Troy Local Development Corporation
Regular MeetingTroy, NY · November 14, 2014
Minutes
TROY LOCAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
Board of Director
Meeting Minutes
November 14, 2014
8:30 a.m.
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Kevin O’Bryan, Bill Dunne, Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan,
Andy Ross and Hon. Ken Zalewski
ABSENT:
ALSO IN ATTENDANCE: Justin Miller, Ken Crowe, Sharon Martin, Tom Rossi,
Selena Skiba and Denee Zeigler
Minutes
Kevin O’Bryan called the meeting to order at 8:34 a.m.
I. Minutes
The board reviewed the minutes from the October 10, 2014 meetings.
Andy Ross made a motion to approve the minutes from the
October 10, 2014.
Hon. Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
II. David Bryce Bridgeloan
Bill Dunne spoke to the board about the loan David Bryce was approved for
at the last meeting. Mr. Dunne advised that after discussion, it was
determined that a bridge loan would be a better fit for this project. Justin
Miller spoke about the current status of the project regarding ownership of the
building and the loan they are asking for. They would like to set up a
bridgeloan until the financing comes in from Empire State Development. The
chairman asked if we would be second behind the construction loan. Mr.
Miller advised that on construction completion, when the CFA grants are
received we will get reimbursed. It is a 5 year loan but would be paid off in
about 18 months. The chairman noted minimal risk. Mr. Dunne added that
he has a lot of properties and has had a successful track record with no
outstanding debt. Mr. Miller handed out a term sheet for the board to review
and explained that there is no motion needed at this time and they can
discuss more at the next meeting.
III. Possible property donation to TLDC
Bill Dunne spoke to the board about a possible donation of property from
Wells Fargo. He advised that the property is located at 2265 Fifth Ave
between Jacob and Hutton and is currently in the foreclosure process. The
1
building is not in good shape and may need to come down. The property is
about a block from City Hall near the proposed Hedley Transit Center. In
addition to the property, they are also offering $10,000 cash that could be
used to secure the building. Mr. Miller advised all taxes will be brought
current at the sale. Mr. Dunne advised they may have some additional
properties that will be offered to the City. Ken Zalewski asked if we would be
interested in keeping the property or the land. Mr. Dunne advised it would
most likely come down. Andy Ross advised that we shouldn’t put any funding
into the building except to secure it in order for it to not become a liability. Mr.
Miller advised that it will be added to our insurance. The chairman asked if
there was anyone in the building currently. Mr. Miller advised no. Mr. Dunne
advised that board approval is needed in order to move forward.
Hon. Ken Zalewski made a motion to acquire the property at
2265 Fifth Ave.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan seconded the motion, motion carried.
IV. King Fuels site update
Mr. Dunne spoke about the request by National Grid to lay a pipe through the
King Fuels site. A meeting was held to discuss a potential path, but no
decision was made yet. Mr. Dunne advised that he has spoken with ELAN
regarding their contract and will bring it to the board when received. The
chairman advised that the meeting was very informative, but nothing was
decided on. Mr. Dunne advised that he will report back when he hears
something regarding the decision.
V. e-Lot site update
Mr. Dunne advised that the water is back on at the e-Lot site and we had to
retain a contractor in order to get it up and running again. Mr. Dunne
explained that they have received correspondence regarding the issue. Mr.
Miller explained that they are asking for credit for the period of time that the
water was not on. Mr. Miller advised that we can discuss any kind of
settlement in executive session at the end of the meeting.
VI. Massive Mesh
Tom Rossi spoke to the board about the updates he has made to the
agreement since the last meeting. He included a cost sheet that shows the
costs of equipment that will be used as the match for the grant. Mr. Rossi
spoke about tower placement for the free Wi-Fi. Mr. Ryan asked if the towers
will be all throughout the City. Mr. Rossi explained that they will be small roof
mounts, not like the larger one on top of some of the buildings. Mr. Rossi
talked about the smaller mounts that are on most of the buildings compared
to the larger towers. The chairman asked if he has come across any issues
with Historic district regulations. Mr. Rossi advised that there is no effect on
the building and it cannot be seen from the street. Mr. Rossi also spoke to
the board about the equipment’s specifications. Mr. Zalewski asked if they
require building permits. Mr. Dunne explained not that he is aware of but will
explore the historic district guidelines. Mr. Rossi noted he has about 70
customers at this time. Mr. Dunne advised that he has the service and will
recuse himself from the votes regarding the agreement.
The chairman advised that the proposal was updated to include the request
at the previous meeting to indicate some type of collateral because this is a
grant. Justin asked about the life cycle of the equipment. Mr. Rossi advised
2
that it is built to last. By that time there will be any issues, it will make more
sense to update to new technology instead of repairing. Mr. Miller suggested
a forgivable grant for up to 5 years, for example, that would have some
recourse in the event of an interruption. Mr. Rossi noted that he would like to
work with not for profits that we can install a tower on their building for
exchange of free Wi-Fi. Mr. Ross asked if the project would move forward if
he was not able to secure the $30,000 grant from the County. Mr. Rossi
advised that it could move forward, however the grant funds would help. Mr.
Ryan noted that this approval would help with the approval from the County.
Mr. Miller advised
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to approve the grant in
the amount of $30,000 to Massive Mesh.
Hon. Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
Bill Dunne abstained from the vote.
VII. Financials
Selena Skiba spoke about the current financials. Mrs. Skiba asked about an
older charge in the amount of $350 for a conference. The chairman asked if
it is something that we should be carrying on the balance sheet. Mrs. Skiba
spoke about some of the outstanding bills, nothing major at this time. Mr.
Zalewski advised that the new style of the financials is much better. Mr.
Dunne noted that the owners of County Waste have changed. Mrs. Skiba will
have that account updated. The board had a general discussion about the
steps taken to collect funds for a late account.
Andy Ross made a motion to charge off $350.00 for a
conference fee.
Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
Bill Dunne made a motion to accept the financials.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan seconded the motion, motion carried.
VIII. Executive Session
Mr. Miller advised that they had some items to discuss in executive session.
Bill Dunne made a motion to enter into executive session to
discuss pending litigation.
Andy Ross seconded the motion, motion carried.
Hon. Ken Zalewski made a motion to adjourn executive
session.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
IX. Bank Account
Selena Skiba advised that an update is needed to remove the Wally Altes as
a signer for the TLDC bank accounts and add Kevin O’Bryan.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to remove Wally Altes
as signer and add Kevin O’Bryan.
Hon. Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
Kevin O’Bryan abstained from the vote.
X. Adjournment
3
The meeting was adjourned at 10:01 a.m.
Andy Ross made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan seconded the motion, motion carried.
4
Agenda
Kevin O’Bryan, Chairman Andrew Ross, Vice Chairman
Ken Zalewski Bill Dunne
Deputy Mayor Pete Ryan
TROY LOCAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
Board of Directors Meeting
Planning Department Conference Room
City Hall
433 River Street, Suite 5001
Troy, New York 12180
November 14, 2014
8:30 a.m.
AGENDA
I. Approval of Minutes from October 10, 2014 board meeting.
II. David Bryce, 30 3rd Street - Bridge loan
III. Possible property donation to TLDC
IV. King Fuels Update
V. eLot Update
VI. Massive Mesh Agreement
VII. Executive Session
VIII. Adjournment
TROY LOCAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
Board of Director
Meeting Minutes
October 10, 2014
8:30 a.m.
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Kevin O’Bryan, Bill Dunne, Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan,
Andy Ross and Hon. Ken Zalewski
ABSENT:
ALSO IN ATTENDANCE: Justin Miller, Ken Crowe, David Bryce, Heidi Benjamin,
Frank Sicari, Tom Rossi, Sharon Martin and Denee Zeigler
Minutes
Kevin O’Bryan called the meeting to order at 8:30 a.m.
I. Minutes
The board reviewed the minutes from the September 12, 2014 and October
3, 2014 meetings.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to approve the minutes
from the September 12, 2014 and October 3, 2014 board
meetings.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
Andy Ross and Ken Zalewski were absent for the vote.
II. David Bryce 50/50 Façade grant for 30 3rd Street
Bill Dunne introduced David Bryce to the board. Mr. Bryce explained that he
is currently working on 30 3rd Street, the former Quackenbush building. Mr.
Bryce explained he has completely removed the brown aluminum storefront
and will completely replace the façade. Mr. Bryce passed around a drawing
that shows what was currently there. The Chairman asked if the building is
historically significant. Mr. Bryce advised yes it is and they have gone
through the historical review process. The Chairman asked if there were any
other questions from the board members.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to approve the 50/50
Façade Improvement Grant application for David Bryce at 30
3rd Street.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
Hon. Ken Zalewski was absent for the vote.
III. Tom Rossi 50/50 Facade grant for 184 River Street
1
Tom Rossi spoke about his current project at 184 River Street where the
Beirut restaurant is located. Mr. Rossi advised that they have run into some
sewer issues and back wall problems. He advised that he is currently getting
proposals for façade work. Mr. Rossi discussed the scope of work which
includes repairing, cleaning up and repainting the exterior. Mr. Dunne
advised that the color of the building will require approval from the historic
review committee. Mr. Rossi is aware and will contact them. Mr. Dunne
asked if the restaurant will be staying in the building once the work is
completed. Mr. Rossi advised yes.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to approve the 50/50
Façade Improvement grant for 184 4th Street.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
IV. David Bryce BDAP loan
Mr. Dunne introduced David Bryce to the board again to discuss his loan
application. Mr. Bryce explained that the building is between 80-90% leased.
He mentioned some of his other tenants that will be occupying the space.
Mr. Ryan asked about the square feet of the building. Mr. Bryce advised it is
about 55,000 sq ft. Mr. Dunne advised that the loan request is for $200,000.
The Chairman asked if there were any other questions for Mr. Bryce.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to accept David Bryce’s
application for a $200,000 BDAP loan for a project at 30 3rd
Street.
Andy Ross seconded the motion, motion carried.
V. Takk House, LLC BDAP loan
Mr. Dunne introduced Frank Sicari and Heidi Benjamin spoke to the board
about their business. Frank Sicari advised the board that they purchased the
Knights of Columbus building at 55 3rd Street and would like to turn it into an
event venue. Mr. Sicari advised that they ran into an issue with installing a
sprinkler system and are looking for assistance to get that installed in order to
continue holding events. Heidi Benjamin explained that they are going to be
installing the sprinklers in stages and have discussed this with the Fire Chief.
Mr. Dunne asked about the previous renovations and how much of the
original façade was left. Mr. Sicari advised the previous owners did a lot of
work and was not sure about the facade, but will be curious to find out.
Mr. Ryan asked about the timeframe for completing the sprinkler process and
asked if they received more than one quote. Ms. Benjamin advised they
have received quotes from five companies but decided to go with Albany Fire.
She added that they will not have a kitchen on the premises; all food will be
brought in. Mr. Dunne advised they are asking for a $30,000 loan.
Andy Ross made a motion to accept Frank Sicari and Heidi
Benjamin’s application for a $30,000 BDAP loan for a project
at 55 3rd Street.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
VI. Utility Vehicle
Mr. Dunne spoke to the board about quotes received for utility vehicles that
will be purchased on behalf of the BID. The vehicles will be used for snow
removal for areas downtown and other tasks throughout the year. The
2
proposal is to authorize up to $20,000 for purchase of the vehicle. It will
greatly assist in clearing out the streets for the downtown businesses and
events. The current vehicle Andy Ross asked who would do the
maintenance on the vehicle. Mr. Dunne advised it will be part of the
agreement that the BID will maintain. Mr. Miller asked if we will fund it and it
will be titled in their name. Mr. Dunne advised yes. Mr. Ryan asked about
where it will be stored. Mr. Dunne explained that they will be able to store it
under the stairs at 273 River Street once completed. Ken Zalewski
questioned whether this purchase was outside of our mission statement. Mr.
Dunne advised that part of our mission is to lessen the burden of City and
plowing is part of this. Mr. Ross spoke about the benefits of clearing the
snow in the downtown. Mr. Ross asked if we would have any liability. Mr.
Miller advised that we would not have any liability.
Andy Ross made a motion to approve up to $20,000 for the
purchase of a utility vehicle.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion.
Ken Zalewski opposed, motion carried.
VII. King Fuels site and development proposals
Mr. Dunne spoke to the board about the progress of the King Fuels site. He
advised that the entire west side of the property is cleaned up. He advised
that we will need to meet soon with National Grid to discuss the project. Mr.
Dunne advised that at this time E-lot does not have any water, we are
currently supplying them. The City is also putting in a sewer line and had
come across some oil while digging. It has been pumped out and the soil has
been removed.
Mr. Dunne advised that everyone has read the proposals and has worked to
narrow the choices down to two applicants, ELAN and VHV. The additional
information we have requested has been submitted and reviews and
references have been checked. The chairman asked if there were any other
questions or issues.
Dep. Mayor Pete Ryan made a motion to award ELAN.
Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
VIII. Massive Mesh
Tom Rossi spoke to the board about the downtown massive mesh project.
Mr. Rossi advised while working on previous projects he started to notice
issues with wireless networks and providers in this area and decided to start
working on this project to make wireless more cost effective and available to
the residents. Mr. Rossi advised that they are looking to create a mesh
network that will cover the entire City. They will do this in three stages. They
have submitted a CFA grant application. Mr. Rossi explained that he will start
with about a thirteen block area that will cover 50 subscribers. Free wireless
is currently in Monument Square. Eventually, they would like it to be
available in all areas of the City. The free subscription will allow a certain
amount of access, but if they would like to get additional time they will be able
to subscribe. Mr. Zalewski advised that users will know about Massive Mesh
because it will come up on their phones. Mr. Rossi advised yes. They will
have the option to use the free internet or sign in to their account. Mr. Rossi
spoke about the process of setting up the wireless network. He advised that
there is not much cost for the process, but there are costs for setting up and
landlord agreements. Mr. Ryan asked if there have been any issues with
3
National Grid. Mr. Rossi advised that they haven’t run into any yet. Mr.
Rossi advised that they are rolling this out in small stages and are talking
about creating some positions. Mr. Dunne advised that Time Warner pays
the City a franchise fee each year but we only get paid for video/cable
service, not internet. If people switch to Massive Mesh it will not have any
effect on this fee paid to the City. Mr. Rossi advised that he is trying to get an
engineer on board to help move the process along. Mr. Dunne explained that
the request is for a $30,000 grant and asked if Mr. Rossi would be willing to
put in a high speed wireless in places that don’t have access. Mr. Rossi
explained that is something he can look into. The board had a general
discussion on the process behind the wireless internet access. Mr. Ross
asked about the funding request from the county and us and asked if we the
grant is used to cover someone’s salary for this year, what happens next
year. Mr. Rossi advised that he wouldn’t have to ask for another grant
because they will be up and running by that point. Mr. Ross would like to see
the grant funding go towards hardware rather than a person. Mr. Zalewski
agreed. Mr. Miller asked if he had a business plan that shows $30,000 in
expenditures. The chairman clarified the boards risk in investing in a person
rather than the equipment. He commended Mr. Rossi for his thorough
presentation and asked the board if we should have Tom come back after we
set up a term sheet. Mr. Miller advised it would benefit us to lay out all of the
terms and set up for next meeting.
Andy Ross made a motion to authorize staff to create a term
sheet for approval at the next meeting.
Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
IX. Budget
Mr. Dunne handed out a proposed budget for the board to vote on. He went
through the items and made a correction in the section that deals with 444
River Street. Mr. Miller explained that we are required by NYS to submit a
five year projected budget. If changes are needed, we can make budget
amendments. The chairman asked if we had a copy of the current balance
sheet on hand. Selena Skiba handed out the financials. Mr. Dunne also
noted that the redevelopment of the King Fuels site would be a future income
item in other development projects. Ken Zalewski asked at what point do we
try and create some revenue. Mr. Dunne advised that a lot of the assets are
tied up in real estate matters that will create revenue in the future. We do
have some income from the loans. Mr. Miller advised that Joe Mazzariello
was working on a 5 year cash flow analysis that will help us going forward.
Andy Ross made a motion to approve the budget.
Ken Zalewski seconded the motion, motion carried.
X. Executive Session
Mr. Miller advised that they had some items to discuss in executive session.
Hon. Ken Zalewski made a motion to enter into executive
session to discuss the proposed acquisition of real estate
and provide a litigation status update.
Andy Ross seconded the motion, motion carried.
Hon. Ken Zalewski made a motion to adjourn executive
session.
Bill Dunne seconded the motion, motion carried.
4
The meeting was adjourned at 9:56 a.m.
Hon. Ken Zalewski made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Andy Ross seconded the motion, motion carried.
5
Get email alerts for Troy
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.