Zoning Board of Adjustment

Final Minutes Board of Adjustment Carnegie Town Hall Tuesday, September 20, 2011 7:00 p.m. Members Present: Members Absent: Chairman John Kolander Lee Van De Walle Monty Miller Erik Helland Greg Neitzert Chris Schiltz Kathryn Henning (non-voting) Staff Present Shawna Goldammer Barb Stoltenburg NEW BUSINESS Case 11-36: Variance in the allowable fence height from 4' to 6'. Applicant: Paul Vaughan Address: 6821 S. Avalon Cir. A motion was made by Helland, seconded by Miller to approve a variance in the allowable fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Schiltz, 3. Noes: Neitzert, Kolander, 2. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case 11-37: Variance in the required number of parking spaces from two to zero for a cold storage building. Applicant: John P. Engelhardt Address: 3510 S. First Avenue Cir. A motion was made by Miller, seconded by Schiltz, to approve a variance in the required number of parking spaces from two to zero for a cold storage building. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case 11-38: Variance in the required rear yard setback from 25' to 21'. Applicant: Brian Spaans 1  Address: 4920 E. Fernwood Dr. A motion was made by Helland, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 21’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Helland, 1. Noes: Miller, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 4. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case 11-39: Variance in the required front yard setback from 20' to 0'. Applicant: Lloyd Companies Address: 4200 W. Empire Pl. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required front yard setback form 20’ to 0’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes: 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case 11-40: Variance in (1) the required front yard setback from 25' to 10' for parking; and (2) the allowable height of a structure from 45' to 75'. Applicant: Dunham Companies Address: 3400 S. Grange Ave. A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Helland to approve a variance in (1) the required front yard setback from 25’ to 10’ for parking; and (2) the allowable height of a structure from 45’ to 75’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes: 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case 11-41: Variance in the required side yard setback from 7' to 5' 6". Applicant: Bob Natz Address: 2020 S. Pendar Ln. A motion was made by Miller, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required side yard setback from 7’ to 5’6”. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, 4. Noes: Kolander, 1. Motion passed. Variance approved. 2 Case 11-42: Variance in the required front yard setback from 15' to 0' for a paved patio (along W. Madison St.). Applicant: Paul Reynolds Address: 909 N. West Ave. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the required front yard setback from 15’ to 0’ for a paved patio (along W. Madison St.). Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes: 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case 11-43: Variance in the allowable sign height from 6' to 18'. Applicant: TSP, Inc. Address: 5101 S. Cliff Ave. A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Helland to approve a variance in the allowable sign height from 6’ to 18’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Neitzert, Schiltz, 2. Noes: Miller, Helland, Kolander, 3. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case 11-44: Variance in the allowable fence height from 4' to 6'. Applicant: James Vollmer Address: 5201 W. Ninth St. A motion was made by Miller, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in the allowable fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: 0. Noes: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case 11-45: Variance in the allowable fence height from 4' to 6'. Applicant: Brandon Gilpin & Heather Twedt Address: 4108 E. 15th St. 3  A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Miller to approve a variance in the allowable fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: 0. Noes: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case 11-46: Variance in the required side street front yard setback from 25' to 15' for a parking lot (along W. Algonquin St.). Applicant: Hugh Dodson Address: 1813 North E Ave. and 1814 North F Ave. A motion was made by Helland, seconded by Miller to approve a variance in the required side street front yard setback from 25’ to 15’ for a parking lot (along W. Algonquin St.) Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes: 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Adjournment A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Helland to adjourn the meeting at 10:18 pm. Vote to adjourn: Roll Call: Yeses: Miller, Helland, Neitzert, Schiltz, Kolander, 5. Noes: 0. Motion passed. The Board was briefed on the recent Supreme Court decision, Daniel Daily v. City of Sioux Falls. 4