Civil Service
Regular MeetingBattle Creek, MI · June 9, 2023
Minutes
Battle Creek Civil Service Commission
Special Meeting
City Hall
10 N. Division Street
Commission Chambers
Battle Creek, Michigan
June 9, 2023
9:00 A.M.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Commissioner Calvin Hardin and Chris McCoy
MEMBERS ABSENT: Commissioners Chris Dopp
STAFF PRESENT: Victoria Houser, City Clerk: Bill Beaty, Fire Chief: Jonathan Baber, Deputy City Attorney: Chelsea
Sears, HR Generalist: Michelle Hull, HR Director and Kimberly Holley, DEI Officer
OTHERS PRESENT: Yoshi Fujita, Fire Fighter
CALL TO ORDER: Commissioner McCoy called the meeting to order at 9:01 PM.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Commissioner McCoy noted the first order of business was to approve the April 24, 2023 Civil Service Commission
minutes.
Comm. Hardin, supported by Comm. McCoy, made a motion to approve the Civil Service Commission meeting minutes of
April 24, 2023. All in favor, none opposed. Motion approved.
PETITIONS AND COMMUNICATIONS: There were no petitions or communications.
REPORTS: There were no reports.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS: There was none.
NEW BUSINESS:
1. Proposed Rule Changes
a. Rule 4: Filling Vacancies above the rank of Firefighter: (3) Interview/Oral Examination
An Assessment Center, which includes a tactical scenario, a role play exercise, an in-basket exercise,
and an interview exercise for promotions which shall be conducted by the Commission or an appropriate
qualified agency or individuals appointed by the Commission. An Assessment Center for line officers
(Lieutenant, Captain, and Battalion Chief) shall include a tactical scenario exercise, a role-play exercise,
an in-basket exercise, and a structured oral interview exercise. The structured oral interview exercise
shall be conducted by the Commission or an appropriate qualified agency or individuals appointed by
the Commission. An Assessment Center for non-line positions of Fire Marshal, Fire Inspector and
Training Officer shall include a structured oral interview exercise, an oral presentation exercise, an in-
basket exercise, and a role-play scenario exercise. (Rule Change: 4-23-12, (Rule Change: 7-13-2020, 6-
xx-2023))
b. Rule 4: Filling Vacancies above the rank of Firefighter: (6) Promotional Scores
The final score for every promotional exam will be determined in the following:
(a) It will be possible to receive one hundred (100) points in each of the following categories: Written
Exam (minimum score of 70% required to move forward to the Assessment Center). The Line Officer
Assessment Center (40% tactical scenario, 20% role-play exercise, 20% in-basket exercise, and 20%
interview exercise) cumulative score of 70% to pass Assessment Center. The Non-Line Assessment
Center (25% structured oral interview exercise, 25% oral presentation exercise, 25% in-basket exercise,
and 25% role-play scenario exercise ) cumulative score of 70% to pass Assessment Center. The
Assessment center structured oral interview exercise will take into consideration a person’s training and,
education, commendations, and yearly evaluations. (Rule Change: 7-13-2020, 6-xx-2023)
Chief Beaty noted it is not appropriate to include a tactical scenario, which is usually a fire or emergency
scenario/incident, in the assessment center for non-line positions, specifically Fire Marshal, Fire Inspector and
Training Officer.
1
Comm. Hardin, supported by Comm. McCoy, made a motion to amend Civil Service Rules, Rule 4, section (3)
Interview/Oral Examination, as presented, to include additional language related to non-line positions. All in
favor, none opposed. Motion approved
Comm. Hardin, supported by Comm. McCoy, made a motion to amend Civil Service Rules, Rule 4, section (6)
Promotional Scores, as presented, to differentiate the scoring for components of the Assessment Center for Line
Officers and Non-Line Officers. All in favor, none opposed. Motion approved
PUBLIC COMMENT: There were no public comments.
COMMISSION COMMENT: There were no commission comments.
NEXT MEETING: June 26, 2023 at 4:00 PM.
ADJOURNMENT: Commissioner McCoy adjourned the meeting at 9:19A.M.
2
Agenda
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
SPECIAL MEETING
FRIDAY, JUNE 9, 2023
9:00 A.M.
BATTLE CREEK CITY HALL
COMMISSION CHAMBERS
BATTLE CREEK, MICHIGAN
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1. APRIL 24, 2023
C. REPORTS
D. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
E. NEW BUSINESS
1. Proposed Rule Changes:
a. Rule 4: Filling Vacancies above the rank of Firefighter: (3) Interview/Oral Examination
An Assessment Center, which includes a tactical scenario, a role play exercise, an in-basket exercise, and
an interview exercise for promotions which shall be conducted by the Commission or an appropriate
qualified agency or individuals appointed by the Commission. An Assessment Center for line officers
(Lieutenant, Captain, and Battalion Chief) shall include a tactical scenario exercise, a role-play exercise,
an in-basket exercise, and a structured oral interview exercise. The structured oral interview exercise shall
be conducted by the Commission or an appropriate qualified agency or individuals appointed by the
Commission. An Assessment Center for non-line positions of Fire Marshal, Fire Inspector and Training
Officer shall include a structured oral interview exercise, an oral presentation exercise, an in-basket
exercise, and a role-play scenario exercise. Where the oral examinations are being conducted by the
Commission, the presence of all three Commission members is required, except in situations where a
Commissioner is unable to be present due to medical emergency or the death of a family member. In such
cases, a quorum of Commissioners is sufficient for conducting the oral examinations. (Rule Change: 4-
23-12, (Rule Change: 7-13-2020, 6-xx-2023))
b. Rule 4: Filling Vacancies above the rank of Firefighter: (6) Promotional Scores
The final score for every promotional exam will be determined in the following:
(a) It will be possible to receive one hundred (100) points in each of the following categories: Written
Exam (minimum score of 70% required to move forward to the Assessment Center). The Line Officer
Assessment Center (40% tactical scenario, 20% role-play exercise, 20% in-basket exercise, and 20%
interview exercise) cumulative score of 70% to pass Assessment Center. The Non-Line Assessment
Center (25% structured oral interview exercise, 25% oral presentation exercise, 25% in-basket exercise,
and 25% role-play scenario exercise ) cumulative score of 70% to pass Assessment Center. The
Assessment center structured oral interview exercise will take into consideration a person’s training and,
education, commendations, and yearly evaluations. (Rule Change: 7-13-2020, 6-xx-2023)
F. PUBLIC COMMENTS
G. COMMISSION COMMENTS
H. ADJOURNMENT
The City of Battle Creek will provide necessary reasonable auxiliary aids and services, such as signers for the hearing impaired and audiotapes of
printed materials being considered in the meeting upon notice to the City of Battle Creek. Individuals with disabilities requiring auxiliary aids or
services should contact the City of Battle Creek by writing or calling the following:
Victoria L. Houser
Office of the City Clerk
P. O. Box 1717
Battle Creek, MI 49016
(269) 966-3348 (Voice/TDD)
MCL 38.512 Sec. 12(2) Vacancies in positions in the fire and police departments above the rank of fire fighter or police officer
shall be competitive and shall be filled by promotions from among persons holding positions in the next lower rank in the
departments who have completed 2 years in that rank and who have at least 5 years in the department. If there are more
vacancies than there are persons with 5 years in the department, the commission may lower the requirements to 3 years in the
department. If no person or persons have completed 2 years in the next lower rank, the commission may hold examinations
among persons in such rank as to all intent and purposes as though 2 years of service had been completed by those persons.
Get email alerts for Battle Creek
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.