Zoning Board of Adjustment

Zoning Board of Adjustment Monday, September 19, 2022 6:00 PM Carnegie Town Hall, Council Chambers 235 West Tenth Street Sioux Falls, South Dakota MEETING MINUTES CALL TO ORDER AND OPENING REMARKS Board Members Present: Mike Gray Chris Heidrich Josh Muckenhirn Graham Oey Jesse Morris Staff Present: Jason Bieber Mitchell Woldt APPROVAL OF MINUTES A motion was made by Mike Gray, seconded by Josh Muckenhirn to approve the minutes. Roll call vote to approve the minutes. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5; No: (None), 0. Motion Passed. UNFINISHED BUSINESS Case BOA-016744-2022 Variance in the required front yard setback off of E. 7th St. from 20' to 4.6' to allow for a fence. Applicant(s): Tim Thompson Address: 315 N. Sherman Ave.  A motion was made by Mike Gray, seconded by Josh Muckenhirn to approve a variance in the required front yard setback off of E. 7th St. from 20' to 4.6' to allow for a fence. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: (None), 0; No: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5. Motion Failed. Case BOA-016894-2022 Variance in the required side street front yard setback off of W. 1st St. from 20' to 0' to allow for a fence. Applicant(s): Kim Pettibone Address: 837 N. Dakota Ave. A motion was made by Jesse Morris, seconded by Mike Gray to approve a variance in the required side street front yard setback off of W. 1st St. from 20' to 0' to allow for a fence. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: (None), 0; No: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5. Motion Failed. NEW BUSINESS Case BOA-016970-2022 Variance in the required side street front yard setback off of N. Bent Grass Ct. from 20' to 10' to allow for a fence. Applicant(s): Don Stahl Address: 2900 N. Pampas Grass Ave. A motion was made by Mike Gray, seconded by Jesse Morris to approve a variance in the required side street front yard setback off of N. Bent Grass Ct. from 20' to 10' to allow for a fence. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Jesse Morris, 3; No: Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, 2. Motion Failed. Case BOA-017084-2022 Variance in the required front yard setback off of N. Euclid Ave. from 20' to 13'6" to allow for a garage.. Applicant(s): Gene Murphy Address: 1020 W. 8th St. A motion was made by Mike Gray, seconded by Josh Muckenhirn to approve a variance in the required front yard setback off of N. Euclid Ave. from 20' to 13'6" to allow for a garage.. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5; No: (None), 0. Motion Passed. Case BOA-017101-2022 Variance in the required rear yard setback from 25' to 12' to allow for a sunroom and covered porch. Applicant(s): Jay MacDonald Address: 3804 S. Morrow Dr. A motion was made by Josh Muckenhirn, seconded by Mike Gray to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25' to 12' to allow for a sunroom and covered porch. A motion was made by Josh Muckenhirn, seconded by Mike Gray to amend the main motion to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 20’ to allow for a sunroom. Roll call vote on the amendment to the main motion. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5; No: (None), 0. Motion Passed. A motion was made by Josh Muckenhirn, seconded by Mike Gray to approve the variance as amended. Roll call vote to approve the variance as amended. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5; No: (None), 0. Motion Passed. Case BOA-017107-2022 Variance in the required rear yard setback from 10' to 7' to allow for a garage. Applicant(s): Alex Halbach Address: 707 E. 21st St. A motion was made by Mike Gray, seconded by Jesse Morris to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 10' to 7' to allow for a garage. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: Mike Gray, 1; No: Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 4. Motion Failed. Case BOA-017108-2022 Variance in the required rear yard setback from 25' to 9' to allow for a four seasons porch. Applicant(s): Tim Ryan Address: 5111 S. River Park Pl. A motion was made by Chris Heidrich, seconded by Mike Gray to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25' to 9' to allow for a four seasons porch. Roll call vote to approve a variance. Yes: Mike Gray, Chris Heidrich, Josh Muckenhirn, Graham Oey, Jesse Morris, 5; No: (None), 0. Motion Passed. PUBLIC INPUT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS (5-minute comment period per individual) ADJOURNMENT Chairperson Graham Oey declared the meeting adjourned.