City Council
Regular MeetingPort St. Lucie, FL · September 23, 2019
Minutes
121 SW Port St. Lucie
City of Port St.Lucie Blvd.
Port St. Lucie, Florida
34984
City Council
Meeting Minutes
Gregory J. Oravec, Mayor
Stephanie Morgan, Councilwoman, District I
John Carvelli, Councilman, District II
Shannon Martin, Vice Mayor, District III
Jolien Caraballo, Councilwoman, District IV
Monday, September 23, 2019 7:00 PM Council Chambers, City Hall
Meeting to begin at 7:00PM or to immediately follow 6:30PM Budget Hearing
1. Meeting Called to Order
A Regular Meeting of the CITY COUNCIL of the City of Port St. Lucie was called to
order by Mayor Oravec on September 23, 2019, at 7:10 p.m., at Port St. Lucie City
Hall, 121 SW Port St. Lucie Boulevard, Port St. Lucie, Florida.
2. Roll Call
Council Members
Present: Mayor Gregory J. Oravec
Vice Mayor Shannon Martin
Councilwoman Jolien Caraballo
Councilman John Carvelli
Councilwoman Stephanie Morgan
3. Invocation & Pledge of Allegiance
Mayor Oravec noted that the Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance were performed
at the Special City Council meeting, which was held at 6:36 p.m.
4. Proclamations and Special Presentations
Proclamation - Breast Cancer Awareness Month and Making Strides Against Breast Cancer
Day
(Clerk's Note: This item was added at the meeting by Mayor Oravec.) Mayor
Oravec read the Proclamation into the record, and presented it to Denise Avril, a
breast cancer survivor.
Page 1 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
5. Public to be Heard
Diane Goldberg spoke about an increase in taxes because of property value, a
one-mill increase for the School District, and an increase in stormwater and waste
collection. She asked the Council to delay the vote for an increase in their salaries
until it was known whether a recession would occur next year.
Steve Carroll spoke against the proposed increase in the City Council's salaries.
Vice Mayor Martin said that the Stormwater Fee was not going up this year. She
said that the issue of Council raises was brought up by citizens, not the
Councilmembers. Mayor Oravec reminded Ms. Goldberg that the one mill increase
for the Schhol District did not have anything to do with the City.
6. Additions or Deletions to Agenda and Approval of Agenda
There being no discussion, Vice Mayor Martin moved to approve the Agenda.
Councilwoman Morgan seconded the motion, which passed unanimously by voice
vote.
7. Approval of Consent Agenda
Mayor Oravec stated that Item 7 f) was requested to be pulled and brought back at
a future meeting. Councilwoman Caraballo requested that Item 7 b) be removed for
separate discussion. VIce Mayor Martin moved to approve the Consent Agenda,
with Item 7 b) removed for separate discussion, and Item 7 f) pulled and
rescheduled to a future date. Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion, which
passed unanimously by voice vote.
7.a August 26, 2019 Regular Council and August 30, 2019 Special 2019-849
Emergency Council Meeting Minutes
7.b Approval to Participate in the Sourcewell Cooperative (Coop) 2019-765
Contract #051717 for Low Speed Vehicles, Medium Speed
Vehicles, and Utility Related Equipment, Accessories, and
Supplies (Golf Carts).
Councilwoman Caraballo commended staff for reducing the cost of the
contract. She asked if golfers typically used GPS on their phones
instead of the golf carts, to which Councilman Carvelli replied that the
GPS in the cart was used to control where the cart could go, and avoid
damage to the golf course. Councilwoman Caraballo moved to approve
Item 7 b). Councilman Carvelli seconde the motion, which passed
unanimously by voice vote.
Page 2 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
7.c Award Contract #20190062 for Geotechnical Services for 2019-815
Westport Wastewater Treatment Plant Phase 2 Expansion to
Ardaman and Associates, Inc.
7.d Request to Subordinate City’s Mortgage in Pending 2019-828
Foreclosure Action
7.e Award Contract #20190093 to Furnish and Install Asphaltic 2019-841
Concrete Paving under 200 tons.
7.f Authorize payment to the Economic Development Council of 2019-844
St. Lucie County for the Annual Investment Partnership.
7.g Approve Declaration of Surplus and On-Line Auction for 2019-851
Departmental Fixed Asset Items.
7.h Acceptance of FY 2019-2020 Victim of Crime Act (VOCA) 2019-846
Grant - Grant # VOCA-2019-City of Port St. Lucie-00450
7.i Motion to approve a Minor Site Plan for 9200 Express Car 2019-635
Wash (P18-174)
7.j Award Contract #20190113 for the construction of the 2019-855
Torino Parkway roundabouts at Cashmere Blvd. and
California Blvd.
8. Second Reading, Public Hearing of Ordinances
Page 3 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.a Ordinance 19-45, Public Hearing, Motion to adopt ordinance 2019-835
amending the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Port St.
Lucie to include a large scale amendment to the future land
use map to change the future land use designation of
approximately 16.17 acres from Commercial General (CG)
and .72 acres from Open Space Conservation (OSC) to 16.89
acres of the future land use designations of High Density
Residential/Commercial General /Open Space Conservation
(RH/CG/OSC) for the Six Diamonds property, generally
located west of U.S. Highway No. 1, east of Morningside
Boulevard, and approximately 840 feet south of Lyngate
Drive (P19-053).
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-45 aloud by title only. Long-Range
Planning Administrator Tobin stated that the item was a Large-Scale
Comprehensive Plan Amendment, and it was the adoption Public
Hearing. She explained that the property's location was between US1
and Morningside, just south of Lyngate, and said that the Future Land
Use designation was General Commercial and Open Space
Recreation. She said that the purpose of the Amendment was to
combine all the Land Uses together. The Long-Range Planning
Administrator advised that the PLanning and Zoning Board
recommended approval of the item in a 6-1 vote, and the Council
unanimously voted to transmit the item. No negative comments were
received from local, State, or Regional agencies.
Mayor Oravec asked if the Council or any member of the public wished
to speak, to which there was no response. Michael Houston, HJA
Design Studio, stated that he represented the applicant. He said that he
would be submitting a PUD within a week, and there would be a new
project within the CRA, on US1. There being no further discussion,
Councilwoman Morgan moved to approve Ordinance 19-45.
Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion. The City Clerk restated the
motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-45. The motion passed
unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 4 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.b Ordinance 19-61, An Ordinance Amending Ch. 92 “Animals” 2019-867
Of The City Of Port St. Lucie Code Of Ordinances To Add Sec.
92.19 To Authorize The City Manager To Institute A Pilot
Trap, Neuter, Vaccinate And Release Program; Providing For
Conflict; Providing For Severability; Providing An Effective
Date.
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-61 aloud by title only. The City
Manager stated that the Ordinance would provide a Pilot Program to
trap, neuter, vaccinate and release cats back into the wild. He said that
it was a way to control the feral cat population long-term, and was
proven to be effective.
Councilwoman Caraballo noted that feral cats were very different from
domestic cats. Mayor Oravec asked if any member of the public wished
to speak.
Diane Goldberg said that she was the Conservation Chair for the St.
Lucie Audubon and asked the Council to consider running a
Consignment Program for the feral cats, instead of releasing them back
into the wild.
Mayor Oravec asked if any other member of the public wished to
speak. There being no response, Vice Mayor Martin moved to approve
Ordinance 19-61. Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion. The City
Clerk restated the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-61.
The motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 5 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.c Ordinance 19-62, An Ordinance Amending Ch. 92 “Animals” 2019-868
Of The City Of Port St. Lucie, Florida, Code Of Ordinances By
Amending Section 92.01 “Definitions” And Section 92.14
“Animal Care; Manner Of Keeping” To Revise And Provide
Additional Restrictions For The Tethering Of Animals;
Providing For Codification; Providing For Conflict; Providing
For Severability; Providing An Effective Date.
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-62 aloud by title only. The City
Manager stated that the Ordinance provided provisions prohibiting
tethering of certain periods of time, and matched an ordinance passed
by Fort Pierce. Mayor Oravec asked if any members of the Council or
the public wished to speak, to which there was no response.
Councilman Carvelli moved to approve Ordinance 19-62.
Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the motion. The City Clerk restated
the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-62. The motion
passed unanimously by roll call vote.
8.d Ordinance 19-63, Motion to Adopt an Ordinance Abandoning 2019-869
a Portion of a Twenty (20) Foot Utility and Drainage
Easement Affecting Lot 3, Block 1670, Port St. Lucie Section
Thirty-One, recorded in Plat Book 14, Page(s) 22, 22A
through 22G, of the Public Records of St. Lucie County.
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-63 aloud by title only. Mayor Oravec
opened the Public Hearing and asked if any member of the public, or
the applicant, wished to speak, to which there was no response. There
being no discussion, Councilwoman Caraballo moved to approve
Ordinance 19-63. Councilwoman Morgan seconded the motion. The
City Clerk restated the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance
19-63. The motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 6 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.e Ordinance 19-64, Public Hearing, Approve an Ordinance for 2019-870
Water, Wastewater, and Reclaimed Water Rate Increase for
FY 2019-20
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-64 aloud by title only. Mayor Oravec
opened the Public Hearing. The City Manager stated the the item was
the annual Water/Wastewater/Reclaimed Water rates, with a few minor
revisions. He said that there was a proposed increase of 1.6%
annually, which matched the CPI Urban Rate for the area, and would
effectively keep the rates the same in total dollars raised.
Councilwoman Caraballo asked if the item would help with the debt and
bonds related to Utilities, to which the City Manager responded in the
affirmative, and explained that because the City kept the rates
consistent with the cost of providing services it helped maintain a bond
rating that increased in a positive manner, while lowering the costs of
borrowing in the future. He said that a recent study conducted for the
Council showed that if rates were raised approximately 1.6%, there
would be no need to borrow for several years, and the Utilities System
would continue to be well-maintained. Mayor Oravec added that there
was a series of articles in Florida Trend about the need for water and
wastewater systems in the State, as overall, the State was not
adequately investing in developing freshwater supplies to meet the
growing demand.
Mayor Oravec asked if any members of the public wished to speak.
There being no response, he closed the Public Hearing. There being
no further discussion, Vice Mayor Martin moved to approve Ordinance
19-64. Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion. The CIty Clerk
restated the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-64. The
motion passed unanimously by roll call vote. Councilwoman Caraballo
noted that the Stormwater Fee was not increasing.
Page 7 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.f Ordinance 19-65, An Ordinance Amending Chapter 32, 2019-871
Article VIII, Section 32.77 of the Code of Ordinances of the
City of Port St. Lucie with respect to the Police Officers’
Retirement Trust Fund
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-65 aloud by title only. The City
Manager explained that the Ordinance was specific to the participants
in the Police Officers' Retirement Trust Fund. He said that several
years ago, a number of Officers were in a Defined Contribution Plan
and were offered the opportunity to enter into the Defined Benefit Plan,
which some did. He said that now, some of the Officers were entering
DROP or getting ready to retire, and an inconsistency was discovered
in how Sick Leave was accounted for in the Defined Benefit Plan. The
Ordinance would correct the inconsistency. It was looked at from an
actuarial standpoint and there was no negative impact. He stated that
staff recommended approval.
Mayor Oravec asked if there were any questions for the City Manager,
to which there was no response. There being no discussion,
Councilwoman Caraballo moved to approve Ordinance 19-65. Vice
Mayor Martin seconded the motion. Mayor Oravec opened the Public
Hearing and asked if anyone was present to speak on the item. There
being no response, he closed the Public Hearing. The City Clerk
restated the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-65. The
motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 8 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
8.g Ordinance 19-67, An Ordinance Approving Agreement as to 2019-873
Park and Recreational Facilities Impact Fees and Off-Site
Drainage for Park Site 1
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-67 aloud by title only. Mayor Oravec
opened the Public Hearing. Deputy City Attorney Hertz stated that the
item was an agreement with GL Homes to give Impact Fee Credits for
the construction of park improvements on Park Site #1, within the
Riverland Development. She said that the estimated Impact Fee Credit
for the park improvements was $2,354,000.
Mayor Oravec asked if any member of the public wished to speak on
the item. There being no response, he closed the Public Hearing.
Councilwoman Morgan moved to approve Ordinance 19-67.
Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the motion. Vice Mayor Martin
pointed out that the Ordinance would give GL Homes the ability to build
the park quicker. Mayor Oravec said that the park was in the CIP,
which would make one think that the City was spending money on it,
but GL Homes was going to build it and get credits. The City Clerk
restated the motion as follows: for approval of Ordinance 19-67. The
motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
A break was called at 8:20 p.m., and the meeting resumed at 8:26 p.m.
9. Other Public Hearings
There was nothing scheduled under this item.
10. First Reading of Ordinances
10.a Ordinance 19-68, Adopt an Ordinance Authorizing the 2019-829
Conveyance of Real Property Located at Crosstown Parkway
(pf 63-34) Lot 2, Acquired by the City on October 28, 2010,
which was Identified and Approved for Surplus on April 8,
2019.
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-68 aloud by title only. There being no
discussion, Vice Mayor Martin moved to approve Ordinance 19-68.
Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion, which passed unanimously
by voice vote.
Page 9 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
10.b Ordinance 19-66, Motion to Adopt Ordinance Amending 2019-872
Section 158.174(G) of the Zoning Code to Modify the
Provisions for Off-Street Parking and Off-Street Loading
Requirements for Planned Unit Developments (PUDS).
The City Clerk read Ordinance 19-66 aloud by title only. There being no
discussion, Councilwoman Morgan moved to approve Ordinance
19-66. Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the motion, which passed
unanimously by voice vote.
11. Resolutions
11.a Resolution 19-R87, Approving Naming City Park #1 Riverland 2019-876
Paseo Park.
The City Clerk read Resolution 19-R87 aloud by title only. Mayor
Oravec asked if the Council had any questions for staff, to which there
was no response. There being no discussion, Vice Mayor Martin moved
to approve Resolution 19-R87. Councilwoman Morgan seconded the
motion. The City Clerk restated the motion as follows: for approval of
Resolution 19-R87. The motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
11.b Resolution 19-R88, Adopt Resolution approving the 2019-837
Preliminary and Final Subdivision Plat for Southern Grove
Plat No. 2 - Community Boulevard (P19-134)
The City Clerk read Resolution 19-R88 aloud by title only. Mayor
Oravec asked the City Manager if there was a presentation, to which
the City Manager replied that it was at the Council's desire. Several
Councilmembers indicated that a presentation was not necessary.
There being no discussion, Councilwoman Morgan moved to approve
Resolution 19-R88. Vice Mayor Martin seconded the motion. The City
Clerk restated the motion as follows: for approval of Resolution 19-R88.
The motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 10 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
11.c Resolution 19-R89, Authorizing the City Manager or his 2019-875
Designee to enter and execute an interlocal agreement
between the City of Port St. Lucie and the Treasure Coast
Regional Planning Council for the purpose of developing a
master plan for the approximately 1,150 acres of land
located in the Southern Grove Development of Regional
Impact.
The City Clerk read Resolution 19-R89 aloud by title only. Interim
Planning and Zoning Director Lamar-Sarno stated that Kim Delaney,
with the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council, was in the
audience. She stated that on August 20, 2019, the GFC Board
recommended that City staff move forward with an Interlocal
Agreement to hire the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council to
work on the Southern Grove Master Plan, and directed staff to provide
a sub-consultant list, which was provided in the supporting
documentation. She said that a scope of service, with a timeline, was
also attached. She said that if unsolicited proposals were submitted,
staff could work with them.
Mayor Oravec stated that the scope and timeline may be missing from
his packet. Councilwoman Caraballo asked for backup to be provided
in a timely fashion, as she observed the scope and timeline paperwork
being placed on the dais when she arrived, and did not have time to
properly review it. She asked the City Manager to consider creating a
policy that staff highlight or indicate what is being changed when there
is an addendum or revision. Councilman Carvelli asked for a cutoff
point for the preparation of documents, going forward. Councilwoman
Caraballo addressed Dr. Delaney, and said that she was supportive of
the partnership, but it was a procedural issue. The City Manager stated
that he was not aware that the information was handed out, and that
typically, staff tried to not have any handouts after Friday. Vice Mayor
Martin said that a red line showing changes would be the best way to
do it, going forward. Mayor Oravec said that the Site Plan was easy, but
the scope, timeline, and Master Planning process was the meat of the
item. He agreed that addendums should be in strikethrough/underline
format, and highlighted. Mayor Oravec asked the City Clerk if there was
a meeting on October 14th, to which she responded in the affirmative.
There being no further discussion, Councilman Carvelli moved to table
Resolution 19-R89 to the Regular City Council meeting of October
14th. Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the motion. The City Clerk
Page 11 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
restated the motion as follows: for approval to table Resolution 19-R89
to the City Council meeting of October 14th. The motion passed
unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 12 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
11.d Resolution 19-R90, Interlocal Agreement for Emergency 2019-880
Animal Services
The City Clerk read Resolution 19-R90 aloud by title only. The City
Manager stated that the Resolution was authorizing an Emergency
Animal Services Agreement between St. Lucie County and Fort Pierce.
He added that there were some last minute changes that staff was not
asking the Council to adopt, specifically. He asked that the Council
adopt the Resolution, allowing him and staff to make changes, and it
would be brought back for finalization at the Regular Council meeting
on October 14th. Mayor Oravec asked if the City Manager needed
approval for the interim. The City Attorney replied in the affirmative that
it needed to be in place by October 1st, and under Florida Law, an
Interlocal Agreement required Council approval. He asked the Council
to approve the City Manager to continue negotiations, as the Interlocal
Agreement was temporary. He said that it would be brought back for
ratification and added that it was the same process that St. Lucie
County and Fort Pierce were proposing to their Commissions.
Mayor Oravec said that there had to be somewhere to take the
animals, beginning October 1st. He asked the City Attorney to explain
termination and how the City could be removed from the Agreement.
The City Attorney replied that this was one of the most recent sticking
points, as the agreements had a Cancellation for Convenience Clause,
but the County wanted the City to lock in for a guaranteed 90 days and
the City and Fort Pierce were unwilling to do so. He said that he would
not be approving anything that locked the City in. Mayor Oravec asked
why staff didn't recommend to give the City Manager an emergency
authorization, and have it ratified after, to which the City Attorney
replied that there were several changes to the language since what
was provided with the Agenda. He said that what was in the packet was
not the most recent thing that the County proposed, but he was asking
the Council to give the City Manager authority to enter the Agreement,
and it would be brought for ratification on October 14th. Councilman
Carvelli asked whether the Council was authorizing the approval of the
contract, to which the City Attorney responded in the negative, and said
that Senior Deputy City Attorney Norbraten could explain it better.
Mayor Oravec said that he did not like being asked to vote on
something that he was not sure of, to which the City Attorney replied
that when the Agreement was done, a Special Council meeting could
be called. Mayor Oravec said that he was comfortable with the Council
directing the City Manager to enter into an Interlocal Agreement, on
Page 13 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
behalf of the City, for Emergency Animal Control Services, provided
that there was a Cancellation for Convenience Clause. The City
Attorney replied that it was made clear to the County that the City could
only agree to it if it had a Cancellation for Convenience Clause, which
was the City's right under law.
Senior Deputy City Attorney Norbraten stated that the County contacted
her on Friday with requested changes to the 90-day provision. The
County had a piece of property that the City would like to use as a
temporary shelter, but the County was concerned that they needed 3
months' commitment for it to be fiscally feasible. She said that what
they asked for was not necessarily unreasonable, and that their
concern was that they did not want the temporary solution to become a
permanent solution. She said that the Resolution was allowing the City
Manager to negotiate up to the PD's budgeted funds for Animal
Services. She said that she did not think that such a high number would
be reached, as it was supposed to be a temporary solution. She said
that the County and the City were not far apart, but there were a few
issues where they differed.
Vice Mayor Martin pointed out that the County Facility was located at
the Airport. She said that currently, a majority of the animals in the City
were taken to the Glades Facility, and asked how much more travel
time and out-of-service time there would be, versus taking them to a
location such as Palm City. Chief Bolduc said that it would work if staff
knew who the vendor was going to be, but right now, there was a
third-party who had indicated an interest in being the Emergency
Center Operator. He said that once the City got past the Interlocal
Agreement, a request for an offer could be made. Vice Mayor Martin
said that if the City went with the Humane Society of the Treasure
Coast, it would be less travel time and they had already indicated that
they would be willing to help. Chief Bolduc said that if it got to the point
where the City was negotiating with the Humane Society of the
Treasure Coast, there was a clear indication that it would be the most
efficient for both parties. Mayor Oravec asked if the City had to go
through the solicitation process for a long-term vendor, to which Chief
Bolduc responded in the affirmative, and said that the first step was to
get the 3 parties to agree about how they were going to contract a
third-party. Ms. Norbraten said that in the Interlocal Agreement and the
Resolution, the County or a third-party vendor would be manning the
Airport location. Councilman Carvelli asked the City Manager if he
anticipated that the costs for Emergency Services was within his
Page 14 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
spending authority, to which the City Manager responded in the
affirmative, and added that he did anticipate that it would cost more
than what was budgeted for FY20 in the total year. He said that staff
was asking for the Council's approval to allow him to enter into an
emergency contract in a form that was somewhat similar to the
Emergency Interlocal Agreement that was provided to them, but with
the inclusion of a Cancellation Clause. He said that the Agreement
would be provided at the next Regular Council meeting. Councilwoman
Caraballo asked if the County was prepared to allow adoptions and get
the animals placed, while the City was waiting for a long-term solution,
to which Chief Bolduc replied that the emergency sheltering would
include all components of a shelter, such as what was currently in
place. He said that the shelter to the south had been responsive to the
needs of the animals in the County, and was helping as the situation
unfolded. Councilwoman Caraballo said that it was important to make
sure that the animals got adopted, and that the public knew where to
go.
Vice Mayor Martin said that she was concerned about how taxing it
would be on Animal Control to take the animals to the Airport. Chief
Bolduc said that the mandatory 5-day holds would be done, and the
trips would not occur every time a stray was picked up, but possibly one
trip a week. Mayor Oravec asked if there was a scenario where the City
could contract with alternate providers, to which Chief Bolduc replied
that an RFP could be put out. Mayor Oravec asked if all bidding could
be waived, under an emergency, to which Ms. Norbraten replied that
the City had the ability, but the goal was to work as a team with the
other entities, and Fort Pierce would issue the RFP. She said that the
the County was asking that the City could only opt out after 90 days,
that there would be 3-month increment extensions of the agreement,
and $2,000 additional after May from each entity to make up for lost
revenue. Councilman Carvelli asked if it was possible to do an RFP and
get a provider within 90 days, to which the City Manager replied that it
would be very close.
Councilwoman Caraballo asked Chief Bolduc if he thought that the City
should work with the Interlocal situation or eventually look at a
third-party provider. Chief Bolduc replied that animal sheltering was
most cost-effective when there was an economy of scale, and his
research showed that the group seeking sheltering services seemed to
get prices down to cost the taxpayers the least. He said that was the
reason why all 3 entities wanted to work together and that in many
Page 15 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
places, there were regional shelters. He said that there were short-term
legal issues causing the City to not take a direct path there.
Councilwoman Caraballo moved to approve Resolution 19-R90.
Councilman Carvelli seconded the motion. Mayor Oravec stated that he
was concerned that the newspaper reported that people would not be
able to surrender animals to the temporary shelter. He said that he was
not okay with it, as dogs would be abandoned in the streets. Vice
Mayor Martin said that Melissa McInturff discovered that 83 animals
were dropped off at the Humane Society of St. Lucie County in the last
3 weeks. Chief Bolduc said that the City of Port St. Lucie was not going
to turn residents away and if people were having issues keeping their
animals because of food or vaccinations, the City could try to help
them. Vice Mayor Martin asked what the citizens would be told if they
wanted to surrender animals, to which Chief Bolduc replied that if
someone lived in the City and could no longer care for their animal,
they could call Animal Control. Vice Mayor Martin said that the
message had to get out. Mayor Oravec asked Chief Bolduc what the
capacity of the shelter was, to which Chief Bolduc replied that he did
not know. Mayor Oravec asked him to follow up and provide an answer.
He asked the City Manager to provide an official statement to the public
regarding what was being done and explaining the transition period.
Councilwoman Caraballo asked if a temporary contract could be done
with the Humane Society of the Treasure Coast to turn over animals
that were surrendered. Mayor Oravec said that he wouldn't mind
entering into a contract with them, but a motion was made and the
Council had to support the City Manager to work it out during the bridge
period. The City Attorney suggested amending the motion to give the
City Manager the authority to execute the Interlocal Agreement, or if it
failed, to enter into an emergency agreement, perhaps with the
Humane Society of the Treasure Coast, on a temporary basis until the
3 parties could come together, or the City did an RFP. Councilwoman
Caraballo amended her motion as follows: to approve Resolution
19-R90, with the stipulation regarding the Interlocal Agreement, as
stated by the City Attorney. Councilman Carvelli seconded the
amended motion. The City Clerk restated the motion as follows: to
approve Resolution 19-R90, with the stipulation regarding the Interlocal
Agreement, as stated by the City Attorney. The motion passed
unanimously by roll call vote.
Page 16 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
11.e Resolution 19-R91, Authorizing the Acquisition of Real 2019-884
Property located at 1333 SE Floresta Drive in Port St. Lucie
for the Floresta Drive Improvement Project.
The City Clerk read Resolution 19-R91 aloud by title only. The City
Manager stated that there was no presentation, unless needed. Mayor
Oravec asked if it was for a u-turn. Public Works Director Sweeney
replied that it was for one of 3 u-turns on the project, which the City was
going to need property for. He said that the parcel was for sale and
staff wanted to accelerate the purchase of the property. Mayor Oravec
asked if there were any questions of staff, to which there was no
response. There being no further discussion, Vice Mayor Martin moved
to approve Resolution 19-R91. Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the
motion. The City Clerk restated the motion as follows: for approval of
Resolution 19-R91. The motion passed unanimously by roll call vote.
12. Unfinished Business
There was nothing scheduled under this item.
13. New Business
Page 17 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
13.a Approve Draft 2020 State Legislative Program 2019-881
Deputy City Attorney Gilbert stated that the 2020 Legislative Session
was going to convene on January 14, 2020, due to the approval of the
Florida Constitution Amendment that was on the ballot in 2018. She
said that staff had an accelerated schedule to approve the Legislative
Program. The St. Lucie County Legislative Delegation was due to meet
on October 7th at Indian River State College. The Draft Program given
to the Council reflected the priorities from 2019, as well as
septic-to-sewer conversion and additional projects from departmental
recommendations. She asked the Council to provide the City's priorities
for the 2020 session. She said that staff was recommending a change
to the title of the McCarty Ranch item, as the Lobbyist indicated that the
City should convey the project with its true intention of water quality
restoration. She said that additionally, the Southern Grove Hegener
Drive Extension, the Riverwalk Extension Project, and the
Septic-to-Sewer Conversion Project were the highest priorities
recommended by staff. Recommendations that came from the
departments included the James E. Anderson Water Treatment Plant
Well Field in the amount of $2.4 million, the Veterans' Memorial Water
Quality Management Improvement Project, the Westport Wastewater
Treatment Facility, and additional monies for recreation. The City was
supporting the following requests: the St. Lucie County Legislative
Program in areas with like issues, the Florida Department of
Transportation's Work Program, the Village Green Corridor
Revitalization, the East Coast Greenway, the Indian River Lagoon
South, and Everglades Restoration. The City was also recommending
support of policies that were resolutions approved by the Florida
League of Cities' Policy Committees.
Councilman Carvelli said that he was okay with the Top 3, but he was
concerned about asking for funding for the Wastewater Treatment
Facility, as it was a customer service request. Mayor Oravec agreed,
and said that grants could be looked into. Ms. Gilbert pointed out that
the Septic-to-Sewer Conversion was the 4th priority, to which Mayor
Oravec agreed and said that Riverwalk was at the bottom and it had to
be laid out better. He said that he did not want to present other
requests. Ms. Gilbert asked if Mayor Oravec wished to remove all other
requests. Mayor Oravec replied that the Council focused on the most
strategic priorities.
Councilwoman Caraballo asked when appropriations requests would
be cut off, to which Ms. Gilbert replied that November 15th was the
Page 18 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
Senate deadline and the Lobbyist was requesting that all forms be
submitted by September 27th. Councilwoman Caraballo stated that she
was okay with the Water Quality Restoration Area 4 Project and the
Hegener Drive Extension. She said that there was grant funding that
would complete the Riverwalk, connecting to the Westmoreland Tract.
The City Manager replied that the funding would take the project up to
the bridge. She asked that materials be updated through the process,
to provide pictures and diagrams of exact locations of the connections
for the Riverwalk Extension Project, to show what was being asked.
She asked that the name for the Riverwalk Extension Project be
changed to make it more marketable to the Legislature, such as adding
Tourism to the title. She said that she agreed with the Septic-to-Sewer
Conversion Project. Mayor Oravec said that he thought that the
Riverwalk Project was the weakest, as it was vetoed 2 years ago. He
suggested calling the Riverwalk Extension Project the Missing Link.
Councilwoman Caraballo said that she was okay with approving things
internally, and asked that supporting projects not necessarily be
submitted but could be ready to go if the opportunity presented. Ms.
Gilbert asked if they would be included as requests in the program, but
submit the forms, to which Councilwoman Caraballo replied that she
thought the internal documents should be completed in case there was
an opportunity, but not submit it in the Legislative Program, nor include
it as a request.
Mayor Oravec said that he was okay with submitting forms on the 4
priorities, and asked if the Council agreed, to which the
Councilmembers responded in the affirmative. Councilman Carvelli said
that he would like to invite the delegation in to explain the requests and
get them on board. Councilwoman Caraballo asked Mayor Oravec how
he wished to proceed, to which Mayor Oravec stated that Senator
Harrell and Representative Hogan-Johnson were very supportive of the
McCarty Ranch. Ms. Gilbert said that Senator Mayfield is the
Subcommittee Chair for the 2 water projects. She suggested finding a
way to enhance the relationship with Senator Mayfield. Mayor Oravec
pointed out that Hegener Extension made its way to the Governor, but
was vetoed. He informed that Senator Harrell said that Septic-to-Sewer
had to be a 50/50 match, which could be the no-interest loan or what
the customer was going to pay. He asked if construction funding for
C-23 St. Lucie River Water Quality Restoration Area 4 was not being
asked for, in hopes that water supply money would be received, to
which Ms. Gilbert responded in the affirmative. Councilman Carvelli
said that there had to be verbiage indicating that it would impact the
Page 19 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
Treasure Coast Region.
There being no further discussion, Councilman Carvelli moved to
approve Item 13 a), with the list of the C-23 St. Lucie River Water
Quality Restoration Area 4, Septic-to-Sewer, Southern Grove, and
Riverwalk. Councilwoman Caraballo seconded the motion and informed
Ms. Gilbert that she wanted to meet with her and the City Manager to
discuss whether there were other State opportunities for the Village
Green Corridor Revitalization Project. Mayor Oravec said that the
application for the Federal grant was not strong. The City Clerk restated
the motion as follows: for approval of Item 13 a), with the list of the
C-23 St. Lucie River Water Quality Restoration Area 4,
Septic-to-Sewer, Southern Grove, and Riverwalk. The City Manager
said that other funding opportunities would be pursued for the other
requests.
14. City Manager's Report
The City Manager announced that the Grand Opening of the Crosstown Parkway
Bridge would be on September 28th, and would begin with an official ceremony at
9:00 a.m., a Ribbon-cutting at 10:00 a.m., and a procession going over the Bridge.
He said that at 4:00 p.m., the Bridge would be officially opened. He said that there
would be tents from community businesses and a children's play area. Mayor
Oravec thanked the sponsors and asked the City Manager to make sure that the
traffic signals were working the way they were supposed to.
Page 20 of 21
City Council Meeting Minutes September 23, 2019
15. Councilmembers Report on Committee Assignments
Councilwoman Morgan attended the Treasure Coast Safe Kids Board meeting, the
Chamber of Commerce's State of the County, and the Fire Board.
Councilman Carvelli said that tourists would be coming soon, and the signals on
the Crosstown Parkway had to be operational as soon as possible. He said that he
met with the Citizens Oversight Committee.
Councilwoman Caraballo attended the September 11th Ceremony, the Prima Vista
Repaving Public Information Meeting, a Birthday Party with Sandpiper Bay, the
Realtors' Association Breakfast, the Treasure Coast Regional League of Cities
Meeting, the Chamber of Commerce's State of the County, the Florida League of
Cities Executive Committee Meeting and Board of Directors Meeting.
Vice Mayor Martin said that the Fire Board's Millage remained the same.
Mayor Oravec stated that Councilwoman Morgan was appointed to be the primary
for the Roundtable, and he would be the alternate. he attended the Treasure Coast
Regional Planning Council meeting. He said that he would be in Washington, D.C.
to lobby for continued funding for Everglades Restoration, and he would be in
Gainesville to lecture about water quality.
16. Public to be Heard - (if necessary as determined by City Council at conclusion of
public to be heard)
There was nothing head under this item.
17. Adjourn
There being no futher business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:20 p.m.
________________________________
Karen A. Phillips, City Clerk
________________________________
Jeannette C. Baechle, Deputy City Clerk
Page 21 of 21
Agenda
City of Port St.Lucie
121 SW Port St. Lucie Blvd.
Port St. Lucie, Florida 34984
Meeting Agenda
Meeting to begin at 7:00PM or to immediately follow 6:30PM Budget Hearing
Monday, September 23, 2019
7:00 PM
Council Chambers, City Hall
City Council
Gregory J. Oravec, Mayor
Stephanie Morgan, Councilwoman, District I
John Carvelli, Councilman, District II
Shannon Martin, Vice Mayor, District III
Jolien Caraballo, Councilwoman, District IV
City Council Meeting Agenda September 23, 2019
1. Meeting Called to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Invocation & Pledge of Allegiance
4. Proclamations and Special Presentations
5. Public to be Heard
6. Additions or Deletions to Agenda and Approval of Agenda
7. Approval of Consent Agenda
7.a August 26, 2019 Regular Council and August 30, 2019 Special 2019-849
Emergency Council Meeting Minutes
7.b Approval to Participate in the Sourcewell Cooperative (Coop) 2019-765
Contract #051717 for Low Speed Vehicles, Medium Speed
Vehicles, and Utility Related Equipment, Accessories, and
Supplies (Golf Carts).
7.c Award Contract #20190062 for Geotechnical Services for 2019-815
Westport Wastewater Treatment Plant Phase 2 Expansion to
Ardaman and Associates, Inc.
7.d Request to Subordinate City’s Mortgage in Pending 2019-828
Foreclosure Action
7.e Award Contract #20190093 to Furnish and Install Asphaltic 2019-841
Concrete Paving under 200 tons.
7.f Authorize payment to the Economic Development Council of 2019-844
St. Lucie County for the Annual Investment Partnership.
7.g Approve Declaration of Surplus and On-Line Auction for 2019-851
Departmental Fixed Asset Items.
7.h Acceptance of FY 2019-2020 Victim of Crime Act (VOCA) 2019-846
Grant - Grant # VOCA-2019-City of Port St. Lucie-00450
Page 1 of 5
City Council Meeting Agenda September 23, 2019
7.i Motion to approve a Minor Site Plan for 9200 Express Car 2019-635
Wash (P18-174)
7.j Award Contract #20190113 for the construction of the 2019-855
Torino Parkway roundabouts at Cashmere Blvd. and
California Blvd.
8. Second Reading, Public Hearing of Ordinances
8.a Ordinance 19-45, Public Hearing, Motion to adopt ordinance 2019-835
amending the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Port St. Lucie
to include a large scale amendment to the future land use
map to change the future land use designation of
approximately 16.17 acres from Commercial General (CG)
and .72 acres from Open Space Conservation (OSC) to 16.89
acres of the future land use designations of High Density
Residential/Commercial General /Open Space Conservation
(RH/CG/OSC) for the Six Diamonds property, generally
located west of U.S. Highway No. 1, east of Morningside
Boulevard, and approximately 840 feet south of Lyngate
Drive (P19-053).
8.b Ordinance 19-61, An Ordinance Amending Ch. 92 “Animals” 2019-867
Of The City Of Port St. Lucie Code Of Ordinances To Add Sec.
92.19 To Authorize The City Manager To Institute A Pilot
Trap, Neuter, Vaccinate And Release Program; Providing For
Conflict; Providing For Severability; Providing An Effective
Date.
8.c Ordinance 19-62, An Ordinance Amending Ch. 92 “Animals” 2019-868
Of The City Of Port St. Lucie, Florida, Code Of Ordinances By
Amending Section 92.01 “Definitions” And Section 92.14
“Animal Care; Manner Of Keeping” To Revise And Provide
Additional Restrictions For The Tethering Of Animals;
Providing For Codification; Providing For Conflict; Providing
For Severability; Providing An Effective Date.
Page 2 of 5
City Council Meeting Agenda September 23, 2019
8.d Ordinance 19-63, Motion to Adopt an Ordinance Abandoning 2019-869
a Portion of a Twenty (20) Foot Utility and Drainage
Easement Affecting Lot 3, Block 1670, Port St. Lucie Section
Thirty-One, recorded in Plat Book 14, Page(s) 22, 22A
through 22G, of the Public Records of St. Lucie County.
8.e Ordinance 19-64, Public Hearing, Approve an Ordinance for 2019-870
Water, Wastewater, and Reclaimed Water Rate Increase for
FY 2019-20
8.f Ordinance 19-65, An Ordinance Amending Chapter 32, 2019-871
Article VIII, Section 32.77 of the Code of Ordinances of the
City of Port St. Lucie with respect to the Police Officers’
Retirement Trust Fund
8.g Ordinance 19-67, An Ordinance Approving Agreement as to 2019-873
Park and Recreational Facilities Impact Fees and Off-Site
Drainage for Park Site 1
9. Other Public Hearings
10. First Reading of Ordinances
10.a Ordinance 19-68, Adopt an Ordinance Authorizing the 2019-829
Conveyance of Real Property Located at Crosstown Parkway
(pf 63-34) Lot 2, Acquired by the City on October 28, 2010,
which was Identified and Approved for Surplus on April 8,
2019.
10.b Ordinance 19-66, Motion to Adopt Ordinance Amending 2019-872
Section 158.174(G) of the Zoning Code to Modify the
Provisions for Off-Street Parking and Off-Street Loading
Requirements for Planned Unit Developments (PUDS).
11. Resolutions
11.a Resolution 19-R87, Approving Naming City Park #1 Riverland 2019-876
Paseo Park.
Page 3 of 5
City Council Meeting Agenda September 23, 2019
11.b Resolution 19-R88, Adopt Resolution approving the 2019-837
Preliminary and Final Subdivision Plat for Southern Grove Plat
No. 2 - Community Boulevard (P19-134)
11.c Resolution 19-R89, Authorizing the City Manager or his 2019-875
Designee to enter and execute an interlocal agreement
between the City of Port St. Lucie and the Treasure Coast
Regional Planning Council for the purpose of developing a
master plan for the approximately 1,150 acres of land located
in the Southern Grove Development of Regional Impact.
11.d Resolution 19-R90, Interlocal Agreement for Emergency 2019-880
Animal Services
11.e Resolution 19-R91, Authorizing the Acquisition of Real 2019-884
Property located at 1333 SE Floresta Drive in Port St. Lucie
for the Floresta Drive Improvement Project.
12. Unfinished Business
13. New Business
13.a Approve Draft 2020 State Legislative Program 2019-881
14. City Manager's Report
15. Councilmembers Report on Committee Assignments
16. Public to be Heard - (if necessary as determined by City Council at conclusion
of public to be heard)
17. Adjourn
Page 4 of 5
City Council Meeting Agenda September 23, 2019
Notice: No stenographic record by a certified court reporter will be made of the
foregoing meeting. Accordingly, if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the
City Council, board, agency, or commission with respect to any matter considered at
such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for
such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings
is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to
be based. (F.S. 286.0105)
Notice: Public and Press are invited to review all the backup for Council Meetings.
Copies are available in the City Clerk’s Office on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and
Monday before Council Meetings. On Meeting nights, a copy of backup material is
available in the reception area of City Hall for public review. Please leave the agenda
and backup material in good order for others to review.
Notice: Anyone wishing to speak during Public to be Heard is asked to fill out a yellow
Participation Card and submit it to the City Clerk. Anyone wishing to speak on any
Agenda Item is asked to fill out a green Participation Card and submit it to the City Clerk.
Participation Cards are available on the side table in Council Chambers, at the reception
desk in City Hall lobby, and in the City Clerk’s Office.
Notice: In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, persons
needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the City
Clerk’s Office at 772-871-5157.
As a courtesy to the people recording the meeting, please turn all cell phones to silent
or off. Thank you.
Page 5 of 5
Get email alerts for Port St. Lucie
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.