Citizens' Advisory Commission on Disabilities
Regular MeetingLong Beach, NY · March 11, 2021
Minutes
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
Nubia Flores Cedeno, Chair Victor A. Garate, Member
Stephen Adams, Vice Chair Chris Karadjov, Member
Kim Vuong, Secretary Jennifer Kumiyama, Member
Elyse Ares, Member Gretchen Swanson, Member
TELECONFERENCE VIA WEBEX
Join from the meeting link:
https://longbeachcity.webex.com/longbeachcity/j.php?
MTID=m3ac2bd5e9e131a72f9e64c1b566b2d26
Or join by calling 1-213-306-3065
Meeting number (access code): 146 858 3604
Meeting password: 5xzEY3Nc5q6
CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order by Chair Cedeno at 1:00 pm.
ROLL CALL
Commissioners Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Present: Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Commissioners Elyse Ares
Absent:
PUBLIC COMMENT
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
Page 1 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
1. 21-009CA Recommendation to approve minutes from the February 11, 2021
meeting of the Citizen's Advisory Commission on Disabilities.
Attachments: CACoD Minutes.February 11 2021.pdf
A motion was made by Secretary Vuong, seconded by
Commissioner Garate, to approve recommendation. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS
Page 2 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
2. 21-010CA Recommendation to receive and file monthly report by the
Accessibility, Transportation & Services standing committee.
Attachments: ATS meeting 03 03 2021.pdf
Commissioner Garate reported the Accessibility, Transportation & Services
standing committee met on March 3, 2021. Commissioners Adams, Garate
and Vuong were present; Commissioner Karadjov was absent. The committee
had also met on February 24th to discuss the leaf blower item brought forth by
Frances Emilty Dawson Harris. Currently, this committee is waiting on data to
be provided by the City related to any other public concerns and complaints.
The committee also discussed the paratransit options now available for
Covid-19 vaccine appointments at the Long Beach Convention Center. Lastly,
the committee discussed crosswalks in the City, including lights, longer cross
times, etc. This item will be discussed at length later in this meeting.
Future agenda items include continued leaf blower and crosswalk discussions,
as well as ramp accessibility on our beaches.
Commissioner Swanson suggested the standing committee become familiar
with the City's new mobility coordinator and that person could assist. Elias
Garcia, senior engineer with public works, offered that any crosswalk
discussion decisions would most likely stay with the engineers because of
specific standards.
A motion was made by Commissioner Kumiyama, seconded
by Commissioner Swanson, to approve recommendation.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
Page 3 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
3. 21-011CA Recommendation to receive and file monthly report by the
Accessibility, Transportation & Services standing committee.
Attachments: Standing Committee Report_Feb2021 (002).pdf
Commissioner Swanson reported the committee met on February 15th,
Heather Van Wijk and Chair Cedeno joined. Commissioner Ares was absent.
This committee is looking at equity in the public space, and outlined a series of
steps and expectations needed to create a new framework concept for the
City. Part of the outcome would include CACoD be a part of review process
carried out by the Department of Development Services for new projects.
Heather Van Wijk was asked to evaluate a possible funding mechanism initiate
a request with a local subject matter expert for a future high-level presentation
at CACoD.
An addendum to this report is that this standing committee and Heather Van
Wijk met with a local subject matter expert on March 8th. A robust discussion
was had with this expert about equity in the public space, more to report next
month.
A motion was made by Secretary Vuong, seconded by Vice
Chair Adams, to approve recommendation. The motion
carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
REGULAR AGENDA
Page 4 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
4. 21-012CA Recommendation to receive and file information from the City of Long
Beach Traffic Engineer related to the timing of crosswalks at signalized
intersections.
Senior traffic engineer, Elias Garcia, joined the commission for Q&A on this
topic. There was a lot of robust discussion with intent for future
recommendations from the Accessibility, Transportation & Services standing
committee to the whole commission.
A motion was made by Commissioner Garate, seconded by
Commissioner Karadjov, to approve recommendation. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
5. 21-013CA Recommendation to receive and file into record the letter of
recommendation sent to Mayor Garcia and the City Council regarding
the vaccine rollout and people with disabilities.
Attachments: Acknowledgement of Re-prioritization of Persons Ages 16 to 64 Yea
A motion was made by Commissioner Kumiyama, seconded
by Commissioner Swanson, to approve recommendation.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
Page 5 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
6. 21-014CA Recommendation to discuss the findings of the Library Services
Performance Audit released last month and decide any next steps
CACoD would like to take to specific to these findings.
Attachments: Library Services Performance Audit Combined Final Report.pdf
Chair Cedeno suggested this discussion go to one of the standing committees
for further review of the audit's recommendations. Chair Cedeno also reported
that Councilmember Richardson suggested that social services be offered at
our libraries in the future and wanted this reviewed during committee's review.
Commissioner Swanson stated that this was good opportunity to revisit the
living resource guide that has been recommended in the past.
A motion was made by Commissioner Kumiyama, seconded
by Vice Chair Adams, to approve recommendation. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
7. 21-015CA Recommendation to receive and file letter of recommendation for
effective and accessible resource dissemination for people with
disabilities sent to Mayor Garcia and City Council in July 2020. This
letter of recommendation was sent in response to the Framework for
Reconciliation.
Attachments: Effective and Accessible Resource Dissemination for Persons with D
A motion was made by Secretary Vuong, seconded by
Commissioner Kumiyama, to approve recommendation. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
Page 6 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
8. 21-016CA Recommendation to form an ad-hoc committee to begin discussions
and planning around ways CACoD can support Disability History Week
in October.
Commissioners Vuong and Kumiyama volunteered to be on this ad-hoc.
A motion was made by Commissioner Kumiyama, seconded
by Commissioner Swanson, to approve recommendation.
The motion carried by the following vote:
Yes: 7 - Victor Garate, Chris Karadjov, Jennifer Kumiyama, Gretchen
Swanson, Kim Vuong, Stephen Adams and Nubia Flores
Cedeno
Absent: 2 - Elyse Ares and Deaka McClain
AGENCY REPORTS
Chair Cedeno reported that she recently met with Councilmember Richardson, CD9. They
discussed the food drive occurring on Saturday, March 20th at Jordan HS. Chair Cedeno also
reported that LBUSD would be opening up on March 29 starting with elementary schools.
Vice Chair Adams reported that The Children's Clinic continues to host Saturday vaccine clinics,
vaccinating on average 200 people with each clinic.
Secretary Vuong reported that Tichenor Clinic has applied for a mobile vaccine clinic.
Commissioner Garate reported that he has been involved in a lot of vaccine-related meetings
and activities, and was part of the logistics planning with our paratransit partners at the Long
Beach Convention Center vaccine site.
Page 7 of 8
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON
DISABILITIES MINUTES
STAFF REPORT
Citywide Accessibility Coordinator Heather Van Wijk reported the following:
-on March 8th, the City opened up vaccines to people with developmental and physical
disabilities (a week before the rest of the State), no appointments needed
-our paratransit partners now have direct and easy access to the convention center vaccine site,
allowing riders to stay in the vehicle and with the driver through the duration of their vaccine appt
-there is a mobile unit for people who are homebound
-Covid-19 numbers continue to decline and Long Beach will move into the less restrictive Red
Tier
-March 11 the City opened up to more essential work groups including City employees,
transportation, janitorial, and airline industry
-the City has started to transition to MyTurn and will no longer use VaxLB for vaccine
appointments
ANNOUNCEMENTS AND CLOSING REMARKS
Commissioner Kumiyama gave a shout out to all of the fierce female disability advocates:)
Commissioner Garate thanked Heather Van Wijk for her efforts in the vaccine roll out.
FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
Framework for Reconciliation
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 2:28 pm.
Page 8 of 8
Agenda
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
COMMISSION ON DISABILITIES
AGENDA
Nubia Flores Cedeno, Chair Victor A. Garate, Member
Stephen Adams, Vice Chair Chris Karadjov, Member
Kim Vuong, Secretary Jennifer Kumiyama, Member
Elyse Ares, Member Deaka McClain, Member
Gretchen Swanson, Member
TELECONFERENCE VIA WEBEX
Join from the meeting link:
https://longbeachcity.webex.com/longbeachcity/j.php?
MTID=m3ac2bd5e9e131a72f9e64c1b566b2d26
Or join by calling 1-213-306-3065
Meeting number (access code): 146 858 3604
Meeting password: 5xzEY3Nc5q6
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
PUBLIC COMMENT
Members of the public are invited at this time to address CACoD on items listed in the
agenda below and matters of public business not listed on the agenda, but within the
subject matter jurisdiction. Please limit remarks to 3 minutes.
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
1. 21-009CA Recommendation to approve minutes from the February 11, 2021 meeting
of the Citizen's Advisory Commission on Disabilities.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: CACoD Minutes.February 11 2021.pdf
STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS
Page 1 of 3
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMISSION ON TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
DISABILITIES AGENDA
2. 21-010CA Recommendation to receive and file monthly report by the Accessibility,
Transportation & Services standing committee.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: ATS meeting 03 03 2021.pdf
3. 21-011CA Recommendation to receive and file monthly report by the Accessibility,
Transportation & Services standing committee.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: Standing Committee Report_Feb2021 (002).pdf
REGULAR AGENDA
4. 21-012CA Recommendation to receive and file information from the City of Long
Beach Traffic Engineer related to the timing of crosswalks at signalized
intersections.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
5. 21-013CA Recommendation to receive and file into record the letter of
recommendation sent to Mayor Garcia and the City Council regarding the
vaccine rollout and people with disabilities.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: Acknowledgement of Re-prioritization of Persons Ages 16
6. 21-014CA Recommendation to discuss the findings of the Library Services
Performance Audit released last month and decide any next steps CACoD
would like to take to specific to these findings.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: Library Services Performance Audit Combined Final Repo
Page 2 of 3
CITY OF LONG BEACH THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021
CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMISSION ON TELECONFERENCE: WEBEX, 1:00 PM
DISABILITIES AGENDA
7. 21-015CA Recommendation to receive and file letter of recommendation for effective
and accessible resource dissemination for people with disabilities sent to
Mayor Garcia and City Council in July 2020. This letter of
recommendation was sent in response to the Framework for
Reconciliation.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
Attachments: Effective and Accessible Resource Dissemination for Per
8. 21-016CA Recommendation to form an ad-hoc committee to begin discussions and
planning around ways CACoD can support Disability History Week in
October.
Suggested Action: Approve recommendation.
AGENCY REPORTS
STAFF REPORT
ANNOUNCEMENTS AND CLOSING REMARKS
FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
ADJOURNMENT
I, Heather Van Wijk, Citywide Accessibility Coordinator, certify that the agenda was posted not
less than 72 hours prior to the meeting.
_________________________________
Note: The City of Long Beach provides reasonable accommodations in accordance with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. If a special accommodation is desired, or if an agenda
is needed in an alternative format, please call Heather Van Wijk at (562) 570-6257. You may
also reach Mrs. Van Wijk by email at heather.vanwijk@longbeach.gov.
Page 3 of 3
Get email alerts for Long Beach
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.