaller than they were before the pandemic.
2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019
Total AP Students 253 147 115 89 60 147 180
Number of Exams 496 265 207 146 133 273 335
AP Students with 3+ Scores 168 40 58 40 31 65 72
Percentage of students with 3+ 66.4% 44.94% 50.43% 44.94% 51.67% 44% 40%
SHS Enrollment 952 948 888 803 860 886 916
District-level MCAS Results
7
Grade 3-8 math results place us in the middle tier
Comparison to Gateway Cities 3-8 Math of Massachusetts Gateway Cities.
Salem outperformed 20 out of 25 other
Comparison to Gateway Cities 3-8 ELA Gateway Cities on 3-8 ELA.
Salem outperformed 20 out of 25 other
Comparison to Gateway Cities 5 & 8 Science Gateway Cities on 5th and 8th Science.
10
MCAS ELA Results
Grades 3-8
11
MCAS Essay Writing Idea Development is scored out of 4 in grades 3-5 and out of 5 in
grades 6-8 and 10
Grade % 0-1 Points % Max Points
Grade 3 85% 1% We see relative strength in idea
development as students enter
Grade 4 76% 2% middle and high school.
However, idea development in
Grade 5 56% 3% the early grades is of particular
concern as it reflects our
Grade 6 46% 10% students ability to
communicate complex ideas in
Grade 7 43% 3% writing effectively, a critical
skill for future successes.
Grade 8 35% 7%
Grade 10 22% 25%
3-8 - Question 12
10 - Question 9
5 out of 6 schools have proficiency above 30
ELA by School percent.
There was an increase in the percentage of students
meeting and exceeding and a decrease in the
3-8 ELA Year to Year Comparisons number of students not meeting in 3-8 ELA and
represents the strongest achievement in ELA for
the last four years.
There is significant disproportionality in
ELA Subgroup Achievement 3-8 achievement for grades 3-8 ELA and moderate
growth for subgroups.
48 SGP
47 SGP
47 SGP
56 SGP
for FEL
49 SGP
MCAS Math Results
Grades 3-8
16
Bates is leading elementary and middle
Math by School schools with 40% of students proficient with
Witchcraft Heights following close behind.
3-8 Math Year to Year Comparison
Overall, math results
were flat with some
schools increasing
their proficiency with
others decreasing.
SGPs for subgroups were in the moderate
Math Subgroup Achievement 3-8 to high-moderate range.
54 SGP
53 SGP
48 SGP
62 SGP
for FEL
55 SGP
Racial Demographics
There is a persistent
racial disparity in
performance
demonstrating the
need for further work
in creating inclusive
environments where
all students
experience a sense of
belonging.
Spotlight–SPS Middle Schools
21
District Middle School ELA
Collins and Saltonstall (6-8)
2024 2025 Change significantly increased the
percent of students
CMS 6 14% 32% +18 meeting or exceeding in
ELA.
Salts 6 5% 44% +39 While 7th grade data for
CMS 7 23% 34% +11 Saltonstall is the lowest in
2025, it reflects a significant
Salts 7 26% 21% -5 increase of 16 points from
the previous year for this
CMS 8 25% 33% +8 cohort of students.
Salts 8 29% 35% +6
Collins Middle School increased the percentage
Math Collins Middle School of students meeting and exceeding overall.
Salts 6th
26% M/E
19% NM
In addition to outperforming neighboring gateway
Science Collins Middle School cities, the % of students meeting and exceeding
increased by 9 points.
Every school had moderate or high growth in ELA
SGP and math. Only one school had low growth in
either content area.
School ELA Math
Bates 61 60
BAIS 52 56
Carlton 47 49
HMLS 45 38
Salts 61 44
WHES 55 50
CMS 58 51
SHS 66 67
25
MCAS Science Results
Grades 3-8
26
The performance in science varies significantly by
Science by School school with Saltonstall 5th graders leading other
schools with 48% proficient.
MCAS Civics Results
Grade 8
28
Gr. 8 Civics – Background Format
The Civics assessment has 2 sessions:
Domains Assessed:
State-Level Performance Task:
● Foundations of Government
● Government Structures ★ Addresses one topic in-depth
● Rights and Responsibilities ○ Three 1-point constructed-response
● Civics Practices questions
● Civic Knowledge ○ One 4-point constructed-response
● Civic-based Questions question
● Analyzing Sources ○ Seven 1-point selected-response
● Explanations and Reasoning questions which include
multiple-choice, multiple-select, and
technology-enhanced items.
Timeline End-of-Course Test:
2018 - DESE launches new History/SS Framework ★ Addresses all of the standards
2023 - Pilot of items and format ○ 32 machine-scored test questions
○ Item types include multiple-choice,
2024 - Field test across the entire state multiple-select, and
technology-enhanced questions
2025 - 1st year of full implementation
F.A.Q.
Gr. 8 Civics – Background
Source Analysis and Content Knowledge
Multiple Choice
Constructed Response
Gr. 8 Civics — Baseline Results
2025 was the first year of
full implementation of the
8th Grade Civics MCAS.
Based on data shared,
students are scoring 5%
points below the state on
the constructed response
items and 8% on selected
response.
jg jg
1. District Achievement & Growth (All Students) 4
1.1 Grades 3–8 Achievement Levels (2025) 4
1.2 Grades 3–8 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 4
1.3 Grade 10 Achievement Levels (2025) 5
1.4 Grade 10 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 5
1.5 Grades 3–8 Scaled Score Change — 2023→2025 6
1.6 Grade 10 Scaled Score Change — 2023→2025 6
1.7 Grades 3–8 Growth (SGP) — 2023→2025 6
1.8 Grade 10 Growth (SGP) — 2023→2025 7
2. ELA (Content Area) 7
2.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students) 7
2.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students) 8
2.3 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 8
2.4 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 9
2.5 Grades 3–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 9
2.6 Grades 3–8: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025 10
2.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 10
2.8 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 11
2.9 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 11
2.10 Grade 10: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025 12
3. Math (Content Area) 12
3.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students) 12
3.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students) 13
3.3 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 13
3.4 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 14
3.5 Grades 3–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 14
3.6 Grades 3–8: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025 15
3.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 15
3.8 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 16
3.9 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 16
3.10 Grade 10: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025 17
4. Science (Content Area) 17
4.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students) 17
4.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students) 18
4.3 Grades 5 & 8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 18
4.4 Grades 5 & 8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 19
4.5 Grades 5–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 19
4.6 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025) 20
4.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025) 20
4.8 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025 21
5. Appendix (Methods & Notes) 22
5.1 Data Sources 22
5.2 Reporting Notes 22
○
1. District Achievement & Growth (All Students)
1.1 Grades 3–8 Achievement Levels (2025)
1.2 Grades 3–8 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025
1.3 Grade 10 Achievement Levels (2025)
1.4 Grade 10 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025
1.5 Grades 3–8 Scaled Score Change — 2023→2025
Year ELA Avg. Scaled Math Avg. Scaled Score Science Avg. Scaled Score
Score
2023 498 491.1 493.5
2024 499.2 492.3 494.2
2025 500.1 493 495.1
Change,
2023–2025 2.1 ▲ 1.9 ▲ 1.6 ▲
1.6 Grade 10 Scaled Score Change — 2023→2025
Year ELA Avg. Scaled Score Math Avg. Scaled Score Science Avg. Scaled Score
2023 507.5 502.2 499.8
2024 508.7 503 500.5
2025 509.3 504.4 501.2
Change,
2023–2025 1.8 ▲ 2.2 ▲ 1.4 ▲
1.7 Grades 3–8 Growth (SGP) — 2023→2025
Year ELA Avg. SGP Math Avg. SGP Science Avg. SGP
2023 47 45 46
2024 50 48 47
2025 52 49 50
Change,
2023–2025 5.0 ▲ 4.0 ▲ 4.0 ▲
1.8 Grade 10 Growth (SGP) — 2023→2025
Year ELA Avg. Math Avg. SGP Science Avg. SGP
SGP
2023 48 46 47
2024 49 47 48
2025 51 50 49
Change,
2023–2025 3.0 ▲ 4.0 ▲ 2.0 ▲
2. ELA (Content Area)
2.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students)
2.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students)
2.3 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
2.4 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025
Note: American Indian N<20, therefore, proficiency is not reported by DESE
2.5 Grades 3–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
2.6 Grades 3–8: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025
Subgroup 2023 SGP 2024 SGP 2025 SGP Change 2023→2025
All Students 48 51 56 8.0 ▲
High Needs 45 50 55 10.0 ▲
Low Income 45 50 54 9.0 ▲
Students with Disabilities 43 45 53 10.0 ▲
English Learners 46 49 48 2.0 ▲
2.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
2.8 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025)
Note: American Indian and Asian, N<20, therefore proficiency is not reported by DESE
2.9 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
Note: English Learners N<20, therefore not reported by DESE
2.10 Grade 10: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025
Subgroup 2023 SGP 2024 SGP 2025 SGP Change 2023→2025
All Students 47 57 66 19.0 ▲
High Needs 45 51 68 23.0 ▲
Low Income 45 51 66 21.0 ▲
Students with
Disabilities 39 51 70 31.0 ▲
English Learners - - - -
Note: English Learners N<20, therefore not reported by DESE
3. Math (Content Area)
3.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students)
3.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students)
3.3 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
3.4 Grades 3–8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025)
Note: American Indian N<20, therefore proficiency is not reported by DESE
3.5 Grades 3–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
3.6 Grades 3–8: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025
Change
Subgroup 2023 SGP 2024 SGP 2025 SGP 2023→2025
All Students 46 51 50 4.0 ▲
High Needs 44 49 49 5.0 ▲
Low Income 44 49 48 4.0 ▲
Students with Disabilities 42 46 47 5.0 ▲
3.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
Note: English Learners N<20, therefore not reported by DESE
3.8 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025)
Note: American Indian and Asian, N<20, therefore proficiency is not reported by DESE
3.9 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
3.10 Grade 10: Growth by Subgroup — 2023→2025
Subgroup 2023 SGP 2024 SGP 2025 SGP Change 2023→2025
All Students 44 65 67 23 ▲
High Needs 44 63 67 23 ▲
Low Income 43 62 67 24 ▲
Students with
Disabilities 41 55 63 22 ▲
English
Learners - - - -
Note: English Learners SGP data unavailable. Students need two years’ worth of data to calculate an SGP.
4. Science (Content Area)
4.1 2025 Achievement by Grade (All Students)
4.2 Achievement Levels — 2023→2025 (All Students)
4.3 Grades 5 & 8: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
4.4 Grades 5 & 8: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025)
4.5 Grades 5–8: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
4.6 Grade 10: Achievement by Subgroup (2025)
4.7 Grade 10: Achievement by Race/Ethnicity (2025)
Note: American Indian and Asian, N<20, therefore proficiency is not reported by DESE
4.8 Grade 10: Subgroup Trend — 2023→2025
5. Appendix (Methods & Notes)
5.1 Data Sources
The data presented in this packet draws from the following sources (all provided by Edwin Analytics
unless otherwise noted):
● MCAS Student-Level Data (2023–2025) – State assessment results for ELA, Math, and Science
across grades 3–8 and 10. Includes scaled scores, achievement levels, and SGPs.
● Student Demographics Snapshot (2025) – Student subgroup information (High Needs, Low
Income, SWD, EL, Race/Ethnicity). Based on Spring 2025 enrollment.
● District Enrollment & Cohort Files – Enrollment counts used for subgroup trend and growth
calculations. N-size thresholds based on DESE reporting guidelines.
● SGP (Student Growth Percentile) Reports – Growth measures for ELA, Math, and Science by grade
and subgroup. Interpreted using DESE growth models.
● Accountability Data Files (2023–2025) – Historical and current accountability indicators and
trends. Used for trendlines, comparisons, and context.
5.2 Reporting Notes
● Subgroup data is only reported for groups with N ≥ 20 per DESE guidelines.
● English Learner data may be suppressed at the grade level due to low counts.
● All growth metrics use the DESE-defined SGP model for longitudinal analysis.
October 3, 2025
RE: MSBA Update
School Committee Members,
Please see the following important updates regarding the Salem High School building project:
● Accenture began the meeting on September 25th with their usual recap of the schedule,
noting that the Schematic Design submission, the last submission of the Feasibility
Process, which confirms the project cost, is due on December 17th to the MSBA.
● The Construction Manager Selection Subcommittee gave an update on the selection
process. A joint venture of Shawmut + WT Rich was selected over three others.
○ The Subcommittee introduced the team leadership, David Malmquist from
Shawmut and Jon Rich from WT Rich. They shared some of the information
from the interview, including a video that visualized one possibility for
undertaking the project. The meeting recording and presentation slides are posted
on the project website.
● The design team presented updates on the extensive design development since the last
meeting. The update included:
○ Reductions in square footage to some programs (overall reduction of just under
12,000sf). These reductions were largely in the CTE areas as the design of these
areas has become more detailed with input from the departments
○ Updates to the building plans to improve adjacencies. This update included room
layouts
○ Updates to the site and athletic field design, based on input from the high school
staff
○ Initial images of the building. A physical model of the site was provided that is
now available to be viewed at public presentations in Salem.
● Upcoming Meeting: The next meeting is scheduled for Thursday, October 16th from 6-8
pm on Zoom.
Sincerely,
Stephen K. Zrike, Jr., Ed.D.
www.salemk12.org @SalemSchoolsk12 @SalemPublicSchools
To: Members of the Salem School Committee
CC: Dr. Stephen Zrike
From: Elizabeth Pauley
Date: October 6, 2025
Re: October operational updates
Below please find selected updates from our operational departments.
● Buildings & Grounds:
○ On 10.6, work will begin to replace the sound system at Bertram Field,
which was part of the FY26 Capital Projects. The project was delayed
due to back-order parts.
○ On 9.29, Curtis playground closed to Carlton school, and the work to
renovate the playground has launched. Carlton school has made
provisions for students to have safe, enjoyable play spaces.
● Food & Nutrition Services (FNS): Farm to School
○ October is National Farm to School Month. FNS is celebrating by
launching salad bars at all schools, including elementary schools.
○ On September 15th, FNS launched composting in the High School
cafeterias. The High School is the third SPS school to launch
composting in the cafeteria. All kitchens have been composting since
the 23-24 school year.
○ October 14-17 is National School Lunch week.
○ The Harvest of the Month this month is Pears; taste tests for pears will
be held during the week of October 20-24.
● Finance: EOYR
○ Every school district is required to submit an annual End of Year
Report by September 30th. Each school district's actual net school
spending in the prior fiscal year and the estimated net school
spending in the current year is calculated based on this report.
○ Salem’s EOYR was submitted one day early, on September 29.
Elizabeth A . Pauley
29 Highland Avenue
Salem, Massachusetts 01970
Tel: (978) 740-1222
epauley@salemk12.org
To: Salem School Committee
CC: Dr. Stephen Zrike
From: Elizabeth Pauley, Camila Salazar
Date: October 2, 2025
Re: FY26
Below please find a transfer that is recommended for your consideration. The total amount
requested for transfer is $6,000.00. Because the transfer is across cost centers, we are
asking for School Committee approval to make this transfer.
The rationale for this transfer is described briefly below.
I recommend approval of these transfers.
Transfer to: Transfer From:
Account Transfer From: Account
Account Amount Account
Name Name
Number Number
DL - 13711521-5514 $6,000.00
Instructional
Supplies
$6,000.00 DL - Stipends 13711520-5150
To help fund SchoolPace subscriptions, stipends will be covered by Gateway grant.
Elizabeth A . Pauley
29 Highland Avenue
Salem, Massachusetts 01970
Tel: (978) 740-1222
epauley@salemk12.org
Get email alerts for Salem
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.