Civil Service Commission
Regular MeetingSaratoga Springs, NY · March 29, 2023
Minutes
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
474 BROADWAY, CITY COUNCIL ROOM
MARCH 29th 2023
MINUTES
PRESENT: CHAIRPERSON HOLMES
COMMISSIONER LEIDIG
ABSENT: COMMISSIONER ZANGRANDO
ANNOUNCEMENT OF RECORDING OF PROCEEDINNGS
The proceedings of this meeting are audio recorded for the benefit of the Commissions Coordinator who acts as Secretary. Because minutes are not
a verbatim record of the proceedings, the minutes are not a word for word transcript of the recordings. Recorded audio available upon request.
CHAIRPERSON HOLMES CALLED THE REGULAR MEETING TO ORDER AT 9:34am and opened the public comment section. Public Safety Commissioner
Montagnino appeared before the commission to make a statement regarding a firefighter candidate item.
CITY CENTER
Executive Director Ryan McMahon from the City Center appeared before the commission to briefly discuss the request for a new single competitive
position of Human Resources Administrative Assistant. Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the New Position as presented. Seconded by
Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
FINANCE
Deputy Commissioner Crocker of Finance appeared before the commission to discuss proposed revisions to the Finance Coordinator job specification.
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the updated revisions as presented. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following extension of a Temporary Appointment. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion
carries unanimously.
Budget Director Donna Woods Effective 01/06/23 – 03/30/23
DPW
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Provisional Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Assistant Chief Water Treatment Plant Operator Ralph Ciccateri Effective 03/06/23
DPW Purchasing Coordinator Benjamin Nygard Effective 03/13/23
Electrician Michael Clancy Effective 03/20/23
Water Meter Service Worker Sean Deangelo Effective 03/20/23
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Completed Probationary Periods. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion carries
unanimously.
Administrative Assistant – Engineer Kate Dale Halliday Effective 02/23/23
Arborist Steve Lashomb Effective 03/13/23
Utilities Clerk Kari Donohue Effective 02/06/23
MAYOR
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Exempt Class Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Assistant City Attorney Michael Phillips Effective 03/22/23 – 12/31/23
Secretary to the Planning Board, Zoning Board of Appeals, Design Review Commission Diane Haight Effective 03/13/23
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Provisional Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Communications Coordinator Jessie House Effective 04/10/23
PUBLIC SAFETY
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Non Competitive and Temporary Appointment. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig.
Motion carries unanimously.
Fire Instructor/Coordinator (part time) Robert Williams Effective 03/13/23
Chairperson Holmes made a motion to approve the following Temporary Appointment. Seconded by Commissioner Leidig. Motion carries
unanimously.
Fire Chief Aaron Dyer Effective 02/25/23 – 03/24/23
RECREATION
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following Non Competitive Class Appointments. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously.
Camp Saradac Counselor Sarah Karns Effective 06/24/23 – 09/01/23
Recreation Assistants Alicia Staiger Effective 02/25/23
Recreation Assistants Emmett Barnes Effective 03/02/23 – 11/17/23
Recreation Leaders Sarah Karns Effective 04/12/23 – 06/23/23
Page 1 of 3
SCHOOL
Assistant Superintendent of Business Tim Hilker was due to appear before the commission to discuss the districts proposed revisions to the Director
of Transportation Job Specification but was unfortunately unable to make it. With the commission citing a few concerns regarding the proposed
updated revisions, Commissioner Leidig made a motion to table and request additional clarification. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries
unanimously. The Coordinator will contact the district to schedule a meeting.
Commissioner Leidig made a motion to approve the following School items. Seconded by Chairperson Holmes. Motion carries unanimously.
Labor Class Appointments
School Monitors Tara Lerman Effective 03/01/23
School Monitors James Meyers Effective 03/0623
School Monitors Freda Pratt Effective 02/27/23
School Monitors Amy Morine Effective 02/10/23
School Monitors Erin Rossi Effective 02/10/23
School Monitors Kaisha Thomas Effective 03/01/23-06/30/23
Non Competitive Class Appointments
Account Clerks (part time) Peter Galatioto Effective 09/26/22
Account Clerks (part time) Laurette Loucks Effective 09/09/22
Clerks (part time) Christine Jpyce Effective 02/07/23
Clerks (part time) Jacqueline Reinhart Effective 02/15/23
Groundskeepers Joshua Cauffiel Effective 03/01/23
Keyboard Specialists (part time) Christine Joyce Effective 02/07/23
Teresa Messina Registered Professional Nurse Effective 02/13/23
School Bus Assistants Edmunc Eckstein Effective 02/14/23
School Bus Drivers Danielle Arruda Effective 02/09/23
School Bus Drivers Brett Booker Effective 03/02/23
School Bus Drivers Andrietta Ramsey Effective 01/26/23
School Bus Drivers William Schnefel Effective 03/02/23
Teaccher Aides Lei Hu Effective 03/07/23
Teacher Aides Christine Joyce Effective 02/07/23
Teacher Aides Amy Morine Effective 02/10/23
Teacher Aides Madison Klick Effective 03/01/23
Teacher Aides Jacqueline Reinhart Effective 02/15/23
Teacher Aides Erin Rossi Effective 02/10/23
Leave of Absence
Custodian Dawn Duerr Effective 02/14/23 – 03/02/23
Completed Probationary Periods
Cooks Margaret Mary DeBlasiis Effective 02/16/23
Cooks Carey Thoabe Effective 02/16/23
Food Service Helpers Patricia Barber Effective 01/07/23
School Bus Assistants Adeyemi Bennett Effective 03/23/23
School Bus Drivers Teresa Meridy Effective 01/26/23
Provisional Appointments
Information Technology Support Technician I Christopher DeLoriea Effective 02/27/23
CIVIL SERVICE
Update on WebEx with NYS Civil Service regarding Police Chief job specification proposed revisions by Public Safety Commissioner
Police Officer Agility Test 03/31/23 update
Appointments from Established Eligible Lists
Budget Director #65-871 Donna Woods Effective 03/22/23
Clerk #10-323 Erica McWatters Effective 02/10/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Salvatore LaTella Conditional Offer Effective 03/??/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Nicholas Alonzo Permanent Offer Effective 03/25/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Derrick Barss Permanent Offer Effective 03/29/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Brian Coffey Permanent Offer Effective 03/22/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Charles Olson Permanent Offer Effective 03/21/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Vincent Parisi Permanent Offer Effective 03/23/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Daniel Reeves Permanent Offer Effective 03/24/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Michael Quinn Permanent Offer Effective 02/15/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Ethan VanPraag Permanent Offer Effective 03/26/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Steven Vinciguerra Permanent Offer Effective 03/27/23
Human Resources Generalist #68-208 Becky Shayne Effective 03/01/23
Keyboard Specialist #10-423 Heidi Brennan Effective 01/27/23
Keyboard Specialist #10-423 Tracy Memos Effective 01/27/23
Police Lieutenant #71-676 Angela McGovern Effective 03/11/23
Police Sergeant #71-680 Justin Ahigian Effective 03/13/23
Page 2 of 3
Police Sergeant #71-680 Rebecca Northrup Effective 03/12/23
Police Sergeant #71-680 Aaron Perkins Effective 03/11/23
Establish Eligible Lists
Animal Control/Parking Enforcement Officer #69-770
Budget Director #65-871
Director of Risk and Safety #65-432
Electrician #68-392
Human Resources Coordinator #65-121
Grants Assistant #63-744
Senior Clerk #63-959
Senior Electrician #68-482
Utilities Clerk #64-078
Exam and Vacancy Announcements
*REMINDER* civil service announces and administers exams (#) whether there is a current vacancy or not, as civil service is responsible for having
established eligible lists in the event of a vacancy*
Administrative Aide #67-995
Administrative Assistant #67-997
Administrative Assistant Engineering #68-033
Assistant Assessor #63-743 (Provisionally announced 02/24/23, then NYS CS released exam series)
Camp Saradac Assistant Director
Camp Saradac Counselor
Camp Saradac Director
Laborer (Carousel Worker)
Executive Assistant to the Mayor (Exempt)
Fire Captain #78-797
Fire Lieutenant #78-799
Police Sergeant #79-508
Reservation Coordinator #68-441
Real Property Appraisal Technician #68-406
Water Meter Accounts Supervisor
Retirements/Resignations
Administrative Assistant Katie Farone Resignation Effective 02/10/23
DPW Purchasing Coordinator Barbara Maughan Resignation Effective 04/05/23
Food Service Helper Stephen Tripoli Resignation Effective 01/03/23
Laborer Robert Macia Resignation Effective 03/08/23
Maintenance Mechanic Kenneth Dooley Resignation Effective 03/03/23
Secretary to the Planning Board, Zoning Board of Appeals, Design Review Commission Diane Buzanowski Retirement Effective 12/31/22
School Monitors Michele Baker Resignation Effective 03/01/23
School Monitors Shayna Conway Resignation Effective 03/01/23
Utilities Clerk Kelly Gliosco Retirement Effective 02/21/23
NEXT CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING:
April 26th 2023 9:30am (Wednesday)
May 31st 2023 9:30am (Wednesday)
June 27th 2023 9:30am (Tuesday)
CSC approved___05/31/23______
Page 3 of 3
Agenda
CITY OF SARATOGA SPRINGS CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING AGENDA
474 BROADWAY SARATOGA SPRINGS, COUNCIL ROOM 1ST FLOOR
WEDNESDAY MARCH 29TH 2023 9:30AM
Roll Call
Approve January 2023 Minutes
Approve February 2023 Minutes
Public Comments
CITY CENTER
Discuss and Vote on Proposed New Position Duty Statement – Human Resources Administrative Assistant
FINANCE
Discuss and Vote on Proposed Revisions to the Finance Coordinator Job Specification
Approve Temporary Appointment Extension
Budget Director (1)
DPW
Approve Provisional Appointment(s)
Assistant Chief Water Treatment Plant Operator (1)
DPW Purchasing Coordinator (1)
Electrician (1)
Water Meter Service Worker (1)
Approve Completed Probationary Periods
Administrative Assistant Engineering (1)
Arborist (1)
Utilities Clerk (1)
MAYOR
Approve Exempt Class Appointments
Assistant City Attorney (1)
Secretary to the Zoning Board, Board of Appeals and Design Review Commission (1)
Approve Provisional Appointment(s)
Communications Coordinator (1)
PUBLIC SAFETY
Approve Non Competitive and Temporary Appointment
Fire Instructor/Coordinator (part time) (1)
Approve Temporary Appointment
Fire Chief (1)
RECREATION
Approve Non Competitive Class Appointments
Camp Saradac Counselor (1)
Recreation Assistant (2)
Recreation Leader ( 1)
SCHOOL
Discuss and Vote on Proposed Revisions to the Director of Transportation job specification
Approve Labor Class Appointments
Food Service Helpers (
School Monitors (6)
Approve Non Competitive Class Appointments
Account Clerks (part time) (2)
Clerks (part time) (2)
Cooks (2)
Groundskeeper (1)
Keyboard Specialists (part time) (2)
Registered Professional Nurse (1)
School Bus Assistants (1)
School Bus Drivers (4)
Teacher Aides (6)
Approve Leave of Absences
Custodian (1)
Approve Completed Probationary Periods
Food Service Helper (1
School Bus Assistants (1)
School Bus Drivers (2)
Approve Provisional Appointments
Information Technology Support Technician (1)
Page 1 of 2
CIVIL SERVICE
Update on WebEx with NYS Civil Service regarding Police Chief job specification proposed revisions by Public Safety Commissioner
Police Officer Agility Test 03/31/23 update
Appointments from Established Eligible Lists
Budget Director #65-871 Donna Woods Effective 03/22/23
Clerk #10-323 Erica McWatters Effective 02/10/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Salvatore LaTella Conditional Offer Effective 03/??/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Nicholas Alonzo Permanent Offer Effective 03/25/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Derrick Barss Permanent Offer Effective 03/29/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Brian Coffey Permanent Offer Effective 03/22/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Charles Olson Permanent Offer Effective 03/21/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Vincent Parisi Permanent Offer Effective 03/23/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Daniel Reeves Permanent Offer Effective 03/24/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Michael Quinn Permanent Offer Effective 02/15/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Ethan VanPraag Permanent Offer Effective 03/26/23
Firefighter Paramedic Trainee #65-848 Steven Vinciguerra Permanent Offer Effective 03/27/23
Human Resources Generalist #68-208 Becky Shayne Effective 03/01/23
Keyboard Specialist #10-423 Heidi Brennan Effective 01/27/23
Keyboard Specialist #10-423 Tracy Memos Effective 01/27/23
Police Lieutenant #71-676 Angela McGovern Effective 03/11/23
Police Sergeant #71-680 Justin Ahigian Effective 03/13/23
Police Sergeant #71-680 Rebecca Northrup Effective 03/12/23
Police Sergeant #71-680 Aaron Perkins Effective 03/11/23
Establish Eligible Lists
Animal Control/Parking Enforcement Officer #69-770
Budget Director #65-871
Director of Risk and Safety #65-432
Electrician #68-392
Human Resources Coordinator #65-121
Grants Assistant #63-744
Senior Clerk #63-959
Senior Electrician #68-482
Utilities Clerk #64-078
Exam and Vacancy Announcements
*REMINDER* civil service announces and administers exams (#) whether there is a current vacancy or not, as civil service is
responsible for having established eligible lists in the event of a vacancy*
Administrative Aide #67-995
Administrative Assistant #67-997
Administrative Assistant Engineering #68-033
Assistant Assessor #63-743 (Provisionally announced 02/24/23, then NYS CS released exam series)
Camp Saradac Assistant Director
Camp Saradac Counselor
Camp Saradac Director
Laborer (Carousel Worker)
Executive Assistant to the Mayor (Exempt)
Fire Captain #78-797
Fire Lieutenant #78-799
Police Sergeant #79-508
Reservation Coordinator #68-441
Real Property Appraisal Technician #68-406
Water Meter Accounts Supervisor
Retirements/Resignations
Administrative Assistant Katie Farone Resignation Effective 02/10/23
DPW Purchasing Coordinator Barbara Maughan Resignation Effective 04/05/23
Food Service Helper Stephen Tripoli Resignation Effective 01/03/23
Laborer Robert Macia Resignation Effective 03/08/23
Maintenance Mechanic Kenneth Dooley Resignation Effective 03/03/23
Secretary to the Planning Board, Zoning Board of Appeals, Design Review Commission Diane Buzanowski Retirement Effective 12/31/22
School Monitors Michele Baker Resignation Effective 03/01/23
School Monitors Shayna Conway Resignation Effective 03/01/23
Utilities Clerk Kelly Gliosco Retirement Effective 02/21/23
NEXT CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING:
April 26th 2023 9:30am (Wednesday)
May 31st 2023 9:30am (Wednesday)
June 27th 2023 9:30am (Tuesday)
Page 2 of 2
Get email alerts for Saratoga Springs
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.