Olde Towne Preservation District Commission

City of Slidell, Louisiana Olde Towne Preservation District Commission Agenda November 13, 2024 at 5:00pm Council Chambers, 2045 2nd St, Slidell, LA Agenda packet available at myslidell.com/planning/boards/otpdc For questions or to provide public comment before the meeting, email OTPDC@cityofslidell.org or call (985) 646-4320 (M-F 8am to 4:30pm) SCAN ME for the OTPDC website 1. Call to Order and Roll Call 2. Minutes. Review and approve minutes from September 25, 2024 3. Public Hearings a. CA24-42: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for exterior alterations at 334 Teddy Avenue. b. CA24-44: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for new construction at 1715 Sgt Alfred Drive. 4. Other Business 5. Informational Items 6. General and Public Comments 7. Adjournment The next Olde Towne Preservation District Commission meeting will be December 11, 2024. Olde Towne Preservation District Commission Agenda for November 13, 2024 Page 1 of 1  Staff Report Case No. CA24-42 Certificate of Appropriateness Planning Department for Exterior Alteration at 334 Teddy Ave 985.646.4320 | 250 Bouscaren St, Ste 203, Slidell, LA 70458 | planningdept@cityofslidell.org | myslidell.com 1. Existing developed residential site at 334 Teddy Ave (Figure 1). 2. The property is listed as an individually historic structure within the OTPD.(LHRI No. 52-00022) (Figure 2). 3. The Planning Director requests a review of the already constructed alterations to the site of a historic structure (c1920, Attachment 1) 4. The applicant’s scope of work: A. An extension to the height of a pre-existing 6-foot wood fence, constructed vertically, around the entire perimeter of the rear yard. 5. The following alterations were made to the site: A. The fence extension is 2 feet high and is attached to the top of the existing fence providing an 8-foot security fence. B. Fence is constructed of new decorative wood in a louvered design. (Figure 2) 6. The applicant constructed the fence extension to provide additional security for pool occupants from their neighbors. FIGURES AND ATTACHMENT ON THE FOLLOWING PAGES OTPDC Page 1 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 1. 334 Teddy Ave: Property Boundary (orange), new fence area (red) Figure 2. 334 Teddy Ave. (Street View.) OTPDC Page 2 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 3. New Fence Height Extension ATTACHMENT 1 ON NEXT 4 PAGES OTPDC Page 3 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 4 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 5 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 6 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 7 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander City Historical Bldg List - Individually Historic Louisiana Historic Resource Inve ntory Louisiana Division of Historic Preseruation Office of Cultural Development Departmentof Culture, Recreation and Tourism IEE-EEEEE-!I I p*"t resour€e# ,l r 52_ooo22 / Name of Propefi: Address: \3q Te>>v AveN uE Parish: Sr, -T-*vt m.o.vY - Locality: XCitV E Community E Vicinity E Rural city/comm u n ity/Vici n itv ot...,lg-jD f r- i- Topograph;"gu"6, St,oe t, Quad size: f7.s l.ts UTM: EE- EEEEEIA-EEEEEEE township OwnerAddress: Tax Parcel: Type: fl site E structure Feriroing E onlect Level of Recognition: E runl E run individual E un districUelement E ooE ElLocal E None Previousfy Surveyed:frv"r fltto When, Located Where?: 1186, -"p Government Preservation Activity: E Section 106 E Grant E ta<Credit tr Local Ord. E Other HABS/HAER: E Ves(ruo NR eligibility: I Potential individual ! eotential district E Ineligible condition: E Excellent FGood ElFair fl Poor E nuin Remark: Integrity: XUnaltered E Anered (Historic) flAhered (Non-Historic) Remark: Threats: E Abandonment flNeglect E Alteration flDevelopment E Government Action !fion" Remark: OTPDC Page 4 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by: T Alexander  Date of .(Circa i/r/) /-\ Moved: tryes Construction: tr Exact t16U tr No \n/nen? 'P" forPresent, "FI" forFlistoric _fortification | -;$lltfilJil _militaryfacility _socid _horticulturalfacilig _ coast guard facility single dwelling meeting hall research facility inigation facility _ battle site _ secondary structure _ clubhouse -library rcligion -_ religious facility _ industry _servant quarter - civic _ _ manufacturing _ park _ multiple dwelling _government _church - school _extractivefacilig -landscape _plaza _ hotel capitol recreation/culture waterworks _garden _ institutional housing _ city hall theater _ communication facility _transportation _camp _ conectional facility -- auditorium _ processing site _ rail-related _commerceltnde _firestation _energyproducfion _air+elated _ business _ government office - sports facility _ heatth care _water-related _ professional _custom house -museum _hospital _ road-related _organizational _ post office - clinic _ pedestrian-related _financial inslitution publicworks -outdoorrecreation sanitarium _unknown _ specialty store -fair of art ]medical office _vacant _departmentstore education -monumenUmarker ]t""ort other _ restaurant -courthouse -work _warehouse _ college _ storage -agriculture/subsistence _ -defense arms storage -school -Processins _ hall-parlor l-house _Creole house _single pen _central-hall qable€ll _ central hall, 2 pile house _shotgun r:F' _Queen Anne house _double-shotgun X bunqalow _ four square _camelback _pyramidal cottage _ minimal tradition cottage _double pen _ Queen Anne cottage _ hall-parlor _ central-hall, 2 pile coftage Height!1 20+ _saddlebag _ blufiland cottage -1.s-2 -2.5 -s Width: _1 _1.52p -4-5-10-10-20 2.5_3_3+ _creole cottage _central-hall l-house _double-pen l-house Depth: _dog trot -1 -1.5-2-2.5$-s+ tr High Styb Kbments of... tr No Style Creole/ French Colonial Federal Late GothicRevival gkyscraper Greek Revival _ ltalianate _ Romanesque _ Mission {Craftsman Gothic Revival _Second Empire _Renaissance _ltalian Renaissance Modeme Italian Villa _ Queen Anne _ Beaux Arts _ French Renaissance _ Art Deco _sill on ground _concrete block pier _continuous stone unknown dstone infill _wooden pier _concrete pylon pier _ continuous concrete block w/ brick infill _ post in ground ,4 Oricf pier _ continuous brick _ concrete slab Wconcrete block infill _ log (note notch) frame _ load bearing concrete block _ w/ bousillage infill _hewn log _unknown wood frame _reinforced concrete _ dbrickinfill _ post in ground _fiench timberframe _load bearing brick _ steel ftame/curtain wall _ dstone infill _ post on sill eastem braceframe _load bearing stone unknown construction _vertical board _stone (note dressing) _tena cotta _asphalt _ board and batten _ concrete block _ glazed bricMile/block _ reconstituted wood siding _ log (note dressing) _wood shingle _ decorative concrete block _sheet metal _ permastone V clapboardireatherboard _exposed bousillage _poured concretewall _enamelled steel _ other (see nanative) '_drop/novelty siding _ stucco _pigmented glass _ asbestos _ unknown flush horizontal board _ brick (note bond) glass block _aluminumtuinylsiding _parapetgable _gambrel _pyramidal _conical _unknown _low pitch _stepped gable )1nip _mansard _flat {moderatepitch front gable _clipped gable _double pitch hip _complex _shed _steep pitch side gable _ cross gable _gable on hip round _ other (see nanative) w/parapetwall - shingle asphalt built uP _asbestos - _other @ -:j|3:ffJ::,", -raterarexterior _wood shingle _metal _unknown -jable end exterior slope center other _ slate _ ceramic/tena cotta tile --gable - end interior/flush ftslope off center unknown OTPDC Page 5 of 7 CA24-42 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by: T Alexander  ?o* L rt)'l OTPDC Distributed November 6, 2024 Page 6 of 7 CA24-42 Prepared by: T Alexander  "Tuc ?AAtr tta< t=y?'.\\?A ?lLFTrp< .41 ExPA<F\7d?t ixt\ ^Jh TXf I Er.A ELEvA'TiDil< at+< A (Avr!?ET\ la^v' rA./.,At^^1aJ. Tie Pa-R.cr+ R.AIF IS sLI??a?TrA Bl TfrVE.* r SE1 QN ^ E?IIK HALF WALL| STEPS 'LU?q|NA Vf[ve T<glc'.t vJtN|-yrv4t L=, T"KLi.t . * ... * .-.-* --** - 4 - storage/misc. shed 7 - corn crib 10 - garcconier 13 -office 16 - privey 2 - double crib barn 5-smokehouse 8-coop 11 - pigeonnier 14 - machine shed 17 - stable 3 - transverse-crib barn 6 -spring/well house I -quarters kitchen 12 - 15 - garage '18 - other #1 #2 fr5 #4 #5 #6 type:-UK type:_ type:_ type:_ type:_ type:_ date: e/S-J32L date: e / c_ date: e/ c date: e / date: e / c_ date: e / c_ - comment:_ comment: comment: comment: comment: comment: HtP ?ea€ LL*TB&RD tiior Ani,ri;', OTPDC Page 7 of 7 CA24-42 5.rr*Prg'r /?11 Distributed November 6, 2024 Prepared by: T Alexander  Staff Report Case No. CA24-44 Certificate of Appropriateness Planning Department for New Residential Construction at 1715 Sgt Alfred Dr 985.646.4320 | 250 Bouscaren St, Ste 203, Slidell, LA 70458 | planningdept@cityofslidell.org | myslidell.com Location: 1715 Sgt Alfred Dr (Figure 1) Historic Status: Not an historic or contributing structure Owner/Applicant: Dylan J. Zimmer Zoning: C-3 Central Business/OTPD Olde Towne Preservation District Request: Certificate of Appropriateness for a New Residential Duplex (see Findings for complete details) OTPDC Meeting: 11/13/2024 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approval BACKGROUND 1. Property located at 1715 Sgt Alfred Drive previously had a structure on it which was demolished sometime after Katrina (Figure 2). This property is not within the Teddy Ave Historic District. 2. The property is located within the City’s C-3 Central Business District which allows for the construction of residences regulated under the City’s A-8 High Density Urban District codes. The new construction must meet all A-8 regulations, International Residential Codes and fire safety requirements. (Figure 3) 3. The property contains 7,300 square feet which, in accordance with Sec. 2.1104, area requirements for the A-8 district, permits a duplex or two-family structure. (Figure 4) 4. Setbacks required for construction as outlined in A-8 regulations are Front – minimum 20 feet; Sides – minimum 5 feet; and rear – minimum 25 feet. 5. The proposed construction will be elevated to meet the FEMA elevation requirements and the City’s Flood Ordinances. The Base Floor of the home will be 6 feet above ground level. 6. The applicant proposes to construct a 2-story double on the property, located between Teddy Ave and Maine Ave with single living units on the first and second floors. (Figure 5). SCOPE OF WORK 7. The construction is for a two-story residential double with a 1,606 sq foot living area on the first floor and a 1,606 sq foot living area on the second floor. (Figure 5) OTPDC Page 1 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander 8. The construction will be setback from the front property line at approximately 20 feet; left side yard setback is 13 feet; right side yard, which includes a healthy oak tree, is 34.5 feet; the rear yard, which contains the two A/C units for the construction, is at 12 feet. Setbacks for elevated residences not meeting the minimum required measurements can get administrative review and approval from the Planning Director. 9. The exterior materials are brick veneer and stucco. The front elevation has the primary entrance to the living unit on the first floor; the primary entrance to the second floor is located at the rear of the right side of the construction. 10. The front elevation provides a stucco treated porch on both floors with one double window on each floor and single-lite insulated fiberglass doors. The remainder of the front elevation is a brick veneer. 11. The elevated portion of the construction is screened with a brick ledge and brick veneer. The required venting for flood code requirements is spaced appropriately along all required elevations, with decorative venting on the front elevation. (Figure 5) 12. Side elevations of the new construction are primarily brick veneer with two soldier brick bands – one along the base floor elevation and another separating the first floor from the second. In addition, there are several brick sills located throughout the side elevations. 13. Decorative features and materials included in this construction are: • Brick veneer, soldier brick bands, and brick sills – M/S Oldwarehouse 77 with a weathered wash finish (cream) • Stucco at porches and along Gable (Omega ColorTek Stucco – Vanilla Cream) • Corrugated Beaded Vinyl Sofit – Almond around perimeter, Savannah Blue at Porches • Recessed lighting on the porches • Almond Color Aluminum Gutter Cans w/ Downspouts • Porch, balcony and stair railings and posts (Black Painted Wrought Iron). Stair railings will have a decorative design. • Lantern-style lighting on the porches and at the Second-Floor entrance door (Bevolo French Quarter – Original Bracket) • Architectural Shingles – Driftwood • Porch and balcony windows – Double windows with stucco band. • 16 single vinyl windows – Single-hung (Almond) • Exterior Doors – single-lite insulated fiberglass - porch and balcony (Almond) • Exterior Doors – 6 panel insulated fiberglass – Side Elevations (Almond) (Figure 6) STANDARDS FOR REVIEW 14. This request is for new construction of a 2-story residential double. It is reviewed against the standards of New construction of the City’s Code of Ordinances. The following factors are considered in this request for a Certificate of Appropriateness: a. Scale. The proposed residence will have a height of31 feet. The C-3 district has a maximum height of 65 feet. 1 Sgt. Alfred Drive at this location has a 50 ft wide right-of-way, which can support the proposed use. 1 Sec. 2.1703, Appendix A Zoning, of the City’s Code of Ordinances. OTPDC Page 2 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander  c. Siting. The residence is proposed to be set back as described in finding #8. The C-3 district does not require setbacks unless the use includes a dwelling. When constructing a dwelling in the C-3 district, the applicable zoning code for such construction is the A-8 district. The a/c compressors are located behind the front building line in the rear yard. The proposed construction and its components are appropriately sited. d. Materials. The materials proposed for the residential construction are outlined in finding #13. The proposed materials are appropriate. e. Decorative details. The proposed residential construction will feature a brick veneer with soldier brick bands and brick sills to clearly identify the separation of the first and second floors giving the structure a multi-textured appearance. These details create a unifying effect and are compatible with the context of the neighborhood. f. Architectural elements. The proposed residential construction is a rectangular shape structure with a gable roof. It features a first floor porch and second floor balcony. The change in exterior wall materials from brick to stucco, lighting, and the porch and balcony railings provide depth to the design elements of the residential construction. The construction elements compliment the context of the Olde Towne Preservation District. FINDINGS 15. The proposed new residential construction is consistent with the applicable standards of the Olde Towne Preservation District. RECOMMENDATION 16. The Planning Director recommends approval of the proposed residential construction as appropriate for the Olde Towne Preservation District. FIGURES Figures provided on the following pages. OTPDC Page 3 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 1 – Aerial location OTPDC Page 4 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 2 – Street view OTPDC Page 5 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 3 – Zoning – C-3 Central Business District (A-8 for Residential) OTPDC Page 6 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 4 – Survey (June 1982) Figure 5 – Construction Plans CONSTRUCTION PLANS FOLLOW ON THE NEXT THREE PAGES OTPDC Page 7 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 8 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 9 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander OTPDC Page 10 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Figure 6 – Materials Brick – M/S Oldwarehouse 77 - weathered wash finish (cream) with Soldier Band Stucco at Porches – Vanilla Cream OTPDC Page 11 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander 2” corrugated beaded Vinyl Sofit - Almond around perimeter; Front Porches – Savannah Blue Recessed Lighting at Porch and Balcony OTPDC Page 12 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander  Stair Railing Porch Railing & Columns OTPDC Page 13 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Bevolo French Quarter Original Bracket Gas Lights Owens Corning Duration Series – Driftwood Shingle OTPDC Page 14 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Windows: OTPDC Page 15 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander Exterior Doors: OTPDC Page 16 of 16 CA24-44 Distributed November 4, 2024 Prepared by T Alexander