Participatory Budgeting Committee
Regular MeetingSaratoga Springs, NY · January 30, 2023
Minutes
DRAFT – For Approval at 02/27/2023 Meeting
Minutes 1/30/23
Attendees:
Danielle, Mary Estelle, Tim, Jeff, Norah, Heather, Samantha
Notes:
Committee plans for 2023: Request for new members; send any identified candidates to Heather. If we
keep committee at 9, need 2; if we change to 11 members, can add up to 4.
2023 Schedule: Meetings for 2023: will be 2nd and 4th Wednesday at 6pm
Program Updates: Rec Dept – funding is in progress; DPW – need line items to finalize; non-profits
pending minutes from city council to approve and then move to payment.
Cannot assign money for 2023 until sufficient funds from 2022 are allocated. Target is to have approx.
$147k in funds for 2023.
Heather is working on documentation requirements for non-profits (to show use of funds post-
implementation); shared to committee to review
In order to provide time to complete financial approvals, project acceptance start date targeted for
March 1. (Motion to approve March 1 – May 1 submission window; Danielle motion, Jeff second; all in
favor). Corresponding project reviews would occur March 1 – June 1.
Specific project updates:
Curling pilot planned and starting Feb 3
Ice skating pending freezing temperatures
CREATE program scheduled
Community garden – need to identify entity to receive funds; cannot distribute to an individual
Urban tree planting – in review with DPW to validate location options, confirming approach in
conjunction with Sustainable Saratoga (submitter).
Dog park – DPW is evaluating options for alternatives that need to be reviewed with project submitter.
Discussion of changes to project criteria:
- Feasibility studies would NOT be supported (do not meet the criteria for project proposals, specifically
provides benefit to the public in year);
- Should we accept non-profit submissions?
There are alternate sources of city funding for some non-profits. There are many small non-
profits that are looking for ways to add benefit to city/general public. Some other areas have different
rules about level of engagement by non-profits. Suggestion from Danielle: add to project submissions
questions regarding if non-profit has submitted project to other city areas previously, or has received
funding from city in past 12 months. Adds criteria for us to evaluate without excluding.
Agreement is to add some small criteria to the application but to encourage all submissions by
organizations or individuals. Vetting process by committee with city advisors will be spot for defining
project feasibility and alternate paths if necessary.
Outreach plans:
Will coordinate schedules and availability in Feb/March for committee members to volunteer to lead
outreach efforts (presentations and workshops).
Send email to participants in cycle 1 regarding project submission dates and to ask for interest in joining
the committee.
Other topics:
Need to define what the project assignment looks like. Need to understand what DPW staffing and
effort will be to support initiatives.
Next meeting: Wednesday Feb 8, 6pm
Agenda
Participatory Budgeting Committee
Agenda
January 30, 2023
1) Organization of committee. Clarify which Members are returning. Selection of
committee chair and vice chair. Selection of meeting day (Wednesdays or
Thursdays). Suggestions for new members.
2) Discussion of funding for 2023. What are the city’s plans to fund PB? What is the
timing?
3) Heather to give a report on discussions with other city departments on
implementation of 2022 projects (cycle 1). What is moving forward? Are there
any difficulties or new concerns?
Discussion about what the city will require for the projects that are grants. Who
is the point person on grants for the city? What documentation will the city
require non-profits to show outcomes and results?
Decide a plan of action with appropriate committee members/project leads to
move 2022 projects forward.
4) Discuss submissions for 2023 be accepted. Starting February 1 or March 1?
Discussion ways to improve collaboration with committee members on projects.
Lessons learned from 2022. Do we want to accept proposals from non-profit
organizations?
5) Discussion of updated documents (guidebook and proposal form) as needed.
Agree on current draft and decide when they will be posted.
6) Outreach plan. Agree on dates and identify committee members to do outreach
training sessions in February and March in different areas of the city. Purpose of
the sessions are to explain the process, show what types of projects are done in
other cities – build capacity of residents to develop proposals. These sessions
are intended to build the capacity of individuals, not really intended for non-
profits. Dates for outreach sessions to be planned with volunteers to fit their
schedules. One PowerPoint will be developed for all to use.
7) Agree on date for next meeting
Get email alerts for Saratoga Springs
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.