Zoning Board of Adjustment

Agenda Board of Adjustment Carnegie Town Hall Tuesday, September 21, 2010 7:00 p.m. Members Present: Members Absent: Chairman Tim Johnson Robert Kummer John Kolander Erik Helland Roger Mack Chris Schiltz Lee Van De Walle NEW BUSINESS Case 10-62: Variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 13’. Applicant: Patrick Devaney Address: 905 S. Jay Circle A motion was made by Kolander, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 13’. After discussion, a motion to amend the main motion to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback only if the deck is never enclosed was made by Kolander, seconded by Mack. Roll Call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion. Passed Vote to approve the main motion as amended. Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. Variance Approved. Case 10-63: Variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 6’. Applicant: Dennis Galbavy Address: 2204 N. North Drive A motion was made by Kolander, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve. Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. Variance Approved. Case 10-64: Variance in the sign height from 8’ to 12’. Applicant: Mercy Church 1  Address: 2100 W. Ralph Rogers Road A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Kolander to approve a variance in the sign height from 8’ to 12’. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. Variance Approved. Case 10-65: Variance in the required front yard setback from 25’ to 17’. Applicant: Lindberg Home Improvement Address: 4008 E. 7th St. A motion was made by Mack, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required front yard setback from 25’ to 17’. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Motion Failed. Variance Denied. Case 10-66: Variance to allow RV parking in the required front yard setback. Withdrawn. Case 10-67: Waiver of requried hardsurfacing for a driveway access and parking lot for two years. Withdrawn. Case 10-68: Waiver of required hardsurfacing for a driveway for two years.. Withdrawn. Case 10-69: Variance in the allowable fence height from 6’ to 8’. Applicant: Kate Christopulos Address: 915 S. 1st Ave. A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Kolander to approve a variance in the allowable fence height from 6’ to 8’. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. Variance Approved 2 Case 10-70: Variance to allow parking in the required side street front yard setback. Applicant: Rick & Alecia Bingham Address: 4001 S. Outfield Ave. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Mack to approve a variance to allow parking in the required side street front yard setback. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Motion Failed. Variance Denied. Case 10-71: Variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 2’. Applicant: Ginger Bethke Address: 644 N. Leadale Ave. A motion was made by Mack, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 2’. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Johnson, 4. Noes, Kolander, 1. Motion Passed. Variance Approved. Case 10-72: Variance in the required lowest floor elevation (including basement) from 1424’ to 1414.5’ MSL for a new building. Applicant: Kenny Anderson Address: 2705 W. 12th St. A motion was made by Mack, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required lowest floor elevation (including basement) from 1424’ to 1414.5’ MSL for a new building. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. Variance Approved. Case 10-73: Variance in the number of trees allowed in the right-of-way from 6 to 18 trees. Applicant: Chad Van Buskirk 3  Address: 7700 S. Minnesota Ave. Deferred to the October 19th meeting. Case 10-74: Variance in the required front yard setback from 25’ to 0’ for parking & a waiver of hardsurfacing for 5 years. Applicant: Michael Kramer Address: 2907 W. 3rd St. A motion was made by Kolander, seconded by Mack to approve a variance in the requird front yard setback from 25’ to 0’ for parking & a waiver of hardsurfacing for 5 years. Vote to approve: Roll call: Yesses, Kolander, 1. Noes, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Johnson, 4. Motion Failed. Variance Denied. Adjournment A motion was made by Mack, seconded by Kolander to adjourn the meeting at 8:35 p.m. Vote to adjourn: Roll call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Mack, Kolander, Johnson, 5. Noes, 0. Motion Passed. 4