Board of Trustees
Regular MeetingScarsdale, NY · October 24, 2017
Minutes
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 443
THREE THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED NINETY-FIRST
REGULAR MEETING
Rutherford Hall
Village Hall
October 24, 2017
A Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Village of Scarsdale was held in
Rutherford Hall in Village Hall on Tuesday, October 24, 2017 at 8:00 P.M.
Present were Mayor Hochvert, Trustees Callaghan, Finger, Pekarek, Ross, Samwick and
Veron. Also present were Acting Village Manager Richards, Village Attorney Esannason,
Deputy Village Attorney Garrison, Village Treasurer McClure, Village Clerk Conkling, and
Assistant to the Village Manager Ringel.
********
The minutes of the Board of Trustees Regular Meeting of Tuesday, October 10,
2017 were approved on a motion entered by Trustee Samwick, seconded by Trustee
Pekarek, and carried unanimously.
********
Bills & Payroll
Trustee Veron reported that she had audited the Abstract of Claims dated
October 24, 2017 in the amount of $1,798,636.18 which includes $49,206.08 in Library
Claims previously audited by a Trustee of the Library Board which were found to be in order
and she moved that such payment be ratified.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Veron and seconded by Trustee Pekarek, the
following resolution was adopted unanimously:
RESOLVED, that the Abstract of Claims dated October 24, 2017 in the amount of
$1,798,636.18 is hereby approved.
********
Mayor’s Comments
Mayor Hochvert stated that he noticed that the New York State Department of
Transportation, perhaps at the behest of Scarsdale legislators, not only paved part of the
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 444
right lane on Post Road from Drake Road up to Richbell Road, but they have now extended
the paving further north from Olmsted Road. This takes out the worst of the potholes
along the right-hand side of the northbound lane. The Village gives both Assemblywoman
Amy Paulin and Senator Andrea Stewart-Cousins credit for some of the work that has been
done.
Mayor Hochvert stated that he and Trustee Callaghan attended a firefighter event
honoring retirees and 20 year members of the force. He stated that Captain Capobianco,
who lives behind the Public Safety Building, stated that if the Village ever needs a volunteer
in Harwood Park, he is available.
This past Friday and Saturday were part of the ‘weekend of weddings’. Mayor
Hochvert noted that he performed two ceremonies on Friday and one on Saturday.
Mayor Hochvert stated that there was a sustainability meeting that Trustee Pekarek
and he attended, as well as School Administration members Duncan Wilson and Drew
Patrick. He noted that he sat next to the former principal of Fox Meadow School, Steve
Frantz.
Mayor Hochvert stated that a delegation of 20 people from Kyoto visited Village
Hall. They were brought here by a former resident of Edgemont that was stationed in the
United States. They heard about our system of government and wanted to understand how
our government works because they are considering changing theirs. Mayor Hochvert felt
that this was wonderful that they think so highly of the Village’s government that a
delegation of 20 people were sent to learn about the system.
Mayor Hochvert stated that directly after that meeting, he had a meeting with the
High School Seniors who are in the City 2.0 class. They had a very pleasant meeting in
Chase Park. The students asked questions about government and want to meet next week to
continue the discussion. Linking up with the younger generation in the Village is another
positive occurrence.
Mayor Hochvert stated that a meeting was held with the traffic consultant. He
noted that he had always thought one of the worst intersections in town is Popham
Road/Scarsdale Avenue/East Parkway. We are considering a delay in the southbound East
Parkway with a green arrow followed by a yellow arrow on the northbound Scarsdale
Avenue. As he watched the intersection and the behavior of the drivers, there may be no
lost time because when the right hand turners on southbound East Parkway run into the
northbound left turners on Scarsdale Avenue, there is a pause there and a delay one after
another as they juggle. If we can move a few of the left turners out of the way, there is a
smoother flow. They are looking into several issues and the improvement costs. They also
checked the conduit because the Village is considering a red light in the right hand lane of
Popham and Chase Roads. Many people run through the no turn on red sign, and with a
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 445
number of people coming out of 50 Popham and 45 Popham and crossing at the
intersection it would be good to have the red light right in front of the drivers. Too many
drivers ignore the sign for no turn on red.
Mayor Hochvert noted that there was a serious accident on Fenimore Road last
week. Someone was crossing the street in one of the crosswalks and was hit by a car. This
person is still heavily sedated in the hospital. The accident is being fully investigated by the
police.
At a parking meeting that Trustee Veron and he attended, Mayor Hochvert stated
that one of best things that happened afterwards was that the business manager for Rush
Wilson informed him that the retail empty spaces are down from 16 last year to 4. Mayor
Hochvert stated that great credit has to be given to 2 or 3 major efforts; he stated that
Trustee Veron has certainly led one of them, Susan Douglass, who chairs a committee of the
Forum is another one. It may be that this will lead to an increase in our parking difficulties
so we have to continue working on parking.
Mayor Hochvert reported that Trustees Pekarek, Callaghan and he attended a
meeting at the Scarsdale Library with the seniors – this was an event sponsored by the
Scarsdale Edgemont Family Counseling Service and the Advisory Council on Scarsdale
Senior Citizens. The room was filled with people who serve the community.
Mayor Hochvert noted that the Chair of the Municipal Services Committee of the
Forum was present this evening and is expected to speak about an upcoming survey during
Public Comment.
Mayor Hochvert thanked those in the community who have adhered to the
prohibition of placing leaves in the street. He read a note forwarded by Village Manager
Pappalardo regarding the fall leaf collection program. The Fall Leaf Collection Program
information was forwarded to the New York Turf and Landscape Association. Additionally,
DPW staff have personally contacted all of the landscapers currently on record to inform
them of the program’s dos and don’ts and advised them of the Village’s enforcement
procedures. Two separate notices were created and printed warning residents of the
consequences of improper placement of leaves in the street and placing materials other than
leaves in the pile placed for collection. Highway personnel in each of the seven leaf zone
routes will place these notices and keep a record to forward to the DPW administration staff
to update the master spreadsheet. As discussed at the earlier meeting, multiple offenders of
the Village Code will be flagged and issued a court appearance ticket. For the first offense, a
warning will be issued. However, after more than one offense, a ticket will be issued.
********
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 446
Manager’s Comments
Acting Village Manager Ingrid Richards gave the following report:
“Con Edison is installing a new gas main on Post Road, please be advised from
October 25th through October 28th, between 9 a.m. and 7 p.m., Fenimore Road at Post
Road will be closed to motorists traveling westbound, weather permitting. It is
recommended that motorists follow the advisory message boards and detour signs in and
around the area.
While police officers will be on site for traffic control, vehicles and pedestrians can
expect delays. Please allow extra time while traveling to this area or take an alternate route to
avoid delays.
Thank you to everyone who has taken time out of their busy schedule to attend
Scarsdale’s Farmers Market. The Village is proud to report that the outdoor Farmers Market
will be extended beyond October 26th to November 16th that means there will be three
additional outdoor farmers markets. To serve as a reminder the Farmers Market is held on
Thursdays between 12pm and 7 pm at Boniface Circle, we look forward to seeing you there.
It is my pleasure to report that the Village has received the Grant Disbursement
Agreement for the State and Municipalities Program grant also known as the SAM grant.
The funds from the SAM grant will be used to pay for expenses associated with the
renovation of the Supply Field Building, the soon to be home of Scarsdale’s Library Loft. As
you know, the Library Loft will serve as the temporary space for Library operations during
the Library Building’s renovation and addition project.
You may remember on September 26, 2017 the Board of Trustees authorized the
Village Manager to execute a contract with Peter A. Camilli & Sons located in Pleasantville
to proceed with the renovation of the Building.
The SAM grant provides required funds for the renovation, as such it is anticipated
that a resolution authorizing the Village Manager to execute the Grant Disbursement
Agreement with the Dormitory Authority of the State of New York will appear on the
November 14, 2017 Board of Trustees agenda for approval.
The Village is grateful to Assemblywoman Paulin for her efforts in securing the
funding for this project which is critical to the overall success of the Library renovation and
addition project.
Tonight, Mr. Daniel Heuberger, Principal from Dattner Architects is here to present
a status update on the design of the Library Building renovation and addition project to the
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 447
Board and the public. Ms. Greenwald, President of the Library Board, will provide a brief
introduction.”
********
Diane Greenwald, President of the Library Board, stated that members of the
Building Committee and Library Board are present this evening. They have been working
steadily all summer and fall, meeting at least a dozen times gathering feedback from the
community, engaging with local library experts, and asking tough questions of the
consultants. In the design process, the architect adds greater detail to the library’s schematic
design and they are better able to refine their cost estimates. With the support of their
construction manager from Savin Engineering, Paul Zaicek, Village Project Manager,
Elizabeth Bermel, Library Director, all members of the Building Committee, and everyone
here this evening, they remain comfortable that they are on track to meet their project
priorities. They have already made and are ready to make more difficult decisions that might
include reductions and substitutions. However, the lengthy process is working and is
ongoing. This evening they asked Daniel Heuberger of Dattner Architects to present the
most recent designs that provide a more developed sense of the renovation project. No
formal actions are required from the Village Board this evening.
Daniel Heuberger, of Dattner Architects presented a visual update on the Library
renovation and addition project. He noted that approximately one month ago the design
development phase was completed. This is the midpoint of the design process; they are
currently in the construction documents phase which is the final phase of design and that is
the time when the design is put into technical specifications and details which will then be
handed over to the construction manager. The construction manager will then bid the
project. Mr. Heuberger gave the Board and those present a brief overview of the current
status of the project in the form of a visual walk-thru of the library.
Trustee Samwick asked Mr. Heuberger if he could highlight any of the changes made
since the last presentation.
Mr. Heuberger stated that it would really be a question of detail rather than of kind –
he noted where some locations have been changed. The makerspace/technology center is
now on the lower level which combines a computer lab and a printing production room.
Some of the spaces have been reconfigured in the entranceway; however, these are minor
changes providing more storage space. The size of some of the meeting rooms have been
slightly changed. The staff areas have been moved into one central location and will have
direct access to the collection areas. For deliveries there will be curb drop off as is currently
done – they will not be coming through the main lobby.
Mr. Heuberger stated that they will be completing construction documents in late
January, after which the project will be put out to bid. The building will have to be abated
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 448
prior to construction, and then construction will begin. Those phases of the building will
have to be coordinated with the new temporary library so service is not interrupted.
Trustee Samwick inquired as to the status of the timeline for the library loft to be
located at the Supply Field building.
Paul Zaicek stated that construction will begin on October 30th. This is a five month
project; they plan to be finished by March 30th.
Mayor Hochvert asked Mr. Heuberger to explain to those present if he had specific
ideas of what equipment might be in the makers’ space in the basement level – would that
equipment be part of the project?
Mr. Heuberger stated that it would be and that they are still discussing what exactly
to put into that space. A makerspace is a glorified garage in a sense – a technically oriented
garage; basically a work bench, a storage space for equipment, and tables and chairs.
Mayor Hochvert asked Mr. Heuberger if he had an opportunity to look at the
makerspace at the high school.
Mr. Heuberger responded that he believed he has seen that space. He stated that the
proposed library makerspace is targeted for the same audience and it will be very familiar to
them.
Elizabeth Bermel, Library Director, stated that she is currently working with the
Westchester Library System and other libraries that have them. There is a full range of ages
that use the makerspace. She stated that they will put the infrastructure in that space and
move on from there as this is an ever-changing item.
Mayor Hochvert stated that we will have the opportunity to sync with the school
system because there is a makerspace to some degree in all of the elementary and middle
schools.
Ms. Greenwald added that a lot of adults are interested in makerspaces and may not
have access to the ones in the schools, so they will definitely welcome adults to come to the
library’s makerspace.
Trustee Pekarek inquired as to whether the construction documents are finished and
asked that she be walked through the construction documents, the land use boards, and the
bidding process.
Mr. Heuberger stated that very shortly they will be going to the Planning Board and
the Board of Architectural Review. Their site plans, which have to do with grading and
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 449
storm water management have been informally reviewed by the Village Engineer and they
will be formally presented shortly. After that, they will make whatever changes they need to
make in response to the comments. They will continue to work in parallel on the design of
the building. They are not done with the construction documents; they will not be done
until the end of January. At that point, they will have a complete biddable package of
documents that can be put out. That package will consist of their drawings and technical
specifications which are very detailed. The entire scope of the project will be described as
well as general conditions, how the contractor will work with the architect and construction
manager, etc.
Mr. Heuberger explained to Trustee Pekarek that the Planning Board is only
interested in certain aspects of the project – the way the building looks, the way it sits on the
site, how drainage is handled on the site, where utilities are running, and things of that
nature. That scope of the work is very close to completion. They have submitted the plans
and have been told what is expected on the plans.
Mr. Heuberger stated that they have just finished a cost estimate. A design
development cost estimate has been done and they feel that they are on target. They will be
doing another cost estimate at 75% construction document completion which will be
sometime in late November. Another cost estimate will be done at 100% construction
document completion.
Mayor Hochvert thanked Mr. Heuberger for his presentation.
********
Mayor Hochvert stated that there had been some discussion on closing streets for
Halloween. Some complex issues arose out of that discussion and he stated that he has
made a commitment to see if there is a path throughout the Village for such activity. One of
his first steps will be to have a discussion at the SNAP meeting on the first Monday of
November to see if it can be determined how many neighborhoods would like an area that is
closed to traffic. He has been told that there are some other municipalities that have done
some street closings and hopes to visit them and determine how they interpreted the State
regulations and how extensive their street closings are. The Village may find a path to do
something during Halloween 2018.
********
Trustee Committee and Liaison Reports
Trustee Ross reported that the Drake Edgewood Neighborhood Association will
shortly be up and running once again. The Association has been dormant for a number of
years but this past summer and fall at the Mayor’s request, he contacted a number of Drake
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 450
Edgewood residents in an effort to get things up and running again. The response was very
positive. There are a number of people interested in getting involved and possibly having
leadership roles in the Association. He encouraged any Drake Edgewood residents who
have not been contacted to get in touch. He can be reached at Seth.H.Ross@gmail.com and
he will include them on any distribution list and forward their contact information to the
leaders of the Association.
Trustee Samwick stated that the Freightway Steering Committee is having its third
public workshop on Monday, November 13th at 7 pm. The workshop is going to be held at
the Teen Center, 862 Scarsdale Avenue. He encouraged people to attend. Interested parties
can also visit the Village’s website for more information on the study as well as see videos of
the first two public workshops that have already taken place.
Trustee Samwick reported on the following evening, Tuesday, November 14th at 6
pm the Village Board is meeting with the Land Use Boards (Planning Board, Board of
Appeals and Board of Architectural Review) in the 3rd floor meeting room in Village Hall.
There will be a general discussion of land use issues which the land use boards encounter.
There have been a number of discussions over the years about how people feel about land
use in the Village. This is a very good opportunity to participate in that discussion.
Trustee Pekarek extended her thanks to the Scarsdale Police Department for their
successful detective work, vigilance, and patience in the arrest of the third participant in the
April 2017 burglary of an occupied residence in Scarsdale.
Trustee Pekarek next reported that the Conservation Advisory Council (CAC) is
doing a sanitation study. The purpose of the study is to review Scarsdale’s sanitation
operations and to provide recommendations to the Board of Trustees. The scope of the
study will include sanitation services, the what and how of collections, and their guiding
principles will be to increase recycling, reduce municipal waste, maintain a high level of
service and that the recommended changes will be fiscally sound. The finalization of this
report is anticipated to be very soon. The CAC is working very closely with DPW.
Trustee Pekarek stated as the Mayor mentioned earlier, they attended a meeting of
the Scarsdale School District Sustainability Committee to begin a conversation around an
essential question, that being how can Scarsdale Schools and the community engage in
sustainability as an enduring context for learning. Although there are many sustainability
practices and learning opportunities underway, one among them is the food waste
composting project. Co-chairs Duncan Wilson, the principal of Fox Meadow School, and
Drew Patrick, the Assistant Superintendent for Human Resources and Leadership
Development of the School District noted that this seems to be the right time to create a
District level coordinated effort to facilitate and communicate these experiences, look for
additional opportunities, and generate a framework for collective thinking about education
for sustainability within the schools and how it links to the community as a whole. Teachers,
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 451
school administrators, various representatives from the School and Village Boards and the
community at large attended the meeting. It was a lively interactive meeting.
Trustee Pekarek noted that there is an article about leaf collection in the Scarsdale
Inquirer; the do’s and don’ts – the biggest don’t is don’t put your leaves in the street.
Included in the article is a map and additional specific information about collection dates,
times, and locations.
Trustee Callaghan stated that he attended a dinner event last Friday evening hosted
by the union firefighters of Scarsdale. That organization is approximately 75 years old. The
department itself will be 125 years old next year. The high point of that evening was the 2nd
time around of giving citations to several firefighters who participated in a rope rescue. A
construction worker was trapped 15 feet in a trench on Heathcote Road – a very tricky,
technical and sophisticated rescue. These firefighters were trained recently in Valhalla and
with the New York City Fire Department in that form of rescue. Scarsdale is one of the few
fire departments in Westchester County that have the technical capability to perform that
type of rescue.
Trustee Callaghan also noted that a swearing in ceremony was held for three new
firefighters. This completes the department’s membership of 47. The three firefighters that
joined Chief Seymour and his staff are highly credentialed. Trustee Callaghan detailed their
various college degrees and concentrations. Approximately 60-70% of the Village’s current
staff are degreed professionals.
Trustee Callaghan reported on a Fire Fair that was held during Fire Prevention Week
and stated that it was the biggest they have ever had. There were at least 300 to 400 young
people in attendance and participating.
Trustee Callaghan stated that there was a Senior Information Fair at the Scarsdale
Library. There was an amazing turnout of people and 30 vendors present.
Lastly, Trustee Callaghan stated that he and Trustee Pekarek were invited to the Fox
Meadow PTA multicultural luncheon and there were approximately 60 people in attendance.
The principal, Duncan Wilson brought to the attention of the group a book that the Fox
Meadow School is using, “Come With Me”. This is a child’s story that leads a young boy
and girl through different international circumstances. What Mr. Wilson is trying to do is to
familiarize the Fox Meadow School students with the idea of globalization which is very
important in education. They hope to bring this program into the Middle School and High
School as well. He stated that he thinks it is important from a Trustee’s point of view that
this be noted this evening because those of us sitting on the dais are stewards of the public
good and welfare.
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 452
Trustee Pekarek thanked Mayra Rodriguez who is involved in multicultural activities
of the PTA at Fox Meadow. She invited the liaisons to the neighborhood associations in the
Fox Meadow area. That was the first time the school’s multicultural contact had invited
Village personnel to this event. She noted that Scarsdale is quite a large international
community. There were many countries represented and there was great food!
Trustee Veron stated that they had a very lengthy and detailed discussion at the
library and she wants everyone to understand the countless hours and expertise that is going
into this entire library project. We have a Library Board, the Friends of the Scarsdale
Library’s group, the Building Committee, the Campaign Committee, and all of these
committees incorporate views from a vast number of residents and experts as well as the
Village staff. It is a huge team. The library is continuing to serve its community which is
quite an accomplishment.
Trustee Veron reminded the community that the Board is going to be discussing the
Communications Committee recommendations on Monday, November 13th at 6:00 p.m.
She encouraged people to attend.
Trustee Veron stated that the Drugs and Alcohol Task Force is sharing the results of
the Pride Survey at the PT Council meeting. The Pride Survey is a survey of Scarsdale
students in the high school that will describe both tween and teen substance usage. This
meeting will be held on Thursday, November 2nd at the Middle School at 7:30 p.m.
As liaison to the Advisory Council on Parks and Recreation, she stated that the
group had worked on two items at the last meeting. The first item was discussion regarding
the ISO’s (Independent Sports Organizations) guidelines. There is now a subcommittee
looking at the guidelines to ensure that they reflect the philosophy of the Village. The other
item discussed was an inventory of the Village parks identifying opportunities for
improvement and areas that need to be fixed.
As an update on the Village Center revitalization efforts, Trustee Veron stated that
everyone has heard about the Farmer’s Market, parking discussions and the Parking Meter
Pilot Program. The community’s feedback is needed. She stated that there has been
discussion amongst property owners and merchants regarding the Chamber of Commerce
transition at the last Business Center discussion group. They spoke about different Chamber
models. For those that do not know, the Chamber is in transition and they are identifying
alternatives that should be evaluated as a possible next step as they look at the evolution of
the community group. TAP brought in multiple models that exist throughout the County
and in Connecticut. The group will reconvene to discuss options.
Trustee Veron noted that there is a group of community members who are pulling
together “Light the Dale”, a December 1st tree lighting festivity. This event will be held
from 5 to 7 p.m. More information will be forthcoming. This event is a collaboration
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 453
between Village staff, volunteers, and other organizations. They are excited by the incredibly
positive momentum with the stores coming into the Village; very few vacancies and lots of
good restaurants and retail and service opportunities.
********
Public Comment
Marion Green, Chair, Council on People with Disabilities, stated that it is very
important for us to understand what is happening in the United States. The Council has
been heavily engaged in all things; however of particular interest is the Federal push to gut
Medicare and Medicaid and how this will affect many of the people that we all know. This
will affect people with disabilities and abilities alike. It is time for the Council and members
of the community to have a voice and say something. She addressed in a statement the
rewriting of Medicare and Medicare for millions of people who will suffer unspeakable
hardships. She stated that the time is now to address the potentially devastating effects that
the cuts will have on society as a whole. This is a grass roots effort to impede the passage of
any bill that will inflict harm on people who are suffering in our society.
Ms. Green stated that she has been working with other councils in other
municipalities and had sent out a proposed press release that documents exactly how many
people in Westchester County rely on Medicaid for attendant care and services,
modifications to their, hospital equipment, nutritional supplement programs, limb resource
centers, and housing programs. Although it is not part of the Council’s mission to be
political, they feel that as human beings that they have to say something.
Ms. Green stated that she would like to engage everyone in this opportunity to be
able to have a voice in this. She asked that the Board respond to her in regard to being part
of this movement.
Mayor Hochvert asked if the proposed press release was still in draft form. Ms.
Green replied affirmatively.
Mayor Hochvert stated that when the document is ready for release, Ms. Green
should send a copy to him and he will share it with the Board. The Board can then have a
decision as to whether this Board should sign on to a press release.
Madelaine Eppenstein, Old Scarsdale, stated that she would like to encourage the
public to take a survey. The Municipal Services Committee of the Scarsdale Forum released
a survey on Friday. The purpose of the survey is to have members of the public weigh in on
observations and experiences they’ve had on our roads, sidewalks, when walking, driving,
bicycling, and otherwise traveling through the Village. The survey is located at
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 454
www.scarsdaletrafficsurvey.com. The results will be shared with the Village Board and they
hope that it will be helpful in making the Village a much safer place.
Robert Harrison, 65 Fox Meadow Road, stated that he was following up on an
invitation that he made at the last meeting of the Board to come to Happy Valley. This past
Saturday night, was an historic evening as Penn State won over Michigan 42-13 before a
record crowd of 110,823 fans. There is a big game this Saturday against Ohio State at Ohio
State at 3:30 p.m. He stated that there are about 25 students from Scarsdale High School
and a few from Edgemont High School who are currently students at Penn State. He
reminded students from the area that as a volunteer alumni recruiter for Penn State for over
25 years, he encourages any seniors to contact him for any assistance or questions. He can
be reached at 914-725-0962.
Mr. Harrison also noted that the Harrison family participated in the Halloween
painting contest with the grandchildren.
There being no further comments, Mayor Hochvert closed the public comments
portion of the meeting.
********
Finance Committee
Trustee Finger reported on the statements of expense and revenue for the various
funds of the Village for the first four months of fiscal year 2017-18.
General fund appropriations were 28.57% spent as of September 2017 as compared
to 41.76% in 2016-2017. Prior year figures include $7,094,558 in bond refunding expenses.
Exclusive of these expenses, the prior period appropriations were 29.32%.
General Fund Revenues other than property taxes are $7,173,997 through September
2017. After adjusting for the sale of 32 Ferncliff ($956,300) the resulting total of $6,217,697
represents a decrease of $404,129 from the 2016-2017 figure of $6,621,826. The 2018-18 tax
penalty revenue is down over $200,000 from 2016-2017. Last year’s revenue included over
$240,000 in tax penalties on a single property. Mortgage tax increased $114,966. Building
Permit revenue (included in License and Permit revenue) is up $60,500 from last year which
is the bulk of the $67,940 increase in overall License and Permit revenue. Parking revenue
declined $48,500 over this four month period. Court fines decreased $48,300 through the
first quarter of fiscal year 2017-2018. Recreation Department revenue decreased $138,400
due to decreased enrollment in summer camp programs. Cable TV and gross receipts taxes
declined $75,000. Investment income increased $36,500 partially offsetting the drop in Sales
tax receipts of $38,100. Overall rental income increased $44,500.
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 455
The actual collection of Village taxes through September 30, 2017 is at 98.64%.
This is a decrease of 39 basis points from last year’s collection rate.
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Finger, and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution regarding Acceptance of Gifts to the Scarsdale Public Library was
approved by a unanimous vote:
WHEREAS, the Henry Laird Smith Foundation has made a $1,000 donation to
the Scarsdale Public Library; and
WHEREAS, the Gellin Zalaznick Foundation, Inc., has made a $750 donation to
the Scarsdale Public Library; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Policy #103: “Gifts to the Village of Scarsdale” of the Village
of Scarsdale Administrative Policies & Procedures Manual,
acceptance of all gifts valued at $500 or greater must be approved by
the Village Board of Trustees; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Board hereby accepts gifts to the Scarsdale Public
Library in the amounts of $750.00 from the Gellin Zalaznick
Foundation, Inc., and $1,000 from the Henry Laird Smith
Foundation to use for general library purposes; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Treasurer take the necessary steps to complete the
transaction and accept these financial gifts of $1,750 and deposit it in
the Library’s Miscellaneous Gifts Account; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees hereby extends their heartfelt thanks and
great appreciation to the Gellin Zalaznick Foundation, Inc., and the
Henry Laird Smith Foundation.
********
Law Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Finger, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution regarding Authorization to Execute an Amendment to the Agreement
with Westchester County for 2 Drake Road was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale (“Village”) owns certain real property known
as 2 Drake Road (“Premises”), which is improved by a one-family
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 456
home and identified on the Village of Scarsdale Tax Map as Section
11, Block 12, Lot 2; and
WHEREAS, the Village and the County of Westchester (“County”) are currently
parties to a lease agreement originally executed in 1987, renewed in
1994, 1999, 2004, 2009, and again in 2014, under which the Village
leases the premises to the County; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the terms of the latest agreement (attached), the County
uses the property to provide transitional housing for homeless
families or for longer-term housing, as approved by the Village
Manager; and
WHEREAS, the proposed lease agreement requires that the County pay to the
Village a sum equal to the monthly shelter allowance approved by the
New York State Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance for
Westchester County, currently estimated at $5,112; and
WHEREAS, the family residing at 2 Drake Road does not meet the eligibility
requirements for federal and state assistance due to their residency
status, an therefore the County is unable to collect the New York
State shelter allowance; and
WHEREAS, previous requests from the County Department of Social Services to
waive the rental fee have been approved by Village Boards via
resolutions dated September 13, 2005, January 8, 2008, September 22,
2009, June 28, 2011, May 22, 2012, May 14, 2013, and April 8, 2014,
attached hereto and made a part hereof, coinciding with the residency
tenure of the current family; and
WHEREAS, the County is again asking the Village to waive the rental payments
provided for in the proposed successor agreement, as they continue
to work with the family to establish a self-sufficiency plan and move
them out of 2 Drake Rd; and
WHEREAS, the approximate $5,112 in annual state assistance represents less than
1% of our Village’s budget revenue estimate for the rental of real
property, with the waiver of such revenue having minimal impact on
the overall budget; and
WHEREAS, staff recommends that the Village Board grant a rent waiver from
May 1, 2015, through April 30, 2018, said waiver to be accomplished
through an addendum to the proposed agreement in the form of a
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 457
letter in substantially the same form attached hereto; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute a lease
agreement with the County of Westchester, in substantially the same
form as attached hereto; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the annual rent payment equal to the monthly shelter allowance
approved by the New York State Office of Temporary Disability
Assistance for Westchester County, identified in paragraph two of
the agreement, is herein waived for the period of May 1, 2015,
through April 30, 2018; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager shall take all administrative acts necessary in
accordance with said lease agreement.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution to Schedule a Public Hearing on School Speed Limits for Butler Road
and Huntington Avenue was approved by the vote indicated below:
RESOLVED, that a Public Hearing is hereby scheduled by the Board of Trustees of
the Village of Scarsdale in Rutherford Hall at Village Hall on
Tuesday, November 14, 2017, at 8:00 pm to receive comments on
the addition of new School Speed Limits pursuant to Sections
290-7 and 290-54 of the Village Code.
RESOLVED, that the Village Clerk is directed to advertise said Public Hearing.
AYES NAYS RECUSED ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None Trustee Finger None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 458
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
In regard to the foregoing resolution, Trustee Pekarek stated that sometime after June
2016, neighboring residents requested a School speed limit be established for Butler Road due
to its proximity to the Fox Meadow Elementary School. The current code has School speed
limits for all of the schools in Scarsdale except for Butler Road. Currently, every school
currently has a 15 mph speed limit. The speed limit on Butler Road was previously 30 mph and
the public hearing will also change the speed limit for Greenacres Elementary School.
********
Municipal Services
Upon motion entered by Trustee Veron, and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution regarding the Award of VM Contract #1227 – Plumbing and Heating
Services, Village of Scarsdale was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, general plumbing work and heater/boiler maintenance services for
Village-owned facilities is currently performed by way of a time and
materials contract with a local plumbing and heating services
pursuant to a previous Request for Proposal process; and
WHEREAS, based on an increase in the amount of work, it is necessary to
perform a sealed bid process to conform with NYS Bidding Laws,
and as such, on September 8, 2017, the Village advertised for the
receipt of bids under M Contract #1227 – Plumbing and Heating
Services; and
WHEREAS, three bids were received on the bid opening date of October 3, 2017,
with the lowest responsible bid submitted by NY Home Maintenance
Co., D/B/A A. Borrelli Mechanical, 147 Wheeler Avenue,
Pleasantville, NY 10570, itemized as follows: Mechanic Standard
Hourly rate $92.00 and Helper hourly rate $82.00; and
WHEREAS, A.Borrelli Mechanical, has previously provided these plumbing and
heating contract services for the Village in a satisfactory manner and
is familiar with the scope of work required; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract #1227 – Plumbing and Heating Services be
awarded to the lowest responsive bidder, NY Home Maintenance
Co., D/B/A A. Borrelli Mechanical, 147 Wheeler Avenue,
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 459
Pleasantville, NY 10570, at the hourly rates specified in their bid for a
total amount not to exceed budget appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute VM
Contract #1227 – Plumbing and Heating Services on behalf of the
Village with NY Home Maintenance Co., D/B/A A.Borrelli
Mechanical; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the costs of VM Contract #1227 be charged to the appropriate
budget accounts, as determined by the Village Treasurer and subject
to adequate budget appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this two year contract may be extended annually by the Village
Manager for three additional one-year periods subject to the
availability of adequate budget appropriations and in accordance with
the provision in the contract for adjusted rates based on certain state
indices and provided that all other contract terms and conditions
remain unchanged.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Veron, and seconded by Trustee Finger, the
following resolution regarding the Award of Contracts Pursuant to VM #1232 – Irrigation
System Services was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Village has fifteen (15) properties containing irrigation systems
which require a combination of preventative and seasonal
maintenance, as well as repairs on an as needed basis; and
WHEREAS, because non-scheduled repairs comprise the largest portion of our
maintenance costs which may exceed $35,000 annually, the threshold
for public works contracts pursuant to the New York State General
Municipal Law, the public letting of an Irrigation Systems Services
contract was deemed prudent; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 460
WHEREAS, the Village Manager reports that he publicly advertised for the receipt
of bids on September 29, 2017, under VM Contract #1232 –
Irrigation System Services, including Unit A (system winterization),
Unit B (system seasonal opening), and Unit C (unscheduled repairs),
and sent the bid documents to five potential contractor’s, with five
sealed bids subsequently received on the bid opening date, October
10, 2017; and
WHEREAS, the bid received from the apparent low bidder was deemed non-
compliant and disqualified due to the contractors failure to
incorporate mandatory New York State Labor Department Prevailing
Wage rates; and
WHEREAS, the lowest responsible bid was received from East Coast Irrigation,
20 Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, comprised of Unit A
($3,500.00), Unit B ($4,700), and Unit C ($135.00 hourly rate for
either a mechanic or laborer), for an estimated combined total of
$20,620.00 annually; and
WHEREAS, staff has received favorable references for East Coast Irrigation, and
determined that the contractor understands the scope of work
required, and as such, recommends the award of VM Contract #1232
– Irrigation System Services to the lowest responsible bidder, East
Coast Irrigation; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation System Services Units A
($3,500.00), and B ($4,700.00), and C (standard hourly rate of $135.00
for either a mechanic or laborer) for an estimated annual total
$20,620.00 for each year of the two-year agreement is herein awarded
to East Coast Irrigation, 20 Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, for
these unit bid prices which are in accordance with the Bid Tabulation
Sheet attached hereto and made a part hereof, subject to the
availability of adequate budget appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to execute VM Contract
# 1232 – Irrigation System Services Units A, B, and C with East
Coast Irrigation, 20 Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, for a two-
year term subject to the availability of adequate budget
appropriations; and be it further
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 461
RESOLVED, that all costs associated with VM Contract #1232 Irrigation System
Services be charged to A-7020 PLGRD- MAINT- 400-499; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that this contract may be extended annually by the Village Manager
for two additional one-year periods, subject to the availability of
adequate budget appropriations and in accordance with all other
contract terms and conditions.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Written Communications
All communications received that are written to the Mayor and Board of Trustees
can be viewed on the Village’s website, www.scarsdale.com under the Board of Trustees or
Village Clerk section.
The Village Clerk reported that two (2) communications have been received since
the last regular Board of Trustees meeting from the following:
• A press release from the Scarsdale Forum Municipal Services Committee announcing
the launch of a traffic survey.
• An email from Mayra Kirkendall Rodriguez concerning an inquiry about placement
of LED street lights on Fox Meadow Road between Crane Road and Wayside Lane.
A response from Ron Schulhof, Chair of the Ad Hoc Committee on LED
Streetlights is attached.
********
Future Meeting Schedule
• Monday, November 13, 2017 –Committee of the Whole Meeting – 6:00 P.M. – 3rd
Floor Meeting Room
• Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Land Use Committee Meeting – 6:00 P.M. – Third
Village Board of Trustees 10/24/2017 462
Floor Meeting Room
• Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Agenda Committee Meeting – 7:30 P.M. – Trustees’
Room
• Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Village Board Meeting – 8:00 P.M. – Rutherford Hall
• Tuesday, November 28, 2017 – Joint Law & Sustainability Committees Meeting – 6:00
P.M. – 3rd Floor Meeting Room
• Tuesday, November 28, 2017 – Agenda Committee Meeting – 7:30 P.M. – Trustees’
Room
• Tuesday, November 28, 2017 – Village Board Meeting – 8:00 P.M. – Rutherford Hall
********
Village Hall Schedule
• Tuesday, November 7, 2017 – Election Day – Village Hall Closed for Business, Open
for Voting Only
• Friday, November 10, 2017 – Veterans Day – Village Hall Closed
********
There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was
adjourned at 9:38 P.M. on a motion entered by Trustee Finger, seconded by Trustee Pekarek
and carried unanimously.
Donna M. Conkling
Village Clerk
Agenda
Village of Scarsdale
Dan Hochvert, Mayor Stephen M. Pappalardo,
Village Manager
Office of the Village Manager
Matthew J. Callaghan Scarsdale, New York 10583
Carl L. Finger 914-722-1110
Deborah Pekarek Fax: 914-722-1119
Seth Ross www.scarsdale.com
Marc Samwick
Jane E. Veron
Village Board Agenda
October 24, 2017
Agenda Committee Meeting - 7:30 PM – Trustees Room
Village Board Meeting - 8:00 PM - Rutherford Hall
Roll Call
Pledge of Allegiance
Minutes
Village Board Meeting of October 10, 2017
Bills
Trustee Veron
Mayor’s Comments ______________________
Manager’s Comments
- Scarsdale Library Addition and Renovation Project Update ______________________
Trustee Committee and Liaison Reports
Public Comments ______________________
Committee Items
Finance Committee –Trustee Finger
Statements of Expense & Revenue for June 2017 – September
2017 ______________________
Resolution re: Acceptance of Gifts to the Scarsdale Public
Library ______________________
Law Committee – Trustee Finger
Resolution re: Authorization to Execute an Amendment to the
Agreement with Westchester County for 2 Drake Road ______________________
Resolution re: Set Public Hearing on School Speed Limits for
Butler Road and Huntington Avenue
Municipal Services Committee - Trustee Veron
Resolution re: Awarding VM Contract #1227 – Plumbing and
Heating Services, Village of Scarsdale ______________________
Resolution re: Awarding VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation
Services ______________________
Future Meeting Schedule
Tuesday, November 14, 2017
6:00 PM – Land Use Committee Meeting – 3rd Floor Meeting
Room ______________________
1. Land Use Discussion with Planning Board, Board of Appeals
and Board of Architectural Review
7:30 PM Agenda Committee Meeting ______________________
8:00 PM Village Board Meeting ______________________
Tuesday, November 28, 2017
6:00 PM – Joint Law and Sustainability Committees Meeting –
3rd Floor Meeting Room ______________________
1. Proposed Amendments to Village Code Chapter 281 - Trees
7:30 PM Agenda Committee Meeting ______________________
8:00 PM Village Board Meeting ______________________
Village Hall Schedule
Tuesday, November 7, 2017
Election Day – Village Hall Closed for Business (Open for Voting only)
Friday, November 10, 2017
Veterans Day – Village Hall Closed
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 420
THREE THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED NINETIETH
REGULAR MEETING
Rutherford Hall
Village Hall
October 10, 2017
A Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Village of Scarsdale was held in
Rutherford Hall in Village Hall on Tuesday, October 10, 2017 at 8:00 P.M.
Present were Mayor Hochvert, Trustees Finger, Pekarek, Ross, Samwick and Veron.
Also present were Village Manager Pappalardo, Deputy Village Manager Cole, Village Attorney
Esannason, Assistant Village Manager Richards, Deputy Village Attorney Garrison, Village
Treasurer McClure, Village Clerk Conkling, and Assistant to the Village Manager Ringel.
********
The minutes of the Board of Trustees Regular Meeting of Tuesday, September 26,
2017 were approved on a motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, seconded by Trustee
Samwick, and carried unanimously.
********
Bills & Payroll
Trustee Pekarek reported that she had audited the Abstract of Claims dated
October 10, 2017 in the amount of $371,541.94 which includes $21,537.34 in Library Claims
previously audited by a Trustee of the Library Board which were found to be in order and
she moved that such payment be ratified.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Pekarek and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution was adopted unanimously:
RESOLVED, that the Abstract of Claims dated October 10, 2017 in the amount of
$371,541.94 is hereby approved.
Trustee Pekarek further reported that she had examined the payment of bills made in
advance of a Board of Trustees audit totaling $983,218.07 which were found to be in order and
she moved that such payments be ratified.
Upon motion duly made by Trustee Pekarek and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution was adopted unanimously:
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 421
RESOLVED, that payment of claims made in advance of a Board of Trustees audit
totaling $101,097.27 is hereby ratified.
********
Mayor Hochvert stated that the Board would deviate somewhat from the regular
agenda format to accommodate the next speaker who had been at the hospital since 3:00
A.M. this morning – he recognized Mr. David Raizen, President of the Scarsdale Volunteer
Ambulance Corps (SVAC).
David Raizen stated that he would like to update the Board on the SVAC fund
raising efforts and support the resolution on this evening’s agenda regarding the purchase of
a new ambulance.
Mr. Raizen stated that SVAC operates three ambulances out of their site at
Heathcote Five Corners and is a self-supporting volunteer ambulance corps providing
emergency medical services to the Village of Scarsdale. Their annual fund drive has gone
out in the last two weeks. Their two main sources of funding are the fund drive and billing
for services. He stated that they need residents to assist them with the fund drive, which
accounts for approximately half of their operating budget. The fund drive from the last few
years has been mediocre and they are hoping for a good response this year.
Mr. Raizen provided an update on the educational program SVAC is running; their
EMT training center has been very successful. Every class has met the minimum
requirements and 95%+ have been successful in graduating.
Mr. Raizen continued, stating that as part of their operating agreement with the
Village, every four years the Village purchases a new vehicle for SVAC. There is a resolution
on the Board’s agenda this evening for the purchase of a new ambulance; he encouraged
them to vote in favor of this purchase.
Trustee Pekarek noted that from personal experience utilizing SVAC for family
members, the service from the medical personnel was amazing – they were respectful, quick
and knowledgeable. She thanked Mr. Raizen for the services SVAC provides to the
community.
********
Mayor’s Comments
Mayor Hochvert stated that a former Village Trustee and Scarsdale Bowl recipient
with her husband, the first dual recipient of the Scarsdale Bowl, Esther C. Shay, passed away
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 422
on October 2, 2017. Esther served two terms as Trustee from 1987 to 1991. She was active
in the Scarsdale League of Women Voters and her father, Warren Cunningham, was the first
Mayor (President) from 1927 to 1928 in the Village of Scarsdale. Esther and her husband
lived on Rectory Lane South during her Village Board years.
Mayor Hochvert requested a moment of silence for Esther Shay at this time.
Mayor Hochvert reported that a week ago Monday, there was a Scarsdale
Neighborhood Association Presidents (SNAP) meeting. The featured speaker was Ben
Boykin, who gave details to the audience on County projects. One of these items included
at $34 million project that included $6 million for a compost site somewhere within the
County. This would have to be approved by the NYS Comptroller which could take quite a
long time. He stated that he contacted the local State representatives to see if that waiting
period could be shortened.
Mayor Hochvert complimented the Scarsdale Concours on a wonderful event. He
stated that the turnout was outstanding, both in terms of the cars that were exhibited and the
attendees. The funds raised in connection with this event are in turn contributed back to
Scarsdale.
Mayor Hochvert noted that three firefighters were sworn in to fill in the vacancies
created by retirements. He stated that it is so nice to see young people who have done so
well and their family support at the swearing in ceremony.
Last Tuesday, Mayor Hochvert stated that the groundbreaking for the temporary
library space at the Supply Field building was held and it was a pleasure for him to introduce
State Assemblywoman Amy Paulin. Ms. Paulin had secured a $500,000 grant from the State
so that the Supply Field building can be retrofitted as a temporary space for the library while
the library renovations ensue.
Mayor Hochvert stated that he attended a Community Support Council meeting.
He explained that this council was formed in response to a series of unfortunate suicide
events. They have reached out to try to build a coalition of religious persons, active
volunteers, and people who can counsel. This meeting was to introduce a class being held at
the high school, City 2.0, to join in as it is important to find as many connections as possible
of support.
Mayor Hochvert next noted that at a meeting of the Forum last Thursday, he
gave the State of the Village to the audience. Following that there was a presentation by the
Downtown Revitalization Committee. This afternoon, he and Trustee Veron visited the
merchants downtown to discuss their parking needs in the Village. A lot of the merchants
felt that there has been a revitalization of the downtown largely due to the Farmer’s Market.
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 423
Mayor Hochvert reported that there will be two compost activities this week:
Wednesday morning, the Verizon Channel, Fios 1, will be coming to shoot a video of Ron
Schulhof and Michelle Sterling at the Recycling Center regarding the food waste composting
program. On Friday, New York State Senator Andrea Stewart-Cousins, will also be meeting
with them at the Recycling center. This composting effort has spread throughout the
County. Both Assemblywoman Paulin and Senator Stewart-Cousins are bringing it to the
rest of the State.
A tour of a home on Dolma Road for which a hardship appeal was heard was taken
by four of the Board members. Mayor Hochvert stated that this house was built in the early
1900’s and noted how differently homes are being built today.
During the summer month period while gas powered leaf blowers are not permitted
under the Village Code, Mayor Hochvert stated that he learned from Police Chief Matturro
that 93 citations were issued for leaf blower violations. This is the second highest number of
violations for this offense on record. In 2008, 99 citations were issued. Mayor Hochvert
commended the enforcement of this aspect of the Village code.
********
Manager’s Comments
Village Manager Pappalardo updated the Board and the Community on the work
being done on various roadways in the Village by Con Edison. Con Edison is in varying
stages of upgrading natural gas mains on Popham Road, Lockwood Road, Route 125, Secor
Road, Mamaroneck Road between Palmer and Brookby, and Post Road between Olmsted
and Fenimore Roads. These new gas mains will enhance service during high demand
periods. In order to perform the work, Con Edison must apply for a street opening permit
from the Village Engineer including the provision of adequate bonds and insurances. They
are also required to hire Scarsdale police officers for directing traffic. Last week Con Edison
completed the gas main installation of roughly 3200 linear feet of plastic gas main along
Palmer Road/New York State Route 125 and Mamaroneck Roads. They still need to pave
the affected areas on Route 125 – that road is regulated by the New York State Department
of Transportation as it is a New York State road. The work on Post Road will continue for
the time being with traffic control handled by the Police Department. The Village will
continue to use the ‘Notify Me’ public announcement function on the Village’s website to
alert residents as to any traffic issues. Residents are always free to call Village Hall; in this
particular case, he urged residents to call the Village Engineer’s office at 722-1106 with any
questions or concerns regarding this work.
Village Manager next promoted two of the Department of Recreation programs; the
Recreation Department’s annual Fall Festival will be held this Sunday, October 15th at the
Scarsdale Pool Complex. Join the Weinberg Nature Center and the Recreation Department
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 424
for a fun filled day with music and live animals. There will be a scarecrow making contest
where families will have the chance to create their own life sized scarecrows. Advance
registration is essential as space is limited. Go to the Recreation Department webpage on
the Scarsdale website, www.scarsdale.com to register; the program can be found under the
Special Events section. Food is also included with the fee. The Halloween window painting
contest is scheduled for the following Sunday, October 22nd in the Village center. There will
also be windows available at the Heathcote Five Corners, and perhaps at the Golden
Horseshoe shopping center, depending on registration. The contest takes place from 9 am
to 4 pm. The rain date will be on Monday, October 23rd from 4 pm to 7 pm. The Chamber
of Commerce will co-sponsor the event and a $100 prize award will be given to the Grand
Prize winner. Winners will be honored in an awards night in November. All Scarsdale
residents are eligible to register.
Mayor Hochvert stated that he believed that the westbound Popham Road will be
repaved after Con Edison finishes all the hook-ups and something will be done with Post
Road although it will be different because it is a State road. He noted that some of Post
Road was repaved from approximately Drake Road to Richbell Road which eliminated some
of the worst potholes along the edge of the road.
********
Other Committee Reports
None.
********
Liaison Reports
Trustee Veron reported on her attendance at a Crane-Berkley Neighborhood
Association meeting. The Crane-Berkley residents have been working hard to maintain the
beauty of the pond and neighboring area. They are working on adding new trees to replace
the diseased ones that were removed and cleaning up the area. It is important for residents
to know that they can play a vital role in their community through their neighborhood
association.
As part of the downtown revitalization program, Trustee Veron stated that they have
been talking to merchants and consumers for feedback in regard to the meter pilot program.
For those that want to provide feedback, they can call 1-800-410-7120 regarding the meter
experience. There is a Survey Monkey link at www.scarsdale.com, type in the search bar
‘parking meter pilot’. For any questions, email metertest@scarsdale.com. She stated that
Assistant Village Manager Richards is working extremely hard at making sure all feedback is
given to the meter vendors and addressed on site.
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 425
Trustee Veron stated that the Village has invited merchants and the business
community to have an open dialogue about their parking needs on Thursday, October 19th at
6:30 pm at Village Hall.
Trustee Veron reminded the community that the Farmer’s Market will continue on
Thursdays and she thanked everyone for their support of the Market which has gotten a lot
of positive feedback. They are now exploring the possibility of moving the market indoors.
Trustee Veron expressed her thanks to the Communications Committee who gave a
full report to the Board of Trustees. Those in attendance were Justin Arest, Lee Fischman,
Dara Gruenberg, Laura Halligan, Barry Meiselman, ML Perlman, Scott Rompala, Andrew
Seresky, and Carol Silverman. The Board will discuss next steps with Village staff and will
be meeting on November 13th at 6 pm.
Trustee Pekarek
********
Public Hearing
Trustee Veron opened a public hearing scheduled for this evening to discuss the
determination of the number of taxicabs to be licensed in Scarsdale in 2018. She requested
any public comment at this time. As there were no comments offered, Trustee Veron
moved that the public hearing be closed, seconded by Trustee Ross and carried
unanimously.
On a motion entered by Trustee Veron, and seconded by Trustee Finger, the
following resolution to determine the Number of Taxicabs to be Licensed in the Village of
Scarsdale for 2018 was adopted by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, Village staff has reviewed the necessary areas of taxi service in
accordance with Village Code Article II, Section 272-3, in order to
recommend the number of taxicabs to be licensed in the year 2018;
and
WHEREAS, the Village Board of Trustees approved the issuance of up to twenty-
five (25) taxicab licenses in 2017, with the Village Clerk having issued
twenty-three (23) taxicab licenses; and
WHEREAS, based on population, train ridership data, and the number of 2017
licenses sold, Village staff has determined that the current number of
25 taxicab licenses is adequate for the proper supply of service
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 426
throughout the Village in 2018; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that pursuant to Scarsdale Village Code Article II, Section 272-3,
twenty-five (25) taxicab licenses should be authorized for 2018; and
be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Clerk is hereby authorized to issue said licenses in
accordance with the provisions of the Village Code.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Public Comment
Lena Crandall, 227 Fox Meadow Road, speaking on behalf of the Scarsdale Forum,
announced that there will be a meeting of the Scarsdale Forum on Thursday, October 5th,
7:30 p.m. in the Scott Room of the Scarsdale Library. Mayor Hochvert will be giving the
State of the Village address. You will hear a comprehensive report on everything that has to
do with the Village and there will be an opportunity to ask questions. There will also be a
program by the Scarsdale Forum’s Downtown Revitalization Committee. The event is free
and everyone is welcome.
Philip Mehler, 54 Birchall Drive, stated that he didn’t understand why the Village
was making such a big thing out of purchasing parking meters. In New York City on every
block there is a center parking machine and all of the meters were disposed of. To purchase
individual meters will cost too much money.
Village Manager Pappalardo stated that New York City uses the multi space meters
which were referenced earlier and there are two different types in the Village Center. As Ms.
Shiffer mentioned, they are much more economical and less expensive in terms of ongoing
maintenance costs and other expenses compared to the single space meters. The Village has
285 parking meter spaces that will have to be accommodated either via single space meters
or multi space meters. Based on their discussions with the meter manufacturers, the Village
has a capital budget of $450,000 for those 285 parking spaces for new meters of some sort.
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 427
Mr. Mehler stated that the residents would be more interested in the condition of
the Scarsdale roads, which in his opinion are deplorable. His road was supposed to be paved
two years ago – he called the Engineering Department many times, and unlike previous
years, no one returned his call. He visited the Engineering Department and no one was
there to speak to him. He has also sent emails and has not gotten any response. He added
that in general, not much has been done to pave the roads. The main roads are still in bad
condition; they have been paved in sections. More money should be given for the roads.
Mayor Hochvert stated that the paving began in July; you need school to not be in
session while paving due to road closures. Over five miles of the 77 miles in Scarsdale were
done this year. There were probably be over six miles done before this year is over. If we
kept up that pace for the next 13 years, we would have paved every road in Scarsdale within
its life. Post Road, which is a State road, and for which the State has responsibility for has
not yet been done, even with the support of our legislators. At this time, Con Edison is
digging up Post Road in the vicinity of Olmsted Road. As soon as they are done, Con
Edison will have some responsibility for repaving. The previous Board did change the Code
to require Con Edison to pay the Village for the repaving of the sections they dig up. He
cited Crane Road as an example. He asked Mr. Mehler to send him an email at
Mayor@Scarsdale.com in regard to his particular concern and he will get an answer.
Mr. Mehler asked why the Assessor has not been fired yet. Mayor Hochvert
responded that she has 2 ½ years left on her contract. Village Manager Pappalardo added
that this is a personnel issue that the Board should not discuss publicly. Trustee Finger
referred Mr., Mehler to the Public Officers Law to review for a better understanding of the
position of the Assessor.
Village Manager Pappalardo spoke to Mr. Mehler, stating that he was concerned
about his initial comment that he had been trying to reach the Engineering Department and
Public Works Department. He asked Mr. Mehler to send him whatever emails he sent to
those departments at Manager@Scarsdale.com. Village Manager Pappalardo stated that he
will speak to those departments tomorrow to see if they have any recollection of hearing
from him. He stated that the Village has a very responsive DPW Superintendent and Village
Engineer; we answer many questions in detail and often visit residents on site. He stated he
was surprised to hear that Mr. Mehler had not gotten any responses. Mr. Mehler stated that
in the past, those departments had been very responsive in addressing his concerns;
however, this year he has not gotten any emails or phone calls in response to his questions.
Mr. Mehler left his contact information with Assistant to the Village Manager Ringel.
Robert Harrison, 65 Fox Meadow Road, noted that there has been more paving
this year than in past years. He asked that the Village Manager and the DPW Superintendent
look at Fox Meadow Road from Crane to Wayside and have it paved. He also noted that the
Fox Meadow/Crane Roads intersection is very dangerous. Nothing has been done about it.
Perhaps some of the bank could be taken down to improve the site line and perhaps some
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 428
signage that warns people to slow down on Crane Road when approaching the intersection
with Fox Meadow Road.
Mr. Harrison stated that he attended the Finance Committee meeting earlier this
evening regarding review of the Fiscal Year 2016/17 Financial Statements with the auditors.
There were comments that the revenue of the Recreation Department was down $200,000
from the previous year. He noted that he has spoken recently at Board meetings regarding
tennis court management. He visited the Middle School courts this past weekend. On
Friday evening there were a number of people playing there that didn’t have permits. On
Saturday, there was a gentleman at the Brite Avenue courts that had a listing of those that
have permits; however, he did not have any receipts to be able to charge those without
permits. He encouraged the Board to hire students or seniors to oversee the courts to be
sure those that are playing have permits and to charge those who do not. Over the weekend,
Mr. Harrison stated that there were 8 people who did not have permits, and the time he
spent there was quite short. The tennis permit system must be enforced. He stated that he
sent an email to the Mayor and Village Manager urging them to enforce the tennis permit
system this weekend.
Trustee Callaghan, liaison to the Parks and Recreation Committee, stated that this
issue is definitely one that is being discussed and reminded Mr. Harrison that the Village
Board does listen to public comments and addresses them. He stated that he will speak to
the Recreation Superintendent and his assistant to find out the best way to handle this
situation.
In regard to the resolution on the Board’s agenda this evening for the Supply Field
Building second floor renovation, satellite library project, Mr. Harrison stated that in the
resolution, there is a whereas clause that talks about an anticipated $500,000 New York
Dormitory grant which is still pending. He thought perhaps we should wait until the money
has been received. We need to be diligent on all of our project expenses.
Mr. Harrison urged the Board to move forward on the installation of a comfort station
at the Middle School tennis courts. Put it back in the budget and get it done. If the School
Board doesn’t want to do it then the Village Board should just do it.
Jill Weiss, President of the Friends of the Westchester Band, gave the Board a history
of the Westchester Band. She noted that in earlier years, the band was funded by
corporations, private donations and one of the unions. Approximately ten years ago, she
took over as the Director of the band. In 1990, Director Joseph Albright moved to Florida
and Walter Handelman succeeded him as Director. At that time the band became a non-
profit corporation. Mr. Handelman filed the papers with New York State and the band
became a 501(c). Mr. Alan Hollander is now Director of the band. The band has an
approximately $50,000 budget per year which is depleted each summer. They no longer
received funding from the now defunct union or corporations and rely solely on private
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 429
donors. The musicians are paid; there are professionals, amateurs, and students. The band
gives community service to the students.
As Mayor, Mr. Handelman had the band program under the Village Budget, as a
Recreation Department program, with a budget of $16,000. The rest of the money comes
from the incorporated Friends of the Westchester Band. Mailings are sent to residents every
year requesting donations. The band is in its 48th season and is the oldest running music
program in the County of Westchester. She thanked the Mayor and Board of Trustees, as
well as the Recreation Department for all of the support they have given to the band over
the years. She stated that they are starting to lose the base of the Friends of the Westchester
Band due to previous members moving to another location or deceased.
Ms. Weiss stated that there has not been an increase in the Village’s budget for the
Westchester Band in ten years and she requested that the Board consider an increase in their
budget. She noted that Superintendent of Parks and Recreation Brian Gray will ask for the
increase in the next Village budget. She further stated that the band needs space – they use
the high school for rehearsals and rain date space and pay them for the use of their
auditorium and custodian. She said they would like to have a more secure space at the high
school with the Village Board’s support.
Mayor Hochvert thanked Ms. Weiss for her effort all of these years. He stated that
the Board will take her request under advisement.
Trustee Callaghan stated that yesterday there were two back-to-back Committee for
Historic Preservation cases, one a month ago and one the month before that. With 15 years
of experience on the Board of Appeals, he stated that he has seen an uptick. He wanted to
assure the viewers and those in the audience that the Mayor at his first meeting set up a
priority list of what he would like to see done. On that list is the Committee for Historical
Preservation and the law itself.
There being no further comments, Mayor Hochvert closed the public comments
portion of the meeting.
********
Finance Committee
Trustee Finger reported on the statements of expense and revenue for the various
funds of the Village for the first three months of fiscal year 2017-18.
General fund appropriations were 22.28% spent as of August 2017 as compared to
34.18% in 2016-2017.
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 430
General Fund Revenues other than property taxes are $6,331,785 through August
2017. This is an increase of $1,085,526 from the 2016-2017 figure of $5,246,259. The 2016-
2017 revenue items included $956,300 from the sale of 32 Ferncliff and an increase in
mortgage tax of $114,966. Building Permit revenue (included in License and Permit
revenue) is up $72,100 from last year which is the bulk of the increase in overall License and
Permit revenue ($81,800). Parking revenue declined $26,200. Court fines are down
$23,400. Recreation Department revenue decreased $62,900 due to decreased enrollment in
some programs. Delinquent tax collections dropped $14,700 due to lower inventory and
Cable TV and gross receipts taxes declined $76,800. Investment income increased $18,700
partially offsetting the drop in Sales tax receipts of $38,100. Overall rental income increased
$159,700. After adjusting for the sale of 32 Ferncliff year-to-date income is $129,226 greater
than 2016-2017.
The actual collection of Village taxes through August 31, 2017 is at 98.19%. This is
a decrease of 35 basis points from last year’s collection rate.
********
Land Use Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Samwick, and seconded by Trustee Finger, the
following resolution Awarding VM Contract #1226 – Brewster Road Sanitary Sewer
Replacement Project was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Village Manager reports that he publicly advertised in the
Scarsdale Inquirer on Friday, August 20, 2017, for the receipt of bids
pursuant to VM Contract #1226 – Brewster Road Sanitary Sewer
Replacement Project, having also provided direct notice to two
construction journals and fifteen vendors known to supply the
services; and
WHEREAS, on the bid opening date, September 7, 2017, five bids were received,
with the lowest responsible bid received from Joken Development
Corporation (Joken), 9 Belway Place, White Plains, New York 10601;
and
WHEREAS, Joken has verified that they are capable of fulfilling all contract
requirements, including having expressed to staff clear understanding
of the scope of work and project completion date set-forth in the bid
documents; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 431
WHEREAS, Joken’s references provided positive recommendation for the firm,
and they have also previously performed satisfactory services for the
Village of Scarsdale; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract # 1226, Brewster Road Sanitary Sewer
Replacement Project, be awarded to Joken Development
Corporation, 9 Belway Place, White Plains, New York 10601, at the
unit bid prices itemized in the attached bid tabulation sheet, with
represented total cost based on estimated work quantities and
expenses not to exceed budgeted appropriations or $157,452.50; and
be it further
RESOLVED, that the cost of same be charged to Capital Budget Accounts H8120-
965 2016-095 and H8120-965 2018-095; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute VM
Contract #1226 on behalf of the Village of Scarsdale with Joken
Development Corporation, 9 Belway Place, White Plains, New York
10601, and to undertake administrative acts as may be required under
said agreement.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Municipal Services Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Veron, and seconded by Trustee Pekarek, the
following resolution Awarding VM Contract #1223 – Supply Field Building Second Floor
Renovation, Satellite Library Project was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale is obligated by both the NYS Education Law
and the Westchester County Library System Service Plan to maintain
certain library services during temporary closure of the Scarsdale
Public Library to facilitate the planned Library Addition and
Renovation project; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 432
WHEREAS, Village and Library staff investigated alternate temporary locations to
host the necessary limited library services required by law, taking into
consideration such factors as inventory, programmatic, operational,
office and parking needs; and
WHEREAS, the unfinished, two-story, Village-owned structure known as the
Supply Field Building, located at 244 Heathcote Road, was identified
as the best location, providing for 3,100 square feet of second floor
space, a finished lobby, elevator, and a parking lot with approximately
30-35 parking spaces; and
WHEREAS, the Village hired the architectural firm of Fuller and D’Angelo
(F&D), Elmsford, in March 2016 for Phase I Design Services to
determine if the Supply Field Building’s second floor would
constitute a viable solution for the temporary library; and
WHEREAS, F& D completed a conceptual plan in June 2016, affirming location
feasibility and incorporating design solutions appropriate for the
temporary library needs; and
WHEREAS, in order to keep the Scarsdale Library Addition and Renovation
project on schedule for construction commencement in May 2018,
the Supply Field Building must be ready for temporary library
occupancy by April 2018; and
WHEREAS, via Village Board resolution of February 28, 2016 (attached), the
Village entered into an agreement with F&D for phase II design
services including the preparation of construction bid documents and
provision of both bidding phase services and construction
administration services; and
WHEREAS, in July 2017, F&D completed the bid documents for a project scope
including a staff work area, administrative office, children’s room,
general book stack area, public computer / copier area, new
accessible bathrooms, and sufficient storage, along with a new second
floor HVAC system and fire sprinkler system, having provided a
construction estimate of $640,000 including contingencies; and
WHEREAS, the Village Manager reports that on July 14, 2017 he publicly
advertised for the receipt of bids under VM Contract #1223 - Supply
Field Building Second Floor Renovation, Satellite Library (Project),
which included the Base Bid work and a separate price for Alternate
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 433
No. 1 work to transfer certain furniture from the Library at 54
Olmstead Road to the Supply Field Building; and
WHEREAS, subsequent to a pre-bid meeting held on August 1, 2017, six bids
were opened on August 15, 2017, with the lowest responsible bid
received from Peter A. Camilli & Sons Inc., 210 Marble Avenue,
Pleasantville, NY 10570, for a lump sum Base Bid amount of $716,924;
and
WHEREAS, based on the F&D estimate of $640,000, a total of $650,000 was
included in the adopted FY 2017/18 Capital Budget, comprised of
$500,000 anticipated from a New York State Dormitory Authority
Grant, which is still pending, and $150,000 in Village funding; and
WHEREAS, in response to higher than anticipated bids, F&D reviewed the
project scope with Peter. A. Camilli and determined that certain
industry-wide increases in the mechanical and plumbing elements
contributed heavily to the higher costs, but that Camilli would further
review his bid and discuss opportunities with the Village after the bid
award to complete the project scope at a reduced cost; and
WHEREAS, it was also determined that neither value engineering nor rebidding
would result in an acceptable project with meaningful savings; and
WHEREAS, F&D is confident that Peter A. Camilli & Sons, Inc., understands and
can complete the necessary scope as designed and within his bid
amount, having also verified the firm’s references; and
WHEREAS, following a thorough review, F&D and Village staff believe that VM
#1223 – Supply Field Building Second floor Renovation, Satellite
Library, should be awarded to the lowest responsive bidder, Peter A.
Camilli & Sons Inc., 210 Marble Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570, for
the Base Bid amount of $716,925, and that Alternate No. 1 should
not be awarded; and
WHEREAS, in order to award the base bid of up to $716,924 plus an approximate
3% contingency of $20,000, for a Project total of $736,924, a transfer
of up to $86,924 from available Village funds is necessary; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract #1223 – Supply Field Building Second Floor
Renovation, Satellite Library, be awarded to Peter A. Camilli & Sons
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 434
Inc., 210 Marble Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570, for a total of
$716,924; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the cost of said project be charged to Capital Accounts HL-
7497-964 2018-076GT ($500,000 Grant) and # HL-7497-964-2018-
076 ($150,000); and
RESOLVED, that up to $86,924 be transferred from Village General Fund balance
to the Supply Field Building Second Floor Renovation, Satellite
Library project account #HL-7497-964-2018-076 which includes an
approximate 3% contingency; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to execute VM Contract
#1223 – Supply Field Building Second Floor Renovation, Satellite
Library in the amount of $716,924 on behalf of the Village of
Scarsdale with Peter A. Camilli & Sons Inc., 210 Marble Avenue,
Pleasantville, NY 10570, and undertake all administrative acts as may
be required under said agreement.
AYES NAYS RECUSED ABSENT
Trustee Finger Trustee Callaghan Trustee Ross None
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Before the vote was taken on the above resolution, the Village Manager stated that
he wanted to address some points that Mr. Harrison raised previously.
Village Manager Pappalardo stated that the Village recognizes that the low bid that
was received out of the six bids was roughly $67,000 higher than budgeted. They asked the
consultant as well as the project manager to speak to not only the low bidder, but to speak to
all of the bidders, which they have done. A common theme heard was that the takeoffs for
the mechanical and plumbing trades’ costs were generally higher than what the Village’s
consultant had estimated. In looking at the six bids, the median cost was over $900,000.
The lowest bidder is 11 ½% less than the second lowest bidder. They looked for
opportunities to value engineer this project and there were really not a lot. There was no
opportunity to eliminate one or more parts of this project where we thought we could save
money – perhaps by doing some of the work in-house. There were no guarantees that by
eliminating some of the work that they would get bids that were any better than the ones
they have. They did speak to the lowest responsible bidder and there may be some
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 435
opportunities to save a few dollars as we move forward. They have come to the conclusion,
however, that at this point in time to make the recommendation to award the contract for
this amount. The additional money that Mr. Harrison mentioned in this case – close to
$87,000 – will come from the unassigned fund balance. There shouldn’t be too many
unknowns in this building as it is fairly new. In regard to the State grant, in making phone
calls, Village Manager Pappalardo stated that he has been assured that the grant is very far
down the line in the approval process and the money is not in jeopardy. If he felt it was in
jeopardy in any way, they would not be discussing this item this evening.
Trustee Finger noted that the original cost figure for this project was well over
$900,000. A lot of work went into getting costs down. The $650,000 figure was an estimate,
and he recalled the Project Manager Paul Zaicek had mentioned an approximate figure of
$700,000. Although this number is not want the Board would have hoped it would be, it is
not a surprise and is certainly far better than some of the numbers previously discussed.
Personally, he stated that he is comfortable with it.
Trustee Veron stated that they are investing in a Village asset that will last long after
being a Library satellite. She felt that they were being prudent in spending money on
something that will have a long life.
Village Manager Pappalardo stated that the fact that they did receive six bids on this
project is beneficial. The low bidder is a responsible bidder; the architect has worked with
him in the past.
Mayor Hochvert asked Village Manager Pappalardo if he would be able to withhold
the execution of this contract until they get further down the road to receiving the grant
from New York State.
Village Manager Pappalardo stated that if the Board does award the contract this
evening, the contractor needs to obtain all the bonds and insurances and that usually takes
approximately three to four weeks. After that, a preconstruction meeting will be held. He
stated that it will probably be at least three to four weeks before any work begins. This VM
Contract will probably be executed within the next month, so that does allow some time.
Trustee Callaghan explained that he voted nay on this resolution because they will be
dipping into the General Fund for $86,000. They should be working within their budget.
Also, he stated that he did not think that they undertook adequate research to place the
satellite library in a location that was less hazardous – Supply Field is very crowded on
Saturdays and Sundays. Finally, he stated that he felt the logistics on this is a bit off.
Before he voted, Trustee Finger stated that in regard to the safety issues, he has been
assured that the library is going to operate the satellite in a way to minimize hours when
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 436
Supply Field will be overly crowded on the weekends. That, combined with his earlier
comments confirms his vote as yes.
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Veron, and seconded by Trustee Samwick, the
following resolution to Authorize the Execution of an Amendment to the 2016/2017 New
York State Indexed Lump Sum Municipal Snow and Ice Agreement was approved by the
vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 12 of the New York State Highway Law, the
maintenance of State highways includes control over snow and ice
removal authorized by the New York State Department of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in order to make these roads safe and
passable, while providing an option for this work to be accomplished
by the host municipality pursuant to an intermunicipal agreement
between the municipality and the NYSDOT; and
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale, in the interest of public safety and plowing
expediency, has contracted with the State to plow the 15.7 miles of
State owned roads since 1999 through successive amendments to the
Indexed Lump Sum Municipal Snow and Ice Agreement, the latest of
which was executed on August 08, 2017, thereby extending the
original agreement through June 30, 2018; and
WHEREAS, during severe winters which require municipalities to perform snow
and ice removal services in excess of the ten-year average, the
NYSDOT amends the inter-municipal agreement covering the
impacted period to provide additional funding; and
WHEREAS, due to the severity of the winter storms during the 2016/17 Snow
and Ice Season, the Village is entitled to an additional $14,493.14 for
the 2016/17 Snow and Ice Season which when added to the 2016/17
original amount of $24,774.60 equals $39,267.74; and
WHEREAS, in order for the Village to obtain these additional funds, the Village
Board must authorize the execution of an amendment to the
2016/17 Snow and Ice Agreement increasing the estimated
expenditure; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Board of Trustees hereby authorizes the Village
Manager to execute Amendment “B” to the 2016/17 Snow and Ice
Agreement, between the Village of Scarsdale and the New York State
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 437
Department of Transportation to revise the estimated expenditures
and increase the Village’s reimbursement for snow and ice removal
services, in substantially the same form as attached hereto, and to
undertake all administrative acts necessary pursuant to the
amendment.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution regarding Acceptance of a New York State Department of
Environmental Conservation Invasive Species Grant was approved by the vote indicated
below:
WHEREAS, an invasive plant species, Japanese knotweed (Reynoutria Japonica), is
aggressively growing along the section of South Fox Meadow Brook
flowing through Harcourt Woods, Harwood Park, and Scarsdale
High School property; and
WHEREAS, left unchecked, the knotweed will work to undermine, through
organic matter deposition and culvert obstruction, the Village of
Scarsdale watercourse restoration work completed in 2015, as well as
dominate the wetlands ecology, thereby adversely impacting
ecological function through severe reduction or elimination of native
wetland plant species; and
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale is desirous of protecting its significant South
Fox Meadow Brook watercourse restoration investment and
capitalizing on the ecological services that a healthy, native wetland
ecosystem provides, thus necessitating a multi-year knotweed
eradication program involving a combination of mechanical and
manual invasive species control, herein referred to as the South Fox
Meadow Brook Knotweed Remediation Project (Project); and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 438
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale applied to the NYS Department of
Environmental Conservation for a $24,500 Invasive Species Rapid
Response and Control Program grant to support the Project; and
WHEREAS, on July 7, 2017, the NYSDEC awarded an Invasive Species Rapid
Response Grant to the Village of Scarsdale in the amount of $24,500,
which requires a $25,000 local match, yielding a total Project cost of
$49,500; and
WHEREAS, the Village Planner reviewed the Project pursuant to the State
Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) and Chapter 152 of the
Village Code, having determined that it constitutes a Type II Action
pursuant to SEQRA, with no further environmental review required
(see attached memo); and
WHEREAS, Village staff has reviewed the rules and guidelines of the Invasive
Species Rapid Response Grant and believe it is in the best interest of
the Village to accept the funding; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to execute NYSDEC
Invasive Species Rapid Response and Control Grant, in substantially
the same form as attached hereto, for Knotweed remediation along
South Fox Meadow Brook, over a three year period, as outlined in
Attachment C of the Grant Agreement, entitled Work Plan; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that the required local match of $25,000 will be comprised of $10,000
included in the adopted FY 2017/18 Capital Budget, Account # H-
1997-961 2018-120, $5,000 in Village of Scarsdale in-kind services,
and $10,000 contributed by Scarsdale School District subject to the
School Board’s approval; and be it further
RESOLVED, that grant funds expended under this program be charged to Capital
Budget Account H-1997-961 2018-120, with grant reimbursements
credited back to the same account; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to undertake the
administrative acts required pursuant to the grant agreement.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 439
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Trustee Pekarek thanked Assistant to the Village Manager Josh Ringel who was
successful in securing this grant.
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution Authorizing the Execution of an Intermunicipal Agreement with the
Scarsdale Union Free School District in Regard to the South Fox Meadow Brook Knotweed
Remediation Project was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, an invasive plant species, Japanese knotweed (Reynoutria Japonica), is
aggressively growing along the section of South Fox Meadow Brook
flowing through Harwood Woods, Harwood Park, and Scarsdale
High School property; and
WHEREAS, left unchecked, the knotweed will work to undermine, through
organic matter deposition and culvert obstruction, the Village of
Scarsdale watercourse restoration work completed in 2015, as well as
dominate the wetlands ecology, thereby adversely impacting
ecological function through severe reduction or elimination of native
wetland plant species; and
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale is desirous of protecting its significant South
Fox Meadow Brook watercourse restoration investment and
capitalizing on the ecological services that a healthy, native wetland
ecosystem provides, thus necessitating a multi-year knotweed
eradication program involving a combination of mechanical and
manual invasive species control, herein referred to as the South Fox
Meadow Brook Knotweed Remediation Project (Project); and
WHEREAS Village of Scarsdale staff met with Scarsdale Union Free School
District staff to discuss the prospect of working cooperatively to
implement the Project, which involves both School and Village
Property, having agreed that the project merits joint funding and that
New York State funding should be pursued, as well; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 440
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale applied for and received a $24,500 NYS
Department of Environmental Conservation Invasive Species Rapid
Response and Control Grant, which includes an equal local match
requirement to be satisfied through separate $10,000 funding
appropriations by the School District and Village with the balance
completed through Village in-kind services; and
WHEREAS, an Intermunicipal Agreement is necessary to establish authority for
joint Project implementation, with the Scarsdale Board of Education
considering said agreement, attached herewith, at its meeting on
September 25, 2017; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees hereby authorizes the Village Manager to
execute, in substantially the same form as attached hereto, an
Intermunicipal Agreement with the Scarsdale Union Free School
District for activities related to the South Fox Meadow Brook
Knotweed Remediation Project; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to undertake any
administrative acts required under the terms of the agreement.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution regarding Rejection of Bids for VM #1225 – South Fox Meadow Brook
Knotweed Remediation was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, on August 25, 2017, the Village published VM Contract #1225
seeking bids for the Fox Meadow Brook Knotweed Remediation
Project for work involving 15 bi-weekly cuttings of Japanese
Knotweed in two separate service areas over a three year period
along the South Fox Meadow Brook; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 441
WHEREAS, on the bid opening date, Tuesday, September 12, 2017, one bid was
received for a total of $53,550, a cost in excess of the established
project budget and available funding; and
WHEREAS, as a result of lack of competition and the potential for reducing
project costs through elimination of unnecessary manual labor and
hauling of plant materials, staff recommends rejecting the sole bid,
modifying the bid specifications, and undertaking a rebidding process
inclusive of additional vendor outreach to cultivate increased
participation; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that pursuant to Section 103 of the New York State General
Municipal Law and Section 57-7 of the Village Code, the Village
Board hereby rejects the sole bid received for VM Contract #1225 –
South Fox Meadow Brook Knotweed Remediation; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to re-advertise and re-
bid these items in accordance with New York State General
Municipal Law.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Upon motion entered by Trustee Pekarek, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution regarding Authorization to Execute a Memorandum of Agreement with
the Village of Scarsdale, Scarsdale Union Free School District and Scarsdale/Edgemont
Family Counseling Service for the FY 2017/18 Youth Services Project was approved by the
vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, in 1984 the Village of Scarsdale, Scarsdale Union Free School District
and Scarsdale-Edgemont Family Counseling Service recognized the
need for a safety net for youth and emotional support for their
parents which led to the creation of the Scarsdale Youth Services
Project; and
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 442
WHEREAS, the Youth Services Project is a partnership of the Village of
Scarsdale, Scarsdale Union Free School District and
Scarsdale/Edgemont Family Counseling Service that provides
challenging programs for youth and parents that build confidence
and strengthen the character of youth in grades six through twelve,
provide outreach to parents, make available support groups, offer
parenting strategies as well as other challenging programs; and
WHEREAS, the current agreement expired effective August 31, 2017, and
Scarsdale/Edgemont Family Counseling Service has proffered a
successor agreement to the Village which includes a new provision
allowing the School Superintendent and Village Manager limited
flexibility to adjust the agreement fee for certain unforeseen
personnel matters effecting the provision of counseling services
provided by the Scarsdale-Edgemont Family Counseling Services;
and
WHEREAS, the term of the proposed agreement is for one year, commencing
September 1, 2017, and terminating August 31, 2018, at a total cost
of $474,418.70, to be distributed equally between the Village and
Scarsdale Union Free School District at $237,209.35 for each
government; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees provided an appropriation of $237,209.35 in
the FY 2017/18 General Fund Budget for the purposes of funding
the Youth Services Project; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Village Manager are herein authorized to execute
the Memorandum of Agreement among the Village of Scarsdale,
Scarsdale Union Free School District and Scarsdale/Edgemont
Family Counseling Service, in substantially the same form as attached
hereto, and that the Village Manager is further authorized to perform
all necessary administrative acts in connection therewith; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that all costs associated with this agreement be charged to FY
2017/18 General Fund Budget Account # A-9990-HUMSV-
YOUTH-400 499 not to exceed budgeted appropriations.
AYES NAYS RECUSED ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None Trustee Samwick None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 443
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Recreation Committee
Upon motion entered by Trustee Callaghan, and seconded by Trustee Veron, the
following resolution regarding Rejection of Bids for VM Contract #1224 – Irrigation System
Services was approved by the vote indicated below:
WHEREAS, costs for irrigations system services have escalated in recent years due
to expansion of irrigated areas and the aging of certain system
components, thus requiring a sealed bid procurement process; and
WHEREAS, the Village now has fifteen properties with irrigation systems of
varying sizes, each of which requires seasonal commissioning and
winterization, as well as unscheduled repairs, collectively “Irrigation
System Services”; and
WHEREAS, on July 28, 2017, the Village published VM Contract #1224 seeking
sealed bids for Irrigation System Services throughout the Village’s
parks and facilities and on the bid opening date, Tuesday, August 21,
2017, four bids were received; and
WHEREAS, bid review revealed that the bid specifications failed to limit the cost
of materials to no greater than 1.1% above the amount invoiced to
the contractor, which renders the bids received not comparable to
one another; and
WHEREAS, it is in the Village’s best interest to reject all bids and reissue the
Request for Bids with modified bid specifications, as related above
and discussed further in the attached staff memo; now, therefore, be
it
RESOLVED, pursuant to Section 103 of the New York State General Municipal
Law and Section 57-7 of the Village Code, the Village Board hereby
rejects all bids received pursuant to VM Contract #1224 – Irrigation
System Services; and be it further
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 444
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized and directed re-bid
these items in accordance with New York State General Municipal
Law.
AYES NAYS ABSENT
Trustee Callaghan None None
Trustee Finger
Trustee Pekarek
Trustee Ross
Trustee Samwick
Trustee Veron
Mayor Hochvert
********
Written Communications
All communications received that are written to the Mayor and Board of Trustees
can be viewed on the Village’s website, www.scarsdale.com under the Board of Trustees or
Village Clerk section.
Mayor Hochvert noted that the Board received a report from the Scarsdale Forum
Municipal Committee on the quality of life and Village Code violations.
Mayor Hochvert further stated that this afternoon he received a note from Cynthia
Roberts relating to trash overflows in the Village Center.
********
Future Meeting Schedule
Tuesday, October 10, 2017 – Committee of the Whole – 6:30 P.M. – Third Floor
Meeting Room
Tuesday, October 10, 2017 – Agenda Committee Meeting – 7:30 P.M. – Trustees’
Room
Tuesday, October 10, 2017 – Village Board Meeting – 8:00 P.M. – Rutherford Hall
Tuesday, October 24, 2017 – Agenda Committee Meeting – 7:30 P.M. – Trustees’
Room
Tuesday, October 24, 2017 – Village Board Meeting – 8:00 P.M. – Rutherford Hall
Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Land Use Committee Meeting – 6:00 P.M. – Third
Floor Meeting Room
Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Agenda Committee Meeting – 7:30 P.M. – Trustees’
Village Board of Trustees 10/10/2017 445
Room
Tuesday, November 14, 2017 – Village Board Meeting – 8:00 P.M. – Rutherford Hall
********
Village Hall Schedule
Monday, October 9, 2017 – Columbus Day – Village Hall Closed
********
There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was
adjourned at 10:05 P.M. on a motion entered by Trustee Finger, seconded by Trustee
Pekarek and carried unanimously.
Donna M. Conkling
Village Clerk
RESOLUTION RE: ACCEPTANCE OF GIFTS TO THE SCARSDALE
PUBLIC LIBRARY
WHEREAS, the Henry Laird Smith Foundation has made a $1,000 donation to the
Scarsdale Public Library; and
WHEREAS, the Gellin Zalaznick Foundation, Inc., has made a $750 donation to the
Scarsdale Public Library; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Policy #103: “Gifts to the Village of Scarsdale” of the Village
of Scarsdale Administrative Policies & Procedures Manual, acceptance of
all gifts valued at $500 or greater must be approved by the Village Board
of Trustees; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Board hereby accepts gifts to the Scarsdale Public Library
in the amounts of $750.00 from the Gellin Zalaznick Foundation, Inc., and
$1,000 from the Henry Laird Smith Foundation to use for general library
purposes; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Treasurer take the necessary steps to complete the
transaction and accept these financial gifts of $1,750 and deposit it in the
Library’s Miscellaneous Gifts Account; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees hereby extends their heartfelt thanks and great
appreciation to the Gellin Zalaznick Foundation, Inc., and the Henry Laird
Smith Foundation.
Submitted by: Village Manager
Date: October 20, 2017
For: October 24, 2017
RESOLUTION RE: AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AN
AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT
WITH WESTCHESTER COUNTY FOR 2
DRAKE ROAD
WHEREAS, the Village of Scarsdale (“Village”) owns certain real property
known as 2 Drake Road (“Premises”), which is improved by a one-
family home and identified on the Village of Scarsdale Tax Map as
Section 11, Block 12, Lot 2; and
WHEREAS, the Village and the County of Westchester (“County”) are
currently parties to a lease agreement originally executed in 1987,
renewed in 1994, 1999, 2004, 2009, and again in 2014, under
which the Village leases the premises to the County; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the terms of the latest agreement (attached), the County
uses the property to provide transitional housing for homeless
families or for longer-term housing, as approved by the Village
Manager; and
WHEREAS, the proposed lease agreement requires that the County pay to the
Village a sum equal to the monthly shelter allowance approved by
the New York State Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance
for Westchester County, currently estimated at $5,112; and
WHEREAS, the family residing at 2 Drake Road does not meet the eligibility
requirements for federal and state assistance due to their residency
status, an therefore the County is unable to collect the New York
State shelter allowance; and
WHEREAS, previous requests from the County Department of Social Services
to waive the rental fee have been approved by Village Boards via
resolutions dated September 13, 2005, January 8, 2008, September
22, 2009, June 28, 2011, May 22, 2012, May 14, 2013, and April
8, 2014, attached hereto and made a part hereof, coinciding with
the residency tenure of the current family; and
WHEREAS, the County is again asking the Village to waive the rental
payments provided for in the proposed successor agreement, as
they continue to work with the family to establish a self-
sufficiency plan and move them out of 2 Drake Rd; and
WHEREAS, the approximate $5,112 in annual state assistance represents less
than 1% of our Village’s budget revenue estimate for the rental of
real property, with the waiver of such revenue having minimal
impact on the overall budget; and
WHEREAS, staff recommends that the Village Board grant a rent waiver from
May 1, 2015, through April 30, 2018, said waiver to be
accomplished through an addendum to the proposed agreement in
the form of a letter in substantially the same form attached hereto;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute a lease
agreement with the County of Westchester, in substantially the
same form as attached hereto; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the annual rent payment equal to the monthly shelter
allowance approved by the New York State Office of Temporary
Disability Assistance for Westchester County, identified in
paragraph two of the agreement, is herein waived for the period of
May 1, 2015, through April 30, 2018; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager shall take all administrative acts
necessary in accordance with said lease agreement.
Submitted by: Village Manager
Date: October 20, 2017
For: October 24, 2017
October 24, 2017
Stacey Reynolds
Director of Temporary Assistance
Westchester County Department of Social Services
85 Court Street, Room 225
White Plains, NY 10601
RE: Amendment to the 2 Drake Road Lease Agreement dated May 16, 2014, between the
Village of Scarsdale and Westchester County
Dear Ms. Reynolds,
The Village of Scarsdale acknowledges your request for a temporary waiver of Westchester
County’s rent obligation in accordance with the above referenced agreement (“Agreement”).
The Village understands that the County’s rent waiver request is advanced because the family
that the County has placed at the 2 Drake Road home since 2005, the Aguirres, is ineligible to
receive the monthly shelter allowance provided under the New York State Temporary Assistance
for Needy Families (TANF) program. Pursuant to the attached resolution adopted by the
Scarsdale Village Board of Trustees on October 24, 2017, the Village herein agrees to waive the
monthly shelter allowance payment identified in Paragraph 2 – “Rent” of the Agreement. This
waiver is provided for a three-year period, from May 1, 2015 – April 30, 2018, and may be
extended by the Village upon written request from the County. The rent waiver will immediately
expire and shall not be renewed once the Aguirres no longer reside at 2 Drake Road; all other
provisions of the Agreement shall remain in full force and effect at such time.
This letter of agreement shall serve as an amendment to the Agreement dated May 16,
2014, between the Village of Scarsdale and the County of Westchester and become a part
thereof. Please forward a fully executed original to my attention for Village of Scarsdale files.
The Village of Scarsdale appreciates the County’s support and concern for the Aguirre
family, and the Village is pleased to able to contribute to this effort.
Sincerely,
.
Stephen M. Pappalardo
Village Manager
(Date) (Signature) (Print Name) __________________
Accepted by Westchester County
RESOLUTION RE: SCHEDULE PUBLIC HEARING ON
SCHOOL SPEED LIMITS FOR BUTLER
ROAD AND HUNTINGTON AVENUE
RESOLVED, that a Public Hearing is hereby scheduled by the Board of Trustees
of the Village of Scarsdale in Rutherford Hall at Village Hall on
Tuesday, November 14, 2017, at 8:00 pm to receive comments on
the addition of new School Speed Limits pursuant to Sections
290-7 and 290-54 of the Village Code.
RESOLVED, that the Village Clerk is directed to advertise said Public Hearing.
Submitted by: Village Manager
Date: October 20, 2017
For: October 24, 2017
Village of Scarsdale
Memorandum
Village Manager’s Office
To: Stephen M. Pappalardo, Village Manager
From: Joshua Ringel, Assistant to the Village Manager
Date: October 17, 2017
Re: School Speed Limit Requests: Fox Meadow School & Greenacres School
Fox Meadow School: Butler Road
The Village of Scarsdale received complaints of speeding vehicles on Butler Road between
Brewster Road and Brite Road in 2016. Scarsdale Police recorded speeds and vehicle counts
in June 2016 and found that no excessive speeding issue existed in relation to the posted 30
MPH limit. Neighborhood residents subsequently requested a school speed limit be established
for Butler Road due to it’s proximity to Fox Meadow Elementary School.
In order for a school speed limit to be established, New York State Vehicle and Traffic Law
Section 1643 and New York State Department of Transportation Regulations requires the
following conditions be met:
1. The facility in question adjacent to the road is a school;
2. Some of the children walk or bicycle to or from the facility, or the facility and related
facilities (e.g., classrooms, cafeteria, gymnasium, playground, athletic fields, parking
lots) are separated by a highway and require the children to cross the highway on foot
to access the facilities;
3. The school speed limit shall not be no lower than 15 MPH; and
4. The length of the school speed limit zone shall not exceed 1,320 feet on a highway
passing a school building, entrance or exit of a school abutting on the highway, and
shall begin no farther than 300 feet from the school property line.
5. The school speed limit may only be in effect 7AM-6PM.
The intersection at Brewster and Butler is directly adjacent to School Property, which conforms
to state law and regulations. The intersection of Brite Ave and Butler Rd is approximately 320
feet from the school property line. Accordingly, a Butler Road School Speed Limit may begin
at the intersection of Brewster Road and Butler Road and end approximately 20 feet prior the
intersection of Butler Road and Brite Ave. The distance between Brewster Road and Brite
Avenue is approximately 1,052 feet. David Parker, NYSDOT Traffic Safety & Operations
Investigator, confirmed that the school speed zone herein described is permissible under NYS
law. Attached to this memo is a map depicting the school speed limit boundaries.
The Traffic Safety Committee considered the request at its July 13, 2017, meeting and
recommends establishment of the Butler Road School Speed Limit.
Greenacres School: Huntington Avenue
This is a technical correction. Huntington Avenue from Brewster Road to Montrose Road
(along the north side of Greenacres School) is already signed with a 15 MPH school speed
limit, however, it was inadvertently omitted from the Scarsdale Village Code when instituted
and is therefore currently uncodified. It is proper to correct this omission at this time.
Page 2
Butler Road School Speed Limit Zone
Fox Meadow Elementary
Print Date: 10/20/2017
INTRODUCTORY LOCAL LAW # ___ OF 2017
A LOCAL LAW AMENDING CHAPTER 290 OF THE SCARSDALE VILLAGE CODE
ENTITLED VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC
BE IT ENACTED by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Scarsdale as follows:
§ 290-54. Schedule III: School Speed Limits
In accordance with § 290-7, no person shall drive a vehicle in excess of the speeds indicated
below, in the areas designated below, during school days between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and
6:00 p.m.:
Speed Limit
Name of Street (mph) Location
Boulevard 15 From Post Road to Bell Road
Brewster Road 15 From Chesterfield Road north for 260 feet
Brite Avenue 15 From Butler Road to a point 260 feet north of Chesterfield Road
Butler Road 15 From Brewster Road to Brite Avenue
Chesterfield Road 15 From Brite Avenue to Brewster Road
Edgewood Road 15 From Nelson Road to Boulevard
Ferncliff Road 15 From Drake Road to Edgewood Road
Gaylor Road 15 From Carman Road to Boulevard
Huntington Avenue 15 From Brewster Road to Montrose Road
Mamaroneck Road 15 From Catherine Road to Mohican Trail
Montrose Road 15 From Huntington Avenue to a point 260 feet north thereof
Nelson Road 15 From Barry Road to Rodney Road
Putnam Road 15 From Sage Terrace to Huntington Avenue
Rodney Road 15 From Nelson Road to Ferncliff Road
Roosevelt Place 15 From Edgewood Road to Ferncliff Road
Wayside Lane 15 From Post Road to Carstensen Road
EFFECTIVE DATE
This Local Law shall take effect immediately upon filing with the Secretary of State.
Underline means addition.
Strikethrough means delete.
RESOLUTION RE: AWARDING VM CONTRACT #1227 – PLUMBING AND
HEATING SERVICES, VILLAGE OF SCARSDALE
WHEREAS, general plumbing work and heater/boiler maintenance services for Village-owned
facilities is currently performed by way of a time and materials contract with a
local plumbing and heating services pursuant to a previous Request for Proposal
process; and
WHEREAS, based on an increase in the amount of work, it is necessary to perform a sealed bid
process to conform with NYS Bidding Laws, and as such, on September 8, 2017,
the Village advertised for the receipt of bids under M Contract #1227 – Plumbing
and Heating Services; and
WHEREAS, three bids were received on the bid opening date of October 3, 2017, with the
lowest responsive bid submitted by NY Home Maintenance Co., D/B/A A.
Borrelli Mechanical, 147 Wheeler Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570, itemized as
follows: Mechanic Standard Hourly rate $92.00 and Helper hourly rate $82.00;
and
WHEREAS, A.Borrelli Mechanical, has previously provided these plumbing and heating
contract services for the Village in a satisfactory manner and is familiar with the
scope of work required; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract #1227 – Plumbing and Heating Services be awarded to the
lowest responsive bidder, NY Home Maintenance Co., D/B/A A. Borrelli
Mechanical, 147 Wheeler Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570, at the hourly rates
specified in their bid for a total amount not to exceed budget appropriations; and
be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is hereby authorized to execute VM Contract #1227 –
Plumbing and Heating Services on behalf of the Village with NY Home
Maintenance Co., D/B/A A.Borrelli Mechanical; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the costs of VM Contract #1227 be charged to the appropriate budget
accounts, as determined by the Village Treasurer and subject to adequate budget
appropriations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this two year contract may be extended annually by the Village Manager for
three additional one-year periods subject to the availability of adequate budget
appropriations and in accordance with the provision in the contract for adjusted
rates based on certain state indices and provided that all other contract terms and
conditions remain unchanged.
Submitted by: Village Manager
Date: October 20, 2017
For: October 24, 2017
ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT
VILLAGE OF SCARSDALE
WESTCHESTER COUNTY, NEW YORK
PLUMBING AND HEATING SERVICES
VILLAGE OF SCARSDALE
VM Contract # 1227
ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT
Albert Borrelli, Owner
__________________________________________________________doing business as
Name of Bidder
NY Home Maintenance Co., Inc., D/B/A A.Borrelli Mechanical
___________________________________________________________________________
Name of Company
147 Wheeler Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570
of_________________________________________________________________________
Address
hereby agrees to furnish labor, materials, parts and equipment and perform the
work for the Village of Scarsdale, Westchester County, New York in accordance
with the Proposal, Information for Bidders, General Conditions, Supplemental
General Conditions and all sections of the Project Specifications dated
September 8, 2017, which are attached to these Articles of Agreement and hereby
made a part of this contract, (all of which contract documents the Contractor
acknowledges he has read and examined) and to accept in full payment for the
work listed in the Proposal, accepted by the Village of Scarsdale, New York,
agrees to make payment per the following Bid Price:
1.) Standard Hours Service- Year 0ne (1) and Year Two (2)
92.00
A.) $___________________________________________per / hr. – Mechanic
(Written in Numbers)
Ninety Two Dollars
$___________________________________________per / hr. – Mechanic
(Written in Words)
82.00
B.) $___________________________________________per / hr. – Helper
(Written in Numbers)
Eighty Two Dollars
$___________________________________________per / hr. – Helper
(Written in Words)
Emergency Service – Shall be 1.5X Standard Hours Service Rate.
Sunday and Holiday Service – Shall be 2X Standard Hours Service Rate.
ARTICLES OF AGREEMENT
Material multiplier shall be 1.1x the cost to the material.
This is a two year contract and the price may be escalated as specified under
the terms on the Contract in the Information for Bidders.
The Village of Scarsdale, Westchester County, New York, agrees to make payment
in full for work performed to the satisfaction of the appropriate Village
officials. Upon the failure of the Contractor to perform in any manner,
in accordance with the Proposal, Information for Bidders, General Conditions,
Supplemental General Conditions and all sections of the Project Specifications
dated September 8, 2017 the Village has the right to cancel this contract.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Village of Scarsdale has caused this Contract to be
executed by its duly authorized officers, who, however, incur no possible
personal liability by reason of the execution thereof or of anything herein
contained, and has hereunto set his hand and seal this__________________day
of____________________________.
Village of Scarsdale: Contractor:
_____________________________ By: _____________________________
Village Manager Name (Signature)
Attest
_____________________________ _____________________________
Village Clerk Name (printed)
_____________________________
Title
Attest:________________________
Village of Scarsdale
Memo
To: Stephen M. Pappalardo, Village Manager
From: Paul Zaicek, Director of Capital Projects
CC: Benedict Salanitro, Superintendent of Public Works
Mary Lou McClure, Village Treasurer
Date: October 18, 2017
Re: VM Contract# 1227 – Plumbing & Heating Services
Plumbing and heating services for Village-owned properties are billed on a time and material
basis whereby a plumbing and/or mechanical contractor performs miscellaneous plumbing &
heating work on an as needed basis, including necessary preventative maintenance and seasonal
servicing, for a set hourly rate and the Village reimburses the contractor for materials used. As
the total annual cost of plumbing and heating services each year may exceed $35,000, the
threshold for public works contracts pursuant to Section 2.4 of the Village’s Internal Control
Policy, the public letting of a plumbing and heating services contract was necessary.
The existing agreement for such services expired in August 2017 and the Village advertised
on September 08, 2017, for the receipt of bids pursuant to VM Contract #1227 – Plumbing
and Heating Services. Notice to Bidders was sent to the Scarsdale Inquirer, Construction Data
News and Dodge Reports, and provided directly to five Plumbing/Mechanical contractors.
The contract specifications were also placed on the Empire State online Bid System. On the
bid opening date, October 03, 2017, three bids were opened, as documented on the attached
bid tabulation sheet.
NY Home Maintenance Co., D/B/A A. Borrelli Mechanical (A. Borrelli), was the lowest
responsible bidder. A. Borrelli’s hourly rates are within industry standards and conform to
NYS Prevailing Wage requirements. Additionally, A. Borrelli provided plumbing and heating
time and material contract work for the Village several years ago and the Village found their
work to be timely and professional. Current references were also checked and the vendor
displayed complete understanding of the required scope of work.
Accordingly, staff recommends award of VM Contract # 1227 – Plumbing and Heating
Services to NY Home Maintenance Co., D/B/A A. Borrelli Mechanical, 124 Wheeler
Avenue, Pleasantville, NY 10570, at the rates specified in their bid, for a total not to exceed
budget appropriations.
Please place the attached resolution and supporting materials on the Village Board’s October
24, 2017, agenda for their consideration.
Page 1
Village of Scarsdale
Memorandum
Parks, Recreation, and Conservation Department
To: Stephen M. Pappalardo, Village Manager
From: Brian Gray, Superintendent of PRC
Date: October 19, 2017
Re: Award of VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation System Services
The Village of Scarsdale has installed irrigation systems at 15 locations across the Village. The
irrigation systems require a combination of preventative and seasonal maintenance, as well as repairs
on an as-needed basis. Non-scheduled repairs comprise the largest portion of our maintenance costs.
Because our annual maintenance costs may exceed $35,000, the threshold for public works contracts
pursuant to Section 103 of the New York State General Municipal Law, the public letting of an
Irrigation System Services contract was deemed prudent.
VM #1232 - Irrigation System Services was advertised in the Scarsdale Inquirer on September 29,
2017, with copies of the bid opportunity also distributed directly to five vendors, as well as posted on
the Village website. On the bid opening date, October 10, 2017, five sealed bids were opened, as
summarized in the attached bid tabulation sheet. The lowest bid was received from Tony Casale, Inc.,
1185 Saw Mill River Road, Yonkers, NY 10710. However, the firm’s bid was deemed non-responsive
to the bid specifications by Village Attorney Wayne Esannason because it did not adhere to Prevailing
Wage requirements. As a result, the lowest responsive bidder was East Coast Irrigation, 20 Wright
Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583.
Based on the aforementioned information, the lowest responsive aggregate bid total for Units A, B, and
C was received from East Coast Irrigation, in the estimated amount of $20,620.00 per year for Year
One and Year Two of this two year contract. The firm’s bid is comprised of $3,500 for Unit A (system
winterization), $4,700 for Unit B (seasonal system start-up), and Unit C unscheduled repair hourly
labor rates of $135.00 for either a mechanic or laborer. The estimated bid total was calculated using
the combination of the Unit A bid, Unit B bid, and the hourly rate multiplied by the estimated number
of repair hours for the mechanic (32) and laborer (60), which was based on actual annual repair billing
historical data, for a Unit C total of $12,420.00, and grand annual total of $20,620.00. Village staff met
with East Coast Irrigation, and determined that the firm conveyed a clear understanding of the scope of
work and confidence in their ability to perform as required.
As a result of the foregoing, I recommend awarding VM Contract # 1232 – Irrigation System Services
Unit A & B in the amount of $8,200.00 for Year One and Year Two (11/17 through 10/18 & 11/18
through 10/19), as well as Unit C for the standard hourly rate for a Mechanic of $135.00 and a Laborer
of $135.00, for an estimated annual total of $20,620.00. As proposed, the Village Manager may extend
the contract for two additional one-year periods, subject to the availability of adequate budget
appropriations in accordance with the annual consumer price index provision provided. Please place
this item on the Village Board’s October 24, 2017, agenda for their consideration.
RESOLUTION RE: AWARDING CONTRACTS PURUSANT TO VM
#1232 - IRRIGATION SYSTEM SERVICES
WHEREAS, the Village has fifteen (15) properties containing irrigation systems which
require a combination of preventative and seasonal maintenance, as well
as repairs on an as needed basis; and
WHEREAS, because non-scheduled repairs comprise the largest portion of our
maintenance costs which may exceed $35,000 annually, the threshold for
public works contracts pursuant to the New York State General Municipal
Law, the public letting of an Irrigation Systems Services contract was
deemed prudent; and
WHEREAS, the Village Manager reports that he publicly advertised for the receipt of
bids on September 29, 2017, under VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation
System Services, including Unit A (system winterization), Unit B (system
seasonal opening), and Unit C (unscheduled repairs), and sent the bid
documents to five potential contractor’s, with five sealed bids
subsequently received on the bid opening date, October 10, 2017; and
WHEREAS, the bid received from the apparent low bidder was deemed non-compliant
and disqualified due to the contractors failure to incorporate mandatory
New York State Labor Department Prevailing Wage rates; and
WHEREAS, the lowest responsible bid was received from East Coast Irrigation, 20
Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, comprised of Unit A ($3,500.00),
Unit B ($4,700), and Unit C ($135.00 hourly rate for either a mechanic or
laborer), for an estimated combined total of $20,620.00 annually; and
WHEREAS, staff has received favorable references for East Coast Irrigation, and
determined that the contractor understands the scope of work required, and
as such, recommends the award of VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation
System Services to the lowest responsible bidder, East Coast Irrigation;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that VM Contract #1232 – Irrigation System Services Units A ($3,500.00),
and B ($4,700.00), and C (standard hourly rate of $135.00 for either a
mechanic or laborer) for an estimated annual total $20,620.00 for each
year of the two-year agreement is herein awarded to East Coast Irrigation,
20 Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, for these unit bid prices which are
in accordance with the Bid Tabulation Sheet attached hereto and made a
part hereof, subject to the availability of adequate budget appropriations;
and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Village Manager is herein authorized to execute VM Contract #
1232 – Irrigation System Services Units A, B, and C with East Coast
Irrigation, 20 Wright Place, Scarsdale, NY 10583, for a two-year term
subject to the availability of adequate budget appropriations; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that all costs associated with VM Contract #1232 Irrigation System
Services be charged to A-7020 PLGRD- MAINT- 400-499; and be it
further
RESOLVED, that this contract may be extended annually by the Village Manager for
two additional one-year periods, subject to the availability of adequate
budget appropriations and in accordance with all other contract terms and
conditions.
Submitted by: Village Manager
Date: October 20, 2017
For: October 24, 2017
Get email alerts for Scarsdale
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.