Board of Review

7725 W. North Avenue Wauwatosa, WI Wauwatosa, WI 53213 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final Thursday, September 11, 2025 8:30 AM Common Council Chambers CALL TO ORDER Vice Chairperson Walsh called the meeting to order at 8:32 AM. ROLL CALL Present 5 Member Pamela Stokke-Ceci Member Rosemary Fox Member Christopher Meuler Member Roger Walsh Alternate Member Lanre Abiola Excused 2 Member Kathy Ehley Alternate Member Alan Kesner PROCEDURAL HEARINGS FOR OBJECTORS WITH EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES REQUESTING A WAIVER OF THE REQUIRED 48-HOUR NOTICE OF INTENT TO FILE AN OBJECTION 1. 8:30 AM – Tax Key # 333-0104-000, Address: 2434 N 85th Street, 25-1442 Owner: Matthew Sato & Amanda Venhaus Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection due to the property owner's failure to fulfill the requirements of Rule 7(G) of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy . Second by Member Meuler. Motion carried 4-0. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Christopher Meuler Aye: 4 Fox, Meuler, Walsh, and Abiola Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 2. 9:00 AM – Tax Key # 345-0812-000, Address: 6135 Washington 25-1443 Circle, Owner: John H. & Georgia Cain Motion by Member Meuler to dismiss the objection due to the property owner's failure to fulfill the requirements of Rule 7(G) of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy . Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Christopher Meuler SECONDER: Lanre Abiola Aye: 4 Fox, Meuler, Walsh, and Abiola Page 1 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 3. 9:30 AM – Tax Key # 343-0552-000, Address: 1813 N 83rd Street, 25-1444 Owner: Audrey Hopper & Peter Templeton Motion by Member Abiola to dismiss the objection due to the property owner's failure to fulfill the requirements of Rule 7(G) of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy . Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Lanre Abiola SECONDER: Rosemary Fox Aye: 4 Fox, Meuler, Walsh, and Abiola Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 4. 10:00 AM – Tax Key # 345-0628-000, Address: 1850 N 68th Street, 25-1468 Owner: Mary Babor Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection due to the property owner's failure to fulfill the requirements of Rule 7(G) of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy . Second by Member Meuler. Motion carried 3-1 (Nay: Abiola). RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Christopher Meuler Aye: 3 Fox, Meuler, and Walsh Nay: 1 Abiola Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 5. 10:30 AM – Tax Key # 331-0500-000, Address: 2466 N 74th Street, 25-1490 Owner: Corey A. Double Motion by Member Meuler to accept the property owner's extraordinary circumstances and grant a waiver of the required 48-hour notice of intent to file an objection. Second by Member Fox. Motion failed 2-2 (Aye: Meuler, Fox. Nay: Abiola, Walsh). The objection is dismissed. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Christopher Meuler SECONDER: Rosemary Fox Aye: 2 Fox, and Meuler Nay: 2 Walsh, and Abiola Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 6. 11:00 AM – Tax Key # 256-0209-000, Address: 4076 Menomonee 25-1491 River Pkwy, Owner: John A. Selwitschka & Grace Santos-Selwitschka Motion by Member Abiola to accept the property owner's extraordinary circumstances and grant a waiver of the required 48-hour notice of intent to file an objection. Second by Member Meuler. Motion failed 2-2 (Aye: Abiola, Walsh. Nay: Fox, Meuler). The objection is dismissed. Page 2 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Lanre Abiola SECONDER: Christopher Meuler Aye: 2 Walsh, and Abiola Nay: 2 Fox, and Meuler Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 7. 11:30 AM – Tax Key # 345-0421-000, Address: 2230 N 64th Street, 25-1492 Owner: Michael Matthiesen Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection due to the property owner's failure to fulfill the requirements of Rule 7(G) of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy . Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Lanre Abiola Aye: 4 Fox, Meuler, Walsh, and Abiola Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner PROCEDURAL HEARINGS FOR OBJECTORS WITH INCOMPLETE AND/OR INACCURATE OBJECTION FORMS 1. 1:30 PM – Tax Key # 406-0076-000, Address: 7026 Grand Parkway, 25-1502 Owner: Brynn and Justin Dux Motion by Member Fox to accept the property owner's revisions to the objection form and grant a valuation hearing. Second by Member Walsh. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Roger Walsh Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola 2. 1:45 PM – Tax Key # 382-0576-000, Address: 641 N 77th Street, 25-1441 Owner: Jonathan P. & Erin C. Groth Motion by Member Walsh to accept the property owner's revisions to the objection form and grant a valuation hearing. Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Roger Walsh SECONDER: Rosemary Fox Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola Page 3 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 3. 2:00 PM – Tax Key # 383-0454-000, Address: 841 N 74th Street, 25-1440 Owner: Charles A. Worthington & Jeffry J. Albanese This objection was withdrawn. RESULT: WITHDRAWN 4. 2:15 PM – Tax Key # 408-0259-000, Address: 8817 Hawthorne 25-1496 Avenue, Owner: Judith A. Lueck Motion by Member Fox to accept the property owner's revisions to the objection form and grant a valuation hearing. Second by Member Walsh. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Roger Walsh Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola 5. 2:30 PM – Tax Key # 342-0095-000, Address: 1857 N 85th Street, 25-1497 Owner: Mark and Bridget Bullio Motion by Member Walsh to accept the property owner's revisions to the objection form and grant a valuation hearing. Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Roger Walsh SECONDER: Rosemary Fox Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola 6. 2:45 PM – Tax Key # 408-0324-000, Address: 145 N 86th Street, 25-1498 Owner: Paul Grinstead & Alicia J. Sprecher The Board determined this procedural hearing was not necessary . RESULT: NO ACTION TAKEN 7. 3:00 P.M. – Tax Key #376-0149-000, Address: 1248 N 119th Street, 25-1425 Owner: Mark Johnson Trust DTD 6/17/2016 – 50% Brian H Johnson Living Trust DTD 8/9/2023 – 50% Motion by Member Walsh to accept the property owner's revisions to the objection form and grant a valuation hearing. Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Roger Walsh SECONDER: Rosemary Fox Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola Page 4 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 8. 3:15 PM – Tax Key # 407-0013-000, Address: 8220 Rockway Place, 25-1503 Owner: Gregory G. Gillis Motion by Member Fox to deny the objection based on non-compliance with Rule 7 of the 2025 Board of Review Rules and Procedures Policy and the property owner's failure to appear for the procedural hearing. Second by Member Walsh. Motion carried 3-0. RESULT: DENIED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Roger Walsh Aye: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Fox, and Walsh Excused: 4 Ehley, Meuler, Kesner, and Abiola 9. 3:30 PM – Tax Key # 408-0199-000, Address: 222 N 89th Street, 25-1504 Owner: Kelsey and John McAuley This objector agreed to a stipulation with the City Assessor's Office. RESULT: NO ACTION TAKEN OTHER ITEMS 1. Objection forms and hearing for property owners who did not submit 25-1463 acceptable income and expense information pursuant to Wis. Stat. §70.47(7)(af) The following objections were dismissed pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7) (af): Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection of Mark T. Mertens & Laura L. Mertens Revocable Trust; Address: 8410 Watertown Plank Road; Parcel # 372-0042-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection of Mark T. Mertens & Laura L. Mertens Revocable Trust; Address: 8502 Watertown Plank Road ; Parcel # 372-0047-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection of Mark T. Mertens & Laura L. Mertens Revocable Trust; Address: 8516 Watertown Plank Road; Parcel # 372-0049-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection of Mark T. Mertens & Laura L. Mertens Revocable Trust; Address: 8528 Watertown Plank Road; Parcel # 372-0051-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Fox to dismiss the objection of Mark T. Mertens & Laura L. Mertens Revocable Trust; Address: 8510 Watertown Plank Road; Parcel # 372-0048-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Abiola. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Meuler to dismiss the objection of Tyler and Tamara Layne; Address: 12309 W Dearbourn Avenue; Parcel # 412-0040-007, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Meuler to dismiss the objection of Tyler and Tamara Layne; Address: 12301 W Page 5 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 Dearbourn Avenue; Parcel # 412-0040-006, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Meuler to dismiss the objection of Beramir LLC; Address: 929 N 123rd Street; Parcel # 377-0136-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Meuler to dismiss the objection of Beramir LLC; Address: 928 N 123rd Street; Parcel # 377-0135-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Abiola to dismiss the objection of M & I Holdings LLC; Address: 2276 N 94th Street; Parcel # 341-0001-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Abiola to dismiss the objection of Tadco Properties LLC; Address: 12101 W Bluemound Road; Parcel # 412-0001-001, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 4-0. Motion by Member Walsh to dismiss the objection of Gregory M. Simmert; Address: 7332 W State Street; Parcel # 370-0391-000, pursuant to the requirements in Wisconsin State Statute 70 .47(7)(af). Second by Member Fox. Motion carried 3-0. 2. Approval of stipulations 25-1494 The stipulations included the following properties: - 1253 Kavanaugh Place - 745 N 119th Street - 1055 N Perry Court - 915 N 75th Street - 922 N 76th Street - 926 N 76th Street - 652 N 68th Street - 1823 N 81st Street - 6327 W Lloyd Street - 6425 W Lloyd Street - 6335 W Lloyd Street - 1263 Martha Washington Drive - 1359 N 64th Street - 1705 N 69th Street - 4505 N 109th Street - 4714 N 100th Street - 12132 W Capitol Drive - 3140 N 124th Street - 2330 N 62nd Street - 6220 W North Avenue - 2641 N 70th Street - 1945 River Park Court RESULT: APPROVED MOVER: Rosemary Fox SECONDER: Lanre Abiola Aye: 4 Fox, Meuler, Walsh, and Abiola Page 6 of 7 Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final September 11, 2025 Excused: 3 Stokke-Ceci, Ehley, and Kesner 3. Action on any other legally allowed/required Board of Review matters 25-1493 RESULT: NO ACTION TAKEN 4. Schedule of future BOR dates 25-1495 The next Board of Review meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, September 16, at 8:30 AM. RESULT: NO ACTION TAKEN ADJOURNMENT Meeting adjourned at 3:17 PM. Page 7 of 7