Human Relation Commission Meeting
Regular MeetingUrbana, IL · June 2, 2020
Minutes
Minutes of an Informal Public Hearing
DATE: Tuesday, June 2, 2020
TIME: 5:30 pm
PLACE: 400 S. Vine Street, Urbana, IL
*Virtually via Zoom
INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING OF APPEAL TO
THE HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION
An informal public hearing pursuant to Urbana City Code Sections 12-82(d) and (e) regarding an
appeal of an initial determination of lack of jurisdiction in case number 001-05-20.
1. Call to Order and Roll Call
Hearing Body:
Peter Resnick (chair)
Marion Knight
Rizwan Uddin
Presenters:
James Simon (Officer)
Christopher Hansen (Complainant)
2. Chair’s Introduction
Chair Peter Resnick introduced the appeal. Mr. Resnick provided guidelines for the hearing and
gave an overview of the process that would take place.
3. Officer’s Statement of Reasons for Determination
James Simon gave a statement and provided reasons for his determination of no jurisdiction. Mr.
Simon cited instances from City code and City ordinances to support his determination of no
jurisdiction. He also provided additional resources and avenues available to the complainant that
he believes would have jurisdiction.
4. Complainant’s Statement of Objections to Determination
Christopher Hansen gave a statement and provided reasons for why he is pursuing an appeal of
the officer’s no jurisdiction ruling. Mr. Hansen cited instances from City code and City
ordinances to support his argument that the Human Relations Commission does have
jurisdiction on the matter in question.
5. Officer’s Reply
James Simon responded to the Complainant’s remarks.
6. Hearing Body Questions to the Presenters
Mr. Uddin asked Mr. Simon about other avenues of complaint. Mr. Simon responded by talking
about the Illinois Human Rights Commission and EEOC.
Persons with disabilities needing special services or accommodations for this meeting should contact the City
of Urbana's Americans with Disabilities Coordinator at 384-2466.
Mr. Resnick asked Mr. Simon about definitions in the ordinance, to which Mr. Simon replied
with his interpretations. Mr. Resnick asked Mr. Simon about how the ordinance might apply to
City workers, and Mr. Simon replied that it could not.
Mr. Resnick asked Mr. Hansen about how fines might apply in this case, to which Mr. Hansen
replied that they need not in this case. Mr. Resnick asked Mr. Hansen about definitions in the
ordinance. Mr. Hansen replied with his interpretations.
7. *Public Input
Tracy Chong shared her disappointment with the situation taking place and her disagreement
with the determination.
Vijal Patell shared his concern with conflicts in the City code and ordinance. He also shared his
disappointment with City staff actions.
Ron Kester shared his outrage and disappointment with City staff actions during this meeting.
8. Hearing Body Deliberations
Members of the hearing body discussed the matters presented.
9. Vote and Announcement of Hearing Body’s Decision
Members of the Hearing Body voted either jurisdiction or no jurisdiction in regards to whether
the Urbana Human Relations Commission should rule on the original complaint filed by the
complainant.
Marion Knight: No Jurisdiction
Rizwan Uddin: Jurisdiction
Peter Resnick: No Jurisdiction
The determination of the panel is no jurisdiction.
10. Adjournment
Respectfully submitted,
Tamra Jane Corbin
Recording Secretary
Persons with disabilities needing special services or accommodations for this meeting should contact the City of
Urbana's Americans with Disabilities Coordinator at 384-2466 or TTY at 384-2447.
Agenda
URBANA HUMAN RELATIONS
COMMISSION
DATE: Tuesday, June 2, 2020
TIME: 5:30 pm
PLACE: 400 S. Vine Street, Urbana, IL
*Virtually via Zoom
INFORMAL PUBLIC HEARING OF APPEAL TO
THE HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION
AGENDA
An informal public hearing pursuant to Urbana City Code Sections 12-82(d) and (e) regarding an
appeal of an initial determination of lack of jurisdiction in case number 001-05-20.
1. Call to Order and Roll Call
Hearing Body:
Peter Resnick (chair)
Marion Knight
Rizwan Uddin
Presenters:
James Simon (Officer)
Christopher Hansen (Complainant)
2. Chair’s Introduction
3. Officer’s Statement of Reasons for Determination
4. Complainant’s Statement of Objections to Determination
5. Officer’s Reply
6. Hearing Body Questions to the Presenters
7. *Public Input
8. Hearing Body Deliberations
9. Vote and Announcement of Hearing Body’s Decision
10. Adjournment
*Due to the Governor’s Stay at Home order, the Urbana City Council Chambers will be not
be open to the public during this meeting. For those wishing to provide public input, please
email your statement to tjcorbin@urbanaillinois.us by the start time on the date of the
meeting. Your statement will be read into the record per council public input rules. Public
input also may be provided via Zoom. Anyone can watch the meeting on streaming
services, UPTV, or attend virtually via Zoom. Additional instructions are attached.
Persons with disabilities needing special services or accommodations for this meeting should contact the City
of Urbana's Americans with Disabilities Coordinator at 384-2466.
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89314305979
Meeting ID: 893 1430 5979
One tap mobile
+13126266799,,89314305979# US (Chicago)
+16465588656,,89314305979# US (New York)
Dial by your location
+1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
+1 646 558 8656 US (New York)
+1 301 715 8592 US (Germantown)
+1 669 900 9128 US (San Jose)
+1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma)
+1 346 248 7799 US (Houston)
Meeting ID: 893 1430 5979
Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kcplgGsa4
Public Input and Viewing for Urbana City Council, Committee of the Whole and some Boards and
Commissions
Anyone can watch the meeting on streaming services, UPTV, or attend virtually via Zoom. The Zoom
session will be recorded as part of the record. We will not be monitoring or using the Chat window for
meetings. The Zoom meeting information is listed on the agenda.
Additional Instructions may be provided by the Chair.
Providing Public Input
Providing Public Input by e-mail:
We ask that if you possibly can, submit your public comments by email by the start of the meeting to the
email address listed on the agenda. These will be read per city council rules and time limits*. Email must
be received by the start of public input at the meeting and will only be taken during the public input
portion of the agenda.
Providing Public Input from a computer browser or the Zoom app on a mobile device:
· The link to join by computer is listed on the agenda.
· You do not need to install software on a computer to use Zoom. You can click “Join from your
browser.” It appears Zoom prefers for users to download and install their meeting client
software on your computer. Choose the option you are comfortable with and note, these may
be browser specific. There is a Zoom app for smartphones.
Persons with disabilities needing special services or accommodations for this meeting should contact the City of
Urbana's Americans with Disabilities Coordinator at 384-2466 or TTY at 384-2447.
· Make sure you have a microphone on your computer if you wish to speak. Please identify
yourself with first and last name in Zoom for the record if you wish to speak*. FCC Guidelines
will be followed.
· Please turn-off any sound from other sources such as UPTV or cable, as there will be a lag in the
audio if you are also watching the meeting. You should see the meeting video stream through
Zoom, see the staff presentation slides, and hear people talking.
· We will be muting participants except during public input, when they will be recognized to speak
after raising their hand (see the next bullet point). Video will remain off for all members of the
public, even while they are speaking.
· Per council rules you must identify yourself to provide public input with your first and last
name*. During Public Input, if you wish to speak, please “Raise your hand” using the option as
shown in the Participant window (if using the Phone App, this option is shown by touching your
name). When called on by the chair or host, you will be un-muted and you should state your
name for the record per city code*.
· You can find tutorials and help information here: https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-
us/articles/201362193-How-Do-I-Join-A-Meeting-
Providing Public Input by phone:
· Please turn-off the sound from watching the meeting on the TV or streaming service, as there
will be a lag in the audio. Join by calling the phone number shown in the agenda.
· Callers will then be asked to enter the Meeting ID number followed by the # key. The Meeting ID
number is listed on the agenda.
· All callers are muted by default.
· If you wish to speak, please “Raise your hand” by pressing *9 once - this toggles the raise/lower
hand option. When called on by the chair or host by your phone number, you will be un-muted
and you should state your name for the record per city code*. When you are done, the host will
“lower your hand” and mute you - there is no need to press any more buttons.
As a reminder, public input can be received and is encouraged before the meeting via email as listed
above. The video recording will be available on UPTV’s YouTube channel and via the Meetings Calendar
on the city’s website, usually by the following day at noon.
This is a work in progress, a learning situation for all involved, so we ask for your patience as we move
forward. We are unable to provide computer and technical assistance and will move forward during the
meeting as necessary. Thank you for your understanding in this difficult situation.
Two websites with some additional tips and tricks:
https://www.groovehq.com/blog/zoom-tips-and-tricks
https://www.colorado.edu/ocg/ocg-staff-resources/meeting-resources/zoom-meeting-tips-tricks
* Public Meetings - Ordinances No. 2011-05-033 & 2019-08-051, ILCS 120/2.06(g)
Persons with disabilities needing special services or accommodations for this meeting should contact the City of
Urbana's Americans with Disabilities Coordinator at 384-2466 or TTY at 384-2447.
Get email alerts for Urbana
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.