Zoning Board of Adjustment

FINAL MINUTES Zoning Board of Adjustment Carnegie Town Hall Monday, July 15, 2019 6:00 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Chairperson Michael Jones Billy Pollema Graham Oey Ryan Rients Aaron Norman Jacqueline Cole Craig Markhardt STAFF PRESENT Jason Bieber Bryan Wilcox Meeting was called to order at 6:00 p.m. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF JUNE 17, 2019, MEETING A motion was made by Craig Markhardt, seconded by Jacqueline Cole to approve the minutes of June 17, 2019. Chairperson Michael Jones called for a voice vote. All members voted yes. Motion passed. UNFINISHED BUSINESS Case BOA-010240-2019: Deferred to August 19, 2019 Case BOA-010381-2019: Variance in the required front yard setback from 25’ to 0’ for a 6’ high fence. Applicant: Robert Galles Address: 3500 W. Teem Dr. A motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Aaron Norman to approve a variance in the required front yard setback from 25’ to 0’ for a 6’ high chain-link fence. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 4. Noes. Aaron Norman, 1. Motion passed. Variance approved. 1 NEW BUSINESS Case BOA-010561-2019: Waiver of the Level B buffer yard requirements along the south property line. Applicant: Duane Spader Address: 5517 N. Cliff Ave. A motion was made by Aaron Norman and seconded by Graham Oey to approve a waiver of the Level B buffer yard requirements along the south property line. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, 0. Noes. Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones 5. Motion failed. Variance denied. Case BOA-010565-2019: Variance in the rear yard setback from 25’ to 10’ for a covered screened porch. Applicant: Sue & Wayne Mossefin Address: 4209 S. Birchwood Ave. A motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Jacqueline Cole to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 10’ for a covered screened porch. An amendment to the main motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Aaron Norman to approve a variance in the required rear yard setback from 25’ to 15’-6” for a covered screened porch due to applicant submitting a revised site plan with correct setback information. Vote to approve amendment: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 5. Noes. 0. Motion passed. Amendment approved. Vote to approve amended main motion: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 5. Noes. 0. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case BOA-010569-2019: WITHDRAWN Case BOA-010573-2019: Variance in (1) the required minimum lot area for proposed replat of Lot 18A Orchard Place Tracts from 1 acre to .61 acres and (2) in the minimum lot area for proposed replat of Lot 19A Orchard Place Tracts from 1 acre to .46 acres. Applicant: Allen Unruh Address: 2709, 2801 & 2809 S. Kinkade Ave. 2  A motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Jacqueline Cole to approve a variance in (1) the required minimum lot area for proposed replat of Lot 18A Orchard Place Tracts from 1 acre to .61 acres and (2) in the minimum lot area for proposed replat of Lot 19A Orchard Place Tracts from 1 acre to .46 acres. Vote to approve: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Michael Jones, 4. Noes, Graham Oey 1. Motion passed. Variance approved. Case BOA-010576-2019 Variance in (1) to allow parking in the required front yard setback, (2) to allow parking in the required side yard setback & (3) exceeding more than 10% non- living ground cover in the required front yard setback. Applicants: Matt & Lindsey Keiper Address: 2101 S. Holly Ave. A motion was made by Aaron Norman and seconded by Jacqueline Cole to approve a variance in (1) to allow parking in the required front yard setback, (2) to allow parking in the required side yard setback & (3) exceeding more than 10% non-living ground cover in the required front yard setback. An amendment to the main motion was made by Michael Jones and seconded by Graham Oey to remove paving within the front yard to meet the 90% living ground cover. No votes were casted to this amendment. A revised amendment to the main motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Graham Oey to defer until August 19th meeting. Vote to approve amendment: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 5. Noes. 0. Motion passed. Amendment to defer approved. Case BOA-010575-2019 Variance in (1) to allow parking in the required front yard setback, (2) to allow parking in the required side yard setback & (3) exceeding more than 10% non- living ground cover in the required front yard setback. Applicants: Travis Oehlke Address: 2109 S. Holly Ave. A motion to defer until August 19th was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Jacqueline Cole. Vote to defer: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Jacqueline Cole, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 5. Noes. 0. Motion passed. Variance Deferred. 3 Case BOA-010574-2019 Variance in (1) to allow parking in the required front yard setback, (2) to allow parking in the required side yard setback & (3) exceeding more than 10% non- living ground cover in the required front yard setback. Applicants: Jizele & Todd Pottratz Address: 2105 S. Holly Ave. A motion to defer until August 19th was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Graham Oey. Vote to defer: Roll Call: Yeses, Craig Markhardt, Aaron Norman, Graham Oey, Michael Jones, 4. Noes. Jacqueline Cole, 1. Motion passed. Variance Deferred. RECOGNITION OF SERVICE FOR BOARD MEMBER AARON NORMAN PUBLIC INPUT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS There was none. ADJOURNMENT A motion was made by Craig Markhardt and seconded by Jacqueline Cole to adjourn the meeting at 9:00 pm. Chairperson Jones called for a voice vote. All members voted yes. Motion Passed. 4