General Employees Retirement Board
Regular MeetingSterling Heights, MI · August 14, 2019
Minutes
OFFICIAL
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF THE
STERLING HEIGHTS
GENERAL EMPLOYEE’S RETIREMENT SYSTEM
August 14, 2019
Location: Room #202 40555 Utica Road, Sterling Heights, MI 48313 (586) 446-2783
Chairperson Weiler called the meeting to order at 1:33 p.m.
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Richard Weiler, Chairperson
Todd Marsh, Trustee
Paul Henig, Trustee
Jennifer Varney, Secretary
Mary Jaganjac, Treasurer
BOARD MEMBERS ABSENT: None
ALSO PRESENT: Tom Michaud, Legal Counsel
Tim Brice, Morgan Stanley, The Brice Group
Ryan Clark, Treasury Service Coordinator
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion by Henig, supported by Marsh, to approve the agenda as presented.
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion by Marsh, supported by Henig, to approve the minutes of the following:
- Regular Meeting of June 20, 2019
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
COMMUNICATION FROM CITIZENS: None
REPORT FROM LEGAL COUNSEL
Michaud reported out on the following items:
Lang case with brief board discussion and a motion from the court is expected in the fall
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Minutes\2019 Fiscal\19.6.20
1 unapproved minutes.docx
CONSENT AGENDA: Items I.A through I.D2
Motion by Jaganjac, supported by Marsh, to approve consent agenda items I.A through I.D2
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
I. RECEIVE AND FILE:
A. Benefit Register Listing for July and August 1, 2019 from Comerica Bank showing 363
active retirees with a payout for the benefit months of $933,135.89 and $932,454.91,
respectively, and a year-to-date of $7,460,739.
B. Cash and Asset Statements as of July 31, 2019 from Comerica Bank and Morgan Stanley
showing a total market value outlined below:
Desired
Percentage Asset Class Manager / Fund $ Balance
Allocation
2.00% 2.81% LARGE CAP GROWTH CLEARBRIDGE $ 3,057,786.91
2.00% 3.00% LARGE CAP GROWTH ISHARES RUSSELL 1000 GROWTH ETF $ 3,267,637.12
3.00% 2.59% LARGE CAP GROWTH JANUS CAPITAL $ 2,825,580.11
4.00% 4.06% LARGE CAP VALUE CONFLUENCE $ 4,423,235.01
3.00% 3.58% LARGE CAP VALUE ISHARES RUSSELL 1000 VALUE ETF $ 3,901,455.74
4.00% 3.80% LARGE CAP VALUE MFS $ 4,134,534.80
6.00% 4.56% LARGE CAP CORE JOHN HANCOCK $ 4,969,803.70
4.00% 4.17% LARGE CAP CORE ISHARES S&P 500 ETF $ 4,547,108.25
4.00% 4.13% SMID CAP VALUE EDGE $ 4,496,464.18
11.00% 7.43% SMID CORE EARNEST PARTNERS $ 8,097,393.37
11.00% 9.99% INTERNATIONAL CAMBIAR $ 10,882,071.77
6.00% 7.86% INTERNATIONAL WCM $ 8,557,460.08
6.00% 6.01% INTERNATIONAL HARDING LOEVNER $ 6,549,088.33
1.50% 1.96% EMERGING HARDING LOEVNER HLEMX $ 2,129,789.08
1.50% 1.19% EMERGING LAZARD $ 1,293,835.31
2.00% 2.67% REITS PRINCIPAL $ 2,904,049.63
12.00% 11.95% FIXED INCOME WESTERN ASSET MANAGEMENT $ 13,013,980.59
12.00% 11.51% FIXED INCOME BOYD WATTERSON $ 12,536,498.23
5.00% 4.95% MLPS CUSHING $ 5,392,538.90
0.00% 1.80% CASH CASH $ 1,958,663.36
100.00% 100.00% $ 108,938,974
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Minutes\2019 Fiscal\19.6.20
2 unapproved minutes.docx
C. Communication items listed below:
Item Date Communication
1 May 31, 2019 RGR&D | Shareholder Class Actions
2 Jun 18, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
3 Jun 19, 2019 MS | Wire xfer confirm
4 Jun 29, 2019 MS | Consolidated Trade confirm
5 Jul 03, 2019 MS | Western Asset Prospectus
6 Jul 10, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
7 Jul 11, 2019 MS | Confirm of Pers. Acct. Info.
8 Jul 12, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
9 Jul 13, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
10 Jul 16, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
11 Jul 16, 2019 MS | Acct Change confirm 333-XXX761
** 12 Jul 18, 2019 GRS | Subpoena
13 Jul 19, 2019 MS | Retirement Plan Fee Changes
14 Jul 23, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
15 Jul 23, 2019 MS | Wire xfer confirm
MS | Updated ADV Brochure for Investment Advisory
16 Jul 26, 2019
Accounts
17 Jul 26, 2019 RGR&D | Shareholder Class Actions
18 Jul 30, 2019 MS | trade confirm
19 Jul 30, 2019 BWAM | Statement of Accounts
20 Aug 01, 2019 MS | Consolidated Trade confirm
D. Approval items
i. Payable from City Assets for the service period ending June 30, 2019:
Q1 Comerica Bank fees Q1: $4,912.15
GRS Benefit calculation fees: $630
ii. Payable from Fund Assets for the service period ending June 30, 2019: $166,360.45
total
Q1 Boyd Watterson management fees: $4,711
Q1 WCM management fees: $18,504.21
Q1 Morgan Stanley consolidated management fees: $149,475.81
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Minutes\2019 Fiscal\19.6.20
3 unapproved minutes.docx
REGULAR AGENDA
II. OLD BUSINESS
A. Service Retirement – Keri Marshall, Treasury Accountant
Motion by Marsh, supported by Henig, to approve Keri Marshall receive Option A –
100% Pop-Up benefits with Annuity Withdraw at a monthly benefit of $2,715.92 with
a one-time annuity withdraw amount of $89,899.64.
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
III. NEW BUSINESS
A. Retroactive Service Retirement Pop-Up Adjustment – Patricia Hassar, MAPE Clerical
Motion by Henig, supported by Marsh, to approve retroactive adjustment for Patricia
Hassar, Option A 100% w/ Pop-Up with Annuity Withdraw from 2/25/2016 going
forward; benefit was adjusted from original amount at $1,492.21 to Option A w/ Pop-Up
without Annuity Withdraw at $1,692.35 instead of being adjusted to Straight Life to w/
Annuity Withdraw at $1,718.66. Total retroactive calculation outlined here:
Opt A w/ P-U
w/out a/w SL w/ a/w Var
Monthly Benefit 1,692.35 1,718.66 26.31
Year Months Variance
Prorata 2/2016 - 3.76
2016 9 236.79
2017 12 315.72
2018 12 315.72
2019 8 210.48
Total Due 1,078.71
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
B. Pension Administration Comments
1. Review of Proposed 2018/2019 GERS Meeting Schedule
2. Annual Update & Review of RFP Status – Service Providers
Motion by Marsh, supported by Henig, to receive and file GERS Meeting Schedule
consider and decide to maintain current legal counsel
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
C. Morgan Stanley – The Brice Group, Quarterly Review & Interviews
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Minutes\2019 Fiscal\19.6.20
4 unapproved minutes.docx
1. 1:45pm - Interview Victory Capital Management
2. 2:00pm - Interview Fidelity Institutional Asset Management
After interviewing and discussing the merits of both Victory Capital and Fidelity
Institutional Asset Management, any decision to move into Small Cap International
funds was shelved leaving the option to revisit this asset class in the future.
The board then studied the quarterly Morgan Stanley Graystone Consulting Investment
Performance Analysis and considered the performance of all current money managers.
Cambiar was cited as a trending underperformer with Aristotle as a parallel manager in
the international space with better overall performance and lower fees.
Motion by Henig, supported by Varney, to move from Cambiar to Aristotle due to
lower fees and better performance.
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
D. Trustee Comments: None
ADJOURN
Motion by Henig, supported by Varney, to adjourn meeting.
Ayes: All. Motion carried unanimously.
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Minutes\2019 Fiscal\19.6.20
5 unapproved minutes.docx
Agenda
AGENDA
REGULAR MEETING – GENERAL EMPLOYEES’ RETIREMENT SYSTEM
Wednesday August 14, 2019 at 1:30 pm
Council Conference Room # 202
Location: Administration Building, 40555 Utica Road, Sterling Heights, MI 48313
Telephone: (586) 446-2783
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
APPROVAL OF MINUTES - Regular Meeting of June 20, 2019
COMMUNICATION FROM CITIZENS
REPORT FROM LEGAL COUNSEL
CONSENT AGENDA - Consent Items I.A through I.D2
I. RECEIVE AND FILE:
A. Benefit Register listing for end of months July & August 2019 from Comerica Bank
B. Cash and Assets Statement as of the end of month July 31, 2019 from Comerica
Bank and Morgan Stanley
C. Correspondence items listed here:
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Agendas\19.8\19.8 Agenda.docx
1
Item Date Communication
1 May 31, 2019 RGR&D | Shareholder Class Actions
2 Jun 18, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
3 Jun 19, 2019 MS | Wire xfer confirm
4 Jun 29, 2019 MS | Consolidated Trade confirm
5 Jul 03, 2019 MS | Western Asset Prospectus
6 Jul 10, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
7 Jul 11, 2019 MS | Confirm of Pers. Acct. Info.
8 Jul 12, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
9 Jul 13, 2019 MS | US Gov't Money Mkt Prospectus - multiple accts
10 Jul 16, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
11 Jul 16, 2019 MS | Acct Change confirm 333-XXX761
** 12 Jul 18, 2019 GRS | Subpoena
13 Jul 19, 2019 MS | Retirement Plan Fee Changes
14 Jul 23, 2019 MS | Trade confirm
15 Jul 23, 2019 MS | Wire xfer confirm
MS | Updated ADV Brochure for Investment Advisory
16 Jul 26, 2019
Accounts
17 Jul 26, 2019 RGR&D | Shareholder Class Actions
18 Jul 30, 2019 MS | trade confirm
19 Jul 30, 2019 BWAM | Statement of Accounts
20 Aug 01, 2019 MS | Consolidated Trade confirm
D. Approval items
1. Payable from City Assets for the service period ending June 30, 2019:
Q1 Comerica Bank fees Q1: $4,912.15
GRS Benefit calculation fees: $630
2. Payable from Fund Assets for the service period ending June 30, 2019:
$166,360.45 total
Q1 Boyd Watterson management fees: $4,711
Q1 WCM management fees: $18,504.21
Q1 Morgan Stanley consolidated management fees: $149,475.81
REGULAR AGENDA
II. OLD BUSINESS
A. Service Retirement – Keri Marshall, Treasury Accountant
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Agendas\19.8\19.8 Agenda.docx
2
III. NEW BUSINESS
A. Retroactive Service Retirement Pop-Up Adjustment – Patricia Hassar, MAPE
Clerical
B. Pension Administration Comments
1. Review of Proposed 2018/2019 GERS Meeting Schedule
2. Annual Update & Review of RFP Status – Service Providers
C. Morgan Stanley – The Brice Group, Quarterly Review & Interviews
1. 1:45pm - Interview Victory Capital Management
2. 2:00pm - Interview Fidelity Institutional Asset Management
D. Trustee Comments
ADJOURN
P:\Ryan\PENSION\GERS MEETING FILES\Agendas\19.8\19.8 Agenda.docx
3
Get email alerts for Sterling Heights
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.