Troy Industrial Development Authority
Regular MeetingTroy, NY · September 20, 2024
Minutes
September 20, 2024
10:00 AM
Regular Board Meeting
Present: Hon. Ryan Brosnan, Stephanie Fitch, Hon. Sue Steele, Alex Carlton, Michael Cusack and
Latasha Gardner.
Absent: Jeff Betts and Elbert Watson
Also in attendance: Justin Miller, Matt Jones, Zachery Gohl, Jeff Mirel, Samantha Hirtler, Nadia
Smirnova, John Boyd, Deanna Dal Pos and Denee Zeigler.
The regular board meeting was called to order at 10:07 a.m.
I. Minutes
The minutes from the August 16, 2024 regular board meeting were reviewed by the board
members.
Motion to approve the August 16, 2024 minutes – Stephanie Fitch
Second – Alex Carlton
Abstained – Latasha Gardner and Michael Cusack
Approved
II. Executive Directors Report
No executive director report this month.
III. New Business
NY-GEO Conference – Mrs. Zeigler gave the background on the geothermal conference
happening in October. She advised the conference will include site tours and provide
details on all aspects of geothermal. We have several current and upcoming IDA projects
that will benefit getting familiar with geothermal. Ms. Gardner asked about the early bird
registration. Mrs. Zeigler noted she will verify that early bird registration will be applied to
the invoice.
Motion to approve the expenditure for Denee Zeigler and Andrew Kreshik to attend
the NY-GEO Conference October 21-23 – Hon. Sue Steele
Second – Stephanie Fitch
Approved
1
IV. Old Business
1818 Fifth Ave project update - Mr. Brosnan advised we have members of Rosenblum
Companies here to give a presentation and catch us up on their project. Jeff Mirel advised
of the changes since they last presented. Costs have gone up significantly since last
presenting to the board and it was one of the main reasons they put the project on hold.
The project at 1818 5th Ave will consist of 71 units and four stories. Mr. Mirel advised that
they wanted to keep the height of the building complementary to the brownstones across
the street as well as the design of the first-floor units. Each one will have an entrance way
similar to the properties around it. He noted that the site plan has been approved. They
are aiming for the most environmentally efficient of all the projects they have done to
date. Mr. Mirel explained that they are aiming for passive house certification. This is a very
high degree of efficiency to aim for, but it has many beneficial byproducts which will result
in healthier and quieter buildings for the tenants. Mr. Mirel also noted that this building is
the winner of NYSERDAs Building of Excellence last round. He also shared as part of the
presentation, an economic impact study that was done for this project. Mr. Mirel spoke
about supply and workforce challenges that will continue. The type of construction being
done on this building will require highly skilled workers who may need additional changes.
Ms. Gardner asked about what changes would be coming about because of the proposed
changes. Mr. Mirel noted that the types of jobs needed will be important to meet the
passive requirements. There are several areas where work has to be modified from how it
is normally done in order to meet the requirements. This could require hiring a workforce
that has this additional training. Mrs. Fitch asked about the sizes of the studios. Mr. Mirel
explained that they range from 450 – 550 sqft. They wanted to create a range of studios
to offer. Ms. Gardner asked about the base rent. Mr. Mirel explained the breakdown of
rents and how they established the rates.
V. Financials
Mr. Jones presented the statement of financial position to the board. He advised that as
of August 31, 2024 the total assets stand at $1,005,816 with $887,892 in cash. There is
$38,449 in liabilities, leaving a fund balance of $967,367. No significant changes for the
month of August.
Mr. Jones presented the statement of activity for August and explained there is a surplus
of $5,360. The largest source of revenue was the application fee from the Troy Savings
Bank. The largest expenses were monthly accounting fees.
Mr. Jones presented a DRAFT copy of the budget to the board for review. He noted that
there may be some changes to the charges for service number on the final version. That
will be presented to the board next month.
Motion to approve the August financials as presented – Hon. Sue Steele
Second – Stephanie Fitch
Approved
VI. Adjournment
With no additional business to discuss, the IDA regular board meeting was adjourned at
10:41 a.m.
2
Motion to adjourn the regular board meeting at 10:41 a.m. – Hon. Sue
Steele
Second – Stephanie Fitch
Approved
3
Agenda
Board Members
Chair
Alex Carlton
Jeff Betts
Michael Cusack
Vice Chair Stephanie Fitch
Hon. Ryan Brosnan Latasha Gardner
Hon. Sue Steele
Executive Director Elbert Watson
Randy Coburn
SEPTEMBER 20, 2024
10:00 a.m.
BOARD MEETING
I. Approval of Minutes from the August 16, 2024 board meeting.
II. Executive Director’s Report
III. New Business
1. NY-GEO Conference – October 21-23rd
IV. Old Business
1. 1818 Fifth Ave – Project Update and Presentation
V. Financials and Draft Budget
VI. Adjournment
City Hall – 433 River Street, Suite 5001, Troy, New York 12180
Phone: 518.279.7166
August 16, 2024
10:00 AM
Regular Board Meeting
Present: Jeff Betts, Elbert Watson, Stephanie Fitch, Susan Farrell, Hon. Sue Steele, Hon. Ryan
Brosnan and Alex Carlton.
Absent: Latasha Gardner and Josh Chiappone
Also in attendance: Randy Coburn, Matt Jones, Deanna Dal Pos, Jon Elbaum, Barb Nelson, Corey
Aldrich and Denee Zeigler.
D
The regular board meeting was called to order at 10:04 a.m.
I. Minutes
R
The minutes from the June 21, 2024 regular board meeting were reviewed by the board
members.
T
Motion to approve the June 21, 2024 minutes – Susan Farrell
Second – Hon. Ryan Brosnan
AF
Absent from this vote – Hon. Sue Steele
Approved
II. Executive Directors Report
Main Street TA Grant– this project was undertaken between May – July and focused on
building assessments from 115th – 117th streets along 2nd Ave in Lansingburgh. We
contracted with Clinton Brown Company Architects who worked with active and willing
participants. Funding for construction was applied for during this past CFA process. A
copy of the final report will be sent around to the board.
1818 5th Ave – this 71-unit residential project will be coming in front of the board next
month. They are in process of revising their application.
FOIL Request – A FOIL request was received related to an injury that happened at City
Station East. Mr. Miller noted that we will receive information such as this from time to time
when there is a personal injury at one of the IDA’s project sites.
Funding Request – In order to continue becoming more efficient and effective we are
looking into systems that manage information between several departments. There are
several processes and applications that would benefits from this. Mrs. Fitch agreed and
noted that it would be great to be able to create custom reports on projects. Mr. Watson
asked if there was a large amount of past data that would have to be entered. Mr. Coburn
advised yes, but going forward it will be useful. He added that a few companies are being
1
looked at to provide the service and will get back to the board with pricing after we solicit
additional bids.
III. New Business
Troy Hub, LLC – Mr. Miller gave an overview of the application received by Troy Hub,
LLC, an entity created by the Troy Music Hall Corporation. They have been working on
making HVAC upgrades to the building as well as renovating the former bank space
known as the annex. The annex space will be used as flex space for performances,
community space and recording. There will also be updates made to their parking area.
Mr. Miller noted that this project set up is similar to what was approved with Proctor’s
American Theater project on River Street. Jon Elbaum spoke to the board about the
project and arrangement and noted that we are currently doing some sitework. Mr. Elbaum
explained this is the most transformative project since it was built 150 years ago. The
seasons will be extended, bring thousands of new visitors to downtown Troy and allow us
to continue our mission. We plan on completing the project at the end of 2025 – beginning
of 2026. Mr. Watson asked about the funding gap. Mr. Elbaum advised they have
$500,000 in capital funds and plan on raising the rest. They also have access to funds in
the event the goal is not reached. A presentation was shared with the board members and
details of the renovation project were discussed. (See resolution 08/24 #1)
D
Motion to approve the Initial Project Resolution for Troy Hub, LLC – Hon. Sue Steele
Second – Stephanie Fitch
Recused – Jeff Betts
Approved
R
Dinosaur BBQ – Mr. Miller updated the board on the slip and fall case that was filed a
few months ago. He advised that it is reconciling itself, no action required by the board.
T
Cookie Factory PILOT – Mr. Miller gave an update to the board about this older PILOT
and noted it is ending this year. We have been in talks with the banks to settle all
AF
outstanding amounts due. It should be resolved in the next few weeks. We have the
authority to terminate without working with them but would like to work with them. Mr.
Watson asked if they are closed. Mr. Miller noted that they are restructuring.
R&M Holdings, LLC (DeFazio’s) – Mr. Miller noted that they are back working again
after a short delay for some environmental issues. We had extended their sales tax
agreement at our last meeting due to its lapsing and will work on finalizing the paperwork.
IV. Old Business
Mr. Coburn spoke to the board about the LWRP plan that was discussed at the previous
meeting. He advised that at the last meeting a board member wanted to see the draft
plan before voting. It has been sent around and reviewed it himself. It is a very generic,
non-descriptive plan that will be revised with the $100,000 funding received through the
DOS. The funding request being asked of by this board is the $17,647 match.
Motion to approve to approve funding in the amount of $17,647 to the City
of Troy to be used as a match towards their DOS LWRP grant in the amount
of $100,000. – Hon. Ryan Brosnan
Second – Elbert Watson
Approved
2
V. Financials
Mr. Jones presented the statement of financial position to the board. He advised that as
of July 31, 2024 the total assets stand at $1,001,540 with $884,189 in cash. There is
$38,985 in liabilities, leaving a fund balance of $962,555. No significant changes for the
month of July.
Mr. Jones presented the statement of activity for May and explained there is a deficit of
$26,411. The largest source of revenue was in administrative fees. The largest expenses
were architectural fees.
Motion to approve the May financials as presented – Elbert Watson
Second – Susan Farrell
Approved
VI. Adjournment
With no additional business to discuss, the IDA regular board meeting was adjourned at
10:41 a.m.
D
Motion to adjourn the regular board meeting at 10:41 a.m. – Stephanie
Fitch
Second – Hon. Sue Steele
Approved
R
T
AF
3
INITIAL PROJECT RESOLUTION
(Troy Hub, LLC – Troy Savings Bank Music Hall Redevelopment Project)
A regular meeting of the Troy Industrial Development Authority (the “Authority”) was
convened on August 16, 2024 at 10:00 a.m., local time, at 433 River Street, 5th Floor, Troy, New
York 12180.
The meeting was called to order by the Chairman and, upon roll being called, the
following members of the Authority were:
Member Present Absent
Jeff Betts
Susan Farrell
Elbert Watson
DHon. Ryan Brosnan
Stephanie Fitch
Latasha Gardner
Josh Chiappone
R
Hon. Sue Steele
Alex Carlton
T
The following persons were ALSO PRESENT:
AF
After the meeting had been duly called to order, the Chairman announced that among the
purposes of the meeting was to consider and take action on certain matters pertaining to a
proposed project for the redevelopment of the Troy Savings Bank Music Hall, which is being led
by TSB Music Hall Corporation and development affiliate Troy Hub, LLC (or on behalf of an
entity to be formed).
On motion duly made by _________ and seconded by __________, the following
resolution was placed before the members of the Troy Industrial Development Authority:
Member Aye Nay Abstain Absent
Jeff Betts
Susan Farrell
Elbert Watson
Hon. Ryan Brosnan
Stephanie Fitch
Latasha Gardner
Josh Chiappone
Hon. Sue Steele
Alex Carlton
Page 1 of 5
Resolution No. ____
RESOLUTION OF THE TROY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
(THE “AUTHORITY”) (i) ACCEPTING THE APPLICATION OF TROY HUB,
LLC, ON BEHALF OF ITSELF AND/OR AN ENTITY TO BE FORMED
(COLLECTIVELY, THE “COMPANY”) IN CONNECTION WITH A
CERTAIN PROJECT (AS MORE FULLY DEFINED BELOW); (ii)
AUTHORIZING THE SCHEDULING, NOTICE AND CONDUCT OF A
PUBLIC HEARING WITH RESPECT TO THE PROJECT; AND (iii)
DESCRIBING THE FORMS OF FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BEING
CONTEMPLATED BY THE AUTHORITY WITH RESPECT TO THE
PROJECT
WHEREAS, by Title 11 of Article 8 of the Public Authorities Law of the State of New
D
York, as amended, and Chapter 759 of the Laws of 1967 of the State of New York, as amended
(hereinafter collectively called the “Act”), the TROY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY (hereinafter called the “Authority”) was created with the authority and power to
own, lease and sell property for the purpose of, among other things, acquiring, constructing and
R
equipping industrial, manufacturing and commercial facilities as authorized by the Act; and
WHEREAS, TROY HUB, LLC, for itself and/or on behalf of an entity to be formed
(collectively, the “Company”), has requested the Authority’s assistance with a certain project
T
(the “Project”) consisting of (i) the acquisition by the Authority of a leasehold interest in
AF
approximately .75 acres of real property located at 32 Second Street and 42-48 Second Street,
Troy, New York 12180 (the “Land”, being more particularly identified as TMID Nos. 101.53-8-
13./1 Music Hall, 101.53-8-13./2 Music Hall Annex and 101.53-13-1 Parking Lot) and the
existing building structure and parking improvements located thereon consisting principally of
an approximately 66,000 square foot, multi-story historic music hall, annex spaces and related
parking lot parcel (the “Existing Improvements”), (ii) the planning, design, engineering,
construction, reconstruction, rehabilitation, equipping and improvement of the Land and Existing
Improvements to (i) establish a Music Hub Initiative within the Annex spaces to establish
flexible space to support performances, instructions, recording spaces and community events, (ii)
the construction, installation and equipping of HVAC and production equipment upgrades within
the Music Hall, and (iii) the reconstruction and equipping of parking lot improvements to
increase parking capacity and enhance green spaces, all to be operated by the Company and
managed by TSB MUSIC HALL CORPORATION, along with related upgrades and
improvements of commercial spaces, exterior façade, access and egress improvements,
mechanical, roof, window, utility and HVAC improvements, and parking, curbage, signage and
related exterior improvements (collectively, the “Improvements”), (iii) the acquisition and
installation by the Company in and around the Land, Existing Improvements and Improvements
of certain items of equipment and other tangible personal property necessary and incidental in
connection with the Company’s development of the Project in and around the Land, Existing
Improvements and Improvements (the “Equipment”, and collectively with the Land, the Existing
Page 2 of 5
Improvements and the Improvements, the “Facility”); and (iv) the lease of the Facility to the
Company; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Act, the Authority desires to adopt a resolution describing
the Project and the Financial Assistance (as hereinafter defined) that the Authority is
contemplating with respect to the Project; and
WHEREAS, it is contemplated that the Authority will (i) accept the Application
submitted by the Company; (ii) approve the scheduling, notice and conduct of a Public Hearing
with respect to the Project; and (iii) approve the negotiation, but not the execution or delivery, of
certain documents in furtherance of the Project, as more fully described below.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MEMBERS OF THE TROY
INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. The Company has presented an application in a form acceptable to the
Authority. Based upon the representations made by the Company to the Authority in the
D
Company’s application and in related correspondence, the Authority hereby finds and determines
that:
(A) By virtue of the Act, the Authority has been vested with all powers necessary and
R
convenient to carry out and effectuate the purposes and provisions of the Act and to exercise all
powers granted to it under the Act; and
(B) The Authority has the authority to take the actions contemplated herein under the
Act; and
T
AF
(C) The action to be taken by the Authority will induce the Company to develop the
Project, and otherwise furthering the purposes of the Authority as set forth in the Act; and
(D) The Project will not result in the removal of a commercial, industrial, or
manufacturing plant of the Company or any other proposed occupant of the Project from one
area of the State of New York (the “State”) to another area of the State or result in the
abandonment of one or more plants or facilities of the Company or any other proposed occupant
of the Project located within the State; and the Authority hereby finds that, based on the
Company’s application, to the extent occupants are relocating from one plant or facility to
another, the Project is reasonably necessary to discourage the Project occupants from removing
such other plant or facility to a location outside the State and/or is reasonably necessary to
preserve the competitive position of the Project occupants in their respective industries; and
Section 2. The proposed Financial Assistance being contemplated by the Authority
includes (i) a sales and use tax exemption for materials, supplies and rentals acquired or procured
in furtherance of the Project by the Company as agent of the Authority; (ii) mortgage recording
tax exemption(s) in connection with secured financings undertaken by the Company in
furtherance of the Project; and (iii) an abatement or exemption from real property taxes levied
against the Land and Facility pursuant to a PILOT Agreement to be negotiated.
Page 3 of 5
Section 3. The Chairman, Vice Chairman, and/or Executive Director/Chief Executive
Officer of the Authority are hereby authorized, on behalf of the Authority, to schedule, notice
and conduct a public hearing in compliance with the Act and negotiate (but not execute or
deliver) the terms of (A) an Agent and Financial Assistance and Project Agreement (the “Agent
Agreement”), (B) a Lease Agreement, pursuant to which the Company leases the Project to the
Authority (or, a Deed of conveyance to the Authority whereby the Authority will acquire fee title
to the Land and Project), (C) a related Leaseback Agreement, pursuant to which the Authority
leases its interest in the Project back to the Company, (D) a PILOT Agreement, pursuant to
which the Company agrees to make certain payments in-lieu-of real property taxes, and (E)
related documents thereto; provided (i) the rental payments under the Leaseback Agreement
include payments of all costs incurred by the Authority arising out of or related to the Project and
indemnification of the Authority by the Company for actions taken by the Company and/or
claims arising out of or related to the Project and (ii) the terms of the PILOT Agreement are
consistent with the Authority’s Uniform Tax Exemption Policy or the procedures for deviation
have been complied with.
D
Section 4. The officers, employees and agents of the Authority are hereby authorized
and directed for and in the name and on behalf of the Authority to do all acts and things required
and to execute and deliver all such certificates, instruments and documents, to pay all such fees,
charges and expenses and to do all such further acts and things as may be necessary or, in the
R
opinion of the officer, employee or agent acting, desirable and proper to effect the purposes of
the foregoing resolutions and to cause compliance by the Authority with all of the terms,
covenants and provisions of the documents executed for and on behalf of the Authority.
Section 5.
T
These Resolutions shall take effect immediately.
AF
Page 4 of 5
T
AF
R
D
NY-GEO
16 West Main St
Cambridge, NY 12816
Tel (518) 313-6436
E-Mail nygeoinfo@gmail.com
INVOICE 1530 PO NUMBER 8/29/2024
BILL TO MESSAGE
Troy Industrial Development Corporation
Denée Zeigler
433 River Street
Troy, NY 12180
QUANTITY DESCRIPTION UNIT PRICE TOTAL
NYC NY-GEO 2024 Attendee Registration -
1 999.00 999.00
Denée Zeigler - NY-GEO Member
* NY-GEO Member - NY-GEO Member (200.00)
NYC NY-GEO 2024 Attendee Registration -
1 999.00 999.00
Andrew Kreshik - NY-GEO Member
* NY-GEO Member - NY-GEO Member (200.00)
SUBTOTAL 1,998.00
SALES TAX 0.00
SHIPPING & HANDLING 0.00
TOTAL 1,998.00
PAYMENT/CREDIT/WRITE OFF/DISCOUNTS APPLIED (400.00)
TOTAL DUE BY 8/29/2024 1,598.00
Thank you for your business!
31-60 DAYS 61-90 DAYS OVER 90 DAYS PAST TOTAL OPEN
CURRENT
PAST DUE PAST DUE DUE INVOICE
1,598.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,598.00
Submit payment online here
Page 2
Get email alerts for Troy
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.