Legal Committee
Regular MeetingRoswell, NM · June 28, 2018
Minutes
Regular Meeting of the Legal Committee
Held in the Conference Room at City Hall
Thursday, June 28, 2018
Notice of this meeting was given to the public in compliance with Sections 10-15-1 through 10-
15-4 NMSA 1978 and Resolution 17-49.
ROLL CALL
The meeting convened at 4:00 p.m. with Chair Stubbs presiding; Councilors Foster, Sanchez, and
Peterson being present.
Staff present: Bill Morris, Chanel Rey, Juanita Jennings, Parker Patterson, Joe Neeb, Scott Stark,
and Monica Garcia.
Guests present: Lisa Dunlap, Larry Connolly, Xavier Acevedo, and Dennis Kintigh.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Councilor Foster moved to approve the June 28, 2018, Legal Committee meeting agenda with the
following corrections:
Item 1 to begin on page 6
Item 2 to be corrected to read “Resolution 18-43”
Item 3 to read “RFP 18-011 second posting on May 10, 2018”
Add the Addendum as Item 4 Resolution 18-44 to the agenda
Councilor Sanchez was the second. A voice vote was unanimous, and the motion passed 4-0.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Councilor Foster moved to approve the minutes from the May 31, 2018, regular Legal Committee
meeting as presented. Councilor Sanchez was the second. A voice vote was unanimous, and the
motion passed 4-0.
REGULAR ITEMS
1. RIAC Leases-
(A) New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC: Mr. Stark stated that New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC,
leases a parcel of land for the purpose of transmitting and receiving telecommunications
signals. New rent amount $1,246 monthly; $14,952 annually. Rent adjustment is 3.49%.
New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC has been a customer since August 2002. Councilor
Sanchez moved to send to full Council on consent agenda recommending approval of New
Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC to renew their lease agreement subject to all terms and
conditions of the lease. Councilor Foster was the second. A voice vote was unanimous and
the motion passed 4-0.
(B) J&S Mechanical, LLC: Mr. Stark stated the J&S Mechanical, LLC is requesting to lease
Building No. 61 for the purpose of storage. Rent amount is $260 monthly; $3,120 annually.
Term: August 1, 2018 through July 31, 2019. Councilor Foster moved to send to full
Council on consent agenda recommending approval of J&S Mechanical, LLC a new lease
agreement subject to all terms and conditions of the lease. Councilor Peterson was the
second. A voice vote was unanimous and the motion passed 4-0.
2. Resolution 18-43: Mr. Patterson and Mayor Kintigh discussed that proposed Resolution
18-43 would request that the New Mexico Department of Transportation dedicate the
pedestrian overpass on North Main adjacent to the east side of the New Mexico Military
Institute as a memorial to Army Sgt. Christopher Sanders. Councilor Foster moved to send
Resolution 18-43 to full City Council for further consideration with the following
amendments:
The addition of “and” after every “Whereas”
Change “a pedestrian overpass” to “the pedestrian overpass”
The addition of “,” to the date to read “April 30, 1985
Councilor Stubbs was the second. The motion passed 3-1, with Councilor Sanchez voting
no.
3. Cubic, Inc. Contract: Ms. Jennings discussed the contract with Cubic Inc. for advertising
and marketing services. As per the conditions of the RFP the one year budget for these
services is $355,000, which includes media placement and contractor compensation.
Councilor Foster moved to recommend to full City Council approval of the Cubic, Inc.
with the assurance of Cubic Inc. for the following amendments:
Item 4 to read “shall make no commitment”
Item 4 strike the word “your”
Item 5c. add “any extension thereof” to the end of the first sentence
Councilor Sanchez was the second. A voice vote was unanimous and the motion passed 4-
0.
4. Resolution 18-44: Councilor Stubbs discussed Resolution 18-44, amending Resolution 18-
27, which created the Roswell Airport Advisory Commission, to include a provision
providing for the size, terms, and first slate of appointments to the Commission. Mayor
Kintigh was present to answer questions. Councilor Sanchez moved to recommend to full
City Council approval of Resolution 18-44. Councilor Foster was the second. The motion
passed 3-1 with Councilor Peterson voting no.
CHAIR COMMENTS, REPORTS, ANNOUNCEMENTS
Councilor Foster discussed the failed ordinance that allowed for backyard chicken coops. He
discussed bringing this back through the Legal Committee so it can be brought back for further
consideration.
Councilor Sanchez discussed a dinner for veterans that would be held at Church on the Move
Saturday, June 30, 2018 at 5:30 p.m.
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Mr. Connolly expressed his concern with bringing the failed ordinance allowing for backyard
chicken coops back.
ADJOURN
The meeting adjourned at 5:05 p.m.
Agenda
LEGAL COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA
Thursday, June 28, 2018 at 4:00PM
City Hall Conference Room
425 N. Richardson, Roswell, NM 88201
Chair: Judy Stubbs, Ward 3
Vice Chair: Barry Foster, Ward 5
Members: George Peterson, Ward 4
Savino Sanchez, Ward 4
Staff Liason: Aaron Holloman
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Approval of the minutes from the Legal Committee meeting on May 31, 2018. (page 3)
REGULAR ITEMS
1. RIAC Leases - To recommend to full Council that the following RIAC agreements to existing leases
be placed on the Consent agenda for approval: (page 1)
(A) New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC - Consider approval to authorize New Cingular Wireless
PCS, LLC a Delaware Corporation, to amend their current lease agreement on a parcel of
land. (page 8)
(B) J&S Mechanical, LLC - Consider approval to authorize J&S Mechanical, LLC, a New
Mexico Corporation, a new lease agreement on Building No. 61. (page 10)
2. Resolution 18-47 - Recommend to City Council the adoption of Resolution 18-43, honoring the
memory of Army Sgt. Christopher Sanders and requesting that the New Mexico Department of
Transportation undertake the dedication of a pedestrian overpass on North Main adjacent to
the east side of the New Mexico Military Institute as a memorial to Sgt. Sanders. (page 12)
3. Cubic, Inc. Contract - Consider recommending that City Council approve the contract for
advertising and marketing services with Cubic, Inc. (page 15)
[continued on following page]
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --1-- City of Roswell, NM
CHAIR COMMENTS, REPORTS, ANNOUNCEMENTS
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
ADJOURN
Notice of this meeting has been given to the public in compliance with Sections 10-15-1 through 10-15-4 NMSA
1978 and Resolution 17-49.
NOTICE OF POTENTIAL QUORUM – A quorum of the City Council may or may not attend, but there will not be
debate by the City Council. The Council, acting as attendees to an informational presentation, will not be
discussing public business and no action will be taken.
If you are an individual with a disability who is in need of a reader, amplifier, qualified sign language interpreter,
or any other form of auxiliary aid or service to attend or participate in the hearing or meeting, please contact
Human Resources at 575-624-6700 at least one week prior to the meeting or as soon as possible. Public documents
including the agenda and minutes can be provided in various accessible formats. Please contact the City Clerk at
575-624-6700 if a summary or other type of accessible format is needed.
Printed and posted: Friday, June 22, 2018
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --2-- City of Roswell, NM
Regular Meeting of the Legal Committee
Held in the Conference Room at City Hall
May 31, 2018
Notice of this meeting was given to the public in compliance with Section 10-15-1
through 10-15-4 NMSA and Resolution 17-49.
ROLL CALL
The meeting convened at 4:04 p.m. with Chair Stubbs presiding and Councilors
Peterson, Sanchez present. Councilor Foster was absent.
Staff present: Scott Stark, Aaron Hollman, Bill Bartlett, Devin Graham, Ana Nieto,
Lupita Everett, and Parker Patterson.
Guests present: Larry Connolly and Alison Penn.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Councilor Sanchez moved to approve the May 31, 2018, 2018, Legal Committee
meeting agenda, removing item number 1A, NM DOT lease, under regular items
and item number 7 Award ITB 18-004. Councilor Peterson was the second. A voice
vote was 3-0, and the motion passed.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Councilor Peterson moved to approve the April 30, 2018 Legal Committee minutes
with the corrections. Councilor Sanchez was the second. A voice vote was 3-0, and
the motion passed.
REGULAR ITEMS
1. RIAC agreements-
(A) Veterinarians Outlet of NM, Inc. - Mr. Stark stated that Veterinarians Outlet of NM,
Inc. leases a portion of the building for the purpose of soaps, sanitizers, and
detergents associated with the dairy industry. New rent amount is $1,567 monthly;
$18,804 annually. Rent adjustment is 2.53%. Veterinarians Outlet of NM, Inc. has
been customer since June 2006. Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full Council
on consent agenda recommending approval of Veterinarians Out of NM, Inc. to
renew his lease agreement on building no. 112A subject to all terms and conditions
of the lease. Councilor Peterson was the second. A voice vote was 3-0, and the
motion passed.
(B) Walker Aviation Museum Fdn. - Mr. Stark stated that Walker Aviation Museum
Foundation leases the office space for operating a museum associated with the
former Walker Air Force Base. Rent amount is $154 monthly; $1,848 annually.
Rent adjustment is 2.67%. Walker Aviation Museum Foundation has been a
customer since July 2010. Councilor Peterson moved to send to full Council on
consent agenda recommending approval of Walker Aviation Museum Foundation
to renew their lease agreement in building no. 1 subject to all terms and conditions
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --3-- City of Roswell, NM
of the lease. Councilor Sanchez was the second. A voice vote was 3-0, and the
motion passed.
(C) Partain - Mr. Stark stated Partain leases the building for the purpose of aircraft
storage and maintenance. Rent amount is $188 monthly; $2,256 annually. Rent
adjustment is 2.17%. David L. Partain has been a customer since July 2002.
Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full Council on consent agenda recommending
approval of Partain renew their lease agreement on “T” Hangar No. 120 space 1
subject to all terms and conditions of the lease. Councilor Peterson was the second.
A voice vote was 3-0, and the motion passed.
2. Resolution 18-32-Federal Aviation Administration - Mr. Stark discussed that
Resolution 18-32 is to authorize the Mayor to accept funding assistance from the
Federal Aviation Administration on behalf of the City of Roswell. Mr. Stark stated that
the City made an application to the FAA for grant of federal funds for project
development at the RIAC, has approved projects for airport development at the RIAC,
and that it is the intent of the governing body to accept the grant offer made by the
FAA. Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full City Council to authorize the Mayor to
accept funding from Federal Aviation Administration. Councilor Peterson was second.
A voice vote was 3-0, and the motion passed
3. Resolution 18-33- Authorizing Manager to accept NM Aviation Funds.- Mr. Stark
discussed Resolution 18-33 authorizing the City Manager to apply for, accept and
execute Grant Agreements for all funding assistance from the State of New Mexico
Aviation Division on behalf of the City of Roswell for project development at the Roswell
International Air Center. Mr. Stark stated the grant of state funds is for project
development at the RIAC. The State of NM has approved projects for airport
development at the RIAC and it is the intent of the governing body to accept the grant
offers made by the State of NM through its Aviation Division. Councilor Peterson
moved to send to full City Council to authorize the City Manager to apply and accept
funding from NM Aviation. Councilor Sanchez was second. A voice vote was 3-0, and
the motion passed
4. Award of RFP 18-008 – Fleet Management and Maintenance – Ms. Everett discussed
the RFP-18-008 Fleet Management and Maintenance Service and authorization for
City Manager to enter into contract negotiations with First Vehicle Services. Ms.
Everett stated that this RFP was posted and four proposals were received on April 24,
2018. Three proposals were rejected as not responsive and the evaluation committee
reviewed one. Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full City Council on the
recommendation to award RFP 18-008 Fleet Management and Maintenance and
Councilor Peterson was the second. A voice vote was 3-0, and the motion passed.
5. Reject Award of RFP 18-014 - Ms. Everett discussed that this RFP was posted and
two proposals were received on April 24, 2018. One proposal was rejected and one
was evaluated. Ms. Everett stated that the Evaluation Committee’s recommendation
was to reject proposals and to terminate RFP-18-014 Fire Apparatus Preventive
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --4-- City of Roswell, NM
Maintenance and Repair Services. Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full City
Council on the recommendation to reject award of RFP 18-014. Councilor Peterson
was the second. A voice vote was 3-0, and the motion passed.
For the Record: During the discussion of the Fire Apparatus Maintenance RFP, the
Committee considered long term development of in house personnel that can service and
maintain these vehicles for the Department.
6. Reissue RFP 18-014 - Fire Preventive Maintenance & Repair Services – Ms. Everett
discussed that staff was requesting that the revised RFP-18-014 (2nd Posting) Fire
Preventive Maintenance & Repair Services to be approved for reissuance including the
amended scope of services. Ms. Everett stated since RFP has so many rejection they will
clarify the proposals better. Councilor Sanchez moved to send to full City Council on the
recommendation to reissue RFP 18-014. Councilor Peterson was the second. A voice vote
was 3-0, and the motion passed.
7. Proposed Ordinance 18-04 - Mr. Holloman discussed the advertisement for a public
hearing of proposed Ordinance 18-04 amending Sec. 2-96 of the Roswell City Code
pertaining to definitions and applicability of the ordinance governing boards and
commissions. Mr. Holloman stated the ordinance specifies that if there need to be
any changes to the structure of a board or commission they can be outlined in the
originating document without creating a conflict in the laws. Councilor Stubbs moved
to send to full Council a recommendation to approve Proposed Ordinance 18-04
updating definitions for boards and commissions and to advertise for a public hearing
in July. Councilor Peterson was second. A voice vote was 3-0, and the motion
passed.
CHAIR COMMENTS, REPORTS, ANNOUNCEMENTS
In revisiting non-action items from previous meetings: (1) The Mayor is reviewing the
City Manager evaluation. (2) The City Manager is outlining plans for a review of financial
policies and procedures. (3) Eighth and Sycamore Street project is still moving forward
with the appraisal and survey of the property in question needed to make it a square
intersection.
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
None
ADJOURN
The meeting adjourned at 5:20 pm.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --5-- City of Roswell, NM
AGENDA ITEM NO. 1– ABSTRACT
LEGAL COMMITTEE MEETING
Thursday, June 28, 2018 at 4:00PM
City Hall Conference Room
425 N. Richardson, Roswell, NM 88201
RIAC LEASES: (A) New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC
(B) J&S Mechanical, LLC
ACTION REQUESTED: (A) Consider approval to authorize New Cingular Wireless
PCS, LLC a Delaware Corporation, to amend their current
lease agreement on a parcel of land.
(B) Consider approval to authorize J&S Mechanical, LLC, a
New Mexico Corporation, a new lease agreement on
Building No. 61.
BACKGROUND: (A) New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC, leases a parcel of land for
the purpose of transmitting and receiving
telecommunications signals. 144 square feet. New rent
amount is $1,246 monthly; $14,952 annually. Rent
adjustment is 3.49%. New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC has
been a customer since August 2002.
(B) J&S Mechanical LLC, request to lease Building No. 61 for
the purpose of storage. 1,425 square feet. Rent amount is
$260 monthly; $3,120 annually. New lease agreement
August 2018.
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATION: (A) New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC, new rent amount is
$1,246 monthly; $14,952 annually. Rent adjustment is
3.49%. Term: August 1, 2018 through July 31, 2023.
(B) J&S Mechanical LLC, new lease in the amount of, $260
monthly; $3,120 annually. Term: August 1, 2018 through
July 31, 2019.
LEGAL REVIEW: The City Attorney has reviewed the lease and
amendment.
BOARD and/or The Legal Committee is scheduled to meet on Thursday, June
COMMITTEE ACTION: 28, 2018.
[continued on following page]
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --6-- City of Roswell, NM
STAFF (A) Consider approval of an addendum to the lease
RECOMMENDATION: agreement with New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC to amend
their current lease agreement by modify the term of the
lease to last from August 1, 2018 to July 31, 2023, updating
the notice provisions, and subject to all other terms and
conditions of the lease.
(B) Consider approval of a one year lease with J&S Mechanical
of Building No. 61 consisting of 1,425 sq. ft. at the RIAC,
for $3,120 payable in 12 monthly installments of $260, to
be placed on the consent agenda subject to all other terms
and conditions of the lease.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --7-- City of Roswell, NM
THE CITY OF ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO, a municipal corporation, hereinafter called
"Landlord" and NEW CINGULAR WIRELESS PCS, LLC, a Delaware corporation hereinafter
“Tenant”, hereby agree to the following amendment to that certain Lease Agreement dated
December 12, 2013.
WHEREAS, Tenant wishes to exercise its option to lease for an additional
five (5) year period; and
WHEREAS, Tenant wishes to update its contact information;
NOW, THEREFORE, the following changes are effective with City Council
approval July 12, 2018:
1. Paragraph 2. TERM is deleted and replaced with the following:
“2. TERM The Lease term is for five (5) years, commencing on August 1,
2018 and ending July 31, 2023 unless sooner terminated by provision
hereof.”
2. Paragraph 26. b. is deleted and replaced with the following:
“b. All notices, requests or other communications to Tenant shall be given
by regular and certified mail addressed to the following:
“If to Tenant:
New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC
Attn: Network Real Estate Administration
Re: Cell Site #: NMALU0740 ; Cell Site Name: MIDWAY (NM)
Fixed Asset No.: 10139189
575 Morosgo Drive
Atlanta, GA 30324
With a copy to:
New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC
AT&T Legal Department- Network
Attn: Network Counsel
Re: Cell Site #: NMALU0740 ; Cell Site Name: MIDWAY (NM)
Fixed Asset No.: 10139189
208 S. Akard Street
Dallas, Texas, 75202-4206
Billing Address:
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --8-- City of Roswell, NM
AT&T Network Real Estate Administration
575 Morosgo Drive
Atlanta, GA 303234
REleaseadmin@att.com
1-877-231-5447
With a copy to Local Contact:
New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC
AZ/NM Property Manager
1355 W. University Drive
Mesa, AZ 85201”
3. Except as amended herein, the Lease shall continue without change,
except as modified above, and in full force and effect as originally
executed.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, this First Addendum to Lease Agreement is done and executed
in Roswell, New Mexico this ______ day of July 2018.
CITY SEAL LANDLORD:
CITY OF ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO
______________________
Dennis J. Kintigh, Mayor
______________________
Sharon Coll, City Clerk TENANT:
New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC
a Delaware limited liability company
By: AT&T Mobility Corporation
Its: Manager
By:
Name: __
Its: Area Manager
Date:
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --9-- City of Roswell, NM
THIS LEASE executed in Roswell, New Mexico on this 12th day of July, 2018 by and between the CITY OF
ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO, a municipal corporation, hereinafter designated “Landlord”, and J & S
MECHANICAL, A New Mexico Limited Liability Corporation, hereinafter designated as “Tenant”.
WHEREAS Landlord has agreed to lease to Tenant the real property described below, together with the
improvements thereon, in Chaves County New Mexico, and Tenant has agreed to lease said real property and
improvements from Landlord;
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and agreements contained herein, the parties agree
as follows
Building No. 61 consisting of 1425 square feet, more or less and the fenced area surrounding the building, located at the Roswell
International Air Center, identified on a plat attached hereto and made a part hereof, identified and listed as Exhibit "A"
(Premises).
1. GRANTING CLAUSE AND PREMISES. For the term, at the rent and otherwise upon the terms,
provisions and conditions contained herein, Landlord hereby lets and leases unto Tenant the surface only to the
following real property, together with all improvements located thereon:
2. TERM. The Lease term is for one (1) year, commencing on August 1, 2018 and ending July 31, 2019
unless sooner terminated by provision hereof.
3. RENT. Tenant agrees to pay to Landlord as rent the sum of Three Thousand One Hundred Twenty
Dollars and No Cents ($3,120.00), payable in 12 monthly installments of $260.00. Rent and other fees are due
on the first day of each month. If Tenant fails to pay all rent and other fees due for any month by the tenth calendar
day of the month that said rent and fees are due, Tenant shall pay to Landlord an additional 2% finance charge, as
a penalty, each month until the full amount of that month’s rent is paid. This penalty shall be immediately payable
without limiting Landlord in the exercise of any other right or remedy to which it may be entitled by reason of
Tenant’s failure to pay rent when due. All rent shall be paid to Landlord without abatement, reduction or set off
of any kind except as herein specifically provided.
4. SECURITY DEPOSIT. Tenant shall pay $260.00 in advance as security for Tenant’s full and faithful
performance of all terms of this lease. This amount shall be used by Landlord at the termination of this Lease
Agreement toward a. payment for rent or penalties due Landlord, b. reimbursement of the costs of cleaning and
repairing damages (beyond normal wear and tear) to the Premises and c. the cost of removal of any hazardous
material not properly disposed of by Tenant. Landlord shall be the sole and reasonable judge of all cleaning and
repairs required for the Premises and the amounts needed for these purposes. Upon termination or expiration of
this Lease the security deposit shall first be applied to necessary cleaning and removal, repairs and the remaining
balance, if any, may then be applied to rentals and penalties then owing to Landlord. Any refund of the security
deposit due Tenant will be delivered or mailed in accordance with Paragraph 26 of this Agreement within 60 days
after the termination of this Lease Agreement.
5. CONDITION OF PREMISES. Tenant has inspected Premises and accepts the Premises in its present
condition “as is”. Tenant acknowledges that any requirements for accessibility and/or public accommodation(s)
are Tenant’s responsibility. Tenant agrees that the Premises is in good repair and condition except as noted herein.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --10-- City of Roswell, NM
EXHIBIT “A”
Premises: Building No. 61 consisting of
1,425 square feet ± and the fenced area
surrounding the building.
510 East Challenger
EXHIBIT “A”
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --11-- City of Roswell, NM
AGENDA ITEM NO. 2 – ABSTRACT
LEGAL COMMITTEE MEETING
Thursday June 28, 2018 at 4:00 pm
City Hall Conference Room
425 N. Richardson, Roswell, NM 88201
Res. 18-43 – A Resolution Honoring the Memory of Army
Sergeant Christopher A. Sanders
ACTION REQUESTED: Recommend to City Council the adoption of Resolution 18-43,
honoring the memory of Army Sgt. Christopher Sanders and
requesting that the New Mexico Department of Transportation
undertake the dedication of a pedestrian overpass on North
Main adjacent to the east side of the New Mexico Military
Institute as a memorial to Sgt. Sanders.
BACKGROUND: Sgt. Christopher Sanders was a Roswell native who joined the
U.S. Army in 2004 and served with tremendous distinction in
two tours in Iraq. He was killed in action, along with five other
soldiers and their interpreter, on January 9th, 2008 in Sinsil, Iraq.
Sgt. Sander’s family has proposed dedication of a pedestrian
overpass on North Main adjacent to the east side of the New
Mexico Military Institute. This Resolution would recognize the
service and sacrifice of Sgt. Sanders and his family, and request
that NM DOT undertake the dedication of the pedestrian
overpass in his memory.
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATION: n/a
LEGAL REVIEW: The City Attorney has reviewed the proposed resolution
BOARD and/or The Legal Committee is scheduled to meet on Thursday, June
COMMITTEE ACTION: 28, 2018.
STAFF Recommend adoption by the City Council of Resolution 18-43 -
RECOMMENDATION: A Resolution Honoring the Memory of Army Sergeant
Christopher A. Sanders, recognizing the service and sacrifice of
Sgt. Sanders and his family, and requesting that NM DOT
undertake the dedication of a pedestrian overpass on North
Main adjacent to the east side of the New Mexico Military
Institute as a memorial to Sgt. Sanders.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --12-- City of Roswell, NM
RESOLUTION 18-43
A RESOLUTION HONORING THE MEMORY OF ARMY SERGEANT
CHRISTOPHER A. SANDERS
WHEREAS, the men and women who serve in the United States armed forces are to be
commended for their heroic service in defense of our country and in the spread of freedom and
democracy throughout the world;
WHEREAS, the family of Army Sgt. Christopher Sander has proposed dedicating a
pedestrian overpass in the City of Roswell, on North Main adjacent to the east side of the New
Mexico Military Institute (“NMMI”);
WHEREAS, Sgt. Sanders was born on April 30th 1985 in Roswell, New Mexico, and
wanted, from the age of 9 years old, to join NMMI as a cadet;
WHEREAS, Sgt. Sanders graduated high school from NMMI, Class of 2004, and enlisted in
the Army in February, 2004;
WHEREAS, Sgt. Sanders had intended to attend college and become a military officer,
however, the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon persuaded him to join
the military as soon as he could;
WHEREAS, after advanced training, Sgt. Sanders served two tours in Iraq, first from
September 2004 to October 2005 with the 1st Battalion, 24th Infantry Regiment, and then from 2005
until 2008 with the 3rd Squadron, Second Stryker Calvary Regiment, 1st Armored Division, known
as the “Wolf Pack”;
WHEREAS, Sgt. Christopher Sanders was tragically killed in action, along with five other
soldiers and their interpreter, on January 9th, 2008 in Sinsil, Iraq;
WHEREAS, Sgt. Christopher Sanders and his fallen comrades will be forever known as the
“Sinsil 7”;
WHEREAS, during his distinguished service, Sgt. Sanders received following medals;
Bronze Star with Valor, Purple Heart, Army Commendation Metal 1st award, Army Commendation
Medal 2nd award, Expert Infantry Badge, Combat Infantry Badge, Army Good Contact Medal,
National Defense Medal, Iraqi Campaign Medal, Global War on Terrorism Expeditionary Medal,
and Overseas Service Medal;
WHEREAS, Sgt. Sanders was a dedicated father, husband, and service man, who loved life
and, above all, his family; and
WHEREAS, Sgt. Sanders is entitled to the respect, recognition and remembrance of the City
of Roswell for his service and sacrifice to this nation.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --13-- City of Roswell, NM
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AS THE
GOVERNING BODY OF THE CITY OF ROSWELL, NEW MEXICO, that:
1. The City of Roswell hereby recognizes the exemplary service and sacrifice of Army
Sgt. Christopher Sanders;
2. The City of Roswell further extends its condolences to the family, friends and loved
ones of Sgt, Sanders;
3. Dedication of the pedestrian overpass on N. Main on the east side of New Mexico
Military Institute in the City of Roswell would constitute a fitting and appropriate memorial to the
memory of Sgt. Sanders; and
4. The City of Rowell encourages and requests that the New Mexico Department of
Transportation undertake the dedication of the pedestrian overpass as a memorial for Sgt. Sanders.
PASSED, ADOPTED, SIGNED and APPROVED the ___ day of July, 2018.
_____________________________
Dennis Kintigh, Mayor
ATTEST:
______________________
Sharon Coll, City Clerk
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --14-- City of Roswell, NM
AGENDA ITEM NO. 3– ABSTRACT
LEGAL COMMITTEE MEETING
Thursday, June 28, 2018 at 4:00PM
City Hall Conference Room
425 N. Richardson, Roswell, NM 88201
Cubic Inc. contract for advertising and marketing services
ACTION REQUESTED: Consider recommending that City Council approve the contract
for advertising and marketing services with Cubic, Inc.
BACKGROUND: The City recently sought proposals for marketing and
advertising services in RFP //no. On //date, Council, following
the Evaluation Committee’s recommendation, selected Cubic,
Inc. This agreement is the final result of negotiations between
City staff and Cubic, Inc.
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATION: As per the conditions of the RFP the one year budget for these
services is $355,000, which includes media placement and
contractor compensation.
LEGAL REVIEW: The City Attorney has reviewed the agreement.
BOARD and/or The Legal Committee is scheduled to meet on Thursday, June
COMMITTEE ACTION: 28, 2018.
STAFF Consider recommending that City Council approve the contract
RECOMMENDATION: for advertising and marketing services with Cubic, Inc.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --15-- City of Roswell, NM
CONTRACT FOR ADVERTISING AND MARKETING SERVICES
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into on , by and between the City of Roswell,
New Mexico (“the City”) and Cubic, Inc. (“the Agency”).
Wherefore, the City desires the services of an advertising agency to assist in developing
the City of Roswell brand, promote tourism initiatives, and assist with public awareness
campaigns; and
Wherefore, the Agency was selected pursuant to the Roswell City Council’s vote on
May 10, 2018 adopting the recommendation of the Evaluation Committee for RFP-18-011 (2ND
POSTING).
NOW, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the covenants and conditions set forth
herein, and the obligations to be fulfilled hereunder, the parties hereto agree as follows:
1. Term: This Agreement shall be from JULY 1, 2018, until JUNE 30, 2019 with up to three
(3) one (1) year extensions based upon mutual written agreement of both parties.
2. Incorporation: All terms, conditions, rights and obligations of the parties as set forth in
RFP-18-011 (2ND POSTING) and in Contractor’s response to RFP-18-011 (2ND
POSTING) are incorporated herein as if set out fully.
3. Agency’s Services to be Performed: The Agency agrees to perform all necessary and
related services required to accomplish the City’s advertising program and goals as set
out in RFP-18-011 (2ND POSTING), Section 9.3, Scope of Services, attached hereto as
Exhibit A.
4. Scope of Agency’s Authority: The Agency will make no commitment for the City’s
account without your prior written authorization.
5. Compensation:
a. This is a non-commission account and the Agency agrees to waive media
commissions and to seek non-profit or remnant prices on ad placements
whenever practicable.
b. The total due to the Agency under this Agreement, not including gross receipts
tax but including expenses, shall not exceed $355,000 for those services actually
provided, subject to the appropriate spending according to budget categories
outlined in Section (5)(c).
c. Both parties agree that the Agency will submit a budget for the expenditure of the
$355,000 throughout the term of the Agreement for approval by the City. The
breakout of this budget for FY 19 shall be as follows, subject to final approval by
City Council:
1. $200,000 for Tourism,
2. $100,000 for Fly Roswell,
3. $30,000 for City branding, and
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --16-- City of Roswell, NM
4. $25,000 for Roswell Police Department recruitment campaign for
FY 19 only.
d. The New Mexico gross receipts tax levied on the amounts payable under this
Agreement shall be paid by the City to the Agency unless the City provides the
Agency with a valid New Mexico NTTC. Payment is subject to any negotiations
between the parties from year to year pursuant to Paragraph 1, Scope of Work
as set forth in RFP 18-011 (2ND POSTING) and approval by the City.
e. Payment is provided when service is rendered and accepted. Invoices are
normally sent and dated the last day of the month that the milestone is delivered.
Invoices are "Due on Receipt” and must be paid within thirty (30) days of the date
of the invoice or as provided in Section (5)(f) below, unless other arrangements
have been made. Interest on past due accounts will accrue at the rate of 18%
annually. The City has the option to make payments via VISA, MasterCard,
Discover Card, and AMEX subject to an agreed upon convenience fees as
follows: 3% for VISA, MasterCard, Discover Card and 3.5% for AMEX. The grant
of any license or right of copyright is conditioned on receipt of full payment.
f. The Agency will submit a detailed statement that accounts for all services
performed and expenses incurred each month. If the City finds that the services
are not acceptable, within fifteen (15) days after the date of receipt of written
notice from the Agency that payment is requested, it shall provide the Agency
with a letter of exception explaining the defect or objection to the services and
outlining steps the Agency may take to provide remedial action. Upon
certification by the City that the services have been received and accepted,
payment shall be tendered to the Agency within thirty (30) days. If payment is
made by mail, the payment shall be deemed tendered on the date it is
postmarked.
6. Media Billing - Due to varying media vendor payment terms and in order to take
advantage of all available cash discounts, rebates or vendor add-ons, Agency will
invoice the City based on the following schedule for contracted and pre-planned media.
The City agrees that all media will be invoiced separately from all other Cubic services,
but shall still conform to the budget requirements of Section (5)(c).
a. Invoices - Agency will invoice the City for media billing one month in advance of
the campaign’s scheduled run.
b. Unplanned Media Invoices - If the City requests a new media placement that will
run during the current or following month, Agency will immediately send an
invoice to cover the costs of the unplanned media placement. Payment will be
due upon certification in Paragraph (5)(f).
c. Special Situations – There are some situations and vendor requirements that
may require City payment prior to placing media with a vendor. In these cases,
Agency reserves the right to request payment from the City prior to scheduling
the media run. In these cases, Agency will not schedule the media until payment
is received.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --17-- City of Roswell, NM
d. Additional Fees - Late payment fees and/or cancellation fees will be the
responsibility of the City to the extent the imposition of the fees is directly
attributable to the City’s action or failure to act in a timely fashion.
7. Third-party Fees - Quoted prices in this scope of work include all of Cubic's services plus
any third-party costs indicated in the quote. While we do not anticipate any costs
outside those in the quote, items not included are photography (stock or custom), travel,
photocopies, file storage/devices, express mail, other courier services, third-party fees,
etc., unless specifically indicated as a line item in this quote. All work outside of this
scope will require an approved estimate before work begins.
8. Stock Photography and Video - In cases where the City does not have access to original
photography or video or is not contracted with Agency for photography or video services,
Agency may use stock photography or video as placeholders in order to present design
concepts. If the City decides to use the stock photography in a finished work, whether
online or offline, the City agrees to pay Agency $75 for each image used in digital final
files and $150 for printed final files. Stock video costs will be quoted separately.
9. Fonts - Agency is licensed to use a number of different fonts in its completed works.
However, Agency cannot transfer the license of these fonts to its clients. If the City
would like to use any font that was used in a finished work, the City agrees to purchase
the font for its own use. The City may purchase the font directly or Agency may
purchase the font and bill for it separately.
10. Delays & Holds – If any action directly attributable to the City’s action or failure to act in a
timely manner results in a delay of more than 2 business days of any planned project
timelines, Agency reserves the right to modify the timeline of deliverables, but will
employ its best efforts to adhere to the original timelines. Agency will notify the client of
the new timeline.
If the City places a project on hold, Agency will invoice for the work completed based on
the deliverables already made plus the percentage of work completed on the current
deliverable. If the City opts to restart the project, Agency will deliver an updated timeline
to the City with a proposed restart date.
11. Cancellations - In the event that the City requests to cancel a media plan, for any reason
including but not limited to a termination of this Agreement, Agency will make every
attempt to cancel the contracted media runs with the media vendors. Should Agency be
unable to cancel these plans per terms of a vendor agreement or other legally binding
obligation, the City will be responsible to pay all invoices related to media placements
that cannot be cancelled regardless of the date of any such placement.
12. Local Services – To the extent commercially reasonable, Agency agrees to use services
of vendors located, first, in Roswell, New Mexico, or, if unavailable or uncompetitive then
within the State of New Mexico.
13. Confidential Information: The Agency will protect the City’s confidential information and
business secrets. The Agency agrees that any information deemed confidential provided
to the Agency or developed in the scope of the Agency’s work outlined in RFP-18-011
(2ND POSTING) shall be keep confidential and shall not be made available to any
individual or organization at any time without the prior written approval of the City
Manager.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --18-- City of Roswell, NM
14. Maintenance and Examination of Records:
a. The City may examine the Agency’s billing records and supporting documents at
any time during this Agreement, after giving reasonable notice. The Agency
agrees to maintain detailed records which indicate activity related to task
performance and the nature of services rendered per corresponding
expenditures. Such records include but are not limited to click-throughs,
impressions, audience shares, and web analytics and states. The Agency agrees
to submit these records to the appropriate committee(s) of the City and City’s
staff. The Agency agrees to submit reports to the Roswell City Council on a
quarterly basis, or more frequently upon the request by the City.
b. The Agency shall maintain detailed financial records consistent with generally
accepted accounting principles and submit a year-end financial report to the City.
15. Termination:
a. This Agreement may be terminated by either of the parties hereto upon written
notice delivered to the other party with at least sixty (60) days’ notice. Upon
termination, the City agrees to pay for all authorized work-in-progress, and to pay
all of those costs which were authorized under the Plan and purchased by the
Agency for the account. In the event of the termination of the agreement as
allowed hereunder, any fees to be paid under the agreement shall be prorated for
the applicable percentage of work completed by Agency prior to termination or
paid at such rate as specified in the agreement, prorated through the date of
termination.
b. In the event that one party breaches any material obligation under this
agreement, the other party may terminate this agreement by providing thirty (30)
days' written notice of termination to the breaching party. The right of Agency and
the City to terminate in any such case shall be in addition to any other rights and
remedies each party may have at law or in equity. Any subsequent breach shall
be subject to immediate termination, to be effective upon written notice.
16. Intellectual and Personal Property Right: All materials developed or acquired by the
Agency under RFP-18-011 (2ND POSTING) shall become the property of the City and
shall be delivered to the City no later than the termination date of this Agreement. The
City retains all rights, title, interest, and ownership of all approved final artwork, in any
media, including but not limited to digital files. Nothing produced in whole or part by the
Agency shall be the subject of an application for copyright by or on behalf of the Agency.
All intellectual, creative or personal property prepared for the City but not accepted
and/or not used by the Agency for the City remains the property of the Agency. Stock
image rights only apply to this project designed and developed by Cubic and are not
transferrable to other media or future versions.
17. Indemnification and Insurance: The Agency shall indemnify and hold harmless the City
from and against any and all claims, liabilities or damages which arise: (a) from dealings
between the Agency and third parties; and (b) the preparation or presentation of
advertising. This indemnification shall include the costs of litigation and counsel fees.
However, the Agency shall not be liable to the City as a result of any default of suppliers
of materials and services or owners of media or other persons who are not agents or
employees of the Agency. The Agency agrees to keep in force, at its own cost and
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --19-- City of Roswell, NM
expense, liability insurance for the benefit of the City in the minimum amount sufficient to
cover a claim under the Tort Claims Act, NMSA 1978, § 41-4-1, et seq. or such other
amounts as authorized in writing by the City.
18. Merger: All representations and agreements, whether oral or written, are merged into
this Agreement, and no representation, whether oral or written, shall be introduced which
contradicts the terms of the Agreement.
19. Conflict of Laws: The validity, interpretation, enforceability of all rights and obligations
under this Agreement shall be governed by, constructed and enforced in accordance
with the laws of the State of New Mexico. Any action or proceeding to enforce the
provisions of this Contract Agreement shall be commenced in the New Mexico District
Court, Chaves County.
20. Compliance with Law: The Agency agrees to abide by all Federal and State laws, rules,
regulations and executive orders by the Governor of the State of New Mexico, and all
policies, procedures and ordinances of the City of Roswell.
21. Subcontractors: In the event the Agency uses subcontractors for the performance of this
contract, the Agency shall be liable for the contractual performance of the
subcontractors.
22. Notices: All invoices and notices shall be sent to each party at the following addresses:
City of Roswell, NM Cubic Inc.
c/o City Manager & Public Affairs Director Billy Kulkin, President
PO Box 1838 1643 S Boston Ave
Roswell, NM 88202 Tulsa, OK, 74119
23. Severability: If any clause or provision of this contract is held to be illegal, invalid or
unenforceable, then it is the intention of the parties that the remainder of the contract
shall remain in full force and effect. However, in the event that either party to the contract
can no longer reasonably perform pursuant to the remainder of the contract terms, or if
the purpose for the contract can no longer be carried out by either party, the contract is
void, and no damages shall accrue to either party.
24. Non-Appropriation: The City’s obligation to make payment under the terms of this
Agreement is contingent upon its appropriation of sufficient funds to make those
payments. If the City does not appropriate funds for the continuation of this Agreement,
this Agreement will terminate upon written notice of that effect to the Agency. The City’s
determination that sufficient funds have not been appropriated is firm, binding, and not
subject to review.
[signatures on following page]
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --20-- City of Roswell, NM
This Agreement is executed by the parties on the day indicated above.
CITY OF ROSWELL CUBIC, INC.
_________________________________ ____________________________________
By: City Manager By:
CITY SEAL
_________________________________
Sharon Coll, City Clerk
Approved as to form:
_________________________________
Aaron Holloman, City Attorney
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --21-- City of Roswell, NM
Exhibit A
Scope of Services
Strategic Partnership: Work in collaboration with the Public Affairs department to determine
effectiveness of ad concepts based on engagement and experiences, integrated, brand
attributed to service, quality and innovation that will support the City of Roswell’s economic
development, tourism and brand identity. Support the City of Roswell and aid in grant
applications, events and co-operative programs. Executing and tracking results while
exemplifying financial integrity of the City of Roswell funds.
Marketing, Promotional and Advertising Planning: Develop recommendations for a Marketing
and Advertising Plan that supports the strategies set forth by the City of Roswell’s Public Affairs
department. Includes strategic direction, creative strategy, brand development and stewardship,
media plan and cooperative plan.
Media Planning, Buying & Placement: Buy and execute the media plan presented in the
Marketing and Advertising Plan and approved by the Public Affairs department. Execution
includes placement, optimization, cancellations and auditing. The Public Affairs director will sign
all advertisement agreements/insertion orders, handle billing and payment.
Concept Development/Production: Concept creative materials/campaign elements (print, online,
digital, etc.) as described in the Marketing and Advertising Plan. Once approved, produce and
bring to final form the approved advertising materials to run on behalf of the City of Roswell.
Research and Analytics: Provide an overview of Campaign successes and opportunities.
Reports and trends in the market place and competitors. Provide analytical tools or services that
will be useful to information to plan and report back to the City of Roswell.
06/28/18 - Legal Committee --22-- City of Roswell, NM
Get email alerts for Roswell
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.