Tourism Development Commission (Meets on the first Tuesday at 1PM)
Regular MeetingSuperior, WI · March 10, 2022
Minutes
PROCEEDINGS
TOURISM DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Thursday March 10, 2022
The meeting was called to order by Chair Graskey at 2:55 pm in 217 in the Government Center.
1. Roll Call
Members Present: Lindsey Graskey (chair), Keith Kern, Bruce Barron (online), JoAnn
Jardine, Pattie Soliday
City Staff Present: Mayor Paine, Clerk Ramos (online), Jane Darwin (online), Terry
Johnson (online) Deputy Clerk Becken
Members of Public: Shelley Nelson (online), Scott Walling (online), Rob Sandstrom
(online), Briana Fiandt, John Gidley, Knute Pederson, Terry Lundberg, Jeff Cushman,
Taylor Pedersen
2. Commissioner Discussion on Marketing Proposals
Each commissioner shared their assessments and opinions of the three presentations.
Discussions focused on the strengths and weaknesses of each submitted proposal and
presentation. Councilor Kern motioned to award the advertising contract to Travel Superior.
No second, motion failed.
3. Recommendation on Marketing contract
Commissioner Soliday motioned to recommend awarding Swim Creative with advertising
contract. Commissioner Jardine seconded. Through roll-call vote: Barron: yes, Soliday: yes,
Jardine: yes, Graskey: yes, Kern: no. Motion passed. Request was made for Contract
Analyst Jane Darwin and Finance Director Puetz to proceed with creating a contract.
4. Recommendation for Bong Museum/Visitor Center grant proposal
Commissioner Barron moved to hold this topic in committee until a future date after Travel
Superior has answered the questions presented by Commissioner Soliday and Chair
Graskey. He would like an opportunity to have Travel Superior available at that future
meeting to discuss more. Commissioner Jardine seconded. Motion passed.
5. Recommendation for Travel Superior request on welcome center
Commission to hold in committee until next meeting, so everyone can read the proposal.
6. Adjournment
Commissioner Soliday asked for more financial details in coming months as the funds come
available to the commission. She requested information on hotel/motel tax rolls and possible
convention center study information.
Tourism Development Commission, 3/10/2022 Proceedings Page 1 of 2
Adjourned until Thursday, April 7th at 3:00 p.m. in room 270 (Becky Scherf)
Respectfully submitted by Stephanie Becken, Deputy City Clerk
Tourism Development Commission, 3/10/2022 Proceedings Page 2 of 2
Agenda
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 1
AGENDA
TOURISM DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
TUESDAY, March 10, 2022, 2:15 P.M. – 3:30 P.M.
Government Center 270
Video call link: https://meet.google.com/mrg-qyha-ahw
Or dial: (US) +1 617-675-4444 (PIN: 748 150 271 0548#)
Mission Statement: “The Superior Tourism Commission will develop, market, and promote Superior
as a destination for visitors to stay and enjoy our natural landscape, culture, arts,
parks, and businesses.”
Commissioners: Lindsey Graskey (Chair), Keith Kern (Council Representative), Bruce Barron,
JoAnn Jardine, and Pattie Soliday
1. Roll Call
2. Commissioner discussion on marketing proposals (discussion only)
3. Recommendation on marketing contract
4. Recommendation for Bong Museum/Visitor Center grant proposal
5. Recommendation for Travel Superior request on welcome center
6. Adjournment
Notice is hereby given that a majority of the members of the Common Council may be present at
the meeting, and although this may constitute a quorum of the Common Council, the Council will
not take any action at this meeting.
*********************************************************************************************************************
Pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, if you are in need of an accommodation to participate
in the public meeting process, please call (715) 395-7200 by 4:30 p.m. on the day prior to the scheduled meeting
date (OR dial 711 for Telecommunications Relay Service). The City will attempt to accommodate any request
depending on the amount of notice received.
*********************************************************************************************************************
In compliance with Wisconsin Open Meetings Law, this agenda was posted on 3/09/2022 at the following locations: Superior Government Center,
Douglas County Courthouse, and online at https://www.ci.superior.wi.us/agendacenter. It was also emailed to the Superior Public Library and the
Superior Telegram, and PACT.
Tourism Development Commission, 3/10/2022 Page 1 of 1
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 2
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 3
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 4
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 5
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 6
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 7
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 8
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 9
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 10
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 11
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 12
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 13
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 14
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 15
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 16
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 17
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 18
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 19
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 20
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 21
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 22
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 23
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 24
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 25
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 26
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 27
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 28
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 29
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 30
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 31
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 32
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 33
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 34
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 35
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 36
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 37
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 38
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 39
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 40
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 41
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 42
Proposal for Superior-Douglas County Welcome Center Funding
Issued On: 02/25/2022
1|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 43
Prepared for:
The Superior Tourism Commission
Attention: Chair Lindsey Graskey
City of Superior
1316 N. 14th St.
Superior, WI 54880
Travel Superior Contact:
Taylor Pedersen
President/CEO
Travel Superior
205 Belknap St.
Superior, WI 54880
2|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 44
Thank you for the opportunity for the Superior-Douglas County Visitor Bureau, Inc.,
known to the public as Travel Superior, to submit this proposal for financial support of
the Superior-Douglas County Welcome Center.
We have had the honor and privilege of promoting City of Superior tourism since 2015,
under the effective Travel Superior brand since 2017. Prior to that, we have operated a
welcome center or information center since 1964 within Superior or Douglas County and
currently operate the only co-branded Travel Wisconsin Welcome Center north of WI
Highway 64.
As just mentioned, we have the privilege to be branded a Travel Wisconsin Welcome
Center which aids to the visibility of the state as well as our Welcome Center. What this
means is that we strongly collaborate with the WI Department of Tourism on
programming, best practices, promotional efforts and in recent years public health
guidance. Travel Superior and the Welcome Center serve as the primary conduit
between our region and Travel Wisconsin.
As you’ll see in the pages that follow, we are uniquely qualified to promote and
showcase many of our community’s assets. Our Welcome Center serves as a gateway
to our community and the State of Wisconsin. On average we assist approximately
20,000 visitors annually and have aided nearly 28,000 visitors at its peak during the last
five years.
We are hopeful you will continue to see the value our Welcome Center provides to the
traveling public visiting our region and have approached this proposal to operate our
Welcome Center as an independent entity within our organization.
Please reach out if you have any questions and we look forward to discussing how we
can best serve the City of Superior and its visitors.
Best Regards,
Taylor L. Pedersen
President & CEO
3|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 45
About Travel Superior and our Welcome Center
Company Name: Superior-Douglas County Visitor Bureau Inc. dba Travel Superior
Company Structure: 501 (c)(6) Non-Profit
Primary Contact for This Proposal: Taylor Pedersen
taylor.pedersen@superiorchamber.org
Telephone: 715-394-7716
Administrative Office Physical Address: 205 Belknap St.
Superior, WI 54880
Welcome Center Physical Address: 305 Harborview Parkway
Superior, WI 54880
EIN: 82-3816137
Incorporated: 2017, during 2017 and prior, Travel Superior was the tourism arm
of The Superior Chamber.
Governance: There is no private ownership in the operations of Travel Superior.
Management leads the day-to-day operations of the organization as
well as Welcome Center and oversight comes from an elected
board of directors made up of community leaders and industry
professionals, including the City of Superior Mayor.
Mission: Our mission is to market Superior-Douglas County as a premier
travel destination outside the region through tourism promotion and
development.
Commitment to DEAI:
Our organization is committed to the success of the tourism sector, our staff and the
community through engagement on topics of equity, diversity, accessibility and inclusion. We
are committed to creating an inclusive business community for all, and promote a welcoming
and enjoyable experience for all visitors.
# of Total Employees: 5 # of Employees at our Welcome Center: 3
4|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 46
What is a “Welcome Center”?
Although it may go by many names – Welcome Center, Visitor Center, Information
Center, Tourist Information Center we call our “center” the Superior-Douglas County
Welcome Center. Often, we will include the words Visitor Information to clarify what
key service we provide.
The goal of a typical Welcome Center is to provide visitors with a location for transient
visitor services and information on the area's attractions, lodging, maps, and other items
relevant to tourism. Often, these centers are operated in an airport, attraction, rest stop
or other port of entry to a destination.
The Superior-Douglas County Welcome Center offers free visitor and travel information
for Superior, Douglas County and the State of Wisconsin to both locals and non-local
visitors. We are staffed for one-on-one travel advice on lodging, dining, shopping,
attractions, recreation, events and more. We also have multiple self-serve display racks
stocked with Wisconsin based tourism publications, travel guides, brochures and maps.
Our Welcome Center offers a friendly experience to individuals of all abilities, has
substantial parking for all types of vehicles, is located near two outdoor parks with play
areas, and has paved walking trails that overlook the Superior Bay as well as Barker's
Island.
5|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 47
What Sets Travel Superior and the Superior-Douglas County
Welcome Center Apart
Travel Superior is uniquely positioned as the lead organization promoting tourism in the
Superior and Douglas County area. We have a phenomenal marketing team that have
exceptional experience in their areas of expertise. Our team on the front lines include
three staff directly assisting our visitors at our Welcome Center located just inside the
lobby area of the Richard I Bong Veterans Historical Center. This space currently has a
lease agreement through 2025. Current we operate seven days per week May-October
and five days a week (Tuesday-Saturday) the remainder of the year.
Our unmatched understanding of Superior, the surrounding area and its assets
positions our staff to be experts on local tourism and attractions. We provide hundreds
of pieces of literature at no cost to our visitors, many of these include rack cards from
regional businesses who pay to have materials placed in our Welcome Center or have
advertised in our publications. We also promote all local attractions (museums/parks) as
well as all lodging properties free of charge. The Welcome Center extensively carry
information from around the state of Wisconsin as well as limited materials from Canada
and our neighboring states. Our staff provide a personal touch on all visitors we assist
and communicate with our hotel properties on availability, weekly. Giving back to the
community is another way we engage with visitors and our community by organizing
annual clothing drives that offer community support.
Our Welcome Center is more than just a great place to visit and find local tourism
information it is an extension of the northern hospitality our region’s visitors appreciate.
All are welcome at our Center and those who visit us leave with customized information
and recommendations to meet their unique interests and budgets.
6|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 48
Financial Request
Research shows that visitors experiencing a Welcome Center increase their value and
economic impact to the city that they are visiting following that experience. These tourist
services are not self-sustaining and typically require subsidized financial support from
local government or private entity. The Welcome Center run by Travel Superior, will not
fund itself or generate enough revenue to maintain current operations, even with
efficient operations and seasonal staffing fluctuations.
Travel Superior and the Superior-Douglas County Welcome Center respectfully request
a contract from April 2022 through December 2025 in the amount of $84,158 (annual) to
operate a Superior based Welcome Center with the following annual budgetary areas:
Operational Costs $22,060
Promotions and Branding $10,500
Allocation of Payroll $51,598
$84,158
Reporting
Historically Travel Superior has provided the City of Superior with quarterly visitor
counts. Moving forward, Travel Superior will provide the Superior Tourism Commission
with a monthly visitor count number and an annual report documenting a summary of
the operations and activities of the Superior-Douglas County Welcome Center at the
end of each contract year.
Payment
Payment is requested to be made at the beginning of each contract year. The process
for payment and timeline will be negotiated with anticipated payment to begin April
2022.
Confidentiality
This proposal in part or in its entirety is property of the Superior-Douglas County Visitor
Bureau, Inc. dba Travel Superior and is not to be shared in any form (digital, written or
verbal) with any individual, entity or third party without written permission of Taylor
Pedersen, President and CEO.
7|Page
Tourism Development Commission 3.10.2022 49
Thank You
Thank you again for the opportunity to present this proposal. For the many reasons
outlined on the preceding pages, Travel Superior already does and will continue to
provide the best value and service for this necessary component of local tourism. And
recognize that this is an investment being made by the City of Superior and the Superior
Tourism Commission. We look forward to your response, and as always, we thank you
for your support shown toward tourism in the City of Superior. Please stay safe and
healthy.
8|Page
Get email alerts for Superior
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.