04/19/2021 Historic Preservation Commission Meeting - Virtual

ZACK MULLOCK Mayor STACY D. SHEEHAN Deputy Mayor City of Cape May National Historic Landmark LORRAINE M. BALDWIN Councilmember City Hall – 643 Washington Street MICHAEL J. VOLL CHRIS BEZAIRE Cape May, New Jersey 08204-2397 City Manager Councilmember (609) 884-9525 * Fax: (609) 884-8589 ERIN C. BURKE SHAINE P. MEIER www.capemaycity.com City Clerk Councilmember Historic Preservation Commission April 19, 2021 - 6:00 PM OPENING: In compliance with the Open Public Meetings Act of 1975, adequate notice of this meeting has been provided. If any member has reason to believe that this meeting is being held in violation of this Act they should state so at this time. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL RESOLUTION(S): Carter, 800 Washington Street, 1091/1 – Resolution #2021-10 Yanich/Wolf, 1015 New Jersey Avenue, 1102/51 Resolution #2021-11 Locke, 1144 Washington Street, 1110/31 – Resolution #2021-12 APPLICATIONS APPROVED IN REVIEW: Caruso, 315 Congress Street, 1031/58, Non Contributing – Awning Goslee, 27.5 Second Avenue, 1014/24, Non Contributing – Siding, Relocate Windows, Steps, Railings Carney’s Inc., 419 Beach Avenue, 1041/21 & 22, Contributing – Second Floor Porch Carney’s Inc., 411 Beach Avenue, 1041/23, Contributing – Rooftop Deck 1 S Lafayette LLC, 1 S Lafayette Street, 1021/9, Contributing - Windows, Banister, Trim Campione, 902 Kearney Avenue, 1082/1, Non Contributing – Pool, Pavers, Landscaping Thorkildsen, 218 Grant Street, 1019/18, Non Contributing – Door, Fence, Patio Pavers Kloosterboer Zicari Living Trust, 25 Second Avenue, 1014/22, Non Contributing – Pool, Fence The Corner Cottage LLC, 315 Broadway, 1027/1.01, Non Contributing – Heat Pump System Lane, 308 Howard Street, 1065/5, Not Rated – Roof Reinhard, 919 Queen Street, 1094/29, Contributing – Fence Colson, 1245 Washington Street, 1129/28, Contributing – Roof Mogck Jr., 1246 Lafayette Street, 1129/19, Non Contributing – Roof Marine, 910 Queen Street, 1092/16, Non Contributing – Roof 617 Columbia LLC, 617 Columbia Avenue, 1057/20, Contributing – Windows Zelman & Backstrom, 514 Hughes Street, 1048/2.01, Contributing – Windows Walchak, 834 Lafayette Street, 1092/10, Contributing – Driveway Pavers Goslee, 27.5 Second Avenue, 1014/24, Non Contributing – Siding, Stairs Thistle Real Estate Services LLC, 1020 Stockton Avenue, 1095/6, Contributing – Siding Morning Star Villa Condos, 1307 Beach Avenue, 1146/25 C-1 to C-14, Key – Fire Escape Repairs Hood, 132 Decatur Street, 1041/1, Contributing – A/C on Platform Corp of the Roman Catholic Clergymen, 901 Beach Avenue, 1081/25 – Contributing – Roof Somoza, 1386 Lafayette Street, 1145/7, Non Contributing – Fence Black, 912 Corgie Street, 1090/21, Contributing – Extend Front Porch, Walkway, Driveway Summer Station Condo Association, 217 Beach Avenue, 1019/25 C-101 to C-415, Non Contributing – Railing, Deck, Steps, Joist System, Facia, Gutters, Downspouts Church of Our Lady Star of the Sea, 500-520 Lafayette Street, 1052/15, Key – Parish Hall Windows Morabito, 1016 Stockton Avenue, 1095/4, Contributing – Fence Tides Condo Association, 9 Jackson Street, 1041/16, Not Rated – Pool Railings Cape May Sea Glass Properties LLC, 933 Beach Avenue, 1081/16, Non Contributing – Reset on New Foundation in Pre-Existing Location Andersen, 1123 New Jersey Avenue, 1116/17, 18, 19 & 20, Contributing – Pavers Quinn, 38 Jackson Street, 1034/2, Contributing – Size Reduction to Approved Rear Addition Brown, 717 Washington Street, 1079/2, Contributing – Pillar, Fencing Pask, 815 Kearney Avenue, 1069/7.01, Contributing – Roof, Siding MacLeod, 1201 New York Avenue, 1132/48, Contributing – Furnace, Heat Pump, Air Handler Myers, 611 Jefferson Street, 1090/58, Contributing – Add First Floor Windows Kirk, 213 Perry Street, 1038/7, Contributing – Roof Wadleigh, 1023 Washington Street, 1112/15, Contributing – Rear Slider, Trim, Rear Steps, Railing Zehnder, 1152 Washington Street, 1110/36, Contributing – Heat, A/C, Trellis Neff, 651 Hughes Street, 1058/19, Contributing – Roof Seltzer, 513 Franklin Street, 1076/4, Contributing – Siding Marquis de Lafayette Hotel, 501 Beach Avenue, 1047/1 C-100 to C-610, Non Contributing – Roof Meholick, 806 Benton Avenue, 1072/2, Non Contributing – A/C Systems Island Creek Towers, 1488 Washington Street, 1160/4.01 C-1 to C-5, Non Contributing – Driveway, Sidewalk Hoff, 817 Corgie Street, 1091/30, Contributing – A/C Condenser Colson, 1245 Washington Street, 1129/28, Contributing – A/C Unit on Platform, Lattice Kieffer, 231-233 Windsor Avenue, 1026/25, Contributing – Fire Escape, Deck Roof Carroll, 625 Hughes Street, 1058/28, Contributing – Generator Historic Preservation Commission April 19, 2021 Agenda Page | 1 APPLICATIONS: CITY OF CAPE MAY FIRE HOUSE………………………………………..….……….…712 FRANKLIN STREET NEW CONSTRUCTION BLK 1059 LOT(S) 4 (NOT RATED) 248 GRANT ST QPR (HEALEY)………………….……………………………….……………248 GRANT STREET ELEVATE ROOF/ADDDITION/ BLK 1019 LOT(S) 12 (NON CONTRIBUTING) DECKS/RENOVATIONS NJ CAPE PROPERTIES LLC…..……………………….………………....................918 LAFAYETTE STREET RENOVATIONS/NEW GARAGE BLK 1094 LOT(S) 9, 10 (CONTRIBUTING) CAPE MAY SEA GLASS PROPERTIES LLC……………………………………..…………..933 BEACH AVENUE ELEVATE/RENOVATIONS BLK 1081 LOT(S) 16 (NON CONTRIBUTING) CASADAY………..…………………………..….........................................................21 SECOND AVENUE SIDING/WINDOWS/REAR ROOF BLK 1014 LOT(S) 19 (CONTRIBUTING) FOUNDATION/RELOCATE STAIRS CROSSED TRUSTEE………………………………………………………..…………………….915 BEACH AVENUE PARTIAL PORCH ROOF BLK 1081 LOT(S) 20 (CONTRIBUTING) CONVERSION TO DECK MILLER…………………………………………………………………….....................1241 LAFAYETTE STREET NEW CONSTRUCTION BLK 1061 LOT(S) 93.03 (NON CONTRIBUTING) HUDSON…………………………………………………………………………………..1527-1529 YACHT AVENUE DEMOLITION & BLK 1160 LOT(S) 21 (1529 NON CONTRIBUTING) NEW CONSTRUCTION BLK 1160 LOT(S) 20, 20.01 (1527 NOT IN DISTRICT) MAGUIRE………………………………..…………………………………………..…..…1003 STOCKTON AVENUE ELEVATOR ADDITION BLK 1096 LOT(S) 17 (NON CONTRIBUTING) OPEN TO PUBLIC DISCUSSION ADJOURNMENT All applications are on file and available for inspection in City Hall Historic Preservation Commission April 19, 2021 Agenda Page | 2  City of Cape May, County of Cape May, State of New Jersey NOTIFICATION OF VIRTUAL MEETINGS AND INSTRUCTIONS Pursuant to the State of Emergency and Public Health Emergency as ordered in Executive Order No. 103 and 107 by the New Jersey Governor, the City of Cape May will hold the City of Cape May Historic Preservation Commission and Zoning Board of Adjustment Meetings at 6:00 P.M. and the Planning Board Meetings at 6:30 PM virtually via Zoom, with a live stream of the meeting on the City’s Facebook page: Cape May, NJ COVID. Members of the public have the following options for observing and/or participating in the meeting: To watch and listen to the Historic Preservation Commission, Planning Board and Zoning Board of Adjustment Meetings • Watch the meeting on Facebook as it is streamed live to the City’s Official COVID Facebook page: - Log into Facebook prior to the meeting date, search for “Cape May, NJ COVID” (@capemaycitycovidinfo), or follow https://www.facebook.com/capemaycitycovidinfo - “Like” and “follow” the page. - If you like/follow “Cape May, NJ COVID” prior to the meeting date, you will receive a notification once the live stream begins or you can visit the City’s Cape May, NJ COVID Facebook page at 6:00 P.M. for Historic Preservation Commission and Zoning Board of Adjustment meetings and 6:30 PM for Planning Board meetings to watch and listen to the meetings. - You are able to visit the City’s COVID Facebook page at any time during a meeting to view the live stream. Please note that comments and questions left on the City’s COVID Facebook live stream, COVID Facebook page or any City Facebook live stream or City Facebook page will not be addressed. The public has the following option for submission of questions or comments: • Dial 609-884-9533 to call-in with your question or comment only when the Chairperson opens the meeting to the public. - If you hear a busy signal: the line is in use by another caller. Please continue dialing in, and we will eventually reach your call. - You must give your full name and address prior to giving your question or making your statement. - Please keep your question/statement concise and specific to an application or agenda topic. - Comments or questions regarding applications can be made only via call-in during the open to the public portion of the meeting to allow for cross examination. Further notice is given that this notification, including instructions, has been provided to each member of the Historic Preservation Commission, Planning Board and Zoning Board of Adjustment, posted on the Cape May City website at capemaycity.com, and transmitted to the Cape May Star and Wave, the Cape May County Herald, and the Press of Atlantic City. The decision to hold virtual Historic Preservation Commission, Planning Board and Zoning Board of Adjustment meetings was made in consideration of the health, safety, and welfare of Board Members, City Officials, and the public. We understand that this may be an adjustment for some individuals who choose to attend and participate in Historic Preservation Commission, Planning Board and Zoning Board of Adjustment Meetings, and ask for your cooperation and patience during this time. The City of Cape May thanks you in advance for your understanding. Karen Keenan, Board Secretary Historic Preservation Commission April 19, 2021 Agenda Page | 3