Old Town La Verne Business Improvement District Agendas
Regular MeetingLa Verne, CA · February 5, 2024
Minutes
OLD TOWN LA VERNE BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTIRICT
MINUTES OF TTTE REGULAR MEETING
Monday, February 5,2024
I. WELCOME AND CALL TO ORDER
Mr. Walters called the meeting to order at 8:33 a.m. The following board members were
present: Craig Walters, Micky Rehm, and George Henderson. Not Present: Marianne
Stark and Ztthey Espinoza. City Representatives present: Community Development
Director Eric Scherer and Secretary Natalie Hiatt. Others present: Mia Valdez, Ken
Valmonte, and Fang Wang.
2, CALENDAR
Cool Cruise Sat. April 6,2024 - 10am - 4pm
Wine Walk Sat. April 27,2024 - 5pm-8:30pm
3. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES November 6,2023 and December 4,2024
It was moved by Ms. Rehm and seconded by Mr. Henderson to approve the minutes of
November 6,2023 and Decemb er 4, 2023. Motion carried by a 3-0 vote.
4. NEW BUSINESS
A. Election of officers - Ms. Rehm nominated Mr. Walters as chairperson. It was
moved by Ms. Rehm and seconded by Mr. Henderson to approve the nomination
Motion carried by a 3-0 vote.
Ms. Rehm nominated Mr. Henderson as vice-chairperson. It was moved by Ms.
Rehm and seconded by Mr. Walters to approve the nomination. Motion carried by
a 3-0 vote.
Ms. Rehm nominated Ms. Stark as treasurer. It was moved by Ms. Rehm and
seconded by Mr. Henderson to approve the nomination. Motion carried by a 3-0
vote.
B Selection of a Budget Subcommittee - Mr. Scherer stated that the subcommittee
will meet to discuss the draft budget and programs for the 2024-25 fiscal year.
The sub-committee's recommendations will be presented to city council.
Ms. Rehm and Mr. Walters volunteered for the sub-committee. The meeting will
be held at City Hall at a date to be determined.
The board discussed the roles of the Association versus the Business
Improvement District (BID). Mr. Scherer recommended holding a special meeting
to provide clarification on the roles of the two groups. A tentative meeting date
was set for February 26,2024 at City Hall.
C Caf6 Wang's Patio Expansion Recommendation - Mr. Scherer stated that the
patio expansion is set to expire in February. The owners have requested that the
patio be left indefinitely (email attached). Staff recommends an annual permit
allowing the patio to remain for one more year. The permit would include a rental
fee per square foot and to be consistent all restaurants will need to adhere to
outdoor dining policies and regulations. Staff will do outreach to restaurants if
approved by Ciry Council.
Ms. Rehm stated that she would possibly abstain due to a conflict of interest.
Mr. Scherer stated that the Board would provide a recommendation to city
Council, and they will be responsible for the final decision.
Mr. Henderson recommended conducting a survey of the old Town businesses
before a recommendation is made by the BID Board.
Mr. Scherer stated that the patio will remain on a monthly basis until the survey is
completed and a meeting is held to discuss the Board's recommendation.
Mr. Walters agreed with the survey and recommended allowing the patio
expansion through May.
lt was moved by Mr. Walters and seconded by Ms. Rehm to perform a survey of
the local businesses and approve the patio expansion until May 31,2024. Motion
carried by a 3-0 vote.
D. Wine Walk Update - Ms. Rehm stated that there are currently 20 wine stops and 2
food stops participating. The Rotary non-profit group has agreed to volunteer on
the day of the event. There was also discussion of the bathroom location and
sponsorship opportunities.
E Date for Annual Meeting - Mr. Scherer stated that the meeting will be held April
1,2024 at the University of La Verne in the Executive Board Room. Presentations
will include the Gold Line update, University presentation, General Budget, and
BID update.
5 CONTINUED BUSINESS
A. None
6, COMMITTEE REPORTS/ UPDATES
A. City Report (Eric Scherer): None
B. University Report (Cindy Vallejo): None
C. Marketing (Micky Rehm): Ms. Rehm stated that the Wine Walk postcard is being
prepared and sponsor space is still available.
D. Chamber Report (Leah Skinner): None
E. Social Media Update (Micky Rehm): Mr. Walters is still searching for someone to
manage the website.
F. Financial Report: Mr. Scherer stated that funds are available for transfer to the
Association if needed. Ms. Stark can prepare an invoice to the City for the request.
Mr. Walters recommended waiting to transfer money until further discussion is held.
7, PUBLIC COMMENT (Any discussion or action on non-agendized items must be
defened to the following meeting, as required by california Brown Act Law)
None
8. ADJOURNMENT
Meeting was adjourned at9:26 a.m., the special meeting will be held on February 26,
2024 at City Hall, time to be determined.
4"(b
Natalie Hiatt
r
Eric Scherer
From: cafewa ng20 1 7@gmai l.com
Sent: Thursday, December 7, 2023 2:32 PM
To: Eric Scherer
Cc: Natalie Hiatt
Subject: Re:Cafe Wang Patio
Hi Eric,
Thank you for the opportunity to share our thoughts with you and the BID Board regarding the patio
We would like to ask the Board to consider allowing us to keep the patio indefinitely.
There are several reasons for this, here are just a few:
1. Provides cusfomers with outdoor dining options. Many customers have told us that they really
enjoy the choice to be able to eat outdoors, which adds to the ambience and overall experience of
coming to Old Town. As you know, most of the dining establishments in Old Town have an outdoor
patio (Chase's,4th St. Mill, Lordsburg, House of Wings, Caffe Allegro, House of Wings, Aoki,
WarehousePizza & Mi Cocina).
2. Live music. Since its construction, many bands have had an opportunity to perform on the patio
on Fridays and Saturdays. We have received lots of feedback from customers and passersby that the
outdoor entertainment creates and vibrant energy and festive mood. Music and food have a way of
bringing together people of all walks of life. ln many cases, followers of the bands come to Old Town
for the very first time. And while they might have come initially to see the band, they often walk
around and visit some the surrounding shops. They in turn become return visitors to Old Town for
other businesses. lt's that type of synergy between the business in Old Town that make it a special
place. As we have seen over the past couple seasons, more establishments have made live music a
part of the overall dining experience (Chase's,4thst Mill, Taberna/Passport, Namba, Mi Cocina and
Lordsburg).
3. lnvestmenf. The patio design was more than just about creating space, it was also about creating
an experience and an ambience for the community. Significant investment was made to create an
appealing, eye-catching design. With the addition of the pergola and lanterns we wanted to create
distinctly Asian theme and unique look. Additional investments were made for the tables, chairs and
heaters. Being able to keep the patio indefinitely will allow us to not only preserve that investment
but give us an opportunity to build upon and enhance it further, for now and into the future.
4. Future planning. The City has completed several upgrades to the corridor that leads to and from
the future La Verne train station. lt's seemed far in the distant future when we were still operating
under COVID protocols and the approval for the patio was granted. And yet now, we are possibly just
over a year from its opening. Undoubtedly the influx of additional visitors to Old Town will create
several challenges for the City Council, ULV, Business Owners and Residents. But if we work
together collectively and get this right, Old Town will transcend beyond the special place it already is,
as the potential for an increased economic boost for the entire district is enormous. With a large influx
of daily visitors anticipated, the patio allows us to preserve the additional capacity for potential
customer growth.
I
ln closing, we have been very grateful and thankful for all the support we have received from the
Board since becoming part of the Old Town family in 2018. And what a ride it has been. Mix in a
couple years of COVID, and now the current challenges of inflation, increased labor costs, and a
slowing economy and no doubt none of us as business owners have been spared these challenges.
But through all this, the Board and the City have been a steady hand in guiding us through
tumultuous times. The patio to us is more than just pieces of wood nailed together, it represents the
evolution of Cafe Wang and Sweet Time. Over the past 2 years it has become part of and identity
with our customers and the community. With your vote, we hope will allow us to maintain that identity
well into the future.
Thank you,
Fang and Ken
On Tuesday, December 5,2023 at 05:52:53 PM PST, Eric Scherer <escherer@cityoflaverne.org> wrote.
Hi Ken and Fang
ln anticipation of the special BID meeting to discuss your patio, I would like you to provide me, in writing, what you would
like to propose to the Board. Are you interested in an extension for a specific amount of time or indeflnilely? ln your
request, you should indicate why the patio is important to the business.
Also, you should know that if allowed to keep the patio, it is expected that you would be required to start paying rent for
the space after February 2024. The current monthly lease rate is $0.691 per s.f. of outdoor area used foi tn-e pitio. tn"
patio is 943 s.f. in size, resulting in a monthly lease payment of $651.62. ln addition, you will be required to pay the one-
-6,3
time parking in-lieu fee ($1,000 per required parking space - Patios require one space for every 15b s.f., thus spaces
which round up to 7 spaces, thus, $7,000) for the expanded patio space if it is determined that ihe patio can remain
indefinitely.
Please let me know if you have any questions. lf you can have your request to me by Thursday afternoon, I would
appreciate it.
-Eric
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here to report this email as spam
2
Agenda
AGENDA
Old Town La Verne Business Improvement District
Advisory Board
Monday, February 5, 2024 – 8:30 am
2316 D Street– Cafe Wang
1. WELCOME AND CALL TO ORDER-
Board Members City Representatives/Others Present
Craig Walters, Chair Eric Scherer, Com. Dev. Director
Marianne Stark Natalie Hiatt, Com. Dev. Admin. Secretary
Micky Rehm
Zuhey Espinoza
George Henderson
2. CALENDAR-
Cool Cruise Sat. April 6, 2024 – 10am -4pm
Wine Walk Sat. April 27, 2024 – 5pm – 8:30pm
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES November 6, 2023 and December 4, 2023
4. NEW BUSINESS
A. Election of Officers
B. Selection of a Budget Subcommittee
C. Café Wang’s Patio Expansion Recommendation
D. Wine Walk Update
E. Date for Annual Meeting
5. CONTINUED BUSINESS
A.
6. COMMITTEE REPORTS/ UPDATES
A. City Report (Eric Scherer):
B. University Report (Zuhey Espinoza):
C. Marketing (Micky Rehm):
D. Chamber Report (Leah Skinner):
E. Social Media Update (Micky Rehm):
F. Financial Report:
7. PUBLIC COMMENT (Any discussion or action on non-agendized items must be deferred to the
following meeting, as required by California Brown Act Law)
8. ADJOURNMENT – Monday, March 4, 2024, at 8:30 am at Café Wang – 2316 D Street
OLD TOWN LA VERNE BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTIRICT
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
Monday, November 6, 2023
1. WELCOME AND CALL TO ORDER
Ms. Rehm called the meeting to order at 8:34am. The following board members were
present: Marianne Stark, Micky Rehm, and George Henderson. Not Present: Craig
Walters and Zuhey Espinoza. City Representatives present: Community Development
Director Eric Scherer, Secretary Natalie Hiatt, Community Services Director Yvonne
Duran, City Manager Ken Domer, Acting Chief of Police Sam Gonzalez, Sergeant Jay
Alvarado, Detective Carlos Flores, and Detective Gabe Chevara. Others present: Cindy
Vallejo, Roy Cannizzo, Ken Valmonte, Fang Wang, Maria Faura, Krista Chakmak, Rick
Sanders, Mary Forgey, Jim Forgey, and Francisco Ramirez.
2. CALENDAR
Cruisin La Verne Car Show Sat. Nov. 18th – 10am – 4pm
Holiday Stroll Sat. Dec. 2nd - 3pm-7pm
Cool Cruise Sat. April 6, 2024 – 10am-4pm
3. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES October 2, 2023
It was moved by Mr. Henderson and seconded by Ms. Stark to approve the minutes for
the October 2nd meeting. Motion carried by a 3-0 vote.
4. NEW BUSINESS
A. Homeless Outreach Services Presentation – Community Services Director
Yvonne Duran discussed the unhoused community and the resources available to
residents and business owners. The City is partnering with Tri-City and L.A.
CADA for non-emergency response.
Acting Chief of Police Sam Gonzelez and staff discussed their approach to the
unhoused population. Detective Flores recommended completing and filing an
annual trespassing form with the department. The form allows for the police
department to act as an agent for the business.
City Manager Ken Domer discussed crime prevention and announced the new La
Verne Link App coming soon. The community will be able to use the app to
report issues and submit pictures.
B. Halloween Recap – The board agreed that they prefer the event to be held from
2:00pm-5:00pm.
5. CONTINUED BUSINESS
A. Holiday Stroll Update – Ms. Rehm stated that John Paddock will be Santa Claus and
the trees are scheduled to be decorated Thanksgiving weekend. Entertainment will
include the Rockstars of Tomorrow and carolers walking throughout Old Town. Mr.
Walters is arranging a petting zoo at Mainiero Square from 3:00pm-5:00pm. In the
event of rain Santa photos will most likely move into the building where Nambah
Coffee is located.
6. COMMITTEE REPORTS/ UPDATES
A. City Report (Eric Scherer): None
B. University Report (Cindy Vallejo): Ms. Vallejo stated that the University received
neighborhood noise complaints. Dr. Zuhey is working on addressing the issues.
C. Marketing (Micky Rehm): Ms. Rehm stated that the Holiday Stroll postcard was
mailed, and they are advertising event on social media.
D. Chamber Report (Leah Skinner): None
E. Social Media Update (Micky Rehm): None
F. Financial Report: None
7. PUBLIC COMMENT (Any discussion or action on non-agendized items must be
deferred to the following meeting, as required by California Brown Act Law)
Ms. Faura of A Place in Time stated that an attorney filed an ADA lawsuit against their
business. She warned that other business owners may fall victim to similar lawsuits.
8. ADJOURNMENT
Meeting was adjourned at 9:50 a.m., the next regular meeting to be held on Monday,
December 4, 2023 at 8:30 a.m. at Café Wang Restaurant.
Respectively submitted,
_____________________
Natalie Hiatt
OLD TOWN LA VERNE BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
Monday, December 4, 2023
The meeting began without a quorum at 8:30 a.m.
Advisory Board Members present: Craig Walters and Micky Rehm. City Representative
present: Community Development Director Eric Scherer and Secretary Natalie Hiatt.
Others present: Fang Wang, Ken Valmonte, and Mia Valdez.
As there was no quorum, no official business was conducted. There was general
discussion about Holiday Stroll and Wine Walk.
The meeting ended at 9:05 a.m.
Respectively submitted,
_____________________
Natalie Hiatt
1
Eric Scherer
From: cafewang2017@gmail.com
Sent: Thursday, December 7, 2023 2:32 PM
To: Eric Scherer
Cc: Natalie Hiatt
Subject: Re: Cafe Wang Patio
Hi Eric,
Thank you for the opportunity to share our thoughts with you and the BID Board regarding the patio.
We would like to ask the Board to consider allowing us to keep the patio indefinitely.
There are several reasons for this, here are just a few:
1. Provides customers with outdoor dining options. Many customers have told us that they really
enjoy the choice to be able to eat outdoors, which adds to the ambience and overall experience of
coming to Old Town. As you know, most of the dining establishments in Old Town have an outdoor
patio (Chase's,4th St. Mill, Lordsburg, House of Wings, Caffe Allegro, House of Wings, Aoki,
Warehouse Pizza & Mi Cocina).
2. Live music. Since its construction, many bands have had an opportunity to perform on the patio
on Fridays and Saturdays. We have received lots of feedback from customers and passersby that the
outdoor entertainment creates and vibrant energy and festive mood. Music and food have a way of
bringing together people of all walks of life. In many cases, followers of the bands come to Old Town
for the very first time. And while they might have come initially to see the band, they often walk
around and visit some the surrounding shops. They in turn become return visitors to Old Town for
other businesses. It's that type of synergy between the business in Old Town that make it a special
place. As we have seen over the past couple seasons, more establishments have made live music a
part of the overall dining experience (Chase's,4thSt Mill, Taberna/Passport, Namba, Mi Cocina and
Lordsburg).
3. Investment. The patio design was more than just about creating space, it was also about creating
an experience and an ambience for the community. Significant investment was made to create an
appealing, eye-catching design. With the addition of the pergola and lanterns we wanted to create
distinctly Asian theme and unique look. Additional investments were made for the tables, chairs and
heaters. Being able to keep the patio indefinitely will allow us to not only preserve that investment
but give us an opportunity to build upon and enhance it further, for now and into the future.
4. Future planning. The City has completed several upgrades to the corridor that leads to and from
the future La Verne train station. It's seemed far in the distant future when we were still operating
under COVID protocols and the approval for the patio was granted. And yet now, we are possibly just
over a year from its opening. Undoubtedly the influx of additional visitors to Old Town will create
several challenges for the City Council, ULV, Business Owners and Residents. But if we work
together collectively and get this right, Old Town will transcend beyond the special place it already is,
as the potential for an increased economic boost for the entire district is enormous. With a large influx
of daily visitors anticipated, the patio allows us to preserve the additional capacity for potential
customer growth.
1
In closing, we have been very grateful and thankful for all the support we have received from the
Board since becoming part of the Old Town family in 2018. And what a ride it has been. Mix in a
couple years of COVID, and now the current challenges of inflation, increased labor costs, and a
slowing economy and no doubt none of us as business owners have been spared these challenges.
But through all this, the Board and the City have been a steady hand in guiding us through
tumultuous times. The patio to us is more than just pieces of wood nailed together, it represents the
evolution of Cafe Wang and Sweet Time. Over the past 2 years it has become part of and identity
with our customers and the community. With your vote, we hope will allow us to maintain that identity
well into the future.
Thank you,
Fang and Ken
On Tuesday, December 5, 2023 at 05:52:53 PM PST, Eric Scherer <escherer@cityoflaverne.org> wrote:
Hi Ken and Fang:
In anticipation of the special BID meeting to discuss your patio, I would like you to provide me, in writing, what you would
like to propose to the Board. Are you interested in an extension for a specific amount of time or indefinitely? In your
request, you should indicate why the patio is important to the business.
Also, you should know that if allowed to keep the patio, it is expected that you would be required to start paying rent for
the space after February 2024. The current monthly lease rate is $0.691 per s.f. of outdoor area used for the patio. The
patio is 943 s.f. in size, resulting in a monthly lease payment of $651.62. In addition, you will be required to pay the one-
time parking in-lieu fee ($1,000 per required parking space – Patios require one space for every 150 s.f., thus 6.3 spaces
which round up to 7 spaces, thus, $7,000) for the expanded patio space if it is determined that the patio can remain
indefinitely.
Please let me know if you have any questions. If you can have your request to me by Thursday afternoon, I would
appreciate it.
-Eric
This email has been scanned for spam and viruses by Proofpoint Essentials. Click here to report this email as spam.
2
Get email alerts for La Verne
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.