Finance Committee (Meets 4th Tuesday of each month at 4:30 p.m.)
Regular MeetingSuperior, WI · March 25, 2025
Minutes
FINANCE COMMITTEE Meeting Minutes
March 25, 2025, Regular Meeting
The meeting was called to order by Chair Sweeney at on March 25, 2025,
Government Center Room
1
PRESENT: Jack Sweeney, Tylor Elm, and Mike
VIRTUAL: Jenny Van Sickle (committee alt.) and Darienne McNamara (Public Works)
CITY STAFF PRESENT: Nick Rhinehart (Finance Director), Renee Hoff (Assistant Finance Director),
Mayor Jim Paine, Todd Janigo (Public Works Director) and Karie Markon
OTHERS PRESENT: Shelley Nelson, Katelyn Baumann, Jordan Stish and Garner Moffat.
2 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2.1 Finance Committee (Meeting held February 25, 2025)
Motion was made by Tylor Elm, seconded Mike Herrick, and carried to approve the Finance Committee
minutes held February 25, 2025.
Chair Sweeney proposed to move 3.2 and 3.3 to the end of the meeting
Motion was made by Tylor Elm, seconded by Mike Herrick, to move 3.2 and 3.3 agenda items to the end of the
meeting.
3 OLD
3.1 Landfill Budget 2025
Mayor Jim Paine spoke on the Budget and was able to propose one with the approved expenditures for 2025
despite the unknown future cost of closing the landfill. We are still waiting for the results of the study to get the
accurate dollar costs, so monthly meetings will occurs until these correct values come in
Motion was made by Tylor Elm, seconded by Mike Herrick, and carried to approve the Landfill Budget 2025.
3.2 Village of Superior – Fire Protection Contract
Chair Councilor Sweeney spoke on the need to update the contract to include the cost of vehicles and
equipment. The need was addressed in approval of the current contract and known that an updated re-
negotiated contract would need to be re-approved.
Motion was made by Tyler Elm, seconded Mike Herrick, and carried to hold in committee to approve the
Village of Superior – Fire Protection Contract.
3.3 Superior Public Museums RFP Review
Upon a proper motion and second, the committee may convene in closed session under Wis.Stat. sec.
19.85(1)(e) for the purpose of deliberating strategies and setting parameters for the negotiation of the Superior
Public Museum Contract
Motion was made by Mike Herrick, seconded by Tyler Elm, and carried to move into closed session at 5:43pm
Motion was made by Mike Herrick, seconded by Tyler Elm, and carried to move out of closed session at
6:57pm
Committee took no action on the Public Museums RFP and to hold in Committee until the May meeting.
4 NEW BUSINESS
4.1 Amended General Fund Budget as of 03/24/2025
Mayor Jim Paine spoke on behalf of the budget, stating the 3% wage increase was not considered for the
library employees in the original budget. The current vacant city positions more than make up the shortfall
deficit.
Motion was made by Tylor Elm, seconded by Mike Herrick, and carried to approve the Amended General Fund
Budget as of 03/24/2025.
5 RECURRING BUSINESS
5.1 Golf Course Report and Financials February 2025
Finance Director Nick Rhinehart spoke on the Golf Course Report and February financials. They were coming
in a little over on budget YTD, and how external factors may have been affecting those numbers.
Motion was made by Mike Herrick, seconded by Tyler Elm, and carried to approve and file the Golf Course
Report and Financials February 2025.
5.2 2024 Check Register – Periods 01 to 13 subtotaled by Vendor
A question and answer period was ensured. After reviewing the vendor list, no bid for contracts could be
established.
Committee took no action on the 2024 Check Register – Periods 01 to 13 subtotaled by Vendor.
5.3 February 2025 Check Register – 2024 Expenditures
5.4 February 2025 Check Register – 2025 Expenditures
A question and answer period was ensured.
Motion was made by Mike Herrick, seconded Tylor Elm, and carried to approve the February 2025 Check
Register –2024 & 2025 Expenditures.
5.5 General Fund Financial Statement – 2024 and 2025 Expenditure vs Budget Analysis as of
March 7, 2025
Finance Director Nick Rhinehart spoke on the Fund, stating that the final financial statements for the 2024
year end had been sent to Tilly Baker for audit review. A question and answer period was ensured.
Motion was made by Tylor Elm, seconded by Mike Herrick, and carried to approve and file the General Fund
Financial Statement – 2024 and 2025 Expenditure vs Budget Analysis as of February 14, 2025.
5.6 American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Fund Budget Review
Finance Director Nick Rhinehart spoke on the budget, as nothing new has transpired and were at a point that
all that was need was to just track the expense spend down of these projects’ obligations.
Motion was made by Mike Herrick, seconded by Tylor Elm, and carried to approve and file the American
Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Fund Budget Review.
5.7 Insurance Update
Finance Director Nick Rhinehart informed the committee he had been working on tying out the vehicle assets,
as values have changed and that there was equipment that some of these vehicles possess could be recycled for
further use. He was also moving some of these assets into other classifications. A question and answer period
was ensured.
No motion was made by Committee
5.8 Other Financial Matters
Finance Director Nick Rhinehart informed the committee on the ERP bids, and that the final contracts
estimates were not to be completed until October.
6. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 6:58 p.m.
Minutes respectfully submitted by Karie Markon
Get email alerts for Superior
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.