Planning Commission Meetings

City Planning Commission Minutes Carnegie Town Hall, 235 West 10th Street Wednesday, August 3, 2011 at 7:00 PM ROLL CALL Members Present: Members Absent: Planning Commissioner Meredith Larson Planning Commissioner Darla Erb Planning Commissioner Nick Sershen Planning Commissioner Jessie Schmidt Planning Commissioner Andi Anderson Planning Commissioner Denny Pierson Planning Commissioner Steve Gaspar Planning Commissioner Lynnette Olson Planning Commissioner Ken Dunlap CONSENT AGENDA Andi Anderson stepped down from the Consent Agenda vote. 1. APPROVAL OF JULY 6, 2011 MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING. 2. PLATS 3. 2011-06-11: REZONE from the RS-2, Residential District to the RC, Recreation/Conservation District for allowed uses at E. 26th St. and S. Canyon Ave. Legal Description: Tract 5, Copper Creek Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval 4. 2011-07-06: REZONE from the I-1, Light Industrial, the C-4, Planned Commercial, and the RA-2, Residential Districts to the I-1, Light Industrial, the C-4, Planned Commercial, and the RA-2, Residential Districts for allowed uses at S. Grange Ave. & W. Village Dr.. Legal Description: A portion of the NW 1/4 NE 1/4, Section 32-101-49 as shown by exhibit, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval 5. 2011-07-10: REZONE from the RA-1, Residential and O, Office Districts to the RS-2, Residential and RC, Recreation/Conservation Districts for allowed land uses at Northwest corner of W. Benson Road and N. Marion Road.  Legal Description: A Portion of SE1/4 Section 35-102-50, as shown by Exhibit, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval 6. 2011-07-11: REZONE from the RS-2, Residential District and the RA-1, Residential District to the RD, Residential District for allowed land uses at W. Madison Street and N. Valley View Road. Legal Description: Tract 6A, Lalley Estates Addition, as shown by Exhibit, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval 7. 2011-07-13: MAJOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Celebrate Community Church Planned Development District to add a retail coffee shop as an accessory use to the the allowed uses at 1000 S. Sycamore Avenue. MOVED TO FIRST ITEM ON REGULAR AGENDA. Legal Description: Block 13, Sycamore East Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Nick Sershen and seconded by Commissioner Meredith Larson to approve 2011-07-13: MAJOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Celebrate Community Church Planned Development District to add a retail coffee shop as an accessory use to the allowed uses at 1000 S. Sycamore Avenue. Legal Description: Block 13, Sycamore East Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 5. Against: Andi Anderson, 1. Motion Passed 8. 2011-07-01: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-4, Planned Commercial District to allow a parking lot expansion at W. 59th St. & S. Louise Ave. Legal Description: Block 6, Rolling Hills Subdivision and Lots 4 thru 6, Block 1, Crystal Springs Addition, all in Lincoln County Recommendation Approval 9. 2011-07-03: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the RD, Residential District to construct a 4-unit townhome at E. 45th St. and S. Outfield Ave. Legal Description: Lot 2A, Block 5, Diamond Field Estates, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval Ken Dunlap left 10. 2011-07-08: MINOR AMENDMENT to Subarea C, Westwood Valley Planned Development District, to reduce front and rear yard minimum required setbacks from 25 feet to 20 feet at W. 32nd Street and S. Norma Trail. MOVED TO 2ND ITEM ON REGULAR AGENDA. Legal Description: Lots 3-15, Block 9, Westwood Valley Addition, Minnehaha  County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Steve Gaspar and seconded by Commissioner Nick Sershen to approve 2011-07-08: MINOR AMENDMENT to Subarea C, Westwood Valley Planned Development District, to reduce front and rear yard minimum required setbacks from 25 feet to 20 feet at W. 32nd Street and S. Norma Trail. Legal Description: Lots 3-15, Block 9, Westwood Valley Addition, Minnehaha County . For: Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Steve Gaspar, 3. Against: Denny Pierson, Lynnette Olson, 2. Meredith Larson Chaired this Item and Ken Dunlap stepped down. Motion Passed Ken Dunlap returned 11. 2011-07-07: PRELIMINARY SUBDIVISION PLAN for the Williams Addition in the I-1, Light Industrial District, the C-4, Planned Commerical District and the RA-2, Residential District for a multi-use development at S. Grange Ave. & W. Village Dr. Legal Description: A portion of the NW 1/4 NE 1/4, Section 32-101-49 as shown by exhibit, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval CONSENT AGENDA APPROVAL A motion was made by Commissioner Steve Gaspar and seconded by Commissioner Denny Pierson to approve the CONSENT AGENDA with Items 7 & 10 moved to Regular Agenda For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 5. Against: 0 Andi Anderson stepped down for this item. Motion Passed Andi Anderson returned REGULAR AGENDA APPROVAL A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Lynnette Olson to approve the REGULAR AGENDA with Item 12 deferred and Item 7 & 10 moved from the Consent Agenda. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 6. Against: 0. Motion Passed 12. 2011-07-12: REZONE from the RS-2, Residential District and the Diamond Valley Planned Development District to the RD, Residential District for allowed uses at E. 73rd Street and S. Eldorado Avenue. Legal Description: A Portion of the SE1/4 NE1/4 Section 14-100-50 as shown by Exhibit, Lincoln County Recommendation Approval 13. 2011-06-17: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the C-2, General Commercial District to allow a hotel on a non-arterial street at 2725 S. Carolyn Ave. Legal Description: Lot 5, Carolyn's Subdivision of Part of Lot 5 of Resubdivision of Sioux Falls Farmstead, Section 25-101-50, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Lynnette Olson and seconded by Commissioner Steve Gaspar to APPROVE W/CONDITIONS. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 6. Against: 0. Motion Passed 14. 2011-07-09: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT in the O, Office District to construct a Day Care Center at W. 90th Street and S. Louise Avenue. Legal Description: Tract A, Cinnamon Ridge Addition, Lincoln County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Steve Gaspar and seconded by Commissioner Nick Sershen to APPROVE W/CONDITIONS changing stipulation 4 to either wood or vinyl fence. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 6. Against: 0. Motion Passed 15. 2011-07-14: FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN in Subarea G of the Dawley Farm Village Planned Development District to construct a large single-use retail building at 601 S. Highline Pl. Legal Description: Lots 6 & 7, Block 17, Dawley Farm Village Addition, Minnehaha County (to be replatted as Lot 12, Block 17, Dawley Farm Village Addition) Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Meredith Larson and seconded by Commissioner Denny Pierson to APPROVE W/CONDITIONS and added a 4th stipulation. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 6. Against: 0. Motion Passed Andi Anderson left 16. 2011-07-02: MINOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Brooks Crossing Planned Development District to increase density to 1 per 2475 square feet and remove provisions A & D from "Other Regulations" of the Planned Development District regulations at E. 54th St. and S. Sycamore Ave.  Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Brooks Crossing Addition, Minnehaha County Recommendation Approval A motion was made by Commissioner Nick Sershen and seconded by Commissioner Lynnette Olson to approve 2011-07-02: MINOR AMENDMENT to Subarea A of the Brooks Crossing Planned Development District to increase density to 1 per 2475 square feet and remove provisions A & D from "Other Regulations" of the Planned Development District regulations at E. 54th St. and S. Sycamore Ave. Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Brooks Crossing Addition, Minnehaha County. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 5. Against: 0. Andi Anderson stepped down for this item. Motion Passed Andi Anderson returned ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Commissioner Nick Serchen and seconded by Commissioner Steve Gaspar to adjourn. For: Meredith Larson, Nick Sershen, Andi Anderson, Denny Pierson, Steve Gaspar, Lynnette Olson, 6. Against: 0. Motion Passed