Board of Trustees
Regular MeetingScarsdale, NY · April 9, 2013
Minutes
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 92
THREE THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY-NINTH
REGULAR MEETING
Rutherford Hall
Village Hall
April 9, 2013
A regular meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Village of Scarsdale was held in
Rutherford Hall in Village Hall on Tuesday, April 9, 2013 at 8:00 P.M.
Present were Mayor Steves, Trustees Brodsky, Eisenman, Lee, Mark, Martin, and
Stern. Also present were Village Manager Gatta, Deputy Village Manager Pappalardo,
Village Attorney Esannason, Village Treasurer McClure, Village Clerk Conking, Assistants to
the Village Manager Azrelyant and Datino, and Administrative Intern Goodwin.
********
The minutes of the Board of Trustees Regular Meeting of March 27, 2013 were
approved on a motion entered by Trustee Mark, seconded by Trustee Brodsky, and
carried unanimously.
********
Bills & Payroll
Trustee Brodsky stated that she had audited the Abstract of Claims dated April 9,
2013 in the amount of $825,894.02 which includes $10,565.27 in Library Claims
previously audited by a Trustee of the Library Board were found to be in order and she
moved that such payment be ratified.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Mark and seconded by Trustee Eisenman, the
following resolution was adopted unanimously:
RESOLVED, that the Abstract of Claims dated April 9, 2013 in the amount of
$825,894.02 is hereby approved.
Trustee Brodsky further stated that payment of bills made in advance of a Board of
Trustees audit totaling $249,265.55 were found to be in order and she moved that such
payment be ratified.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Brodsky and seconded by Trustee Eisenman,
the following resolution was adopted unanimously:
RESOLVED, that payment of claims made in advance of a Board of Trustees
audit totaling $249,265.55 is hereby ratified.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 93
********
Mayor’s Comments
Mayor Steves stated that the Board has received an email expressing concern
about employment of DAS equipment. Later on in the meeting, just before public
comments, Trustee Brodsky will read the Village’s clarification on this issue.
Last Friday, Police Chief John Brogan was sworn in as the new President of the
Westchester County Chiefs of Police Association. Mayor Steves stated that he had the
honor of swearing him in and would like to extend the congratulations of the entire
Board and the entire community for this honor which not only reflects on Chief Brogan,
but the entire Police force.
Last Thursday, Mayor Steves attended the Greenacres Neighborhood
Association’s Annual Town Hall meeting. The Neighborhood Associations in general
play a major role in bringing issues to the attention of the Board. He urged the
community to be active in their neighborhood associations. With all of the issues facing
the Village, however, he stated that it was a little distressing that one of the topics of
concern broadly expressed at the meeting was the failure of people to clean up after their
pets. There was also a discussion of the Village’s role in enforcing these laws. In his
observation, the Village could more aggressively enforce the laws and could have the
Animal Control Officer stake out the playing fields to ensure that the laws are in force.
However, this is not how the Village should be using its limited resources. We are a
community, and a community requires that we do certain things as a matter of basic
courtesy. Cleaning up after your pet is about as basic as it gets.
This evening, much of the agenda is related to the Annual Organizational
requirements for the Board and the Village. We are a new Board and Mayor Steves stated
that he would like to welcome the new Trustees, Bill Stern and Tom Martin. This
evening we will appoint committee assignments for the Board. Much of the work that
the Board does is done at the Committee level. Committee meetings are open to the
public; times and places are posted for the public’s information. Mayor Steves
encouraged residents to attend if there is a topic of interest on the agenda. We will also
approve Liaison assignments for various Boards and Councils. A Trustee is assigned to
each of the Boards to ensure timely flow of information between the many Boards,
Councils, and Advisory Boards, and back to the Trustees.
Mayor Steves stated that as noted before, neighborhood associations are an
important part of the flow of information in the community. At this meeting, we will
also assign Trustees to the various neighborhood associations. There will also be some
Village housekeeping; newspaper designation, reappoint some of the senior officials;
starting a new year.
On April 27th, from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m., the Scarsdale Police Department and
the Drug Enforcement Administration will give the public an opportunity to prevent pill
abuse by ridding their homes of potentially dangerous unwanted and unused
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 94
prescriptions. Bring the medication for disposal to Scarsdale Village Hall. The service is
free and anonymous.
After the Manager’s comments, the Board will hold a public hearing on the
proposed Tentative 2013-2014 Budget. The Budget is available to the public at the
Scarsdale Library and on line at the Village’s website, www.scarsdale.com. The Finance
Committee and the Board will meet on April 18th at 6:30 p.m. to discuss comments heard
at this meeting and any additional input from the Trustees with respect to the Budget.
There is still time for public input.
********
Manager’s Comments
None.
********
Public Hearing
Mayor Steves opened the public hearing on the Fiscal Year 2013-2014 Tentative
Budget for comment.
Joan Frankel, 11 Rectory Lane, representing the League of Women Voters gave the
following report:
“The League of Women Voters of Scarsdale (the “League” or “LWVS”) held a
membership meeting on Monday, April 1, 2013 to evaluate the 2013-2014 Tentative
Village Budget. We thank Village Manager Al Gatta, Village Treasurer Mary Lou McClure
and Trustee Stacey Brodsky for attending the meeting and addressing our questions
related to the proposed budget, as well as potential issues going forward.
The League supports the proposed FY 2013-14 budget and commends the
Village staff, former Mayor Miriam Levitt Flisser, the Board of Trustees (the “Board”)
and it’s Finance Committee for a budget that meets the stated goal of continuing to
provide services to the community at a level consistent with prior years while minimizing
spending. The League understands that it was necessary for the Board to vote to allow an
increase in the 2013-14 budget that exceeds the state-mandated 2% tax cap. The
estimated non-controllable costs of pension and health insurance in this budget account
for an increase of $877,065 while the dollar amount over the tax cap is $538,209. The
increase in the pension payment alone accounts for almost the entire amount in excess of
the cap. The combination of the pension increase and the health insurance increase more
than accounts for the excess over the cap.
Deferral of Capital Maintenance Projects and Maintaining Municipal Service
Levels
We thank the Village for its capital planning to maintain debt service as level as
possible. However, the League has concerns about the continued deferral of capital
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 95
maintenance projects. We recognize that this is a result of the efforts to minimize
property tax increases in this current economic environment; however, it is not always
prudent to continue to forego necessary maintenance and improvement projects.
We recognize that the Village has walked a tight rope to maintain the current level
of municipal services while reigning in tax increases, despite the substantial increases in
uncontrollable costs, such as pension and health insurance costs. We understand the
Village’s decision to defer capital expenditures during these trying economic times.
However, we urge the Board to look critically at the potential ramifications of continued
deferral of capital improvements. While we note the Board and the Village administration
have strived to maintain services at the level to which residents are accustomed, we
suggest that the Board reconsider whether the desire to maintain service levels should be
the overriding determinant of budgetary decisions. We believe a reexamination of
priorities may be useful at this time.
The League is pleased to learn that Mayor Steves plans to engage the community
in conversation to identify the services residents want and what we are willing to pay for,
whether residents want to maintain Scarsdale as a “Village in the Park” and at what cost.
The League has a strong interest in participating in a study, conducted with community
input, regarding the continuation of a level of 2 services that are perceived to distinguish
Scarsdale as a beautiful milieu with a small town community aura with attendant benefits,
such as bi-weekly sanitation collection, leaf collection, park maintenance, summer
concerts and Fourth of July fireworks.
We note with concern that several union contracts (the Teamsters Public Works,
Teamsters Trades, UFFA Firefighters, CSEA Clerical & Technical, and PBA) have
already expired or will expire at the end of May 2013. In these cases, existing contract
terms are retained until new contract terms are reached; however, the budget does not
account for any retroactive obligations that may result from new contract terms.
Sanitary Sewer Service Fee
The League endorses the establishment of a Sanitary Sewer Fee. The League
agrees that a designated fee, rather than a tax, will provide much-needed funds specifically
targeted to maintain this vital part of Scarsdale’s infrastructure. Parts of our 85-mile
sanitary sewer system date back ninety years, with a twenty-five year life expectancy. With
a potential for dangerous environmental impacts as well as possible penalties from New
York State for sanitary sewage waste seepage into the storm water system, it is imperative
to have designated funds to repair, replace and maintain this system.
The League also supports the stated goal that setting the Sanitary Sewer Service
Fee based on water usage may increase awareness of residents about their water usage
and perhaps encourage residents to conserve. We believe that a fee of $.30 per unit of
water used, resulting in an estimated average annual fee of $60 per average residential
property owner (based on the average current annual usage of 200 units of water or
149,800 gallons) is reasonable. The estimate is $360 for commercial establishments.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 96
Tax Reassessment
The League commends the Village for expeditiously moving forward with the
property revaluation project. We are encouraged that Village management reports its
satisfaction that, at this time, Tyler Technologies has collected data from 60 to 65% of
Scarsdale homes with interior access to approximately 50% of these homes. The
assessments are expected to be finalized in 2014 and put into effect with the 2015 tax
bills. The League strongly encourages the Village to continue to keep its residents
apprised of the progress of and the forecast timeline for the property revaluation project.
Storm Drainage Projects
The League encourages the continuation of the storm drainage projects such as
the Sheldrake River Drainage project. We commend the Village management for taking
the initiative to seek grants whenever possible.
The League greatly appreciates the assistance and cooperation that was extended
to us in our study of the proposed budget. We commend the professionalism and
diligence with which the Village Manager, Treasurer, former Mayor Levitt Flisser and the
Trustees approached the budget development process. Thank you for considering our
comments as you finalize the budget.”
Mayor Steves thanked the League for its work on the Budget.
As there were no further comments, Mayor Steves closed the public hearing at
this time.
********
Mayor Steves stated that before the agenda item of Public Comments is opened,
due to concerns regarding the DAS process where an email was received from a number
of people, the Board thought it would be helpful to outline where the Board believes the
process is now and what the efforts of the Village are with respect to the DAS process.
In anticipation of public comment regarding this subject, Mayor Steves requested that
Trustee Brodsky address this with the following statement:
Trustee Brodsky read the following statement:
“Questions have been raised in an email that is circulating in the Village about a
proposed amendment to the zoning code relating to distributed antenna systems
(“DAS”). This statement is an effort to explain the process that is underway with respect
to this proposal. It is important to state at the outset that no change can be made to the
zoning code without a process that provides ample opportunity for community input.
Crown Castle Corporation (“CCC”) has proposed to amend Village zoning laws
to allow for the installation of DAS technology in Scarsdale. For simplicity’s sake, in this
statement, the entity that is proposing these changes is consistently called CCC. The
original corporate applicant was Next G, which was acquired by CCC shortly after the
initial application was filed.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 97
A DAS system is different from traditional wireless facilities that are typically
located on tall cell towers. DAS uses smaller wireless antennas, sometimes referred to as
nodes, that can be installed on existing or new utility poles, such as the Con Edison or
Verizon poles that stand in the right of ways (“ROW”) along roads, or on existing
monopoles, building roofs, or other structures. CCC builds and installs DAS
infrastructure, including the antennas and fiber connecting the antennas, for the delivery
of broadband services. CCC leases its DAS infrastructure to wireless providers.
Under the existing zoning code, a wireless telecommunications facility cannot be
located within 350 feet of “the nearest dwelling unit, school, day-care center, or place of
worship as measured from the base of the support structure.” Scarsdale Village Code Sec.
310-79D(2). CCC seeks to distinguish DAS from other wireless facilities and to allow
installation of its nodes within the Village ROW.
Federal law governs telecommunications issues. Local municipalities are barred
from prohibiting an entity’s ability to provide telecommunications services on any basis
that discriminates between one entity and another with respect to the management of the
local ROW or the regulation of the entity by means of other police powers. New York
State law provides that a utility company must seek the consent of the local government
to use the ROW. CCC has registered itself in New York State as “facilities-based provider
and reseller of telephone services” and, as such, is claiming the right under federal law to
be able to install its infrastructure in the Village ROW.
There are many other federal and state laws and standards that are implicated by
any proposed amendments to the zoning code that would involve DAS technology. As is
obvious, this is a complex issue that has already been extensively studied by the Planning
Board and continues to be studied. The following is a brief chronology of what has taken
place to date.
In late 2010, CCC approached the Village with a proposal to install DAS facilities
within the Village ROW. Because this proposal did not meet the 350 foot distance
requirement in the Village code, the issue was tabled. In late 2011, CCC submitted a
proposed amendment to the zoning code to allow the installation of DAS technology
within the Village ROW. This proposed amendment was submitted to the Village and
considered by the Village Board on February 13, 2012. On that date, as is the case with
all proposed amendments to the zoning code, the Village Board referred these proposed
amendments to the Planning Board for review and recommendation.
The Planning Board first considered the referral of the proposed amendments at
its March 21, 2012 meeting. At that meeting, CCC representatives made a presentation
about DAS technology, the proposed amendments to the code, and its intention to seek
to install DAS nodes at 15 locations in Scarsdale. In response to this presentation, the
Planning Board sought additional information from CCC and decided to schedule a
separate work session, which was then held on May 7, 2012.
To assist the Planning Board in understanding the framework of federal and state
laws that are implicated by this proposal, the Planning Board requested the assistance of
an attorney who specializes in telecommunications law. The Village retained Mr. Joe Van
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 98
Eaton of Best, Best & Kreiger, to advise the Planning Board.
At the May 7, 2012 work session, Mr. Van Eaton explained the applicable laws
and issues to the Planning Board. Mr. Van Eaton’s presentation is available on the Village
website. CCC representatives also spoke at the meeting. The Planning Board then
requested that the Village retain an engineering firm to evaluate the wireless coverage and
the potential to use existing sites for the DAS nodes without amending the zoning code.
The Village retained Columbia Telecommunications Corp. (“CTC”), a firm with extensive
experience advising municipalities in wireless matters.
CTC submitted a report dated December 12, 2012, that was transmitted to the
Planning Board in January 2013. A copy of CTC’s report is also available on the Village
website.
On February 13, 2013, the Planning Board held another work session at which
Mr. Lee Afflerbach of CTC presented CTC’s report. Mr. Van Eaton made a second
presentation, and this presentation is also available on the Village site. At the end of the
meeting, the Planning Board requested that Mr. Van Eaton inform them of policy
options and draft specific zoning language, which the Board could review at a future
work session, that is anticipated to be scheduled later this spring.
Without notice to the Village about their activities, over a period of some months
up to February 2013, CCC installed five DAS antennas on locations on New York State
ROW:
Rte. 22 at Edgewood Road
Rte. 22 at Richbell Road
Rte. 22 at Rugby Lane
Rte. 125 at Secor Road
Rte. 125 at 60 Palmer Road.
According to CCC, these installations are in lieu of five specific locations that it
had requested in the Village ROW. When the Village learned of these installations –
through the complaints of residents – it requested that the New York State Public Service
Commission determine whether CCC’s actions comply with New York State law and
with CCC’s Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity. If these installations are not
in compliance with the law, Scarsdale will have the opportunity to seek a remedy.
Scarsdale will also continue its careful review of the proposal to amend the zoning code.
As has been the case with all Planning Board meetings and study sessions to date, future
meetings about the proposed amendments will be publicly noticed and publicly held. In
addition, no amendment to the Village Code can take place without a public hearing
before the Village Board. Residents have spoken at the meetings that have already been
held and are welcome at all future meetings.
The email correctly notes that federal law expressly prohibits municipalities from
considering health concerns when determining whether to allow a telecommunications
installation. However, aesthetic guidelines, including the appearance of any antenna,
equipment, newly installed poles, height, and separation of nodes and poles, may be
addressed through local zoning. Additionally, under existing law, all wireless installations
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 99
require a Special Use Permit from the Planning Board. Applications for such permits are
all publicly noticed and considered at public hearings. Factors that are considered by the
Planning Board in issuing such Special Use Permits include what, if any, coverage gaps
exist in Scarsdale for any wireless provider that seeks to install antennas or related
equipment. Even if the zoning code were amended to permit DAS installations on the
Village ROW, applications for each such installation would require the same notice and
public hearing process that presently exists.
In short, the process triggered by the proposed zoning amendments related to
DAS technology is ongoing and any decision-making by the Village Board will only occur
after the issues raised have been fully vetted and comments from all parties have been
heard and taken into account.”
Mayor Steves stated the Board will make every effort to keep the public informed
of the progress as they work through this issue. This is a complicated issue as there are a
number of regulatory layers involved. It is clear from Trustee Brodsky’s comments that
between the Planning Board, Village Board, and the staff, we are on top of this issue and
any questions should be directed to him at Mayor@scarsdale.com or any of the Trustees
or the Village Manager, and a response will be given.
********
Public Comment
Lewis Arlt, 45 Popham Road, representing the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce,
stated that the 2013 Fine Arts Festival will be held on May 18th and May 19th. He
encouraged the Board to approve the resolution on this evening’s agenda for the
proposed Fine Arts Festival. Organized by Paragon Fine Art Festivals, a wide array of
juried fine art from around the country will be on display. The festival will be staged as it
was last year on Chase Road in front of Chase Park and on Woodland Place adjacent to
the park. The Chamber of Commerce feels that this location continues to provide a
beneficial combination of easy access to the Village Center shops as well as a green, tree
shaded setting. He thanked the Board for their support in the past and asked for their
continued support this year.
Mayor Steves noted that there is a resolution on the Board’s agenda this evening
to approve this event.
As there were no further comments, Mayor Steves closed the public comments
portion of the meeting.
********
Mayor Steves and the Board of Trustees
ANNUAL MEETING RESOLUTIONS
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 100
The Mayor hereby appoints Trustee Jonathan Mark as Deputy Mayor, Trustee
Katherine Eisenman as Police Commissioner and Trustee Stacey Brodsky as Fire
Commissioner.
****************
The Mayor also appoints the following Board of Trustee Committee assignments:
Finance Committee Land Use Committee Law Committee
Trustee Brodsky, CH Trustee Mark, CH Trustee Lee, CH
Trustee Mark Trustee Eisenman Trustee Brodsky
Trustee Martin Trustee Stern
Municipal Services Personnel Committee Recreation Committee
Committee Trustee Martin, CH Trustee Lee, CH
Trustee Eisenman, CH Trustee Lee Trustee Eisenman
Trustee Stern Trustee Martin
Sustainability Committee Agenda Committee
Trustee Stern, CH Mayor Steves, CH
Trustee Eisenman All Trustees
The Mayor is an ex-officio member of all committees.
****************
The Mayor announces the following liaison assignments:
Eisenman: Conservation Advisory Council, Friends of the Scarsdale Parks
Mark: Board of Ethics, Board of Architectural Review; Planning Board; Board of
Appeals, Committee for Historic Preservation
Brodsky: Judicial Qualifications Advisory Committee, Village Historian, Library Board,
Scarsdale League of Women Voters, Junior League of Central Westchester
Lee: Advisory Council on Parks and Recreation, Scarsdale Edgemont Family
Counseling, Advisory Council on Youth, Task Force on Drugs and Alcohol, Scarsdale
Teen Center, Advisory Council on Scarsdale Senior Citizens, Scouts
Martin: Town Board of Assessment Review, Council on People with Disabilities, SVAC,
Scarsdale Arts Council
Stern: Advisory Council on Technology, Cable Television Commission, Advisory
Council on Human Relations, Chamber of Commerce
Steves: Board of Education, Westchester Municipal Officials Association
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 101
Mayor Steves pointed out that the liaison assignments insure a flow of
information between the Board of Trustees and its valuable Boards and Councils.
********
The Mayor announces the following Neighborhood Association assignments:
Eisenman: Arthur Manor, Drake Edgewood, Heathcote
Mark: Overhill, West Quaker Ridge, Greenacres
Brodsky: Colonial Acres, Secor Farms, Fox Meadow
Lee: Sherbrook Park, Old Scarsdale, Murray Hill/Middle Heathcote
Martin: Bramlee Heights, Crane-Berkeley-in-Scarsdale
Stern: East Heathcote, Quaker Ridge, Scarsdale Meadows
Steves: SNAP
********
RESOLVED, that pursuant to the provisions of Section 57-1 of the Village
Code, Alfred A. Gatta is hereby appointed Village Manager for the current official year,
and be it further
********
RESOLVED, that pursuant to the provisions of Section 57-1 of the Village Code,
Stephen M. Pappalardo is hereby appointed Assistant Village Manager for
the current official year.
Pursuant to provisions of Section 57-3 of the Village Code, the Village Manager
hereby designates Stephen M. Pappalardo as Deputy Village Manager.
********
The Village Clerk states that pursuant to the provisions of Section 4-402 of
Village Law, and the opinion of the State Comptroller 362, 1960, she hereby appoints
Veronica Regazzi as Deputy Village Clerk for the current official year.
********
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 4-400 of the Village Law, the Mayor
hereby appoints Maria Colotti as Deputy Village Treasurer for the current official
year.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 102
RESOLVED, that the appointment of Maria Colotti as Deputy Village Treasurer for the
current official year is hereby approved.
********
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 4-400 of the Village Law, the Mayor
hereby appoints Wayne Esannason as Village Attorney for the current official year.
RESOLVED, that the appointment of Wayne Esannason as Village Attorney for the
current official year is hereby approved.
********
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 3-301 and 4-400 of the Village Law, the
Mayor hereby appoints Arlene Katz as Acting Village Justice for the current official year.
RESOLVED, that the re-appointment of Arlene Katz as Acting Village Justice for the
current official year is hereby approved.
********
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 11-c. of the New York State Domestic
Relations Law, the Mayor hereby appoints Miriam Levitt Flisser and Carolyn Stevens as
Marriage Officers for a two-year term ending April 6, 2015.
RESOLVED, that the Marriage Officers shall receive no compensation for performing
their duties, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the appointment of Miriam Levitt Flisser and Carolyn Stevens as
Marriage Officers for two-year terms ending April 6, 2015 or until such
time as a successor is appointed, is hereby confirmed.
********
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 4-400 of the Village Law, the Mayor hereby
appoints Eric Rothschild to serve as Village Historian for the current official year.
RESOLVED, that the appointment of Eric Rothschild to serve as Village Historian for a
term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is appointed, is
hereby approved.
********
The Mayor hereby appoints Barbara Josselsohn as a member of the Scarsdale Arts
Council for a term ending April 6, 2015 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 103
Further, the Mayor hereby re-appoints Edward Morgan and Joan E. S. Uchitelle
as members of said Council for terms ending April 6, 2015 or until such time as a
successor is appointed.
Further, the Mayor hereby appoints Edward Morgan as Chair of said Council for
a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
********
The Mayor hereby appoints William Ortner and Vanessa Brosgol as members of
the Judicial Qualifications Advisory Committee for terms ending April 2, 2018 or
until such time as a successor is appointed, and
Further, the Mayor hereby re-appoints Roger Brandwein as a member of said
Committee for a term ending April 2, 2018 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
Further, the Mayor hereby appoints Paul Pickelle as Chair of said Committee for
a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Mayor Steves, and seconded by Trustee Mark, the
aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
********
Trustee Mark:
RESOLVED, that the regular meetings of the Board of Trustees of the Village of
Scarsdale for 2013-2014 be held in Rutherford Hall in Village Hall, located
on Post Road, between Crane and Popham Roads, on the second and
fourth Tuesdays of each month at 8:00 p.m. except during the months of
July, August, and December, and that special meetings may be called by
the Mayor as necessary, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the meetings for the months of July, August, September, December
2013, and March 2014 will be as follows:
July 9, 2013 8:00 P.M.
July 23, 2013 8:30 A.M. (Limited Agenda)
August 13, 2013 8:00 P.M.
August 27, 2013 8:30 A.M. (Limited Agenda)
December 10, 2013 8:00 P.M.
December 24, 2013 8:30 A.M. (Limited Agenda)
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 104
March 11, 2014 8:00 P.M.
March 25, 2014 8:30 P.M.
and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Agenda Committee of the Board of Trustees shall meet 30
minutes prior to every scheduled meeting of the Board, and be it further
RESOLVED, that The Scarsdale Inquirer is hereby designated the official Village
newspaper, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Wells Fargo Bank, JP Morgan Chase, HSBC Bank and the
Cooperative Liquid Assets Security System (CLASS administered by First
Southwest/J.P. Morgan Asset Management) are hereby designated as
official depositories of the funds of the Village of Scarsdale; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that pursuant to Section 10 of the General Municipal Law, the maximum
amount which may be kept on deposit at each bank be set at $60 million,
and the maximum amount which may be invested in CLASS and any
other secured money market investment fund be set at $15 million.
********
BOARD OF ETHICS
RESOLVED, that Jason Rifkin and Soknan Han Jung are hereby appointed to serve as
members of the Board of Ethics for terms ending April 2, 2018 or until
such time as a successor is appointed.
RESOLVED, that Mary Lou McClure is hereby re-appointed to serve as a member of
said Board for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time as a
successor is appointed.
RESOLVED, that Evelyn Stock is hereby appointed to serve as Chair of said
Board for a term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
********
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
RESOLVED, that Jack Scott Miller is hereby appointed to serve as a member of the
Board of Architectural Review for a term ending April 4, 2016 or until
such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 105
RESOLVED, that Bana Choura is hereby appointed to serve as a member of said Board
to fill the unexpired term of Richard Kadin, ending April 6, 2015 or until
such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Farley Baker is hereby re-appointed to serve as a member of said
Board for a term ending April 4, 2016 or until such time as a successor is
appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Carl Finger is hereby appointed to serve as an alternate member for a
term ending April 4, 2016 or until such time as a successor is appointed,
and be it further
RESOLVED, that Georgene Mongarella is hereby re-appointed to serve as an alternate
member for a term ending April 4, 2016 or until such time as a successor
is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Farley Baker is hereby re-appointed to serve as Chair of said Board
for a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
********
PLANNING BOARD
RESOLVED, that James Blum and Tom Longman are hereby appointed to serve as
members of the Planning Board for terms ending April 2, 2018, or until
such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Marc Samwick is hereby appointed to serve as an alternate member
of said Board for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time as a
successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Seth Ross is hereby appointed to serve as Chair of said Board for a
term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is appointed.
********
BOARD OF APPEALS
RESOLVED, that Mary Lou Green is hereby appointed to serve as a member of
the Board of Appeals for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time
as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Jonathan Drescher is hereby re-appointed to serve as Chair of said
Board for a term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
********
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 106
COMMITTEE FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION
RESOLVED, that Abigail Olsen and William Silverman are hereby appointed as
members of the Committee for Historic Preservation for terms ending
April 4, 2016, or until such time as successors are appointed, and be it
further
RESOLVED, that Paul Diamond is hereby re-appointed as a member of said
Committee for a term ending April 4, 2016, or until such time as a
successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Jennifer Constantin is hereby re-appointed to serve as an alternate
member of said Committee for a term ending April 4, 2016, or until such
time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Paul Diamond is hereby appointed Chair of said Committee for a
term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Eisenman, and seconded by Trustee
Brodsky, the aforementioned resolution and appointments were approved by a
unanimous vote.
********
Trustee Eisenman:
CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
RESOLVED, that Laura Porosoff and Arthur Newman are hereby appointed to serve as
members of the Conservation Advisory Council for terms ending April 6,
2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Robert Falk is hereby appointed to serve as a member of said Council
to fill the unexpired term of David Silberstein for a term ending April 7,
2014, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Lee Fischman, Lena Crandell, Jeannie Mackler, and Julie Weinstein
are hereby re-appointed to serve as members of said Council for terms
ending April 6, 2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed, and
be it further
RESOLVED, that Lee Fischman is hereby appointed as Chair of said Council for a term
ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Brodsky, and seconded by Trustee Mark, the
aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 107
********
Trustee Brodsky:
LIBRARY BOARD
RESOLVED, that Terri Singer is hereby appointed to serve as a member of the Library
Board for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time as a successor is
appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Joan Bowen is hereby re-appointed to serve as a member of said
Board for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Brodsky, and seconded by Trustee Mark, the
aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
********
Trustee Stern:
ADVISORY COUNCIL ON TECHNOLOGY
RESOLVED, that Michael Goldstein and Neil Pierson are hereby appointed as
members of the Advisory Council on Technology for terms ending April
6, 2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Bruce Wells, Paul Goldstein, Scott Rampala, and Randy
Guggenheimer are hereby re-appointed as members of said Council for
terms ending April 6, 2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed,
and be it further
RESOLVED, that Bruce Wells is hereby re-appointed as Chair of said Council for a
term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is appointed.
********
CABLE TELEVISION COMMISSION
RESOLVED, that Drew Hahn is hereby appointed to serve as a member of the Cable
Television Commission for a term ending April 2, 2018, or until such time
as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Lorayne Fiorillo is hereby re-appointed to serve as Chair of said
Commission for a term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a
successor is appointed.
********
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 108
ADVISORY COUNCIL ON HUMAN RELATIONS
RESOLVED, that Margery Arsham, Alfredo Gonzalez, Jiyon Lee, Kathy Steves, and
Jonathan Tamir are hereby re-appointed as members of the Advisory
Council on Human Relations for terms ending April 6, 2015 or until such
time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Michael Duncanson is hereby re-appointed as Chair of said Council
for a term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Mark, and seconded by Trustee Eisenman,
the aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
********
Trustee Lee:
ADVISORY COUNCIL ON PARKS AND RECREATION
RESOLVED, that Tara Greco and Nicholas Black are hereby appointed as members of
the Advisory Council on Parks and Recreation for terms ending April 6,
2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Gerard Varlotta, Shawn Singer, and Rochelle Waldman are hereby re-
appointed as members of said Council for terms ending April 6, 2015 or
until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Gerard Varlotta is hereby appointed as Chair of said Council for a
term ending April 7, 2014, or until such time as a successor is appointed.
********
ADVISORY COUNCIL ON YOUTH
RESOLVED, that Alexis Arinsburg and Robin Schiff are hereby appointed to serve as
members of the Advisory Council on Youth for terms ending April 6,
2015 or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Scott Altabet, Scott Bookner and Sheri Wolfe are hereby re-
appointed to serve as members of said Council for terms ending April 6,
2015 or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Evan Gross is hereby re-appointed to serve as Chair of said
Council for a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor
is appointed.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 109
********
ADVISORY COUNCIL ON SCARSDALE SENIOR CITIZENS
RESOLVED, that Eda Newhouse is hereby appointed to serve as a member of the
Advisory Council on Scarsdale Senior Citizens for a term ending April 6,
2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Carol Silverman, Norman Alterman, Janice Cohen, Barbara Greebel,
Eunice Laughlin, Anita Malina, Jane Nussbaum, Dino Venuto, and Judy
Watiker are hereby re-appointed to serve as members of said Council for
terms ending April 6, 2015, or until such time as a successor is appointed,
and be it further
RESOLVED, that Carol Silverman is hereby appointed to serve as Chair of said Council
for a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time as a successor is
appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Lee, and seconded by Trustee Eisenman, the
aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
********
Trustee Martin:
COUNCIL ON PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES
RESOLVED, that Norma Litman is hereby appointed to serve as a member of the
Council on People with Disabilities for a term ending April 6, 2015, or
until such time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Marc Carter and Sue Adams are hereby re-appointed to serve as
members of said Council for terms ending April 6, 2015, or until such
time as a successor is appointed, and be it further
RESOLVED, that Marc Carter is hereby appointed to serve as Chair of said Council for
a term ending April 7, 2014 or until such time a successor is appointed.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Martin, and seconded by Trustee Eisenman,
the aforementioned appointments were approved by a unanimous vote.
********
Mayor Steves stated that this is a good time to reflect on the wealth and depth of
the volunteers in this community. This is a theme he plans to hit on through this year –
this Village is great and it is because of the number of volunteers. These volunteers don’t
look for recognition. However, the community can get a sense from the number of
appointments this evening of what it takes to make this community work and of the
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 110
people who come out and volunteer. On behalf of the Board, Mayor Steves extended his
thanks for their willingness to serve.
********
Law Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Brodsky, and seconded by Trustee Eisenman, the
following resolution regarding an Amendment to the Lease Agreement with Metro-North
Commuter Railroad was adopted by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Metro-North Commuter Railroad (Metro-North) or its
predecessors lease from the Village of Scarsdale (Village)
approximately 1,200 square feet of space in the Scarsdale Railroad
Station for use as a ticket office and waiting room in conjunction
with their railroad operation; and
WHEREAS, the original lease agreement, dated September 29, 1961, has been
amended three times to address permitted uses of the leased
space, including subleasing, and trash removal; and
WHEREAS, the terms of the lease agreement and amendments allow Metro-
North to sublease 250 square feet of the leased space for a bank
or newsstand provided that one half of the rent received is paid to
the Village; and
WHEREAS, based on the use limitations for this subleased space, Metro-North
has been unable to locate a tenant and the space has been vacant
for a number of years, and as such, Metro-North recently
requested that the Village amend the lease agreement to allow for
any and all uses permitted under the Village Zoning Code; and
WHEREAS, the Village Attorney considered this request and has drafted a
fourth amendment to the agreement, attached hereto and made a
part hereof; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute the
Fourth Amendment to the Village of Scarsdale lease agreement
dated September 29, 1961 with the Metro-North Commuter
Railroad on behalf of the Village of Scarsdale and undertake all
associated administrative acts.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Brodsky None None
Trustee Eisenman
Trustee Lee
Trustee Mark
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 111
Trustee Martin
Trustee Stern
Mayor Steves
********
Municipal Services
Upon motion entered by Trustee Eisenman, and seconded by Trustee Mark, the
following resolution regarding the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce Fine Arts Festival was
adopted by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce has requested permission to
hold a Fine Arts Festival in the Village Center on Saturday, May
18 and Sunday, May 19, 2013; and
WHEREAS, this event will require the authorized use of Chase Park and the
partial closure of Woodlands Place roadway from Chase Road to a
point 300ft northeast (midblock) and Chase Road between
Spencer Place and Christie Place; and
WHEREAS, the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce hosted a similar event in
2012 and the proposed location and event layout is a result of
recommendations from local merchants, residents and Village
staff and are substantially the same as the past show; and
WHEREAS, the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce membership
overwhelmingly supports the 2013 Fine Arts Festival with
additional support expressed by other Village Center merchants;
and
WHEREAS, participants in the Fine Arts Festival agree to furnish public
liability insurance in a form and amount satisfactory to the Village
Attorney naming the Village of Scarsdale as an additional insured
against any and all claims, damages, or causes of action resulting
from the use of Village owned land; and
WHEREAS, all other licenses, permits for tents, assembly, amusement devices
and sale of food must be secured by merchants and vendors prior
to the event in accordance with applicable laws; and
WHEREAS, the Village will be reimbursed for any additional costs incurred in
conjunction with the Fine Arts Festival, including, but not limited
to, Police personnel, DPW personnel and Fire and Building
Inspectors, as indicated on the Event Permit form; and
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 112
WHEREAS, upon completion of the event, the participants will restore all
public areas utilized to the same condition as existed before the
Fine Arts Festival; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce is hereby authorized to
utilize the Village-owned Chase Park, Woodlands Place roadway
from Chase Road to a point 300ft northeast (midblock) and Chase
Road between Spencer Place and Christie Place, for the purpose
of holding the Westchester Festival of the Arts on Saturday, May
18 and Sunday, May 19, 2013, conditioned on the timely receipt of
all aforementioned insurances, licenses and permits; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is authorized to execute the attached
Village Event Permit form and subsequent terms and conditions
in substantially the same form as attached hereto and made a part
hereof, subject to a deposit of $1,500.00 by Paragon Fine Arts
Festival for additional Police personnel, DPW personnel and Fire
and Building Inspectors; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the $125.00 tent permit fee in conjunction with the Fine Arts
Festival is herein waived by the Village Board subject to the event
organizer filing an application with the Fire Department and
obtaining subsequent approval pursuant to an inspection by the
Fire Inspector and other authorized Department personnel.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Brodsky None None
Trustee Eisenman
Trustee Lee
Trustee Mark
Trustee Martin
Trustee Stern
Mayor Steves
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Eisenman, and seconded by Trustee Brodsky, the
following resolution regarding VM Contract #1147 – Furnish and Deliver One (1) or more
Leaf Machines(s), Leaf Vacuum Machine Parts and Leaf Collection Boxes was adopted by
the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale through its Public Works Department
annually collects fall leaves from Village residences, and
WHEREAS, this leaf program necessitates the annual purchase of one (1) or
more leaf vacuum machines or metal leaf boxes, as well as the
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 113
annual purchase of leaf vacuum machines parts to assist in the
collection of the leaves, and
WHEREAS, staff developed VM Contract #1147 - Furnish and Deliver One
(1) or More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Leaf Vacuum Machine
Parts & Leaf Collection Boxes, which included three separate
proposals: Proposal A – Furnish and Deliver One (1) or More
Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Proposal B – Leaf Vacuum Machine
Parts, and Proposal C – Furnish and Deliver Leaf Boxes; and
WHEREAS, the Village Manager reports that he publicly advertised for the
receipt of bids for VM Contract #1147 - Furnish and Deliver One
(1) or More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Leaf Vacuum Machine
Parts & Leaf Collection Boxes on March 1, 2013 and sent bid
proposals to three (3) vendors and placed the contract on BidNet,
and
WHEREAS, on April 2, 2013, the bid opening date, three individual companies
responded, and
WHEREAS, there was one bid received for Proposal A, one bid received for
Proposal B and two bids received for Proposal C, with the
apparent low bid received for Proposal “C” deemed non-
compliant with the bid specifications; and
WHEREAS, the sole responsible bidder meeting bid specifications for Proposal
“A” – Furnish and Deliver One (1) or More Leaf Vacuum
Machine(s), was Trius, Inc., 458 Johnson Avenue, P.O. Box 158,
Bohemia, NY 11716, for the unit bid price of $30,820.00, and
WHEREAS, the sole responsible bidder meeting bid specifications for Proposal
“B” – Leaf Vacuum Machine Parts, was Old Dominion Brush
Company (ODB), 5118 Glen Alden Drive, Richmond, VA 23231,
at the unit bid prices identified on the attached Bid Tabulation
Sheet; and
WHEREAS, the sole responsible bidder meeting bid specifications for Proposal
“C” - Furnish and Deliver Leaf Boxes, was also ODB, for the unit
bid price of $4,874.00, and
WHEREAS, the Village has been satisfied with equipment previously
purchased from Trius, Inc. and ODB; and
WHEREAS, the contract term is three (3) years and subject to available budget
appropriations in the FY 2013/14 and FY 2014/15 Operating or
Capital Budgets, an additional leaf machine or leaf boxes may be
purchased pursuant to the contract; now therefore be it
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 114
RESOLVED, that Proposal “A” of VM Contract #1147 - Furnish and Deliver
One (1) or More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Leaf Vacuum Machine
Parts & Leaf Collection Boxes be awarded to the lowest
responsible bidder meeting bid specifications, Trius, Inc., 458
Johnson Avenue, P.O. Box 158, Bohemia, NY 11716, for the unit
bid price of $30,820.00; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the cost of the leaf machine be charged to FY 2012/13
General Fund Account # A-1490-HWY-LFCOL-200 20 and A-
1490-HWY-LFCOL-400-462 and charged to the same account(s)
for FY 2013/14 and FY 2014/15 subject to the availability of
adequate budget appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute Proposal
“A” of VM Contract #1147 - Furnish and Deliver One (1) or
More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Leaf Vacuum Machine Parts &
Leaf Collection Boxes on behalf of the Village of Scarsdale with
Trius, Inc., 458 Johnson Avenue, P.O. Box 158, Bohemia, NY
11716; and be it further
RESOLVED, that Proposal “B” and Proposal “C” of VM Contract #1147 -
Furnish and Deliver One (1) or More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s),
Leaf Vacuum Machine Parts & Leaf Collection Boxes be awarded
to the lowest responsible bidder meeting bid specifications, Old
Dominion Brush Company, 5118 Glen Alden Drive, Richmond,
VA 23231, at the unit bid prices identified on the Bid Tabulation
Sheet for Proposal “B”, attached hereto and made a part hereof,
not to exceed budget appropriations and for the unit bid price of
$4,874.00 for Proposal “C”; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the cost of the leaf vacuum machine parts be charged to FY
2012/13 General Fund Account A-1490-HWY-LFCOL-400-462
with the leaf collection boxes charged to # A-1490-HWY-
LFCOL-200 20 with said parts and boxes charged to the same
account(s) for FY 2013/14 and FY 2014/15 subject to the
availability of adequate budget appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute Proposal
“B” and Proposal “C” of VM Contract #1147 - Furnish and
Deliver One (1) or More Leaf Vacuum Machine(s), Leaf Vacuum
Machine Parts & Leaf Collection Boxes on behalf of the Village of
Scarsdale with Old Dominion Brush Company, 5118 Glen Alden
Drive, Richmond, VA 23231; and be it further
RESOLVED, that all contract awards and unit bid prices be held for three (3)
years; and be it further
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 115
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to undertake all
administrative acts as may be required under the terms of the
contract.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Brodsky None None
Trustee Eisenman
Trustee Lee
Trustee Mark
Trustee Martin
Trustee Stern
Mayor Steves
Trustee Eisenman noted after approval of this resolution that as you can see how
much money the Village is spending on collecting leaves, this is a good time to remind
everyone that the Village is trying very hard to get residents to recycle their leaves. The
Village will be recycling, mulching our leaves in all our twenty-six (26) parks in this year,
2013. The Village is setting a good example for its citizens. She asked residents to
request this of their gardeners. If they do it themselves, they should purchase a gator
blade and try mulching their own leaves. It is extremely easy and information is on line at
the Village website, www.scarsdale.com.
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Eisenman, and seconded by Trustee Lee, the
following resolution regarding VM Contract #1148 – Tree Stump Removal Services was
adopted by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, in accordance with the Village’s Trees Maintenance Program,
approximately 200 trees are removed from Village property on an
annual basis; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with said program, the Village contracts for the
removal/grinding of stumps from street trees removed from the
public right-of-way; and
WHEREAS, the Village has traditionally provided for these services with a
private contractor through a formal bid process, which was
completed for the last year through VM Contract #1128 – Tree
Stump Removal Services; and
WHEREAS, a new contract, VM# 1148- Tree Stump Removal Services was
developed; and
WHEREAS, on March 1, 2013, the Village Manager reports that he publicly
advertised for the receipt of bids under VM Contract # 1148 –
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 116
Tree Stump Removal Services and sent bid proposals to two
vendors and placed it on Bidnet.com; and
WHEREAS, on the March 26, 2013 bid opening date, four bids were received;
and
WHEREAS, the apparent low bid meeting the specifications of VM Contract #
1148 – Tree Stump Removal Services, was received from
Almstead Tree & Shrub Care Co, 58 Beechwood Avenue, New
Rochelle, NY 10801, at $88.00 per stump removed; and
WHEREAS, the term of the contract is for one (1) year with an option to
renew for two additional one (1) year periods at the same bid price
per stump; and
WHEREAS, the senior arborist of Almstead Tree & Shrub Care Co stated that
he understands the scope of work and is confident he can provide
the necessary tree stump removal services at the stated bid price
pursuant to the contract specifications; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract # 1148 – Tree Stump Removal Services, be
awarded to Almstead Tree & Shrub Care Co, 58 Beechwood
Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801, for the bid price of $88.00 per
stump removed; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the costs be charged to General Fund Account # A-1490-
HWY-SHDTR-400-458, not to exceed budgeted appropriations;
and be it further
RESOLVED, that pursuant to Section 2.12 of the Village Internal Control
Policy, the Village Manager is hereby authorized and directed to
execute VM Contract # 1148 – Tree Stump Removal Services on
behalf of the Village of Scarsdale with Almstead Tree & Shrub
Care Co, 58 Beechwood Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801; and
be it further
RESOLVED, that this contract may be extended by the Village Manager for two
additional one (1) year periods subject to the same bid price and to
the availability of adequate budget appropriations; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to undertake any
administrative acts required under the terms of the contract.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Brodsky None None
Trustee Eisenman
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 117
Trustee Lee
Trustee Mark
Trustee Martin
Trustee Stern
Mayor Steves
********
Recreation Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Lee, and seconded by Trustee Eisenman, the
following resolution to award VM Contract #1103 – Village Properties/Specialized Services
– Change order was adopted by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees at their meeting on March 22, 2011 adopted
a resolution awarding VM Contract # 1103 “Village Properties:
Applications/Specialized Services” to Almstead Tree and Shrub
Care Company (Almstead), 58 Beechwood Ave., New Rochelle,
N.Y. 10801; and
WHEREAS, the contract was for two years (2011 and 2012) with an option to
renew for one additional year, 2013, at the discretion of the Village
Manager; and
WHEREAS, each year to determine the protocol for the following year, soil
samples and related analysis is conducted by Osborne Organics.
Based on the results of the samples, recommendations are made
for the maintenance including fertilization, aeration, seeding,
additional work, and other related treatments keeping within our
organic protocol. The proposal prices are broken down by item to
allow for the most flexibility when putting together the program
for the following year; and
WHEREAS, in 2011, based on the soil sample results and recommendations by
Osborne Organics, the Village paid $44,591 for Almstead’s
services plus a change order in the amount of $5,460 for a grub
control application which was not included in the proposal, and
WHEREAS, in 2012, a protocol was developed and the Village paid $29,134.96
for their services and a change order for $5,125 for a grub control
application, and
WHEREAS, the total amount of change orders for this contract to date is
$10,585 and in accordance with the Internal Control Policy,
change order requests for contracts under $100,000 cannot exceed
$10,000 without Village Board approval, and
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 118
WHEREAS, Village staff met with Almstead Tree and Shrub Care
Company to discuss the protocol for the 2013 year and reviewed
the work and specifications, and
WHEREAS, for the 2013 season, the basic specialized services are estimated to
be $44,955.75 and the following additional work needs to be
included:
• Pool complex and Crossway 3 ball field; treatment to
reduce clover in the amount of $1,455,
• Scout field and Boulder Brook field ; perform additional
aeration, over seeding, supply and apply fertilizer in the
amount of $2,515,
• Memorial Garden; treatments for weeds, slice seeding,
core aeration with compost , and over seeding in the
amount of $3,951.86; and
WHEREAS, the total amount for the 2013 season is $44,955.75 plus $7,921.86
for additional work which totals $52,877.61; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Board approves the change order request
in the amount of $7,921.86 which will bring the total cost for 2013
to $52,877.61 with Almstead Tree and Shrub Care Company, 58
Beechwood Ave., New Rochelle, N.Y. 10801, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the contract which expires at the conclusion of 2013 be rebid
for the 2014 season.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Brodsky None None
Trustee Eisenman
Trustee Lee
Trustee Mark
Trustee Martin
Trustee Stern
Mayor Steves
********
Other Committee Reports
None.
********
Liaison Reports
None.
Village Board of Trustees 04-09-2013 P a g e | 119
********
Written Communications
None.
********
There being no further business to come before the Board, on a motion entered
by Mayor Steves, seconded by Trustee Eisenman and carried unanimously, the meeting
adjourned at 9:10 P.M.
Donna M. Conkling
Village Clerk
Get email alerts for Scarsdale
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.