Civil Service Commission
Regular MeetingSaratoga Springs, NY · August 31, 2022
Minutes
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
474 BROADWAY, CITY COUNCIL ROOM
AUGUST 31st 2022 9:30AM
MINUTES
PRESENT: CHAIRPERSON HOLMES
COMMISSIONER ZANGRANDO (Absent)
COMMISSIONER LEIDIG
ANNOUNCEMENT OF RECORDING OF PROCEEDINNGS
The proceedings of this meeting are audio recorded for the benefit of the Commissions Coordinator who acts as Secretary. Because
minutes are not a verbatim record of the proceedings, the minutes are not a word for word transcript of the recordings. Recorded
audio available upon request.
CHAIRPERSON HOLMES CALLED THE REGULAR MEETING TO ORDER AT 9:33am and opened the public comment section. There being
no one wishing to speak, Chair Holmes closed the public comment section at 9:34am.
July minutes tabled.
ACCOUNTS
Commissioner Moran appeared before the commission to briefly discuss the request. Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the proposed
revisions (adding a sub section specific to Accounts) to the Administrative Assistant job specification. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion
carries unanimously.
CITY CENTER
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Labor Class Appointments. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion carries
unanimously.
Cleaner Angela Carisquillo Effective 08/01/22
DPW
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Non Competitive Class Promotional Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes.
Motion carries unanimously.
Maintenance Mechanic Todd Thomas Sr Effective 08/21/22 Heavy
Equipment Operator Gene Ellis Effective 08/21/22
Heavy Equipment Operator Andy Gary Effective 08/21/22
Heavy Equipment Operator Vincent Kenyon Effective 08/21/22
Heavy Equipment Operator Kyle Kirk Effective 08/21/22
Heavy Equipment Operator John Prevost Effective 08/21/22
Motor Equipment Operator Andrew Medick Effective 08/21/22
Motor Equipment Operator Todd Thomas Jr Effective 08/21/22
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Temporary Appointment. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion carries
unanimously.
HVAC/Plumbing Technician Lyle Shultz Sr Effective 07/30/22 – 12/31/22
MAYOR
Mayor Kim and Commissioner Moran both appeared before the commission to briefly discuss the proposed revisions by Mayor Kim to the Director
of Risk and Safety job specification. A resolution passed at the August 2nd City Council meeting with a 3 yes, 1 no, 1 abstain vote transferring the
singular position and its duties and responsibilities from the Accounts Department to the Mayors Department. Upon advice from legal counsel, the
resolution passed by the legislative city council body was the driving force thus creating the need to update the supervisory piece of the job
specification from the supervision of the Commissioner/Deputy Commissioner of Accounts to the Mayor/Deputy Mayor. Nothing else in the job
specification was revised. Commissioner Moran disagreed with the transfer and revisions.
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the proposed revision to the Director of Risk and Safety job specification. Seconded by Chairperson
Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Provisional Appointment. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Grants Assistant Michael Dutre Effective 09/12/22
PUBLIC SAFETY
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Reinstatement. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion carries unanimously.
Public Safety Dispatcher Justin Siskavich Effective 08/20/22
RECREATION
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Non Competitive Class Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Recreation Leader Arissa Gillani Effective 08/09/22
Youth Parker Supervisor Sarah Mack Effective 08/17/22 – 09/09/22
Page 1 of 2
SCHOOL
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the proposed revisions to the Data and Assessment Coordinator job specification. Seconded by
Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
CIVIL SERVICE
No vote on the 70.2 was necessary, as was confirmed with legal counsel before the start of this meeting.
Establish Eligible Lists
Deputy Registrar of Vital Statistics #69-454
Police Department Records Management Clerk #61-543
Receptionist #68-162
Senior Clerk #69-756
School District Registrar #65-845
Transportation Routing Clerk #69-217
Utilities Clerk #64-742
Permanent Appointments from Established Eligible Lists
Assistant Assessor #64-401 Carrie Schermerhorn Effective 08/31/22
Deputy Registrar of Vital Statistics #69-454 Sabrina Lauzon Effective 08/31/22
Keyboard Specialist #10-421 Kelly Barone Effective 08/15/22
PD Records Management Clerk #61-543 Siobhan Buskey Effective 08/31/22
Receptionist #68-162 Hope Flynn Effective 08/31/22
Senior Clerk #69-756 David Queenan Effective 08/31/22
Senior Typist #22-222 Casey DeLaurie Effective 07/28/22
Exam and Vacancy Announcements
Animal Control/Parking Enforcement Officer #
Budget Director #65-871
Clerk #10-323
Community Development Planner #66-243
Director of Risk and Safety #65-432
Grants Assistant #68-344
Human Resources Coordinator #65-121
Human Resources Generalist #68-208
Human Resources Manager #67-749
Human Resources Specialist #68-404
Keyboard Specialist #10-423
Laborer
Parking Enforcement Officer #69-775
Planner #62-524
Police Officer #66-533
Principal Planner #62-482 and #77-615
Receptionist #67-786
Senior Clerk #63-959
Senior Planner #62-513
Service Coordinator – Housing Authority #67-859
Transportation Routing Clerk #67-843
Utilities Clerk #64-078
Computer Support Technician – Provisional
Help Desk Technician – Provisional
Public Safety Dispatcher – Part Time and Temporary
Resignations/Retirements
Automotive Mechanic Evan Hoss Resignation Effective 05/16/22
Help Desk Technician Justin Siskavich Resignation Effective 08/20/22
Laborer Austin Willard Resignation Effective 08/26/22
Public Safety Dispatcher Alan Clemmer Resignation Effective 08/14/22
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to add a discussion regarding promotions and lateral transfers to the October 2022 agenda. Seconded by
Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to close the meeting at 10:48am. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
CSC Approved___
Page 2 of 2
Agenda
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING AGENDA
474 BROADWAY SARATOGA SPRINGS, COUNCIL ROOM 1ST FLOOR
WEDNESDAY AUGUST 31st 2022 9:30AM
Roll Call
Public Comments
Approve July 2022 Regular Meeting Minutes
ACCOUNTS
Discuss and Vote on Proposed Addition (sub section) to Administrative Assistant Job Specification
CITY CENTER
Approve Labor Class Appointment
Cleaner (1)
DPW
Approve Non Competitive Class Promotional Appointments
Heavy Equipment Operator (5)
Maintenance Mechanic (1)
Motor Equipment Operator (2)
Approve Temporary Appointment
HVAC/Plumber Technician (1)
MAYOR
Discuss and Vote on Proposed Revisions to the Director of Risk and Safety Job Specification (attached)
Approve Provisional Appointment
Grants Assistant (1)
PUBLIC SAFETY
Approve Reinstatement
Public Safety Dispatcher (1)
RECREATION
Approve Non Competitive Class Appointments
Recreation Leader (1)
Youth Parker Supervisor (1)
SCHOOL
Discuss and Vote on Proposed Revisions to the Data and Assessment Coordinator Job Specification
CIVIL SERVICE
Discuss and Vote on Position Transfer under NYS CSL 70.2 – Director of Risk and Safety
Establish Eligible Lists
Deputy Registrar of Vital Statistics #69-454
Police Department Records Management Clerk #61-543
Receptionist #68-162
Senior Clerk #69-756
School District Registrar #65-845
Transportation Routing Clerk #69-217
Utilities Clerk #64-742
Permanent Appointments from Established Eligible Lists
Assistant Assessor #64-401 Carrie Schermerhorn Effective 08/31/22
Deputy Registrar of Vital Statistics #69-454 Sabrina Lauzon Effective 08/31/22
Keyboard Specialist #10-421 Kelly Barone Effective 08/15/22
PD Records Management Clerk #61-543 Siobhan Buskey Effective 08/31/22
Receptionist #68-162 Hope Flynn Effective 08/31/22
Senior Clerk #69-756 David Queenan Effective 08/31/22
Senior Typist #22-222 Casey DeLaurie Effective 07/28/22
Exam and Vacancy Announcements
Animal Control/Parking Enforcement Officer #
Budget Director #65-871
Clerk #10-323
Community Development Planner #66-243
Director of Risk and Safety #65-432
Grants Assistant #68-344
Human Resources Coordinator #65-121
Human Resources Generalist #68-208
Human Resources Manager #67-749
Human Resources Specialist #68-404
Keyboard Specialist #10-423
Laborer
Parking Enforcement Officer #69-775
Planner #62-524
Police Officer #66-533
Principal Planner #62-482 and #77-615
Receptionist #67-786
Page 1 of 5
Senior Clerk #63-959
Senior Planner #62-513
Service Coordinator – Housing Authority #67-859
Transportation Routing Clerk #67-843
Utilities Clerk #64-078
Computer Support Technician – Provisional
Help Desk Technician – Provisional
Public Safety Dispatcher – Part Time and Temporary
Resignations/Retirements
Automotive Mechanic Evan Hoss Resignation Effective 05/16/22
Help Desk Technician Justin Siskavich Resignation Effective 08/20/22
Laborer Austin Willard Resignation Effective 08/26/22
Public Safety Dispatcher Alan Clemmer Resignation Effective 08/14/22
Prepared by: Corissa Salvo, Civil Service Coordinator
Page 2 of 5
Director of Risk and safety (COMPETITIVE)
DISTINGUISHING FEATURES OF THE CLASS: This is important financial and operational management work
involving direction, control and management of City’s Insurance, Risk Management, Compliance and Safety programs
and includes responsibility to assist the City Council and each department in controlling claims costs and all applicable
State and Federal Health and Safety Regulations.
The work involves the identification and measurement of all risks of accident loss, the selection of appropriate risk
management techniques for resolving exposure problems, the development and maintenance of an information system
in coordination with existing systems for timely and accurate recording of losses, claims, insurance premium and other
risk costs to the budgetary units. The incumbent also administers the procurement of all insurance for, and in behalf
of the City. General direction is received from the Commissioner of Accounts Mayor and Deputy Mayor with wide
leeway allowed for independent judgment. Direct supervision is exercised over clerical staff assigned to the Director
of Risk and Safety. The Director for Risk and Safety does related work as required. This position serves the City
Council, Civil Service Commission, Recreation Commission, and each department in risk and safety management
activities.
.
TYPICAL WORK ACTIVITIES: The duties listed are intended only as illustrations of the various types of work
performed. The omission of specific statements of duties does not exclude them from the position if the work is
similar, related or a logical assignment to the position.
Is primary Safety Officer for the City and Chairs City’s Safety Committee and makes periodic reports to the City
Council;
Is primary Compliance Officer for Risk and Safety State and Federal regulatory and emergency management matters;
Completes and submits periodic and annual reports to State agencies as required by law or special circumstance;
Represents the City on insurance, risk and safety related legislative and regulatory issues at the State and
Federal levels;
Meets with other City staff to identify and resolve compliance, risk and safety related problems;
Manages and participates in the development and implementation of goals, objectives, policies, and priorities for
insurance, risk and safety programs;
Develops and implements global and department specific safety training in accordance with state and federal
regulations;
Evaluates and assesses probability and severity of potential losses to which the City, its employees and/or the general
public may be exposed and reports to City Council on methods of avoiding or handling risks;
Works with representatives from each department to identify all potential possibilities for accidental loss
to the City's assets including traveling to any or all City work sites as necessary;
Develops and assists in implementing and monitoring City-wide strategies to prevent and minimize losses
including the development of programs regarding regulatory compliance, insurance, risk and safety;
Collects, analyzes and distributes information on City’s losses to Safety Committee with recommendations for
corrective action;
Investigates and manages all property and casualty accidents, claims, and lawsuits;
Establishes and manages procedures for submission of property and casualty accident reports and handling of claims
by City personnel, and performs related duties as required;
Closely monitors and evaluates losses, providing verbal and written information to departments, assisting them in loss
reduction efforts;
Prepares and administers specifications for insurance proposals to insurance carriers and makes recommendations to
the City Council for placement;
Maintains all insurance policies, endorsements and loss runs;
Page 3 of 5
Prepares the annual Risk and Safety budget and maintains control over same through accounts payables and
receivables;
Allocates property and casualty insurance program and self-insurance program costs to City departments and divisions
allocating payment of claims to self-insured retention program as are applicable;
Reviews appropriate contract language for City sponsored contractual agreements, and recommends coverage limits
and approves insurance limits for contracts, awards of bids and licenses;
Serves on a variety of boards, committees and commissions and attends and participates in professional
group meetings as a representative of the City;
Administers the City’s NYS LENS Program for the City’s insurance program and City Clerk’s taxi cab driver
licensing;
Works in partnership with the Department of Public Safety and the Police Department to develop security
and video surveillance programming;
Assists the Department of Public Safety and the City Council in the maintenance, development and
deployment of the comprehensive City Emergency Management Plan.
FULL PERFORMANCE KNOWLEDGES, SKILLS, ABILITIES AND PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS:
Excellent knowledge of Public Entity Insurance; good knowledge of techniques and procedures involved in claims
adjustments; good knowledge of laws and ordinances relating to claims filed by or against municipalities; good
knowledge of character evidence required for trail of actions; good knowledge of interviewing techniques, ability to
read and understand complex written material, ability to examine evidence and conduct investigations independently;
ability to assess evidence and draw conclusions; ability to investigate and supervise execution of appropriate and
prescribed disciplinary actions; ability to assess evidence and draw conclusions; ability to make recommendations for
settlement of claims; ability to determine needed reserves for future claims payment; ability to communicate both
verbally and in writing; ability to prepare and deliver written and verbal reports to the City Council; ability to prepare,
originate, organize and conduct training seminars; ability to establish and maintain an effective working relationship
with employees and department heads; ability to maintain appropriate professional distance and balance, objective
observation and reaction;, good judgment, thoroughness, physical condition commensurate with the demands of the
position.
MINIMUM QUALILFICATIONS: EITHER
1. Graduation from a regionally accredited or New York State registered college or university with a Bachelor’s
Degree and FIVE (5) YEARS of experience involving commercial property and casualty insurance, risk
management techniques and safety administrations; OR
2. Graduation from a regionally accredited or New York State registered college or university with an Associates
Degree and SEVEN (7) YEARS of experience involving commercial property and casualty insurance, risk
management techniques and safety administrations.
NOTE: Possession of any one or combination of the following designations may be substituted for one year of
experience:
Chartered Property Casualty Underwriters (CPCU)
Certified Safety Professional (CSP)
Associates in Risk Management (ARM)
Adopted: January 25, 2003
Revised: January 7, 2004; December 1, 2004; February 13, 2007;March 19, 2014;
August 31, 2022
Title change: October 21, 2009
Page 4 of 5
Page 5 of 5
Get email alerts for Saratoga Springs
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.