Beautification Advisory Committee
Regular MeetingMarco Island, FL · January 8, 2020
Minutes
City of Marco Island Florida
51 Bald Eagle Drive
Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Meeting Minutes - Final
Wednesday, January 8, 2020
3:00 PM
'"Changed from January 1, 2020"
Community Room
Beautification Advisory Committee
Chair: Andrew Kirlin
Vice-Chair: Maria Tobin
Members: Becky Irwin, Peter Strungis, Shelli Connelly, Mary Beth Cummings
Staff Liason: Tonia Selmeski
Beautification Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final January 8, 2020
(1) CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kirlin called meeting to order 3:00 p.m.
(2) ROLL CALL
Present: 7- Chair Kirlin, Member Tobin, Member Strungis, Vice-Chair Irwin, Member Irwin,
Member Connelly and Member Bachich
(3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Led by Chair Kirlin.
(4) APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
MOTION by Member Tobin, seconded by Member Strungis, that the AGENDA be
Approved. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 7- Chair Kirlin, Member Tobin, Member Strungis, Vice-Chair Irwin, Member Irwin,
Member Connelly and Member Bachich
(5) APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
ID 19-688 BAC Draft Minutes December 4, 2019
MOTION by Member Strungis, seconded by Member Connelly, that the MINUTES
of December 4, 2019 be Approved. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 7- Chair Kirlin, Member Tobin, Member Strungis, Vice-Chair Irwin, Member Irwin,
Member Connelly and Member Bachich
(6) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
a. City Tree Replacement
Ms. Selmeski noted Public Works working on estimates and planting locations from BAC
recommendations to replace lost trees from Hurricane such as: Shady Lady, Gumbo
Limbo, Japanese Fern and Satin Leaf, tree installation scheduled February 2020.
Mrs. Benarroch, Affordable Landscaping working on tree issues, presently mulching
Collier Boulevard and South Barfield Drive. She reported two crews working on garbage
issues, while another crew cleans up debris and vacuums garbage. Chair Kirlin stated
City Council was impressed with appearance of cul-de-sacs landscaping by dedicated
crew.
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT
None.
(8) PRESENTATIONS
None.
(9) OLD BUSINESS
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1
Beautification Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final January 8, 2020
a. Utility Wrapper Update - Shelli Connelly
Member Connelly working on donor letter deadline to community. February 23rd artwork
submission date, artwork selection by March 30th-May 3rd, panel decision meetings,
unveiling artwork to donors to view wrapper box artwork by May 7th, and discussions with
Ms. Selmeski on selection of contractor. To date, collected $8,400 in donations,
continuing advertising for additional funds. January 17th-20th deadline for local artists to
respond, advertise Marco Island Center for the Arts newsletter, Coastal Breeze, Chamber
of Commerce, then present to City Council.
Color Reflections contractor has 5 year. product warranty (fading) includes installation,
third estimate twice as much money. Member Connelly will bring additional information for
discussion at next BAC meeting.
Ms. Selmeski noted three (3) quotes needed, lowest bidder gets job, or justify if selected
contractor provides more warranties with better customer service.
b. Tree City USA Update - Becky Irwin
Vice Chair Irwin had no update.
c. Committee Outreach Opportunities (i.e. Farmers Market Table)
Chair Kirlin noted Farmers Market BAC table display scheduled February 5 and March 11,
7:30 a.m.-1:00 p.m.
BAC members volunteered presence each day to sponsor Marco in Bloom with
nomination forms, to educate community on BAC Mission Statement and
accomplishments, promote Marco Nature Night Community presentation and Arbor Day.
Consensus: 6-0 to order display boards from local printer not to exceed $50.00.
Member Bachich will clarify BAC using Parks & Recreation Committee 501(c)(3) funds for
Arbor Day, Adopt a Tree or any other program/event.
d. Adopt A Cul-De-Sac Vouchers
Chair Kirlin stated winner and runner up for Marco in Bloom cul-de-sacs (cds) category
would receive $200 voucher each. Ms. Selmeski will research project to keep at $200.
Affordable Landscape said they would assist with making a plant list brochure of plants
needing minimal maintenance (FL Friendly Plantings) for cul-de-sac areas.
e. Community Presentation - Change Name
Ms. Connelly noted date confirmed for February 19, 2020 at 5:30 p.m.-7:30 p.m. with
exhibition tables from MI Center for the Arts, Rookery Bay, and Master Gardener, Donna
Kay with speakers from Audubon, Collier County Pollution Control and Fruit and Spice
Park. Posting electronic sign to advertise to community along with school handouts.
Committee finalized presentation name with Consensus 6-0: "Marco Nature Night - Know
Your Environment".
Member Irwin starting BAC Facebook Event Page, will insert BAC Bio to advertise events
and projects. Ms. Selmeski clarifying rules for social media with concerns with Sunshine
Law, possible restrictions? Consensus 6-0 to add presentation on City website.
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2
Beautification Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final January 8, 2020
f. 2020 Arbor Day/Tree Planting - Becky Irwin
Vice Chair stated Affordable Landscape agreed to donate a edible tree, such as Mulberry
tree, on ArborDay at Calusa Park. Member Strungis suggested planting that donated tree
as a replacement tree for a dead tree in the park
Arbor Day scheduled April 22, 2020, (on Earth Day), Wednesday, 10:00 a.m.-11:00 a.m.
Checking with MI Middle Island Jazz Band. Need podium, flag, microphone and
Proclamation. Consensus 6-0 to purchase cookies, not to exceed $20.
g. 2020 Marco in Bloom - Maria Tobin
Committee discussed Marco in Bloom (MiB) Landscape Award categories for property
owners, application deadline date March 13, 2020, BAC voting date March 16, 2020 at
4:00 p.m.-5:00 p.m. at City Hall, lower conference room, winners announced April 6, 2020
at City Council meeting. Sending Press Release to Marco Island Eagle, Coastal Breeze
and Marco Island Gazette. Advertising on 98.1 FM radio station, and Facebook page.
Committee will review properties in person prior to deadline using map created by Member
Tobin.
h. Edible Garden
Chair Kirlin noted PRAC worked on edible garden. Director Pinter objected to edible trees
in park except for citrus trees due to iguana consumption. Vice Chair Irwin will speak to
PRAC Vice Chair Richards to discuss at next BAC meeting.
(10) NEW BUSINESS
a. Responsibility of Sidewalks
Chair Kirlin discussed people complaints about sidewalks being off, cracked, etc. In
motion, if sidewalk is damaged, home owner needs to replace whole sidewalk within
8'-100'. Ms. Selmeski suggested individuals present concerns to City Council on City's
direction.
(11) COMMITTEE COMMUNICATIONS
a. Committee Concerns
Member Connelly inquired why empty member chair on dais (one less BAC member for
long time). Chair Kirlin stated a City Councilor has not requested replacement since
Member Colombo resigned from committee. If volunteers interested, please contact
Councilor Roman for appointment.
MOTION by Member Connelly, seconded by Member Strungis, to
request empty BAC member seat be filled for BAC to achieve
goals and objectives, that this MOTION be Approved. MOTION
CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 7- Chair Kirlin, Member Tobin, Member Strungis, Vice-Chair Irwin,
Member Irwin, Member Connelly and Member Bachich
b. Future Agenda Recommendations
Committee discussed future agenda items:
City of Marco Island Florida Page 3
Beautification Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes - Final January 8, 2020
1.Research siren sounds in middle of night, bring back to next BAC meeting for
discussion.
2. Selection of City tree projects? Not good idea for citrus trees.
3. Elections for Chair/Vice Chair in February. Chair Kirlin stated this is his final year as
Chair, he will stay on if needed if no one else wants elected position.
4. Chair Kirlin will present Utility Wrappers project at City Council meetings until
completed.
5. Present Annual Report requested by City Council featuring activities, projects,
motions, etc.
6. Member Tobin proposed adding “Irrigation” as a topic at next year’s Marco Nature Night
event
(12) ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned 4:39 p.m.
_________________________________
Patty Mastronardi, Administrative Assistant
City of Marco Island Florida Page 4
Agenda
51 Bald Eagle Drive
City of Marco Island Florida Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Meeting Agenda - Final
Beautification Advisory Committee
Chair: Andrew Kirlin
Vice-Chair: Becky Irwin
Members: Maria Tobin, Peter Strungis, Shelli Connelly, and
Maria Bachich
City Staff: Tonia Selmeski, Patty Mastronardi
Wednesday, January 8, 2020 3:00 PM Community Room
'"Changed from January 1, 2020"
(1) CALL TO ORDER
(2) ROLL CALL
(3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
(4) APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
(5) APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
ID 19-688 BAC Draft Minutes December 4, 2019
Attachments: BAC Draft Minutes 4-Dec-2019.pdf
(6) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
a. City Tree Replacement
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT (TIME CERTAIN 3:30 P.M.)
(8) PRESENTATIONS
(9) OLD BUSINESS
a. Utility Wrapper Update - Shelli Connelly
b. Tree City USA Update - Becky Irwin
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1 Printed on 1/6/2020
Beautification Advisory Committee Meeting Agenda - Final January 8, 2020
c. Committee Outreach Opportunities (i.e. Farmers Market Table)
d. Adopt A Cul-De-Sac Vouchers
e. Community Presentation - Change Name
f. 2020 Arbor Day/Tree Planting - Becky Irwin
g. 2020 Marco in Bloom - Maria Tobin
h. Edible Garden
(10) NEW BUSINESS
a. Responsibility of Sidewalks
(11) COMMITTEE COMMUNICATIONS
a. Committee Concerns
b. Future Agenda Recommendations
(12) ADJOURNMENT
NOTE: TWO OR MORE CITY COUNCILORS OR OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2 Printed on 1/6/2020
Get email alerts for Marco Island
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.