Troy Industrial Development Authority
Regular MeetingTroy, NY · May 9, 2014
Minutes
City of Troy
Industrial Development Authority
May 9, 2014
10:30 AM
Meeting Minutes
Present: Steve Bouchey, Bill Dunne, Hon. Dean Bodnar, Mary O’Neill, Hon. Robert
Doherty, Paul Carroll, Tina Urzan and Lisa Kyer
Absent: Lou Anthony
Also in attendance: Monica Kurzejeski, Justin Miller Esq., Selena Skiba, and Denee
Zeigler
Vice Chair, Steve Bouchey, called the IDA portion of the meeting to order at 10:30 a.m.
I. Minutes from the April 11, 2014 meeting
Tina Urzan made a motion to approve the minutes
from the April 11, 2014 meeting.
Hon. Bob Doherty seconded the motion, motion carried.
II. 33 Second Street
Bill Dunne spoke to the board about the recent purchase of 33 Second Street by
Sonny Bonacio. It appears that both restaurants will stay and residential
apartments will be located on the upper floors. The board had general
discussion on the two businesses currently in the building. Steve Bouchey said
that he was happy to hear that it was purchased.
III. IBT loan
Bill Dunne advised the board members that IBT received a loan from the IDA to
encourage the expansion of the business and retain jobs in Troy. They have
recently relocated their business and the building is for sale. Mr. Dunne
explained that they would like to get the balance of the loan paid back from the
proceeds of the sale of the building. Justin Miller advised that there is
approximately $150,000 remaining on the loan. Mr. Miller advised that Greco is
planning to buy it and allow IBT to continue to lease the space for storage for
about six months. Mr. Dunne advised that Greco construction and MMC will both
be occupying the site and will bring about 40 new jobs to Troy. Mr. Dunne
advised that board member Lou Anthony is vice president of Greco construction
and will recues himself from any future discussions or votes on the project. The
board had a general discussion about the best way to pursue the repayment of
the loan.
IV. Riverfront Park Access
1
Bill Dunne spoke on the project to date. He advised that the deck was
completely removed without a problem. Originally there were concerns that
there could be damage to the adjacent buildings but thankfully that was not the
case. Mr. Dunne advised that they are currently installing reinforcements to the
retaining wall that currently holds up River Street. The board expressed
excitement about the project. Mr. Bouchey stated that it will offer a great
connection to the park from the businesses on River Street. Mr. Doherty asked
how wide the access was going to be. Mr. Dunne advised that it is about 35 ft.
across with the stairs taking up about half of the width. They stairs will go
halfway down then there will be landing and then the stairs will continue down to
the park. They will be lit and have security cameras installed. Mr. Dunne
explained that the iron work archway will be added at another time. The project
should be completed by the end of the summer.
V. Ingalls Avenue Development project
Justin Miller introduced a resolution to the board which outlined the project on
Ingalls Avenue. Mr. Miller suggested that the project details be discussed in
executive session because it involves real estate matters. Mr. Bouchey asked if
for a motion to move to executive session at this time to discuss real estate
matters.
Lisa Kyer made the motion to move to executive session to
discuss real estate matters.
Tina Urzan seconded the motion, motion carried.
Hon. Bob Doherty made the motion to adjourn executive session
with no action taken.
Tina Urzan seconded the motion, motion carried.
The board continued their discussion about the project. Mr. Bouchey asked the
board if they had any additional questions.
Hon. Bob Doherty made a motion to approve the resolution for
the Ingalls Avenue Development project.
Paul Carroll seconded the motion, motion carried.
VI. Financials
Selena Skiba went over the current financials and discussed outstanding PILOTs
with the board members. Mrs. Skiba advised the board that a letter was
received from Troy Living LLC asking to waive late fees from their late payment.
The letter indicated that they did not receive the invoice and always pay on time
without any issue. Hon. Bob Doherty asked how much the fee was. Mrs. Skiba
advised that the fee amount is $883.00. Mr. Bouchey advised that he is in favor
of waiving the fee noting that they have been good tenants. Mary O’Neil noted
that once taxes are due, they are due. Lisa Kyer questioned if there was a
mandatory 5% or if there was a grace period that he would legally be
responsible for. Mrs. Skiba asked if she is required to send out invoices. Mr.
Miller advised that they are not obligated. In the agreement, it states that the
payment is due on a certain date or a penalty is imposed. It could set an
unwanted precedent. Mr. Miller advised he should be responsible for the fee.
2
Monica Kurzejeski suggested that we send a letter explaining our position. Hon.
Dean Bodnar asked if we were sending bills. Mrs. Skiba advised yes. Mrs. Urzan
asked if automatic withdrawal was a possibility. Mrs. Skiba advised no. Mr.
Bouchey took an informal vote to see if the board members would be interested
in waiving the fees. The board members expressed an interest in having a vote.
Mr. Bouchey asked the board if they agree to waive the penalty fees of $883.00
for Troy Living, LLC. 4 yes, 3 no. Mr. Miller advised he will look into and send
out a letter. Hon. Bob Doherty spoke in favor of the positive changes that have
occurred in the area of the Troy Living LLC project and encouraged some
discussion with them regarding the fee whether they waive it or not.
Mrs. Skiba spoke about IBT's late payments. Mr. Miller advised that he will send
them out a letter advising payment due and intentions to collect the balance due.
Mrs. Kurzejeski asked how long we usually wait before going back to collecting
full taxes on a PILOT that is not making payments. Mr. Miller noted that it is
usually 30 days after the default letter is sent, however, there is no timeframe
established to send the default letter. Mrs. Kurzejeski suggested that they board
discuss a specific timeframe to send a default letter. Mr. Miller recommended
sending a default notice after 30 days. It is already in the language. Policy can
be enforced after payment not received within 30 days. Mr. Miller also
suggested sending notice to the bank or other lenders that have noticed rights.
VII. Adjournment
Mr. Bouchey asked if there were any other items before they adjourn to the CRC.
Paul Carroll made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Tina Urzan seconded the motion, motion carried.
The IDA portion of the meeting was adjourned at 11:15 a.m.
3
Agenda
Vice-Chair
Troy
Steve Bouchey
Industrial Development
Authority
Board Members
Hon. Dean Bodnar And
Mr. Paul Carroll Capital Resource Corporation
Hon. Robert Doherty
BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING
Louis Anthony
May 9, 2014
Mary O’Neill
10:30 a.m.
Lisa Kyer
Planning Department Conference
Tina Urzan Room
City Hall
AGENDA
I. Approval of Minutes from the April 11, 2014 IDA board meeting and committees and the CRC board
meeting.
IDA
II. Ingalls Avenue Development Project (Bill / Justin)
III. 33 Second Street (Bill)
IV. IBT loan (Bill)
V. 273 Riverfront Park access (Bill)
CRC
VIII. Land Bank funding (Monica)
City Hall – 433 River Street, Suite 5001, Troy, New York 12180
Phone: 518.279.7166
City of Troy
Industrial Development Authority
April 11, 2014
10:30 AM
Meeting Minutes
Present: Steve Bouchey, Bill Dunne, Hon. Dean Bodnar, Mary O’Neill, Lou Anthony,
Hon. Robert Doherty,
Absent: Paul Carroll, Tina Urzan and Lisa Kyer
Also in attendance: Justin Miller Esq., Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan, Selena Skiba, and
Denee Zeigler
Vice Chair, Steve Bouchey, called the IDA portion of the meeting to order at 10:30 a.m.
I. Minutes from the March 28, 2014 meeting
Hon. Bob Doherty made a motion to approve the minutes
from the March 28, 2014 meeting.
Lou Anthony seconded the motion, motion carried.
II. Public Hearing Dauchy/River Triangle, LLC
Steve Bouchey opened the public hearing at 10:30. Justin Miller described the
project to the board members and went through the cost benefit analysis. Mr.
Miller advised they are looking for the three benefits that the IDA has to offer.
They are looking to start work this summer. Mr. Miller advised that they have
gone through the City planning process for the River Triangle, but have not gone
through the process for the American Theater. The resolution will be held until
May or June to allow time for the theater portion of the project to go through the
planning process.
Bob Doherty asked if we had information on the current market rates. Bill
Dunne advised that the residential rate is about $1.25-$1.35 per square foot.
The commercial rate is $14-$16 per square foot. Mr. Dunne noted the recent
article stating The City of Troy has the lowest % of unoccupied space.
Steve Bouchey asked if there were any additional questions regarding the public
hearing. With no additional questions the public hearing was closed at 10:35.
III. 33-31 Second Street
Mr. Dunne spoke about the property at 33-31 Second Street that was recently
purchased by SEFCU. An RFP was sent out and four proposals were received
back by SEFCU. They plan on keeping the two restaurants and put residential on
the upper floors. Mr. Dunne noted there was concern that the building would sit
vacant, but is glad to see it being filled with tenants.
1
Mr. Bouchey asked about the status of the Troy Savings Bank which is across the
street from 33-31 Second St. Mr. Dunne advised that there has been some
interest, but no change at this time.
IV. Riverfront Park Access
Bill Dunne spoke on the project advising the board that the deck is completely
gone. The work will be completed by the end of July. Bonacio, the owner of the
Dauchy building, will be ready around the same time to fill the building with their
new tenants. They currently have a list of tenants that want to occupy both the
residential units and the commercial spaces. Mr. Dunne noted one is a deli that
will be open later than some of the businesses. Mr. Bouchey added that will help
accommodate to the residents of the area and help other businesses.
V. Mlock property
Mr. Bouchey asked if the board could move to executive session at this time to
discuss real estate matters.
Hon. Bob Doherty made the motion to move to executive session
to discuss real estate matters.
Lou Anthony seconded the motion, motion carried.
Hon. Bob Doherty made the motion to adjourn executive session
with no action taken.
Lou Anthony seconded the motion, motion carried.
VI. Financials
Selena Skiba went over the current financials with the board members. Mrs.
Skiba reviewed the cash available, accounts receivable, PILOTs and profit/loss.
Mrs. Skiba advised that administrative fees were received for Cookie Factory and
went over the outstanding PILOTs. Letters were sent out to all of them. Justin
Miller advised to send Don Boyajian a copy of the Realex PILOT letter because
he is the owner of the building.
Mr. Bouchey asked about the sale of the IBT building. Mr. Miller advised that he
is going to have a discussion with sellers to see if something could be collected.
Mr. Miller noted that they will also have discussions with the new owners
regarding PILOT.
Hon. Dean Bodnar had concerns about Troy Living LLC’s PILOT and asked if we
should reach out to him. Mrs. Skiba advised that they can send out an addition
notice. Mr. Miller advised he is highly motivated to keep the PILOT in place.
Mrs. Skiba advised they will be in contact with them.
VII. ByLaws
Mr. Bouchey asked if they could adjourn the regular meeting to meet with the
Governance Committee. Mr. Dunne noted that the all of the committee
members are not here. The committee was going to discuss the current bylaws.
2
A copy of the IDA by laws was handed out to the full board to review and
discuss at the next meeting.
VIII. Adjournment
Mr. Bouchey asked if there were any other items before they adjourn to the CRC.
Lou Anthony made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Hon. Bob Doherty seconded the motion, motion carried.
The IDA portion of the meeting was adjourned at 11:10 a.m.
3
City of Troy
Capital Resource Corporation
April 11, 2014
11:10 AM
Meeting Minutes
Present: Steve Bouchey, Bill Dunne, Hon. Dean Bodnar, Mary O’Neill, Lou Anthony,
Hon. Robert Doherty,
Absent: Paul Carroll, Tina Urzan and Lisa Kyer
Also in attendance: Justin Miller Esq., Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan, Selena Skiba, and
Denee Zeigler
Vice Chair, Steve Bouchey, called the CRC meeting to order at 11:10 a.m.
I. Land Bank Funding
Justin Miller spoke to the CRC board about an item that was discussed
earlier this morning with the LDC finance committee. The City of Troy is
looking to establish a land bank. Mr. Miller explained that a land bank is a
not for profit corporation that has the capability to take properties and tax
liens from municipalities to redevelop them and get them back on the tax
rolls. He advised that there is a process that the municipality has to go
through in order to establish the land bank which will then manage the
properties for the City. Mr. Miller explained that it starts with a sponsoring
resolution from the City council and an application being filed and
approved by Empire State Redevelopment Corporation. Mr. Miller advised
that there is a lot of work to be done between several groups to get the
application ready. Once the application is approved, the certificate of
incorporation is filed with the state and the newly established board can
meet and do business.
Mr. Miller advised the council does not have funds available to contribute,
but the CRC and LDC do have funds. Mr. Miller advised that at the LDC
finance committee meeting earlier today earmarking $50,000 to contribute
to the start up funds. The CRC is being asked to match that amount.
There is nothing to approve at this time, but will have a formal request in
May with additional discussion.
Mr. Doherty advised that the council looked at the idea of land banks
about a year ago when Schenectady established theirs, which is county
wide. They talked about setting up a county wide land bank but decided
against it because the LDC had the same functional powers. Mr. Doherty
added that at this point the attorney general will only be giving funding to
land banks. Mr. Doherty asked if there were other communities that have
had success with land banks. Mr. Dunne advised that some communities
have had success, but doesn’t want to make an across the board
statement. Mr. Bodnar spoke about a land bank that was set up in Flint,
1
Michigan that was very successful and has been used as a model. Mr.
Bodnar advised that he had been to a presentation by the man who
established the land banks in Michigan. He advised that it was a very
impressive presentation that pointed out all the things a land bank can do
that the municipality cannot. Mr. Miller agreed and added that
municipalities are limited in what they can do to redevelop vacant
buildings. Land banks can help to facilitate the process of redeveloping
them and makes it quicker and easier. Mr. Doherty spoke about the
housing situation in his district.
Mr. Dunne added that the benefit of a land bank is that their one and only
focus will be their job. Mr. Miller advised that during that period of time
between council action and meeting as a board, we can work to map out
the plans and priorities that we want to focus on. Mr. Bodnar suggested a
working group. Mr. Miller agreed that would be a good idea to get
everything lined up for when they are able to meet as a board.
II. Adjournment
Mr. Bouchey asked if there were any items to discuss for New Business before
they adjourn the CRC meeting. The board had no other items to discuss.
Hon. Bob Doherty made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Mary O’Neill seconded the motion, motion carried.
The CRC meeting was adjourned at 11:30 a.m.
2
Get email alerts for Troy
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.