Architectural Review Board - Design Review Guideline Update

AGENDA City of Williamsburg Architectural Review Board DESIGN REVIEW GUIDELINES UPDATE WORKSESSION #8 Monday, August 16, 2021 A meeting of the Architectural Review Board will be held Monday, August 16, 2021 in the Stryker Center, 412 N. Boundary Street commencing at 6:00 p.m. When invited by the Chairman, speakers should state their name and address before making brief comments. Page CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL OPEN FORUM DESIGN REVIEW GUIDELINES UPDATE Architectural Preservation District: AP-3 A. AP-3 - Draft 1 2 - 20 ADJOURNMENT Page 1 of 20  Chapter 5* --Architectural Chapter ArchitecturalPreservation PreservationDistrict District AP-1 AP-3 - DRAFT 1 ARCHITECTURAL PRESERVATION DISTRICT - (AP-3) This District contains neighborhoods that were constructed post World War II Colonial Revival and a more modern style dwelling which includes the Pinecrest, Capitol Court Crispus Attucks, and the Arts and Cultural District. The Arts and Cultural District is a subset of AP-3 and allows for more design freedom of paint colors, sign colors, and site elements to distinguish this area from other areas in the City. Specifically, Chapter ** windows (page **), Chapter **, acceptable colors (page **), and Signs Chapter **, Page ** describe guidelines uniquely applicable in the Arts and Cultural District. Guidelines for the construction of existing buildings/structures are found on pages 3-6. Guidelines for modifications to new buildings/structures are found on pages 13-16. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 1 Page 2 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 2 Page 3 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 EXISTING BUILDINGS - (AP-3) Preserving architectural features on the remaining historical buildings in the City is one of the principal goals of the Design Review Guidelines. Maintaining and repairing features such as siding, trim, doors, and windows is germane essential to that goal. Conservation is preferable to reconstruction because it preserves evidence of past building practices and construction techniques by retaining original materials. Original wood siding, trim, and architectural features should be retained and repaired on existing buildings whenever possible. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 3 Page 4 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 SIDING – (AP-3) • Wood siding and trim on buildings listed on or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (Appendix 1) must be replaced with wood siding and trim that matches or duplicates the existing material or product. • Wood siding and trim on buildings listed on the Cities Listing of Buildings 50 years old or older (Appendix 2) should be replaced with wood siding and trim that matches or duplicates the existing material or product. • Except for buildings listed on or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (Appendix 1), the Architectural Review Board may grant the following exceptions on a case-by-case basis for existing buildings: 1. If the original siding material is wood and it is covered with a synthetic material that cannot be replaced in kind because the siding material is no longer available in the market, replacement with other types of similar synthetic siding may be considered as follows, provided that the original wood material is not removed: a. Aluminum siding may be replaced with vinyl siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. b. Asbestos siding may be replaced with vinyl siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. 2. If the original siding material is a synthetic material and cannot be replaced in kind because the existing siding is no longer available in the market, replacement with horizontal wood siding or similar synthetic siding may be considered as follows: a. Aluminum siding may be replaced with vinyl or cementitious siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. b. Vinyl siding may be replaced with cementitious siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. c. Asbestos siding may be replaced with cementitious siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. d. Masonite siding or other hardboard sidings may be replaced with cementitious siding that resembles horizontal wood siding. 3. If vinyl siding is approved for use, it shall meet the following standards: Standard: ASTM D3679 is the accepted industry standard for quality. Thickness:A minimum of 0.042 inches is required for impact resistance and durability. Style: A beaded siding with a minimum of 6.5 inches of exposure is required. Color: White, ivory, and other soft, colonial-style colors are recommended. Applicants must provide specifications of their vinyl siding and trim details with their application. The specifications must address the items listed above. When applying vinyl siding over existing siding, it is important to consider retaining trim details with their applications. • Engineered wood products may be considered on a case-by-case basis. • Synthetic trim will be considered on a case-by-case basis. • For guidance on rehabbing older buildings, see Chapter ** Rehabilitation. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 4 Page 5 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 WINDOWS, STORMS, AND SHUTTERS - (AP-3) • Existing wood windows should be retained and repaired for buildings located in AP-3. • If restoration is not possible, then copies of the original window matching the existing sash and frames with duplicates in wood following the early form and details will be required. • Other window types may be replaced with windows that are allowed in AP-3 for new buildings or additions on a case- by-case basis. • Storm windows should be full view and constructed of wood or aluminum. • An energy panel (interior storms) is an alternative to exterior storms and does not require approval from the Architectural Review Board. • Operable wooden shutters, painted, sized to fit the opening, must be retained and repaired. • If restoration of existing shutters is not possible, then copies of the original wood shutter must be installed sized to fit the opening with appropriate hardware. Vinyl and metal shutters are not allowed. • High-quality composite material shutters that resemble original shutters may be approved on a case-by-case basis. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 5 Page 6 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 DECKS - (AP-3) See Section 21-607 of the Zoning Ordinance for setback encroachments. • Decks are not historic features for buildings prior to World War II and are therefore not acceptable in a front yard or if they are visible from a public street. • More appropriate outdoor seating areas for backyards of traditional architecture styles are stone or brick terraces, patios, or pergolas designed to be compatible with the architectural style of the building. • Unpainted, pressure-treated decks are not acceptable. • If visible from a public street, they must be compatible with the building and contain rails that are appropriate for the architectural style of the building. • For buildings constructed after World War II, decks, may be acceptable on a rear elevation if the design is compatible with the architectural style of the building. OTHER ELEMENTS - (AP-3) • Existing roofing material should be repaired or replaced in kind. • Wood shingles, slate, architectural grade fiberglass shingles, high-quality synthetic slate, textured concrete shingles, and standing seam metal roofs are permitted. • Material replacement in kind with no change to style of form does not require approval from the Architectural Review Board. • Any change in materials on the exterior requires approval from the Architectural Review Board. • Decks are not historic features for buildings prior to World War II and are therefore not acceptable in a front yard or if they are visible from a public street. • More appropriate outdoor seating areas for backyards of traditional architecture styles are stone or brick terraces, patios or pergolas designed to be compatible with the architectural style of the building. • Unpainted, pressure-treated decks are not acceptable. • If visible from a public street they must be compatible with building and contain rails that are appropriate for the architectural style of the building. • For buildings constructed after World War II decks may be acceptable on a rear elevation if the design is compatible with the architectural style of the building. • For other elements and color schemes not listed in this section, see New Buildings and Additions in the AP-3 above. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 6 Page 7 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 SOLAR FACILITIES - (AP-3) • Only facilities located on the roof are allowed. • Facilities shall not be visible from the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area (CW). • The use of solar roof tiles, laminates, glazing, and other technologies requiring the removal of intact historic fabric or permanently altering or damaging such fabric should be avoided. • Solar panels should not project greater than 12 inches above the existing roof surface and should not be visible above the roof-line of a primary facade. • Solar panels and their support structures should be compatible with the existing roof color. • Consider placing solar panels on an existing, non‐historic addition or accessory structure, thereby minimizing the impact of solar installation on the significant features of the historic resource’s significant features and as well as specifically protecting historic fabric against alteration. • To the greatest extent possible, avoid placing solar panels on street‐facing walls or roofs, including those facing side streets. Installations below and behind parapet walls and dormers or on rear‐facing roofs are encouraged. • Solar panels should not require alterations to significant or character‐defining features of a historic resource, such as altering existing roof lines or dormers. Avoid installations that obstruct views of significant architectural features, such as overlaying windows or decorative detailing. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 7 Page 8 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 NEW BUILDINGS AND ADDITIONS - (AP-3) New designs should contribute to existing buildings located in the district. Additions and alterations should be compatible with existing building designs with the use of high-quality building materials. • New buildings and additions should be constructed of brick, horizontal wood siding, vinyl, aluminum, stucco, or cementitious siding. Wood shingles may be appropriate depending on the specific design. • If vinyl siding is approved for use, it shall meet the following standards: Standard: ASTM D3679 is the accepted industry standard for quality. Thickness: A minimum of 0.042 inches is required for impact resistance and durability. Style: A beaded siding with a minimum of 6.5 inches of exposure is required. Color: White, ivory, and other soft, colonial-style colors are recommended. Applicants must provide specifications of their vinyl siding and trim details with their application. The specifications must address the items listed above. When applying vinyl siding over existing siding, it is important to consider retaining trim details with their applications. • Engineer wood products may be consdered on a case-by-case basis. • Materials such as Metal siding, tiled-faced or ceramic-faced masonry units, and synthetic stucco such as EFIS are not allowed. • Wood siding should be horizontal with a six to eight-inch exposure. • Side and rear elevations should relate to the design elements and materials of the front elevation. • Any wall should be built of not more than two materials, and those materials should change along a horizontals line such as a floor line or gable end. The heavier material, such as brick, should always be below the lighter material, such as wood. • Small additions may be constructed with the same type of siding that is on the building, provided it matches the existing siding material in color, size, and thickness. • Solid synthetic trim may be allowed on a case-by-case basis. • All wood siding, wood shingles, and wood trim shall be sealed with paint or an opaque stain. • Mortar used for brick should be buff or gray. White mortar is not recommended. Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 8 Page 9 of 20  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 DOORS - (AP-3) • Entrance doors should be wood or fiberglass with panels or some variation thereof. Windows, sidelights, and transoms in entrance doors are permitted, provided that they are proportioned and appropriate to the specific style of the building. • Flush doors with applied trim are not permitted. • Garage doors, utility doors, and service doors should be painted wood, steel, aluminum, or fiberglass and should correspond with the style of the building. For purposes of this section, utility and service doors are not located on the front of the structure. • Storm doors should be made of painted wood or aluminum. Storm doors should relate to the architectural character of the entrance. • Screen doors should be made of wood or aluminum with full view, shuttered, or appropriate for the specific style of the building. Page 10 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 9  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 PORCHES, DECKS, TERRACES, STOOPS, AND RAILS - (AP-3) • Porches with a narrow frontage should be no less than six feet deep, while porches with a wide frontage should be at least eight feet deep. • Porches and stoops should be constructed of wood or brick and contain appropriate-sized columns and rails for the design. • Terraces may be constructed using masonry elements that are consistent with the structure. • Vinyl and other synthetic materials are not acceptable, except that Solid synthetic materials will be considered on a case-by-case basis. Samples of proposed materials must be submitted with the application. • Materials for railings may be wood, wrought iron, steel, or aluminum and should be designed to complement the architectural design of the building. Solid synthetic rails will be considered on a case-by-case basis. • Face nailed balusters to a bottom and top rail are not acceptable. • Screened porches should be located on the side or rear of the building. • Columns are preferred to be Tuscan or Doric orders, although other types exist within the area. When used, columns should have correct proportions and profiles as described in The American Vignola and other traditional pattern books. • Columns maybe made of wood, although certain grades of high-quality fiberglass columns and cellular PVC are acceptable. • All posts should be at least five inches in the least dimension. • Wood columns and posts should be sealed with paint or opaque stain. • Modern deck designs are not appropriate in a front yard or if visible from a public street. • Stoops at secondary entrances should be made of wood, brick, or concrete. If made of concrete, the sidewalls and stair risers should be faced with brick. Page 11 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 10  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 WINDOWS, STORMS, SHUTTERS, AND AWNINGS - (AP-3) Windows contribute to the façade of a building and will be evaluated on (1) the pattern of the openings and their size; (2) proportions of the frame and sash; (3) configuration of window panes; (4) muntin profiles; (5) material; (6) paint color; (7) characteristics of the glass; and (8) details or decorative elements. • Wood, vinyl-clad wood, or pre-finished aluminum-clad wood windows are allowed. • High-quality synthetic windows may be approved on a case-by-case basis. Applicants must provide the AAMA/WDMA/CAS101/I.S.2/A440-11 certification reference, manufacturer’s warranty (minimum 15-year), local examples of existing installation with a duration of at least 5 years, and how long the manufacturer has been in business (recommended length of business is at least as long as the warranty period). • Windows in the Arts and Cultural District must have muntins on the exterior. • Windows located in AP-3 outside of the Arts and Cultural District may have muntins on the interior or exterior of the glass. • Windows should be rectangular single, double, or triple hung or operable casement type. • Semi-circular, circular, or hexagonal windows are permitted but with minimal application and should be consistent with the architectural character of the building. • Windows on the ground floor should be the same proportion but slightly larger than windows on upper floors. • Window openings in upper floors should be centered directly over openings in the ground floor whenever possible. • Openings in gable ends should be symmetrical. • Window openings should be at least three feet from building corners. • Total glazed area on the street frontage should not exceed 30 percent of the total surface. • Storm windows should be full view and constructed of wood or aluminum. • An energy panel (interior storms) is an alternative to exterior storms and does not require approval from the Architectural Review Board. • Shutters if proposed must be painted may be wood, vinyl, or high-quality composite shutters. If used, they must be that are sized to fit the opening with appropriate hardware. • Metal shutters are not allowed. • Shutters nailed affixed to the side of a building are not allowed. • Awnings, if used, must be made of fabric with side panels to cover the undercarriage. Vinyl and metal awnings are not allowed. Page 12 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 11  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 ROOFS - (AP-3) The types of wood-framed roofs typically fall into categories of symmetrical gables, gambrels, or hip roofs. Gables are the most prevalent. One-story primary roofs should have slopes not less than 7:12 and no steeper than 14:12. Two-story primary roofs may be as low as 4:12 and no steeper than 14:12. Secondary roofs may have slopes less than 7:12 depending on the material used (i.e., metal roof over porches can be less than 7:12; whereas a shingle roof should be not less than 7:12). On residential structures, flat roofs should be used only as occupiable areas directly accessible from the outdoors. These must-have appropriate parapets and railings. • Wood shingles, slate, architectural grade fiberglass shingles, metal shingles, high-quality synthetic slate, textured concrete shingles, and standing seam metal roofs are permitted. High-quality synthetic slate roofs must meet the following minimum standards: Impact UL 2218-Class 4, Accelerated Weathering ASTM 4798–little or no color changes, and Freeze- thaw ICC-ES Acceptance Criteria ACO7 Section 4.9–no crazing, cracking, or other adverse surface changes, which must be provided with the application. • Shiny metal roofs, exposed aluminum or exposed galvanized metal roofs, ceramic or synthetic ceramic roofing tiles, stamped metal decorative roofing panels, flat roofs, plastic, vinyl or other synthetic types of roofs are not permitted. • Metal roofs are recommended may be appropriate for porch roofs or ancillary elements and should be copper or gavalume type. Other colors may be acceptable on a case-by-case basis. • Non-glossy colored anodized metal roofs should be gray, black, brown, dark green, or other earth tones. Flashing may be copper, vinyl, or anodized aluminum. • Copper roofs, gutters, and flashing should not be painted or sealed but should be permitted to age naturally. • Gable roof ends should have a minimum overhang of 12 inches. • Steep gable roofs like the “Swiss Chalet” shall not be used (pitches in excess of 14:12). • Single plane pitch roofs, i.e., shed roofs for houses, shall not be used on the main house but can be used on wings. • Roof penetrations should be on the rear slope of roofs and painted to match the color of the roof. Skylights or solar panels should be mounted on the rear slope of the roof, colored to match the roof, and not be visible from the street. • Dormers should have gabled, hipped, or shed roofs. • Shiny metal roof vents, fireplace stacks, plumbing vents, or other pipes are not acceptable. • Gutters and downspouts should be made of copper or aluminum and may be half-round or ogee. Where gutters are not used, it is recommended that brick, concrete, or gravel be placed at the drip line. Page 13 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 12  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 SOLAR FACILITIES - (AP-3) • Only facilities located on the roof are allowed. • Facilities shall not be visible from the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area (CW). • The use of solar roof tiles, laminates, glazing, and other technologies requiring the removal of intact historic fabric or permanently altering or damaging such fabric should be avoided. • Solar panels should not project greater than 12 inches above the existing roof surface and should not be visible above the roof-line of a primary facade. • Solar panels and their support structures should be compatible with the existing roof color. • Consider placing solar panels on an existing, non‐historic addition or accessory structure, thereby minimizing the impact of solar installation on the significant features of the historic resource’s significant features and as well as specifically protecting historic fabric against alteration. • To the greatest extent possible, avoid placing solar panels on street‐facing walls or roofs, including those facing side streets. Installations below and behind parapet walls and dormers or on rear‐facing roofs are encouraged. • Solar panels should not require alterations to significant or character‐defining features of a historic resource, such as altering existing roof lines or dormers. Avoid installations that obstruct views of significant architectural features, such as overlaying windows or decorative detailing. CHIMNEYS - (AP-3) • Chimneys can be used but are not required. They should be constructed of brick (unpainted) or, if constructed with the same material as the siding of the building, painted to match the building. • Stucco is not permitted. • Chimneys should be capped to conceal spark arresters. • Primary chimneys should be rectilinear in design and should have a corbelled termination in keeping with existing types. Page 14 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 13  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 OUTBUILDINGS - (AP-3) • Outbuildings must meet the same criteria (i.e., walls, openings, roof, etc.) as noted above for the main building. • Metal outbuildings are not permitted. FENCES - (AP-3) • Wood, aluminum, and wrought iron fences that are in keeping with a residential scale are permitted. The maximum height allowed for fences located in a front yard is four feet, with up to six feet being allowed for a side or rear yard. • Solid synthetic materials may be considered on a case by case basis. • Salt-treated wooden fences must be painted or stained. • Chain-link, wire, plastic, and vinyl fences are not permitted. • The finished side must face the street and/or adjoining properties. • Fences should contribute to the site’s character and not detract from the site’s principal architectural features and should be compatible with adjacent sites. • Fences that disrupt the harmony of the streetscape by breaking up established architectural rhythms are discouraged. Page 15 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 14  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 SITE ELEMENTS, SITING AND LANDSCAPE FEATURES – (AP-3) • Site elements should contribute to the site’s character and not detract from the site’s principal architectural features and should be compatible with adjacent sites. • Mechanical equipment and trash facilities should be located in a side or rear yard and screened with a fence which must be stained or painted to match the building. • Landscape features above grade, but less than three feet in height may be constructed of timber, brick, or stone. • Retaining walls (three feet or greater), if visible from the street, shall be constructed of brick. Retaining walls not visible from the street may be constructed of brick, stone, block, timber, or smooth finished concrete. If rails are required, they should be constructed of wrought iron or aluminum and colored to blend in with the building. • Site furnishings such as tables, chairs, benches, planters, flower pots, light poles, trash containers, bike racks, and the like similar furnishings for commercial properties, must be submitted and approved by the Board on a case-by-case basis Single- family residential site furnishings do not require approval from the Board. SMALL CELL WIRELESS FACILITIES-(AP-3) • Facilities located on the interior of a building are permitted. Facilities not visible from the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area (CW) or from a public right-of-way may be allowed if appearance and screening requirements are designed as outlined in the Design Review Guidelines. Co-location on utility poles may be permitted if appearance and screening requirements are designed as outlined in the Design Review Guidelines. • Facilities shall not be visible from the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area (CW) or a public right-of-way. Facilities shall be painted the same color as the structure for facilities affixed to the exterior of a building. All surfaces must contain a matte finish. Co-location on utility poles on private property must be painted to match the utility pole color. No shiny or reflective surfaces shall be allowed. • Screening may be required for facilities. If required, screening shall match the existing building material. If there is no existing building, the facility must be screened with a wooden privacy fence not to exceed six feet in height. Salt-treated wooden fences must be painted or stained with the finished side of the fence facing the street and/or adjacent properties. Page 16 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 15  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 Paint - (AP-3) • Painted siding and trim should be limited to two colors from the approved color palette unless additional colors are approved by the Architectural Review Board on a case-by-case basis. A third color may be used for shutters and doors. • Buildings located in the Arts and Cultural District will allow a wider range of colors and the total number of colors to allow flexibility and latitude in design. • Additional paint colors from the approved color palette may be approved on a case-by-case basis. • Brick that is bright red, orangish-red, pink, light red, or other colors may not be acceptable. Brick color should be a through-the-body color. • Siding that is pink, Pink siding, bright silver, red, bright green, or blue, or colors that are visually out of character for the area and architectural style are not acceptable. • Wood fences and decks must be painted or stained if this is necessary to compliment the site or is required for maintenance of to maintain the materials. • If colors are proposed that are not from the approved color palette; they may be approved by the Architectural Review Board on a case-by-case basis. Specific color chips or samples to include the color name must be submitted with the application. • Existing single-family dwellings or commercial buildings may duplicate or match existing color schemes without approval from the Architectural Review Board. • Any new color scheme for single-family dwellings that are proposed to be applied to already painted surfaces and which are comprised of no more than three colors as stated above from the Benjamin Moore Colonial Williamsburg color palette. • Any new color schemes for commercial buildings must be approved by the Architectural Review Board. New color schemes should respect the architectural style of the building and the colors of existing signage for any business on the property. Page 17 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 16  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 ACCEPTABLE COLORS FOR SIDING, DOORS, SHUTTERS, TRIM, AND WINDOWS - (AP-3) Buildings shall be stained or sealed with a natural earth tone or painted using colors from the following Benjamin Moore Williamsburg color palette. These colors are approved for use on the entire structure. White and Tan Color Range Harwood Putty CW-5 Capitol White CW-10 Parish White CW-15 Geddy White CW-20 Williamsburg Stone CW-25 Market Square Shell CW-30 Palace Tan CW-35 Lime White CW-95 Prentis Cream CW-100 Bracken Cream CW-105 Cornice Tan CW-115 Bracken Biscuit CW-120 Brush Beige CW-125 Coffeehouse Tan CW-130 Timson Sand CW-140 Brick House Tan CW-145 Randolph Bisque CW-185 Raleigh Tan CW-190 Chowning’s Tan CW-195 Byrd Beige CW- 365 Wythe Tan CW-415 Bruton White CW-710 Brown and Black Color Range Raleigh Sorrell CW-135 Dixon Brown CW-160 Coffeehouse Chocolate CW-165 Tarpley Brown CW-170 Reid Brown CW-260 Charlton Brown CW-265 Lampblack CW-695 Gray Color Range Tavern Gray CW-40 York Gray CW-45 Tyler Gray CW-50 Finnie Gray CW-55 Cole Stone CW-60 Randolph Stone CW-75 Carter Gray CW-80 Tavern Charcoal CW-90 Slate CW-700 Tucker Gray CW-705 Bone Black CW-715 Green Color Range Timson Green CW-470 Bassett Hall Green CW-480 Levingston Green CW-490 Waller Green CW-510 Red Color Range Carriage Red CW-250 Palace Arms Red CW-255 Nicholson Red CW-270 Blue Color Range Wetherburn’s Blue CW-580 Apollo Blue CW-645 Chiswell Blue CW-660 Yellow and Gold Color Range Ludwell White CW-275 Sweeney Yellow CW-370 Tavern Ochre CW-375 Massicot CW-380 Coffeehouse Ochre CW-385 Bryan Ochre CW-390 Governor’s Gold CW-395 Chamber Yellow CW-410 Wythe Gold CW-420 Scrivener Gold CW-430 Everard Gold CW-435 Page 18 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 17  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 ACCEPTABLE DOOR, SHUTTER, TRIM, AND WINDOW COLORS- (AP-2) These colors are acceptable for limited use and are not allowed for the body or siding of a structure. White and Tan Color Range Calcite CW-110 Franklin White CW-200 Galt Peach CW-210 Brown and Black Color Range Everard Coffee CW-150 Revolutionary Storm CW-155 Tucker Chocolate CW-175 Bucktrout Brown CW-180 Walnut CW-240 Mopboard Black CW-680 Bone Black CW-715 Gray Color Range Gunsmith Gray CW-65 Pelham Gray CW-70 Randolph Gray CW-85 Powell Smokehouse CW-360 Pearl CW-640 Powell Gray CW-665 Ambler Slate CW-685 Bracken Slate CW-690 Geddy Gray CW-720 Green Color Range Gloucester Green CW-440 Burwell Green CW-445 Greenhow Moss CW-450 Palmer Green CW-475 Burgess Green CW-485 Russell Green CW-495 Nicholson Green CW-500 Windsor Green CW-505 Palace Green CW-520 Raleigh Green CW-525 Colonial Verdigris CW-530 Buffet Green CW-535 Goodwin Green CW-555 Red Color Range St. George Red CW-245 Cochineal Red CW-330 Blue Color Range Everard Blue CW-575 Washington Blue CW-630 Brush Blue CW-675 Yellow and Gold Color Range Moir Gold CW-280 Gamboge CW-285 English Ochre CW-290 Damask Yellow CW-400 Page 19 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 18  Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 - DRAFT 1 DISCUSSION POINTS - Changes are shown in red Page 5 - Discussion of replacement windows in AP-3 Page 15 - Consideration of other paint colors in AP-3; this has been removed in other districts. Page 16 - Discussion of retaining wall materials; this has been removed in other districts. Page 20 of 20 Design Review Guidelines Chapter * - Architectural Preservation District AP-3 Page 19