City Council
Regular MeetingTroy, NY · November 26, 2019
Minutes
Minutes of the
TROY CITY COUNCIL
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA
November 26, 2019
6:00 P.M.
The meeting was called to order at 6:03 p.m. by Council President Mantello.
Pledge of Allegiance
Roll Call: The roll being called, the following answered to their names: Council Member Gulli,
Council Member Paratore, Council Member Cummings, Council Member Bissember, Council
Member Kennedy, Council President Mantello, Chair. Council Member Garrett was absent.
In attendance were Mayor Patrick Madden, Deputy Mayor Monica Kurzejeski, Deputy
Comptroller Andy Piotrowski, and Deputy Director of Public Information John Salka.
Approximately 6 members of the public attended.
Public Forum:
No one came forward.
116. Ordinance Appropriating The Various Amounts of Funds In The City of Troy Budget
For Fiscal Year 2020 and Levying Taxes On All Taxable Property Within The City of Troy
In The Amount Required To Be Raised By Property Taxes In The City of Troy For The
Fiscal Year 2020 Budget (Council President Mantello) (At The Request of The
Administration)
Ordinance passed 5 ayes, 1 no (Mantello), 1 absence (Garrett).
83. Resolution Adopting The Mayor’s Recommended Budget For The City of Troy For
Fiscal Year 2020 or Adopting An Amended Budget For The City of Troy For Fiscal Year
2020 (Council President Mantello) (At The Request Of The Administration)
Resolution amended with new Schedule A. Resolution passed 5 ayes, 1 no (Mantello), 1 absence
(Garrett).
84. Resolution Appointing Daniel P. McCarthy to The Board of Assessment Review of The
City of Troy (Council Member Cummings)
Resolution passed 6 ayes, 0 noes, 1 absence (Garrett).
85. Resolution Amending Proposed 2020 Troy City Budget (Council President Mantello)
Resolution failed 1 aye, 5 noes (Gulli, Paratore, Cummings, Bissember, Kennedy), 1 absence
(Garrett).
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 6:56 p.m.
An audio recording of this meeting is on file at the City Clerk's office.
Agenda
TROY CITY COUNCIL
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA
November 26, 2019
6:00 P.M.
Pledge of Allegiance
Roll Call
Public Forum
LOCAL LAWS
ORDINANCES
116. Ordinance Appropriating The Various Amounts of Funds In The City of Troy Budget For
Fiscal Year 2020 and Levying Taxes On All Taxable Property Within The City of Troy In The
Amount Required To Be Raised By Property Taxes In The City of Troy For The Fiscal Year
2020 Budget (Council President Mantello) (At The Request of The Administration)
RESOLUTIONS
83. Resolution Adopting The Mayor’s Recommended Budget For The City of Troy For Fiscal
Year 2020 or Adopting An Amended Budget For The City of Troy For Fiscal Year 2020
(Council President Mantello) (At The Request Of The Administration)
84. Resolution Appointing Daniel P. McCarthy to The Board of Assessment Review of The City
of Troy (Council Member Cummings)
85. Resolution Amending Proposed 2020 Troy City Budget (Council President Mantello)
ORD116
ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING THE VARIOUS AMOUNTS OF FUNDS IN THE
CITY OF TROY BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020 AND LEVYING TAXES ON ALL
TAXABLE PROPERTY WITHIN THE CITY OF TROY IN THE AMOUNT REQUIRED
TO BE RAISED BY PROPERTY TAXES IN THE CITY OF TROY FOR THE FISCAL
YEAR 2020 BUDGET
____________________________________________________________________________
The City of Troy, in City Council convened, ordains as follows:
Section 1. Pursuant to the City of Troy Charter § 47-K, the City Council is required to adopt
an ordinance appropriating the various amounts of money as set forth in the fiscal
year 2020 City Budget necessary for the operation of the City government.
Section 2. The City Council hereby appropriates the various amounts of money set forth in
the 2020 budget as approved for the several departments, bureaus, divisions,
offices, courts, boards and commissions of the City and for the several purposes
specified in the fiscal year 2020 City Budget.
Section 3. Pursuant to the Troy City Charter, § 47-N, the City Council is required to levy
taxes on all taxable property in the City of Troy as shown on the annual tax
assessment rolls to raise the amount of revenue required by the City Budget for
fiscal year 2020, through the collection of property taxes.
Section 4. The amount of $25,716,297 as set forth and specified in the City Budget for Fiscal
Year 2020 is hereby determined to be the amount of revenue required to be raised
from real property taxes for fiscal year 2020.
Section 5. The said amount of $26,116,297 is hereby levied, assessed and raised by property
tax on all taxable property within the City of Troy as shown on the annual
assessment rolls for the City of Troy.
Section 6. This ordinance shall take effect immediately.
Approved as to form, November 25, 2019
_______________________________________
James A. Caruso, Corporation Counsel
ORD116
Memo In Support
Pursuant City Charter §47-N, the final legislative task imposed on the City Council at the Special
Meeting is to pass an ordinance setting the tax levy for the City for all taxable property on the
assessment roll of the City. The purpose of this ordinance is to obtain the actual revenues
necessary to support those expenditures contained in the approved City Budget that are funded
via property taxes collected by the City.
RES83
RESOLUTION ADOPTING THE MAYOR’S RECOMMENDED BUDGET FOR THE
CITY OF TROY FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020 OR ADOPTING AN AMENDED BUDGET
FOR THE CITY OF TROY FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020
____________________________________________________________________________
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-E, the Mayor filed with the City Clerk a
budget message and recommended budget for the City of Troy for Fiscal Year 2020
on10/10/2019; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-F, the City Council conducted a special
meeting on 10/15/2019 at which it referred the recommended budget to the City Council Finance
Committee which in turn referred the recommended budget to the respective Standing
Committees of the City Council; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-H, the Finance Committee and respective
Standing Committees of the City Council conducted preliminary public hearings between
10/17/2019 and 11/12/2019; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-H, the Finance Committee and respective
Standing Committees of the City Council, on 11/15/2019, filed reports with the City Clerk
regarding the preliminary public hearings; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-I, a meeting of the Mayor and the City
Council was held on 11/19/2019 to review suggested changes to the recommended budget; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-J, a final public hearing was conducted on
11/21/2019 at which all persons desiring to be heard in relation to the budget estimates in the
recommended budget were given an opportunity to do so; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to City Charter § 47-K, the City Council is conducting a
special meeting on 11/26/2019 to adopt the Mayor’s recommended budget or to amend and adopt
a budget for the City of Troy for Fiscal Year 2020 and to submit same to the Mayor for approval.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Mayor’s recommended budget be
adopted; or in the alternative, the City Council’s amended budget and the estimates contained
therein be adopted; with such adopted budget to be in the amount of $74,740,743.
Approved as to form, November 25, 2019
_______________________________________
James A. Caruso, Corporation Counsel
RES83
Memo In Support
City Charter § 47-K provides that the City Council shall hold a special meeting, after the final
public hearing to accomplish certain specific tasks related to the budget and the funding of City
operations in the upcoming fiscal year. That special meeting has been scheduled for
11/26/2019. One legislative task to be accomplished at the meeting by the City Council is to
approve the Mayor’s recommended budget or to amend and adopt an amended budget. In the
event that the Council does neither, the Mayor’s recommended budget takes effect.
The Mayor’s proposed budget, submitted to the City Clerk on October 10, 2019, included
appropriations in the General Fund totaling $74,740,743, Garbage Fund appropriations totaling
$4,339,671, Water Fund appropriations totaling $14,675,024 and Sewer Fund appropriations of
$4,945,852. This resolution adopts, or amends and adopts, the Mayor’s proposed budget.
This resolution reflects the appropriations in each of the City’s four operating funds as proposed
by the Mayor for the 2020 fiscal year and does not include any potential amendments by the
Troy City Council.
RES84
RESOLUTION APPOINTING DANIEL P. MCCARTHY TO THE BOARD OF
ASSESSMENT REVIEW OF THE CITY OF TROY
WHEREAS, Daniel P. McCarthy, residing at177 River Street 3 East, Troy, New York, desires
to serve the City of Troy and its property owners as a member of the Board of Assessment
Review and possesses the credentials to serve with competence, diligence and dedication; and
WHEREAS, Mr. McCarthy will serve a five (5) year term in office and will fill the vacancy
created by Janice Cohen who has resigned due to the fact that she no longer lives in the City of
Troy. It is the sense of this Legislative Body that Mr. McCarthy should be appointed to fill this
vacancy; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that, pursuant to Section 523 of the Real Property
Tax Law; Mr. McCarthy is hereby appointed to the Board of Assessment Review for the
uncompleted term of five (5) years, to commence immediately and will expire September 30,
2019.
Approved as to form, November 25, 2019
_____________________________________
James A. Caruso, Esq., Corporation Counsel
RES84
MEMO IN SUPPORT
Members of the City Council:
The Board of Assessment Review has five members. Every September one member's term expires. A
requirement of the members is they must live in the City. Board Member, Janice Cohen has moved out
of the City and has resigned from the Board. Janice's term expires 9/30/19. Janice was originally
chosen for the board because she is a local Realtor. Having a Realtor on the Board with access to the
Multiple Listing Service has been beneficial to the Board.
I contacted Michael Flynn, also a local Realtor, to ask for a recommendation for a Realtor replacement
for the Board. Michael recommended Daniel P. McCarthy. Daniel forwarded his resume and is
interested in serving on the Board. I have attached Daniel's resume with this memo. Please consider
appointing Daniel to finish Janice Cohen's term through 9/30/19.
Thank you for your consideration,
Sharon Martin, lAO
RES84
Daniel P. McCarthy
177 River Street 3 East Troy, New York 12180
SALES- MANAGEMENT- OPERATIONS- TRAINING- CONSULTING- RESULTS ORIENTED
EXPERIENCE:
Coldwell Banker Prime Properties, East Greenbush, NY 2014-
Residential, commercial and land sales in the Capital District area
Creative Materials Corporation, Albany, NY 2012-2013
National Sales Representative
• Responsibilities for tile and masonry products.
• Opened the largest of national hospitality accounts at CMC.
• Developed a sales and marketing plan to best penetrate the corporate architectural group and
hotel franchise owners groups.
YourFranchiseSolution.com, Troy, NY 2008-2012
Consultant
• Independent f r a n c h i s e consulting group representing in excess of 300 franchisors in virtually
every industry.
• Primary f u n c t i o n is to match the best candidate with the best possible business opportunity
based on experience, financial requirements, ability and demographics.
• Assisted in due diligence process, answering questions and guiding through financing process.
Business Environments, Albany, NY 2002-2008
President
• Full service office furniture Steelcase dealership.
• Offered design services, light construction and fit up services, commercial office furniture and
installation to private and public sectors in the Albany and surrounding markets.
• At peak BE had 45 employees and surpassed $13mm in sales.
Interior Solutions, Troy, NY 1991-2008
President
• Manufacturer's representatives group with six national office furniture manufacturers, exclusive
territory throughout New England and upstate New York.
• Primary function was developing sales through dealers with product education and end user
presentations.
• IS (Interior Solutions) evolved to a full service office furniture dealership which wholesaled and
retailed new, used and refurbished office furniture to end users and dealers in the Northeast.
• IS purchased BE and eventually merged into BE.
Alma Industries, Boston, MA 1989-1991
Northeast Regional Sales Manager
• Wood manufacturer of high quality office furniture.
• Responsibilities included sales through dealers throughout Boston, ME, VT, NH and upstate
NY in non-represented areas direct sales.
• Company was hurt with downturned economy and was liquidated.
RES85
RESOLUTION AMENDING PROPOSED 2020 TROY CITY BUDGET
WHEREAS, the City of Troy adopted a 1 year temporary garbage fee of $161 per unit in 2018; and
WHEREAS, the temporary garbage fee was made permanent at $164 per unit in 2019; and
WHEREAS, the proposed 2020 city budget is increasing the garbage fee to $180 per unit; and
WHEREAS, the garbage fee has not substantially increased services or reduced the waste stream to
date; and
WHEREAS, the increase in the garbage fee to $180 per unit and a 2019 bulk rate charge puts an undue
burden on Troy taxpayers.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the proposed 2020 budget is amended to cap the garbage fee at
$164 per unit for the years 2020 and 2021.
This resolution shall take effect immediately.
Approved as to form, November 25, 2019
_____________________________________
James A. Caruso, Esq., Corporation Counsel
Get email alerts for Troy
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.