Zoning Board of Adjustment

Final Minutes Board of Adjustment Carnegie Town Hall Monday, October 21, 2013 6:00 p.m. Members Present: Members Absent: Chairman Erik Helland Kathryn Henning Chris Schiltz Monty Miller Lee Van De Walle Greg Neitzert Aaron Norman Staff Present: Shawna Goldammer Bryan Wilcox NEW BUSINESS Case: 13-37: Waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West Madison Street improvements are completed. Applicant: Dieter W. Proehl Address: 2404 W. Madison St. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to approve a waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West Madison Street improvements are completed. Motion was amended by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to approve a waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West Madison Street improvements are completed and no later than 6 months after storm water improvements are completed. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Noes, 0. Amended Motion passed. Variance approved. Case: 13-29: Waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West Madison Street improvements are completed. Applicant: Alazar Dimue Address: 1013 N Garfield Ave. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to approve a waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West 1  Madison Street improvements are completed and no later than 6 months after storm water improvements are completed. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case: 13-36: Variance in the required rear yard setback from 30' to 22'. Applicant: Todd Porter Address: 2500 W. Brentridge Cir. A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 30' to 22'. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 4. Noes, Neitzert, 1. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case: 13-38: Variance in: (1) lowest floor elevation (including basement) from 1418.0’ to 1417.4’MSL: (2) Relief from Section 156.065(c) and 156.066 (b) & (d1-3). Applicant: Darla Erb Address: 3823 S. Kiwanis Circle A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in the lowest floor elevation (including basement) from 1418.0’ to 1417.4’MSL. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Schiltz to approve Relief from Section 156.065(c) and 156.066 (b) & (d1-3). Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 4. Noes, Neitzert, 1. Motion passed. Variance approved. 2 Case: 13-39: Variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 26th St. Applicant: Collin Kollars Address: 6121 W. Sioux K Court A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 26th St. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, 0. Noes, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 13-40: Variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 28th St. Applicant: Keith Hoekstra Address: 2000 S. Willow Ave. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 28th St. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, 0. Noes, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 13-41: Variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along E. 57th St. Applicant: Josh Johnson Address: 4900 & 4902 S. Kalen Pl. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along E. 57th St. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Norman, Schiltz, Helland, 3. Noes, Neitzert, Van De Walle, 2. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 13-42: Variance in: (1) Waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West 69th Street improvements are completed; (2) The allowable fence height from 6' to 8'; (3) The required front yard setback from 25' to 10'; and (4) To allow nonstandard front yard driveways. Applicant: Ronald Golden, East River Electric 3  Address: 5800 W. 69th St. A motion was made by Schiltz, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in: (1) Waiver of hardsurfacing of a parking lot until West 69th Street improvements are completed; (2) The allowable fence height from 6' to 8'; (3) The required front yard setback from 25' to 10'; and (4) To allow nonstandard front yard driveways. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance’s approved. Case: 13-43: Variance in: (1.) the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' (along W. 13th St.) for a trash enclosure; and (2.) the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' (along W. 15th St.) for a trash enclosure. Applicant: Parkview Apartments Address: 500 & 600 S. Kiwanis Ave. A motion was made by Norman, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in: (1.) the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' (along W. 13th St.) for a trash enclosure; and (2.) the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' (along W. 15th St.) for a trash enclosure. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 4. Noes, Norman, 1. Motion passed. Variance’s approved. Case: 13-44: Variance to allow parking in the required front yard setback. Applicant: Nancy Swenson Address: 516 S. Thompson Ave A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to approve a variance to allow parking in the required front yard setback. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, 0. Noes, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 13-45: Case Withdrawn 4 Case: 13-46: Variance in the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 31st St. Applicant: Faith Bradley Address: 1516 W. 31st St. A motion was made by Norman, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in the allowable fence height from 4' to 6' along W. 31st St. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, 0. Noes, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Adjournment A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Schiltz to adjourn the meeting at 9:10pm. Vote to adjourn: Roll Call: Yeses, Neitzert, Norman, Van De Walle, Schiltz, Helland, 5. Noes, 0. Motion passed. 5