Urban Design Commission
Regular MeetingAnchorage, AK · November 18, 2020
Minutes
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION
Assembly Chambers
Z.J. Loussac Library
3600 Denali Street
Anchorage, Alaska
MINUTES OF
November 18, 2020
6:30 PM
Due to COVID-19, this meeting was conducted virtually.
A. ROLL CALL
Present Barbara Cash, Edith McKee, Melissa Morse, Monica Sullivan, Jerry
Winchester, Arthur Clark, Nichole Rehm
Excused Carla Baxley
Staff Ryan Yelle
B. MINUTES
1. Wednesday, October 14, 2020
COMMISSIONER CLARK moved to approve the minutes. VICE CHAIR WINCHESTER
seconded.
AYE: Clark, Cash, McKee, Winchester, Morse, Sullivan, Rehm
NAY: None
PASSED
C. SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS / EXECUTIVE SESSIONS
1. Disclosures - None
D. CONSENT AGENDA - None
1. Resolutions for Approval
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION MEETING
November 18, 2020 Page 2 of 4
2. Site / Landscape Plan Approval
3. Other
E. UNFINISHED BUSINESS AND ACTIONS OF PUBLIC HEARINGS – None
F. REGULAR AGENDA - None
1. Resolutions for Approval
2. Site / Landscape Plan Approval
3. Other
G. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. CASE: 2020-0132 (RY)
PETITIONER: Jack Pomerantz
REQUEST: Variance from AMC 21.07.080E.2, Parking Lot Landscaping
Requirements to allow the existing landscaping (meeting the standard of
site enhancement landscaping) and drainage facilities along W. 19th Ave to
remain instead of L1 Visual Enhancement Landscaping; and a variance
from AMC 21.05.040A.3.d. Parking and Setbacks to allow off-street parking
spaces and loading areas to be placed within required setbacks.
RYAN YELLE presented the staff report and recommendations on behalf of the
Municipality's Planning Department.
CRAIG BENNETT with S4 Group represented the petitioner.
CHAIR REHM opened the hearing to public testimony. There was no public testimony.
MR. BENNETT provided rebuttal testimony.
CHAIR REHM closed the public hearing.
COMMISSIONER MORSE moved in Case 2020-0132 to approve variances from AMC
21.07.080E. 2., Parking Lot Landscaping Requirements and AMC 21.05.040A.3.d, Parking and
Setbacks, subject to Conditions 1 and 2. VICE CHAIR WINCHESTER seconded.
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION MEETING
November 18, 2020 Page 3 of 4
COMMISSIONER MORSE thanked the petitioner for their patience in dealing with the technical
difficulties that come with these online meetings. She stated the following findings:
1. The requirements of this variance are to meet all approval criteria of
AMC 21.03.240G. All standards were met.
2. The project is a great reuse in the center of the city.
3. The point of the Urban Design Commission is to find a way to allow the city to
continue and grow and refill these empty spaces.
4. It is a well-rounded project for the municipality.
VICE CHAIR WINCHESTER will be supporting the motion for the following reasons:
1. He finds that with these irregular lots and trying to accommodate all the various code
requirements is the reason we have this variance process, and should be reasonable. He
thinks this is a reasonable interpretation.
2. Staff did a great job in finding that all approval criteria standards were met.
3. With regard to Standard A that was partially met, he found that it dealt with only the
stormwater, ice damming, and drainage, which are a significant piece of our
landscaping and land needs in Anchorage. Making sure we maintain stormwater, ice
requirements, and drainage ditches is what put some of these criteria into a partially
met standard.
4. The petitioner has fully met the intent of the standards.
AYE: Clark, Cash, McKee, Winchester, Morse, Sullivan, Rehm
NAY: None
PASSED
H. APPEARANCE REQUEST - None
I. REPORTS - None
1. Chair
2. Secretary
3. Committee
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION MEETING
November 18, 2020 Page 4 of 4
J. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS
K. ADJOURNMENT
VICE CHAIR WINCHESTER moved to adjourn. COMMISSIONER CLARK seconded.
AYE: Clark, Cash, McKee, Winchester, Morse, Sullivan, Rehm
NAY: None
PASSED
The meeting adjourned at 7:07 p.m.
Agenda
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION
A G E N D A
Assembly Chambers
Z.J. Loussac Library
3600 Denali Street
Anchorage, Alaska
November 18, 2020
6:30 P.M.
Live Streaming and Archived Meetings/Podcasts at http://www.muni.org/watchnow
Nichole Rehm, Chair
Jerry Winchester, Vice Chair
The Urban Design Commission meets the second and fourth Wednesday of each month except holidays
as regular meetings. If the Urban Design Commission fails to complete its agenda for its regular
meetings, the Commission carries over the remainder of the agenda to the following meeting date.
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR: Due to concerns over large gatherings amid the COVID-19
outbreak, community members are strongly encouraged to provide testimony via email or by
telephone. Because of the federal, state, and local health department guidance and emergency
measures, the Assembly Chambers will be closed to the public.
The Urban Design Commission encourages anyone wishing to provide public testimony via
telephone to email PlanningTestimony@anchorageak.gov by 2:00 p.m. the day of the
meeting. Please provide your Name, Phone Number, and Agenda Item Number/Title for which
you wish to provide testimony. The Subject Line should read “Phone Testimony”. The
Secretary will phone you at the number you have provided. You will have 3 minutes to provide
testimony on each item you wish to speak on or 5 minutes for group representatives.
ALL DOCUMENTS LISTED ON THIS AGENDA ARE AVAILABLE ONLINE AT
www.muni.org/watchnow.
FOR AUXILLARY AIDS, SERVICES, OR SPECIAL MODIFICATIONS TO
PARTICIPATE, PLEASE CONTACT THE MEETING SECRETARY TO REQUEST
REASONABLE ACCOMMODATIONS AT 343-7576; FAX 343-7927
Page 1
Urban Design Commission
November 18, 2020
The procedure by which the public may speak to the Urban Design Commission at its meeting is:
1) After the staff presentation is completed on public hearing items, the Chair will ask for public
testimony on the issue.
2) Persons who wish to testify will follow the time limits established in the Urban Design Commission
Rules of Procedure.
a. Petitioners (including all his/her representatives) - 10 minutes. Rebuttal by the petitioner may
be allowed when time has been reserved.
b. Representatives of groups (community councils, PTA's etc.) - 5 minutes.
c. Individuals - 3 minutes.
3) When your testimony is complete you may be asked questions by the Commission. You may only
testify once on any issue unless questioned by the Commission.
4) An individual may have appeal rights relating to any action the Urban Design Commission takes,
except Commission recommendations to the Assembly which are not appealable. Appeals must be
filed with the Clerk's Office within (20) twenty days after approval by the Urban Design
Commission of the resolution which is the Commission's final decision. A fee for the appeal is
required at the time of filing.
Revised: 10/13/20
Page 2
Urban Design Commission
November 18, 2020
A. ROLL CALL
B. MINUTES
1. Wednesday, October 14, 2020
C. SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS / EXECUTIVE SESSIONS
1. Disclosures
D. CONSENT AGENDA
1. Resolutions for Approval
2. Site / Landscape Plan Approval
3. Other
E. UNFINISHED BUSINESS AND ACTIONS OF PUBLIC HEARINGS
F. REGULAR AGENDA
1. Resolutions for Approval
2. Site / Landscape Plan Approval
3. Other
G. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. CASE: 2020-0132 (RY)
PETITIONER: Jack M. Pomerantz
REQUEST: Request for Design Variance from AMC 21.07.080, Table 21.07-1 to
allow existing landscaping to remain and Design Variance from AMC
21.05.040A.3.d. and AMC 21.07.090, Table 21.07.090, Table 21.07-4
to allow for a reduction in required off-street parking spaces and to
allow required parking spaces to be located within a yard setback.
TOTAL AREA: .74 acres
LOCATION: Generally located south of West 19th Avenue, West of K Street, north
of West 20th Avenue and east of Spenard Road
SITE ADDRESS: 1120 & 1130 West 19th Avenue, Anchorage, Alaska 99503
CURRENT R-2M Mixed Residential District
ZONE:
COMMUNITY North Star, South Addition
COUNCIL(S):
H. APPEARANCE REQUEST
Page 3
Urban Design Commission
November 18, 2020
I. REPORTS
1. Chair
2. Secretary
3. Committee
J. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS
K. ADJOURNMENT
Page 4
Urban Design Commission
November 18, 2020
URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION
Late Public Hearing Submittal Policy
Voluminous information shall not be submitted to the Commission at a public
hearing. Generally, maps, graphic and photographs will be allowed. Type written
information shall be limited to two pages, submitted no later than three (3) working
days prior to a public hearing (i.e. the Friday before a regularly scheduled or special
UDC Wednesday meeting). Information may be accepted, if the Commission
chooses, to allow the additional information. If the petitioner or public insists that
the voluminous information is important and critical to the case, the hearing shall be
postponed for 30 days to allow staff to review the information, include it in the
board member packet, and allow a thorough review by the Commission.
Policy Re: Postponement of Public Hearing Applications
When there is a short 5 member Board or Commission, and a postponement is
offered to, and agreed to by the petitioner, they will be moved to the next regular
agenda. This should occur within 30-days, which does not require re-noticing the
case (new public hearing notices, advertising).
If the petitioner is willing to postpone, but unable to attend the next available
meeting date within 30 days, the petitioner has a one-time only option to choose the
next date certain he/she can attend, at no extra fee.
When a postponement is requested by the petitioner, there is a rescheduling fee
(AMCR 21.20.007.A), and a new public hearing date shall be determined by the
Planning Department. This will put their case in the next available cut-off date
queue as if they were submitting their case for the first time.
Effective January 01, 2004
Page 5
Get email alerts for Anchorage
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.