Sustainability Commission
Regular MeetingAlbany, NY · January 5, 2023
Minutes
Sustainability Advisory Committee
Minutes of Jan. 5, 2023 Meeting
Attending: A quorum was present, with the following in attendance.
Appointed Members City Officials
Daniel Kirk-Davidoff (chair) Frank Zeoli
David Hochfelder (recording) Joseph Coffey
Scott Kellogg Poulomi Sen
Andre Lake Michelle Rogat
Tina Lieberman Jason West
Violetta DeRosa Bill Trudeau
Randy Milano
Emma Morse
Chris Cech (non-voting)
Regular Business
Daniel Kirk-Davidoff called the meeting to order at 6:07.
Upon motion duly seconded, the Committee unanimously approved the
minutes of the Dec. 1, 2022 meeting.
No public comments were offered.
New Business
Motion to approve Memo on Climate Plan Recommendation Process.
Upon motion duly seconded, the Committee unanimously approved the
memo.
Motion to approve Letter to Governor Hochul in support of the Bigger
Better Bottle Bill. No vote was taken, but the Committee passed the
document on for review by the Department of General Services and
Corporation Counsel. Several members expressed hope that the letter
would arrive at the Governor’s office in time for her to include it in her
proposed budget and budget message.
Posting for interns wanted. The Committee discussed particular needs for
interns, and how to obtain them from area colleges.
Preparations for Sustainability Tent at Tulip Fest. The Committee
discussed the nature and location of the Sustainability Tent.
o Some members noted that the location of the tent last year was not
very visible, which lowered attendance by the public.
o Members noted that this is the 75th Tulip Fest and that Albany’s
sister city in the Netherlands, Nijmegen, will be sending
representatives, and that Nijmegen has an excellent sustainability
track record.
o Some members suggested that anyone interested in helping with
preparations should meet in the near future.
Annual Review Status. Daniel Kirk-Davidoff reported that Gabriella
Cebada Mora will shortly complete the 2021 annual review for transmittal
to the Mayor and Common Council.
Q&A for Department and Subcommittee Heads on Basis of their
Submitted Reports. Some discussion took place on these reports.
Proposed Revised Law. Since this item was not on the meeting agenda,
no vote was taken on this matter. A vote will likely occur during the Feb.
2023 meeting.
Upcoming Events, calls for Volunteers, call for new Members.
Committee members discussed the need for volunteers on subcommittees,
and the relationship between subcommittees and the Sustainability
Advisory Committee generally.
A discussion took place about the relative merits of standing
subcommittees and ad-hoc, task-oriented subcommittees.
The Committee discussed the relative merits of the SAC meeting monthly
or every two months, with alternate months set aside for subcommittee
meetings.
Some members suggested that presentations at neighborhood
associations might generate more volunteers.
Upon motion duly seconded, the Committee voted unanimously to adjourn at
7:20 PM.
The next SAC meeting is Thursday, Feb. 2, 2023 at 6:00 PM at City Hall.
Respectfully submitted,
Dave Hochfelder
Agenda
Sustainability Advisory Committee
MEETING AGENDA
Thursday, January 5, 2023
6:00 PM-7:30 PM
In Person, Albany City Hall
.
Meeting notice will be posted on the Sustainability Advisory Committee webpage at
https://www.albanyny.gov/342/Sustainability-Advisory-Committee,
the Sustainable Albany Facebook page and Albany Office of Sustainability Facebook page.
Meeting will be livestreamed via Facebook.
Advance questions/comments from the public can be sent via Facebook message or emailed to:
Sustainability@albanyny.gov
● Regular Business – 10 minutes
o Call to Order and roll call – Commissioners, please send designee if
unable to attend
o Review/Approval of December 1, 2022 minutes
o Public Comment Period (Approx. 3 minutes per comment)
● New Business –70 minutes
o (10 minutes) Motion to approve Memo on Climate Plan Recommendation
Process (attached, see next page).
o (10 minutes) Motion to approve Letter to Governor in support of Bigger
Better Bottle Bill (attached, see next page).
o (5 minutes) Posting for interns wanted (we need one at least for outreach)
o (10 minutes) preparing for Sustainability Tent at 75th Anniversary of Tulip
Fest
o (5 minutes) Annual Review Status
o (15 min) Q&A for Department and Subcommittee Heads on Basis of their
Submitted Reports
● Upcoming events, calls for Volunteers, call for new Members
● Adjourn
Next meeting –Thurs. Febuary 2, 2023 at 6 pm.
Sustainability Advisory Committee
CLIMATE ACTION POLICY PLANNING
January 5, 2023
Dear Mayor Sheehan, President Ellis, and members of the Common Council,
The Sustainability Advisory Committee has initiated a process to develop a series of
recommended steps that will align the City of Albany with New York State’s climate policy,
taking advantage of available State and Federal programs designed to encourage such actions,
while attracting investment from private organizations in clean energy and infrastructure
modernization.
We are confident that our research will help inform an updated climate action planning process.
We are recommending the City seek funding to develop a revised Climate Action Plan through
round seven of the NY Department of Environmental Conservation’s Climate Smart
Communities program, expected to be announced in February of 2023. Our recommendations
will be grounded in research and formulated to ensure that the proposed steps are consistent with
principles of environmental justice. We expect to research the following topics to put the City of
Albany on a path towards near-zero carbon dioxide emissions by mid-century:
1. Preparation for enforcement of updated building codes that will require substantially improved
energy efficiency.
2. Setting a deadline after which all new buildings in the City must be constructed without
reliance on combustion of fossil fuels for heating.
3. Supporting development of a plan to convert existing buildings to non-fossil-fuel-based
heating, contingent on available funding.
4. Accelerated deployment of electric vehicle charging infrastructure.
5. Sourcing increasing amounts of renewable energy for city operations, as well as business and
residential use.
6. Climate change adaptation and resilience initiatives including but not limited to reducing heat
stress.
7. Reducing methane emissions by promoting reduction of food waste and increased composting
of food scraps.
8. Encouraging local food production, particularly in low-income communities, to provide an
affordable supply of nutrient-dense foods in the face of an unstable climate.
Thank you for your consideration and leadership in this area.
Sincerely,
Daniel Kirk-Davidoff, Chair
On behalf of the Sustainability Advisory Committee
December 1, 2022
The Honorable Kathy Hochul
Governor of New York
NYS State Capital Bldg.
Albany, NY 12224
Dear Governor Hochul,
As Mayor and Commissioner of the Department of General Services for the City of Albany, we are
writing to express our strong support for updating New York’s Returnable Container Act, commonly
known as the ‘Bottle Bill.’ We believe it is time to modernize the law to include popular non-
carbonated beverages, wine, spirits, and hard cider. Expanding the type of beverages in the Bottle Bill
deposit program will result in billions of bottles being diverted from NYS landfills and incinerators. A
recent national report found that redemption rates are estimated to increase up to 90% if the expansion
of beverage types is coupled with an increase of the redeemable deposit value to a dime.
Modernizing the Bottle Bill is an economic and environmental justice issue. A Bigger, Better Bottle
Bill will further reduce pollution, especially plastic pollution, all while lifting up workers in the
recycling and redemption industry. It will help economically disadvantaged residents in Albany and
the rest of the state who rely on collecting redemption containers to supplement their income.
Crucially, expansion will lower the cost burden of recycling on municipal governments like ours – and
our taxpaying residents - by reducing the volume of glass and plastics that we must pay to process in
the local materials recycling facility. It will also reduce the amount of non-recycled glass and plastic
that ends up in our near-capacity landfill.
There are two important steps needed to modernize the current 40-year-old Bottle Bill and increase
New York’s recycling rate:
Expand the number of beverage containers covered by the Bottle Bill. New York would not be the
first state to include non-carbonated beverages, wine, and liquor. Maine’s Bottle Deposit Law includes
all containers covered in New York’s existing Bottle Bill plus wine, spirits, hard cider, and most non-
carbonated beverages such as lemonade and iced tea. Maine has a 5-cent deposit for all beverages,
except wine and liquor, which have a 15-cent deposit. Other states with Bottle Deposit Laws that
include non-carbonated beverages include Connecticut, California, and Oregon.
Increase the amount of the deposit to a dime. The impact of the nickel deposit that was approved in
1982 has eroded over time. A mere inflation update would likely make that deposit nearly fifteen cents.
2
To ensure that those who wish to redeem their deposits can easily do so, a portion of the additional
revenues collected by the state should be used to ensure better compliance and enhance access to
redemption entities.
There are three very important reasons to support the updating of the Bottle Bill. A Bigger, Better
Bottle Bill will:
1. increase New York’s recycling rates and reduce litter in both low-income and affluent
communities.
2. reduce municipalities' waste burden and their solid waste disposal and recycling expenses.
3. stimulate job creation, benefit redemption center workers and provide increased income to
those who most need it.
We urge your support for this important environmental and economic justice initiative. Including the
Bigger, Better Bottle Bill in your FY 2023-2024 Executive Budget will assist Albany and other cities
in New York State to reduce litter, enhance redemption recycling, reduce the cost burden of rising
recycling processing rates, create jobs and provide income to disadvantaged communities.
Sincerely,
Kathy M. Sheehan Sergio Panunzio
Mayor, City of Albany Commissioner, Albany Dept. of General Services
Get email alerts for Albany
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.