Board of Review

City of Manistee March Board of Review Minutes 13th& March March 14th 2017 The Board of Review for the City of Manistee met on Monday March 13t", 2017 in the Second Floor Conference Room, at City Hall, 70 Maple Street for the first meeting of the March Board of Review. Meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 3: 00 P. M. Members present Chariperson: Judianne Sibley, Mary Kowalski Wilhelm and T. Eftaxiadis. Other Present: Assessor Whetstone and Secretary Heather Pefley Call for public comment: None given Petition 1 Kenneth Warren, 51- 764- 702- 01 Petitioner questioned his value and presented the Board with pictures of his property. A motion by Eftaxidias to lower the Class to D and change the depreciation to 45% due to documentation presented support by Wilhelm. All in favor motion passed to change Assessed from$ 30, 300 to$ 19, 200 Petition 2 Donald Kilter, 51- 146- 710- 12 Petitioner questioned his value. Motion was made by Wilhelm to deny request due to no documentation for the Board to look at with support by Sibley. Motion passed. Petition 3 Donald Kilter, 51- 748- 733- 11. Petitioner questioned his value. Motion was made by Sibley to deny request due to no documentation for the Board to look at with support by Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 4 Littler River Band of Ottawa Indian, 51- 448- 731- 03 Petitioner was represented by Brian Werschem, talked about the value of this property. Motion by Eftaxiadis support by Sibley to deny request as the petition did not provide any market or income analysis for the Board to consider. Motion passed. Petition 5 Little River Band of Ottawa Indian, 51- 146- 724- 07 Petitioner was represented by Brian Werschem, talked about combining this parcel with the House of Flavor parcel. Motion by Sibley support by Wilhelm to deny request as all combinations in the City of Manistee must be approved by the planning commission, Motion passed. Petition 6 Littler River Band of Ottawa Indian, 51- 448- 731- 03 Petitioner was represented by Brian Werschem, talked about the value of this property. Motion by Eftaxiadis support by Sibley to deny request as the petition did not provide any market or income analysis for the Board to consider. Motion passed. Petition 7 Littler River Band of Ottawa Indian, 51- 448- 731- 07 Petitioner was represented by Brian Werschem, talked about the value of this property. Motion by Eftaxiadis support by Wilhelm to deny request as the petition did not provide any market or income analysis for the Board to consider. Motion passed. 1-  tition 7 Littler River Band of Ottawa Indian, 51- 448- 731- 07 Petitioner was represented by Brian Werschem, talked about the value of this property. Motion by Eftaxiadis support by Wilhelm to deny request as the petition did not provide any market or income analysis for the Board to consider. Motion passed. Petition 8 Bison Construction, 51- 155- 018- 00 Petitioner questioned his value, upon looking at the record card it was determined that the completion of the building was put at 100% not complete. Motion by Eftaxiadis with support by Wilhelm to lower the completion to 65% and to change the Assessed Value from 81, 000 to 56, 900 and the Taxable from 81, 000 to 56, 470. Motion passed. Petition 9- 38 A Motion was made by Eftaxiadis with support by Wilhelm to grant the Veterans Exemptions to the listed Parcels and to make the Assessed and Taxable Values to Zero. Motion Carried Petition# Parcel ID Owner Assessed Value Corrected Taxable Value Corrected 9 51- 146- 710- 07 Richard Skocelas 49, 300 0 37, 696 0 10 51- 146- 712- 11 James Merritt 38, 900 0 29, 300 0 11 51- 146- 724- 07 Connie Grenell 43, 600 0 33, 279 0 12 51- 150- 159- 00 Thomas Soley 75, 100 0 66, 287 0 13 51- 270- 705- 05 Alan Syverson 37, 000 0 18, 766 0 14 51- 274- 704- 09 Chester MaGee 12, 600 0 10, 074 0 15 51- 274- 704- 11 Chester MaGee 46, 900 0 43, 595 0 16 51- 311- 400- 09 Martin Kensil 39, 200 0 37, 322 0 17 51- 340- 709- 05 Thomas Batzer 71, 100 0 67, 788 0 18 51- 355- 703- 03 Roy Swiatlowski 41, 400 0 43, 035 0 19 51- 355- 708- 17 William Kruse 49, 000 0 38, 192 0 20 51- 364- 708- 11 Musculus Trust 44, 000 0 34, 299 0 21 51- 448- 706- 04 Robert Rennie 27, 800 0 27, 800 0 22 51- 448- 709- 05 Ronald Showalter 37, 200 0 28, 904 0 23 51- 554- 702- 05 John Williams 24, 400 0 21, 996 0 24 51- 572- 702- 08 Judith Pefley 32, 200 0 29, 097 0 25 51- 646- 701- 09 Michael Bauman 75, 900 0 71, 666 0 26 51- 647- 705- 05 Norma Hinkle 40, 100 0 40, 100 0 27 51- 647- 713- 07 Joseph Sullivan 49, 400 0 47, 091 0 28 51- 647- 714- 09 Anne Pinkerton 58, 900 0 58, 900 0 29 51- 648- 705- 10 Larry Johnson 32, 900 0 26, 814 0 30 51- 648- 706- 05 Ross Brown 24, 000 0 19, 277 0 31 51- 648- 720- 01 Roger Yoder 44, 400 0 38, 481 0 32 51- 654- 704- 03 Harry Conway 36, 100 0 29, 772 0 33 51- 672- 703- 33 Irving Cooper 39, 600 0 31, 919 0 34 51- 672- 702- 05 Betty Budnik 44, 800 0 35, 874 0 35 51- 764- 703- 03 Joseph Filiaggi 42, 100 0 34, 032 0 36 51- 764- 710- 01 Louis Fortin 82, 200 0 67, 553 0 37 51- 764- 712- 01 Arthur Krause 25, 300 0 19, 503 0 38 51- 770- 702- 03 Anthony Daunis 19, 900 0 16, 450 0 Petition 39 Catherine Mossner, 51- 448- 715- 01 Motion was made by Eftaxiadis, support by Wilhelm, to deny petition due to the fact that the Board of Review cannot set the Assessment at 50% of Sale Price per 27( 5) of the General Property Tax Act. 2-  Petition 40 Desiree Svidron, 51- 374- 720- 09 Motion was made by Eftaxiadis, support by Sibley to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from 33, 400 to 0 and Taxable Value from$ 23, 886 to 0. Motion passed Petition 41 Carl Peterson, 51- 574- 731- 11 Motion by Eftaxiadis with support by Sibley to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from 24, 500 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 24, 186 to 0. Motion passed Petition 42 Shelly Wilson, 51- 670- 718- 11 Motion by Wilhelm with support by Sibley to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from$ 28, 400 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 25, 203 to 0. Motion passed Petition 43 Ashley Wall 51- 748- 736- 09 Motion by Wilhelm with support by Sibley to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from$ 28, 400 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 25,203 to 0, the board deviated from Eligibility# 5. Motion passed Petition 44 Phyllis McEntaffer, 51- 764- 705- 02 Motion by Sibley with support by Eftaxiadis to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from 19, 6000 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 16, 450 to O. Motion passed Petition 45 Nancy Catlett, 51- 453-705- 05 Motion by Eftaxiadis with support by Sibleys to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from 32, 800 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 30, 765 to 0. Motion passed. Petition 46 Joyelle Fox, 51- 358- 714- 03 Motion by Wilhelm with support by Sibley to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from$ 28,400 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 25, 203 to 0., and to deviate from the following policies Eligibility# 4,# 5, 7. Motion passed. The Board was moved by the information provided by Ms. Fox. Motion passed Motion by Eftaxidis with support by Hilhelm to recess until Tuesday March 14, 2017 at 9: 00 P. M. Board of Review came back into session on Tuesday March 14th at 9: 00 a, m. in the Second Floor Conference Room, at City Hall, 70 Maple Street for the first meeting of the March Board of Review. Meeting was called to order by the Chairperson at 3: 00 P. M. Members present: Chariperson: Judianne Sibley, Mary Kowalski Wilhelm and T. Eftaxiadis. Other Present: Assessor Whetstone and Secretary Heather Pefley and Cynthia Lokovich Call for public comment: None given Petition 47 Ronald O' Hagan, 51- 748- 743- 01 Motion by Eftaxiadis, support by Sibley to change the Class to C and lowered the depreciation to match the year built to 70%, Assessed Value from$ 85, 000 to$ 70, 700. Motion Passed Motion was made by Sibley, support by Kriskywicz to remove the value for 2015. Motion passed Petition 48 Pier 31 LLC, 51- 174- 702- 01 Petitioner questioned his value. Motion was made by Wilhelm to deny request due to no documentation for the Board to look at with support by Sibley. Motion passed. 1- etition 49 George Butler, 51311- 275- 00 Motion by Eftaxiadis, support by Sibley to change the lowered the depreciation to match the year built. Assessed Value and Taxable Value from$ 96, 900 to$ 79,600. Motion Passed 3-  tition 50 Angelia Krause, 51- 764- 715- 01 Petitioner questioned her value. Motion was made by Sibley to deny request due to no documentation for the Board to look at with support by Eftaxiadis. Motion passed. Petition 51 Arthur Krause, 51- 764- 712- 07 Petitioner questioned his value. Motion was made by Wilhelm to deny request due to no documentation for the Board to look at with support by Sibley. Motion passed. Petition 52 Union Bag& Barrell, Inc, 51- 448- 711- 01 Motion by Eftaxiadis, support by Wilhelm to change the Class to D and lowered the depreciation to match condition of building, per the appraisal, Assessed Value and Taxable Value from$ 33, 100 to$ 18, 000. Motion Passed Petition 53 Union Bag& Barrell, Inc., 51- 448- 710- 01 Motion by Sibley, support by Eftaxiadis to change the depreciation to 50% to match condition of building, per the appraisal, Assessed Value and Taxable Value from$ 148, 500 to$ 114,400. Motion Passed Petition 54 Glenn Davis, 51- 764- 705- 02 Motion by Sibley with support by Wilhelm to grant a Hardship Exemption to change the AV from$ 35, 300 to 0 and the Taxable Value from$ 34, 610 to 0. Motion passed Petition 55 Nicholas Callesen, 51- 145- 003- 00 Motion by Wilhelm, support by Sibley to change the lowered the depreciation to match the year built. Assessed Value and Taxable Value from$ 505, 300 to$ 477, 400. Motion Passed Eftaxiadis left at 1: 00 P. M. Adjourned at call of the Chariperson at 3: 00 p. m. Respectfully submitted, Heather of ey, Secretary U Date a 1 01 Approved 4-