City Council Regular Meeting
Regular MeetingStar, ID · November 17, 2015
Minutes
Star City Council
Regular Meeting Minutes
November 17, 2015
The regular meeting of the Star City Council was held on November 17, 2015 at the Star City Hall, 10769
W. State Street, Star, Idaho. Mayor Nathan Mitchell called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm and all stood
for the Pledge of Allegiance.
Roll Call: Councilmen Richard Lockett, Tom Erlebach and Chad Bell were all present.
Approval of the Agenda: Bell moved to approve the agenda, Lockett seconded the motion. All ayes:
motion carried.
Consent Agenda: Bell moved to approve the Consent Agenda consisting of: Special Meeting Minutes
of November 2, 2015, Waterview Estates Final Plat, Phase 6 and a Beer and Wine License for Down To
Earth, Lockett seconded the motion. All ayes: motion carried.
Presentations/Public Input:
Law Enforcement Report: Chief John Laraway reviewed – officer at the library reading right now. The
detective has run 25 health and welfare cases this month. The Chief thanked Council for hiring Detective
Bowman. The crime rate for 2015 is at 21.2%. Calls for service is about 150 calls per month, there were
180 calls in February. When the numbers drop off they do other things like patrolling the neighborhoods
more. They are currently patrolling Highway 44. Crashes mainly happen at Hwy 16; the highway district
has put a delay on the lights to try and help with accidents. Neighborhood patrols will increase due to the
holidays and kids. The Chief stated that he gave out 15 pounds of candy at the Halloween event.
Audience member asked how police control the race on State Street with the roads going down to one
lane? The Mayor stated that ITD did not widen it all the way because of lack of money.
Audience member that lives in Celestial Village stated the officers are very professional. The officer
came when they suspected someone in the neighborhood. It turned out great and the officer was very
professional. The man asked if the Chief could attend his HOA meeting. The Chief stated that they can
come to the meeting.
Public Input:
Randy Furniss, 347 N. Hullen Place, Star, Idaho, came to congratulate David Hershey as a new
Councilman. He thanked everyone for the way the race went, very above board. Furness would like to
help the City even though he wasn’t elected and thanked the Council for their service.
Theresa Tinsley, 10459 W. Achillea, Star, Idaho, stated that she was there representing a citizens group
that would like the big pine tree out front of City Hall decorated for Christmas. They would like that to
be our Christmas tree. She gave the Council several bids she had gotten. Bids one, two, and three do not
have their own man lift. Tinsley asked Star Crane what they would charge to put up the lights, it will be
$200. So $400 would be added to bids one, two, and three to put up and take down the lights. Bid four
does not sell the lights, they would charge $1500 this year. All four bids do include storage of the lights.
The Lions Club has agreed to donate $500 and Robert Wurster will donate $200 to offset the costs for the
first year.
1
Erlebach asked about the discounts. Tinsley stated that they also put lights on buildings, she said we
wouldn’t do it this year, but maybe next year. Tinsley stated that Council needs to read bid 3 as there is
more information about that bid. The Chamber will be doing the tree lighting on the 5th of December.
Bell asked about what the advanced notice is. Tinsley stated that they could get the lights up by
Thanksgiving. Discussion was held on bulb color.
Bell agrees that if you go to the mini lights, it won’t be enough on that big tree. He thinks we would be
disappointed if we went with the mini lights. We should go with the C7 light bulbs. He thinks we should
buy the lights and pay someone to install them. With the donation from the Chamber and Wurster, it
comes pretty close to purchasing the lights.
Bell stated that this has not been budgeted for. The Mayor stated that we do have the money. Bell moved
to amend the agenda adding item 6C Christmas tree lighting. All ayes: motion carried.
Gary Smith, 258 S. Langer Lake Way, Star, Idaho, handed information out to the Council. Smith stated
that he was there to talk about the process that he believes is illegal. The Mayor asked Smith if he was
talking about the same thing they have emailed about. Smith stated that it was and he is looking for
Council clarification. The Mayor stated that everything they’ve talked about is in regards to an
application. The City has scheduled a public hearing for that meeting and that is the time Smith needs to
bring this information forward. The Mayor stated that Smith needs to submit his paperwork on the
December 15, 2015 meeting; there will be no further discussion.
Jon Turnipseed, 11725 Caribee Inlet Drive, Star, Idaho, stated he was a risk managers and had bad
experiences with attorneys and he is getting the same feeling now. He would like to help save the City.
Turnipseed suggested that the City attorney do an audit of all the paperwork to make sure all the
paperwork is in place. The Mayor stated that our processes and procedures are audited by ICRMP (risk
management). They have a team of attorneys and we participate with ICRMP. They are actively engaged
in the City and they are comfortable with our procedures. We have things in place so that everyone
doesn’t do something stupid.
Gerrard Cattin, 12097 W. Caribee Inlet, Star, Idaho, asked if he could get a copy of the Council packet.
The Mayor stated that Cattin can request a copy the Wednesday prior to the Council meeting with a
public records request. Cattin asked the Chief about mutual aid between the Cities as he notices cars from
Star go east but never sees them go the other way. The Mayor explained the mutual aid process. Cattin
stated that he was very impressed the way everyone ran their campaigns.
Tinsley stated that “The Independent” will give another $200 towards the Christmas lights.
Old/New Business:
Acceptance of the Canvassed Votes – Bell moved to accept the canvassed votes, Erlebach seconded the
motion. All ayes: motion carried.
Swearing in of Councilman David Hershey – The Mayor explained that when Councilwoman McDaniel
left in July the seat was empty and was not filled at that time. David Hershey won the vote and he will be
sworn in tonight. Bell moved to approve the appointment of David Hershey from now until January 5th,
2016, Lockett seconded the motion. All ayes: motion carried.
The Mayor congratulated David Hershey, and administered the oath of office.
2
Christmas Tree Lights - Bell moved to accept the Elk Ridge bid for $1969 for C7 lights, Lockett seconded
the motion. Light colors were discussed. No man lift has been included in the bid. Bell amended his
motion to add rental of a man lift and have them store the lights, Lockett amended his second. Hershey
asked what happens if a strand goes out; do they fix it or do we? The Mayor stated that the Elk Ridge bid
does not include any maintenance. Bell stated that LED lights usually last longer. The contract does not
say we are buying the lights. Bell amended his motion to add to the bid that the lights will be the property
of the City, Lockett amended his second. All ayes: motion carried. The final motion is to accept the bid
from Elk Ridge for $1969 for the C7 lights, to rent a man lift, have Elk Ridge store the lights and that the
lights are City property.
Reports:
Staff – No reports were given.
Council – Hershey stated that he has never done an election before. He wants to give back to Star and to
echo what he’s heard regarding the elections - the ethics were so high. He was sure that whomever won
that position would run Star ethically and he makes no delusion as to how close the race was. He will
always listen to the public, but there are things that he can’t listen too as well. He thanked all for showing
up.
Lockett stated that he attended the Fire District meeting and attended an AIC training.
Erlebach stated that Heidi Prigge has asked about getting her stuff out of the house. Erlebach thanked
Tinsley and Christopherson for all their work on the Halloween Trunk or Treat.
Bell said he attended the VRT meeting and the AIC meeting. He too gave out candy at the Halloween
event and ran out of candy and had to go for more.
Adjournment: The Mayor adjourned the meeting at 8:24 pm.
Approved:
Respectfully submitted: _________________________________
Nathan Mitchell, Mayor
__________________________
Cathy Ward, City Clerk
3
Agenda
NOTICE OF
STAR CITY
COUNCIL MEETING
Star City Hall
November 17, 2015
7:00 pm
AGENDA
1. CALL TO ORDER (Welcome/Pledge of Allegiance)
2. ROLL CALL
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA (Approval of Agenda as it stands/Amend Agenda)
4. CONSENT AGENDA
*All matters listed within the Consent Agenda have been distributed to each member of the Star City Council for
reading and study, they are considered to be routine, and will be enacted by one motion of the Consent Agenda or
placed on the Regular Agenda by request.
A. Special Meeting Minutes of November 2, 2015
B. Waterview Estates – Final Plat, Phase 6
C. Beer & Wine License for Down To Earth
5. PRESENTATIONS/PUBLIC INPUT
A. Law Enforcement Report – Chief Laraway
B. Public Input
6. OLD/NEW BUSINESS
A. Acceptance of the Canvassed Votes
B. Swearing in of Councilman Hershey
7. REPORTS
8. ADJOURNMENT
Get email alerts for Star
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.