Planning Commission Meetings

City Planning Commission Minutes Carnegie Town Hall, 235 West 10th Street Wednesday, February 2, 2011 at 7:00 PM ROLL CALL Members Present: Members Absent: Planning Commissioner Jessie Schmidt Planning Commissioner Ken Dunlap Planning Commissioner Steve Gaspar Planning Commissioner Pam Breidenbach Planning Commissioner Lynnette Olson Planning Commissioner Darla Erb Planning Commissioner Kent Metzger Planning Commissioner Meredith Larson CONSENT AGENDA 1. APPROVAL OF JANUARY 5, 2011 MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING. 2. PLATS 3. 2011-01-01: REZONE from the RS-1 and RS-2, Residential Districts to the RC, Recreation/Conservation District for allowed uses at East of S. Ellis Rd. & W. 22nd St. Legal Description: A portion of the N1/2 SW1/4, Section 22-101N-50W, except the W 561' thereof and except Lot H1 of the NW1/4 SW 1/4 contained therein, Minnehaha County (as shown by exhibit) Recommendation Approval 4. 2011-01-05: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-4, Planned Commercial District to allow off-sale alcohol within 500 feet of a school at 900 N. Sycamore Ave. Legal Description: Tract 11, Richmond Estates 4th Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval 5. 2011-01-03: FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN in Subarea F of the Dawley Farm Village Planned Development District to construct a restaurant at 1010 S. Highline Place. Legal Description: Lot 4, Block 18, Dawley Farm Village Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval  6. 2011-01-07: FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN in Subarea A of the Eastern Hills Planned Development District to construct a 48 unit apartment building at 4200 S. Sycamore Ave. Legal Description: Lot 5, Block 15, Prairie Gardens Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval Deferred by petitioner CONSENT AGENDA APPROVAL A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Pam Breidenbach to approve with Item 4 moved to Regular agenda and Item 6 Deferred. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed REGULAR AGENDA APPROVAL 7. 2011-01-02: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-2, General Commercial District to develop a site greater than an acre and to allow off-sale alcohol within 500 feet of a school at 1901 E. 10th St. Legal Description: Lots 1-12, Block 6, Dunning & Wagner's Addition (except Lot H-1 in said Lots 1 & 12), Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Steve Gaspar and seconded by Commissioner Kent Metzger to approve 2011-01-02: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-2, General Commercial District to develop a site greater than an acre and to allow off-sale alcohol within 500 feet of a school at 1901 E. 10th St. Legal Description: Lots 1-12, Block 6, Dunning & Wagner's Addition (except Lot H-1 in said Lots 1 & 12), Minnehaha County with the following stipulation: No outdoor advertising of alcohol. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed 8. 2010-12-07: MAJOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Scooter Planned Development District to add retail trade and service as an allowed land use at 1108 E. 2nd St. Legal Description: Lots 20, 21, & 22 (Ex. W 8' and Ex. Lot E and Ex. Lot H-1), Block 2, Gamberg's Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Lynnette Olson and seconded by Commissioner  Darla Erb to approve 2010-12-07: MAJOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Scooter Planned Development District to add retail trade and service as an allowed land use at 1108 E. 2nd St. Legal Description: Lots 20, 21, & 22 (Ex. W 8' and Ex. Lot E and Ex. Lot H-1), Block 2, Gamberg's Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed 9. 2011-01-06: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-2, General Commercial District to allow motor vehicle sales and display at 1520 W. 12th St. Legal Description: W1/2 Vac Alley & Lots 5-6 (Exc. S 7' Lot 5), Block 20, Covell's 2nd Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Kent Metzger and seconded by Commissioner Steve Gaspar to approve 2011-01-06: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-2, General Commercial District to allow motor vehicle sales and display at 1520 W. 12th St. Legal Description: W1/2 Vac Alley & Lots 5-6 (Exc. S 7' Lot 5), Block 20, Covell's 2nd Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Ken Dunlap, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 7. Against: , 0. Motion Passed 10. 2011-01-09: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-3, Central Business District to allow residential dwelling units on the first floor at 620 N. Main Ave. Legal Description: Lots 1-6, Block 33, Brookings & Edmunds Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Lynnette Olson and seconded by Commissioner Pam Breidenbach to approve 2011-01-09: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-3, Central Business District to allow residential dwelling units on the first floor at 620 N. Main Ave. Legal Description: Lots 1-6, Block 33, Brookings & Edmunds Addition, Minnehaha County . For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed 11. 2011-01-08: DESIGN REVIEW in the Downtown Design Review District to construct a 44 unit multi-family apartment complex for the elderly at 620 N. Main Ave. Legal Description: Lots 1-6, Block 33, Brookings & Edmunds Addition, Minnehaha County  Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Darla Erb to approve 2011-01-08: DESIGN REVIEW in the Downtown Design Review District to construct a 44 unit multi-family apartment complex for the elderly at 620 N. Main Ave. Legal Description: Lots 1-6, Block 33, Brookings & Edmunds Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed Pam Breidenbach left 12. 2010-12-02: MINOR AMENDMENT In Subarea C of the Valhalla Planned Development District to reduce the number of required parking stalls from 116 to 102 and the reduce the required side yard setback from 10' to 0' at 4400-4426 S. Technology Dr.. Legal Description: Lot 2, Evergreen Office Park Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Kent Metzger and seconded by Commissioner Lynnette Olson to approve 2010-12-02: MINOR AMENDMENT In Subarea C of the Valhalla Planned Development District to reduce the number of required parking stalls from 116 to 102 and the reduce the required side yard setback from 10' to 0' at 4400-4426 S. Technology Dr.. Legal Description: Lot 2, Evergreen Office Park Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 5. Against: , 0. Motion Passed Pam Breidenbach returned 13. REPORT OF THE PARKING REQUIREMENT STUDY GROUP Recommendation Accept A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Kent Metzger to accept REPORT OF THE PARKING REQUIREMENT STUDY GROUP. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed 14. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, SD, AMENDING THE REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY TO REVISE RESIDENTIAL PARKING TO ALLOW FOR TEMPORARY PARKING FOR  RECREATIONAL VEHICLES Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Pam Breidenbach to approve AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, SD, AMENDING THE REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY TO REVISE RESIDENTIAL PARKING TO ALLOW FOR TEMPORARY PARKING FOR RECREATIONAL VEHICLES. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, 5. Against: Kent Metzger, 1. Motion Passed 15. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, SD, AMENDING THE REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF COMMERCIAL VEHICLE AND ADD A DEFINITION FOR SERVICE VEHICLES Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Lynnette Olson and seconded by Commissioner Pam Breidenbach to approve AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, SD, AMENDING THE REVISED ORDINANCES OF THE CITY TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF COMMERCIAL VEHICLE AND ADD A DEFINITION FOR SERVICE VEHICLES. For: Meredith Larson, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 5. Against: Steve Gaspar, 1. Motion Passed ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Commissioner Kent Metzger and seconded by Commissioner Steve Gaspar to adjourn. For: Meredith Larson, Steve Gaspar, Pam Breidenbach, Lynnette Olson, Darla Erb, Kent Metzger, 6. Against: , 0. Motion Passed