Zoning Board of Adjustment

Final Minutes Board of Adjustment Carnegie Town Hall Monday, July 16th 2012 7:00 p.m. Members Present: Members Absent: Chairman Erik Helland Chris Schiltz Lee Van De Walle John Kolander Greg Neitzert Monty Miller Kathryn Henning Staff Present Shawna Goldammer Jason Bieber NEW BUSINESS Case: 12-35: Variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 1’. Applicant: Jill Hurley Address: 1308 E. 30th St. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 1’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 12-36: Variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 3’. Applicant: Chris Kelliher Address: 5900 W. Pebble Creek Rd A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Henning to apporve a variance in the required side yard setback from 5’ to 3’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 12-37: Variance in the maximum area of a turnaround adjacent to a driveway from 120 square feet to 160 square feet. Applicant: John & Ann Wineinger Address: 4202 S. Cliff Ave. 1  A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in the maximum area of a turnaround adjacent to a driveway from 120 square feet to 160 square feet. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case: 12-38: Variances in (1) the maximum height of an off-premise sign from 40’ to 48’; and (2) an off-premise sign within the 600 foot radius of an existing off-premise sign. Applicant: Lamar Outdoor Advertising Address: 4401 E. 10th St. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in (1) the maximum height of an off-premise sign from 40’ to 48’; and (2) an off-premise sign within the 600 foot radius of an existing off-premise sign. After discussion, a motion was made by Henning, seconded by Van De Walle to amend the main motion to include the variance in sign height from 40’ to 48’. Vote to approve the montion to amend: Roll Call: Yesses, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Action was then taken on the main motion as amended to approve a variance in the sign height from 40’ to 48’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Neitzert, 1. Noes, Henning, Van De Walle, Helland, 3. Motion failed. Variance denied. A motion was made by Henning, seconded by Van De Walle to approve an off-premise sign within the 600 foot radius of an existing off-premise sign. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case: 12-39: Variance in the required front yard setback from 30’ to 10’ for a circular driveway. Applicant: Thaddeus Wells 2  Address: 4304 S. Cliff Ave. A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Neitzert to approve a variance in the required front yard setback from 30’ to 10’ for a circular driveway. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Van De Walle, Helland, 2. Noes, Henning, Neitzert, 2. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 12-40: Variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 6’. Applicant: Roxann Robinson Address: 5801 W. Sioux K Court A motion was made by Neitzert, seconded by Henning to approve a variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 12-41: Variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 4.5’. Applicant: Shelia Norman Address: 6712 S. Whitechurch Circle A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Henning to approve a variance in the required fence height from 4’ to 6’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, 0. Noes, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case: 12-42: Variance in the maximum height from 60’ to 100’. Applicant: Raven Industries Address: 1809 N. E Ave. A motion was made Henning, seconded by Van De Walle to approve a variance in the maximum height from 60’ to 100’. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. 3 Case: 12-43: Variance in the requried number of parking spaces from 53 to 50. Applicant: Scott Blount Address: 108 S. Minnesota Ave. A motion was made by Neitzert, seconed by Van De Walle to approve a variance in the required number of parking spaces from 53 to 50. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yesses, Hennign, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland, 4. Noes, 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Adjournment A motion was made by Van De Walle, seconded by Neitzert to adjourn the meeting at 8:50. Vote to adjourn: Roll Call: Yesses, Henning, Neitzert, Van De Walle, Helland. Noes, 0. Motion passed. 4