Planning Commission - Regular Meeting

TWENTYNINE PALMS PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA 6136 Adobe Road Twentynine Palms, CA 92277 www.29palms.org Tuesday, February 20, 2024 AGENDA 5:00 P.M. CALL TO ORDER Pledge of Allegiance. Roll Call. ANNOUNCEMENTS These proceedings may be viewed on demand on the City of Twentynine Palms website at www.29palms.org. You may also Live Stream this meeting by going on the City website and clicking on the "Meeting Agendas" link. PUBLIC COMMENTS This is the time for the public to address the Planning Commission on issues within the jurisdiction of the Commission that are NOT on this agenda. All comments are to be directed to the Chair of the Commission and shall not consist of any personal attacks. Members of the public are expected to maintain a professional, courteous decorum during their comments. There is a time limitation of three minutes per person. If you haven’t already done so, please fill out name and address slips and give them to the Planning Commission Secretary. The Planning Commission is prohibited by the Brown Act (State law) from taking action or discussing at length items not included on the printed agenda. Public comments on specific agenda items will be deferred until consideration of the item on the agenda. COMMISSION COMMENTS AND REPORTS OF MEETINGS ATTENDED CONSENT CALENDAR 1 Housing Element Annual Report 3-5 The Planning Commission accept and forward the Housing Element Annual Progress Report to the City Council. Housing Element Annual Report - Pdf Page 1 of 26 ITEMS REMOVED FROM CONSENT CALENDAR FOR DISCUSSION PUBLIC HEARINGS 2 DCA23-000004 Special Occupancy Parks 7-8 That the Planning Commission discuss the regulations for Special Occupancy Parks, provide direction to staff and postpone the hearing to a future meeting. DCA23-000004 Special Occupancy Parks - Pdf DISCUSSION AND POTENTIAL ACTION ITEMS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR UPDATES 3 Vacation Home Rentals Violation Database 9 - 26 The Planning Commission review and receive the current Vacation Home Rentals Violation Database and Current Statistics. Vacation Home Rentals Violation Database - Pdf STUDY SESSION-NONE ADJOURNMENT It is the intention of the City of Twentynine Palms to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act in all respects. If you are a person with a disability who requires a disability-related modification or accommodation in order to participate in a meeting, including auxiliary aids or services, please request such modification or accommodation from the City Clerk at (760) 367-4890 (facsimile). Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to assure accessibility to the meeting. Please advise us at the time whether you will require accommodations to participate in meetings on a regular basis. Any person affected by any application on this agenda may submit their concerns in writing prior to the meeting or appear in person and be heard in support or opposition to the proposal at the time the matter is considered on the agenda. The staff reports, applications and environmental documents may be viewed at either the office of Community Development or the office of the City Clerk, 6136 Adobe Road, from 7:00 a.m. until 6:00 p.m. Monday through Thursday, except legal holidays. The Invocation is given per Policy 10-01, and does not reflect the views of the City but rather is an expression of speech by a private citizen making the presentation. Telephone inquiries may be made at (760) 367-6799. If you challenge any agenda issue in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues that you or someone else raised at the public meeting described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City of Twentynine Palms at, or prior to, the public meeting. This notice of agenda is hereby certified to have been posted on or before 5:00 p.m., February 15, 2024. Cindy Villescas CMC, City Clerk Time/Date Page 2 of 26  STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development Director FOR MEETING: Feb 20 2024 SUBJECT: Housing Element Annual Report RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission accept and forward the Housing Element Annual Progress Report to the City Council. ORDER OF PROCEDURE: ATTACHMENTS: Request Staff Report Commission Question of Staff • Housing Element Annual Request Public Comment Progress Report Commission Discussion Motion/Second Discussion of Motion Call the Question BACKGROUND: Pursuant to State Government Code Section 65400, an annual progress report on the progress towards meeting the goals of the adopted Housing Element is required. This annual report, once approved by the Planning Commission and the City Council, will ultimately be submitted to the State Office of Planning Research and the California Department of Housing and Community Development. This report is meant to give detailed information regarding building permit activity. This includes both planning and building permit applications for housing developments, the type of housing, and the expected income of the future residents. The attachment to this report is the form provided by the State department of housing and Community Development and is standard throughout the State. This report shows the City's progress in meeting the goals set by the State for the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA). According to the analysis in the form provided by the state, we have 13 residential units in process at this time in both the Planning and Building Department application stage. A total of 27 residential units were constructed last year. A total of 989 more residential units are needed to be constructed by 2029 in order for the City to meet the RHNA goals. ENVIRONMENTAL: Not applicable. Page 3 of 26 FISCAL IMPACT: None. Page 4 of 26  This table is auto-populated once you enter your jurisdiction name and current year data. Past Jurisdiction Twentynine Palms ANNUAL ELEMENT PROGRESS REPORT year information comes from previous APRs. Reporting Year 2023 (Jan. 1 - Dec. 31) Housing Element Implementation Please contact HCD if your data is different than the material supplied here Planning Period 6th Cycle 10/15/2021 - 10/15/2029 Table B Regional Housing Needs Allocation Progress Permitted Units Issued by Affordability 1 Projection Period 2 3 4 Projection Period - Total Remaining RHNA Allocation by Total Units to Income Level 06/30/2021- 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 RHNA by Income Income Level Date (all years) Level 10/14/2021 Deed Restricted - - - - - - - - - - 231 - 231 Very Low Non-Deed Restricted - - - - - - - - - - Deed Restricted - - - - - - - - - - 127 18 109 Low Non-Deed Restricted - - - 18 - - - - - - Deed Restricted - - - - - - - - - - 185 40 145 Moderate Non-Deed Restricted 3 3 25 9 - - - - - - Above Moderate 504 - - - - - - - - - - - 504 Total RHNA 1,047 Total Units 3 3 25 27 - - - - - - 58 989 Progress toward extremely low-income housing need, as determined pursuant to Government Code 65583(a)(1). 5 6 7 Extremely low-Income Total Units to Total Units 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Need Date Remaining Extremely Low-Income Units* 116 - - - - - - - - - - 116 *Extremely low-income houisng need determined pursuant to Government Code 65583(a)(1). Value in Section 5 is default value, assumed to be half of the very low-income RHNA. May be overwritten. Please Note: Table B does not currently contain data from Table F or Table F2 for prior years. You may login to the APR system to see Table B that contains this data. Note: units serving extremely low-income households are included in the very low-income RHNA progress and must be reported as very low-income units in section 7 of Table A2. They must also be reported in the extremely low-income category (section 13) in Table A2 to be counted as progress toward meeting the extremely low-income housing need determined pursuant to Government Code 65583(a)(1). Please note: For the last year of the 5th cycle, Table B will only include units that were permitted during the portion of the year that was in the 5th cycle. For the first year of the 6th cycle, Table B will only include units that were permitted since the start of the planning period. Projection Period units are in a separate column. Please note: The APR form can only display data for one planning period. To view progress for a different planning period, you may login to HCD's online APR system, or contact HCD staff at apr@hcd.ca.gov. Page 5 of 26 Page 6 of 26  STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Assistant Planner FOR MEETING: Feb 20 2024 SUBJECT: DCA23-000004 Special Occupancy Parks RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission discuss the regulations for Special Occupancy Parks, provide direction to staff and postpone the hearing to a future meeting. ORDER OF PROCEDURE: Request Staff Report Commission Questions of Staff Open the Public Hearing Receive Public Comment Close the Public Hearing Commission Discussion Motion/Second Discussion on Motion Call the Question BACKGROUND: Staff is frequently approached by potential applicants with ideas for campgrounds that are not traditional. In particular, the term “glamping” has been used to describe activities that would include non-permanent structures for temporary habitation – primarily tents. Additionally, other structures that have been presented to staff in the past have included such things as boats, cabooses, rail cars, planes, and large passenger vehicles such as RVs or vans. Currently, City regulations list camping and RV parks under the same section of the development code with the same development standards. The Planning Commission held public hearings on September 19th, 2023, and November 07, 2023, to discuss the regulations for Special Occupancy Parks. In the prior Planning Commission discussions, Staff was presented with a potential State law (SB620) would allow or prescribe for the permitting of commercial campgrounds on a local level. Upon further research from our legal team, it has been discovered that this proposed bill is not up for consideration in this legislative session. Therefore, Staff has not included this information in our recommendations to the Planning Commission. The direction from the Commission was to separate regulations for Recreational Vehicle Parks and campgrounds and to research the regulations of other municipalities. Staff and the City Attorney's office have conducted the research and have found no other jurisdictions that have regulations for private commercial campgrounds of this nature. Several other jurisdictions have similar regulations to Twentynine Palms with regards to RV parks. Page 7 of 26 Chafee County, Colorado is the only jurisdiction that Staff has found so far that allows for commercial campgrounds on private lands. Their regulations have very low densities of use, only one tent for every five acres. To Staff’s knowledge, campgrounds are primarily developed and managed by Federal, State or County agencies. The Commission discussed the matrix below at the meeting of November 7th and added the items highlighted in red. High Impact Low Impact Dry/Primitive Approval Process CUP (commission) AUP (staff) SPR (staff) Max Density 5 sp/ac 1 sp/ac 1 sp/ac Min. Acreage 10 gross 5 gross 2 gross Restrooms required required to be defined not required Electricity required optional not required RV's allowed not allowed optional not allowed other mobile trailer allowed allowed not allowed Accessibility required optional not required Screening required not required not required Amenities yes allowed no no Parking 1 per campsite 1 per campsite 1 per campsite Distance btwn campsites to be discussed to be discussed to be discussed Alternative Structures allowed not allowed not allowed number of spaces 9 5 Distance to major roads to be discussed to be discussed to be discussed Noise/setbacks/sanitation Hosting requirements Zones where allowed P, CT, RL CT, RL (with CUP) CT It is Staff’s opinion that the various levels of permitting previously discussed are problematic in their complexities, and therefore very difficult to implement. In particular, the “dry” or “primitive” camping category that does not have sanitary or access to water services is not desirable within the City limits. Based upon the research conducted and further review of the standards and proposed permitting processes, together with community feedback, it is staff's recommendation that commercial campgrounds not be allowed within the City limits and that the Development Code be amended to allow only Recreational Vehicle Parks within the Tourist Commercial and Public zoning districts. Alternatively, if the Planning Commission wishes to allow for commercial campgrounds, Staff would recommend that they be located only in the CT (commercial tourist) and P (public) zones with a conditional use permit. It is the opinion of Staff that these types of activities are not appropriate in residential zones. ENVIRONMENTAL: not applicable ALTERNATIVES: 1) Make no changes to the Development Code, and keep regulations as they are currently. 2) Provide other direction to Staff. FISCAL IMPACT: None Page 8 of 26  STAFF REPORT TO: Planning Commision FROM: Community Development Director FOR MEETING: Feb 20 2024 SUBJECT: Vacation Home Rentals Violation Database RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission review and receive the current Vacation Home Rentals Violation Database and Current Statistics. ORDER OF PROCEDURE: ATTACHMENTS: Request Staff Report Commission Questions of Staff • Vacation Home Rental Request Public Comment Violations Database Commission Discussion Motion/Second Discussion of Motion • Violation Charts Call the Question • VHR Violation Matrix BACKGROUND: On May 24, 2022, the City Council approved Ordinance No. 299 which was the amendment to the Development Code Chapter 19.41 Vacation Home Rental. The City Staff has followed the direction of the City Council and has kept a database for Vacation Home Rental Violations to understand any trends or needs that may arise. The City Code Enforcement Department has created a database with information that has been provided by multiple sources. The Building and Safety Department, the Citizenserve Code Enforcement Online Compliance Portal and Southwest Security Services, the City's weekend complaint response unit, has helped to establish a database listing all currently approved Vacation Home Rental with their violations and dispositions. The City has a total of 439 Vacation Home Rental permits issued to date, and 10 Vacation home rental permits pending out of the 500 allowed by City code. While number of permits has declined over time, the Code Enforcement Department continues to receive complaints on a weekly basis. The creation of a database has shown that there are areas of concerns which may require further amendments to the Development Code. The complaints received range from noise, night sky ordinance violations, number of vehicles, trash receptacles, unpermitted short-term rentals, illegal campgrounds and signage. The Code Enforcement Department investigates each complaint to ensure they are legitimate, actionable and verifiable. These complaints must have complete details, including timelines and, when possible, photos or videos of the issue at hand; the reporting party is interviewed to ensure they understand the appropriate procedures in reporting the complaints. Questions such as did they contact the 24-Hour Contact number on the sign? Was there a response? Did they call the City code compliance number (if the disturbance occurred during normal business hours), the Southwest Security Page 9 of 26 Compliance Number or the Sherriff's department? After careful investigation, the Code Enforcement Department contacts the property owner to discuss the concern to try to find a resolution to the matter at hand. Some property owners have installed decibel readers, cameras and other monitoring systems at their properties where multiple noise complaints have been reported, so that they can provide evidence to Code Enforcement as to the reality on the ground. The Code Enforcement Department has reviewed all the Vacation Home Rental violations to establish the database and have included the spreadsheet, and charts to visually show the areas of concern or common trends amongst the violations. There are two (2) types of violations: Buidling and Safety and Code Enforcement. Each one has a specific process to achieve compliance and guidelines to bring the property up to code. The charts attached shows the City has received 183 Code Enforcement complaints and 53 Building and Safety referrals. It has been identified from the 183 complaints there are several which are submitted by the same person on the same day multiple times making the numbers inflated. The Building and Safety referrals are primarily from the safety inspections which are due every three (3) years upon renewal. The Inspectors come across a number of unpermitted improvements and modifications that have taken place after the initial approval. The top three complaint types are noise (parties, people in pools and music), Red Tags (unpermitted conversions and modifications), Unpermitted improvements (cowboy pools, spas, mini splits, etc.). These violation types are found during the Safety Inspections and/or come in as resident complaints. The charts also show the resolutions for the concerns received. The totals are: 37% non-actionable, 31% no violation, 25% unverifiable and 7% result in citations. Some residents have been clear on their opposition to Vacation Home Rentals in the City, and at times resolve to submit complaints to hinder the Vacation Home Rentals or skew complaint numbers. The Code Enforcement Department has worked with both residents and Vacation Home Rentals property owners to separate the perceived negative impacts from the real issues. The Code enforcement Department has found that most of the residents and property owners, when educated on what constitutes a violation, are able to report accordingly and able to maintain the property in compliance. Educating the public about the process of submitting a concern, what is an actual violation, who to contact based on the concern and how to be a responsible property owner helps create an accurate database. The creation of this database helps the City's official understand the needs and issues which enables them to create effective policy that supports the trends/changes in the community. The matrix of Vacation Home Rental License Violations and Punishments (attached) has been created to address the most common concerns and the proposed outcomes for the violations based on their severity and where the responsibility lies. It should be understood that the issuance of the Vacation Home Rental License can be obtained by providing all the requirements documentation and it requires the property owner to comply with all Codes. The approval of the license requires the property owner to maintain compliance throughout the term of the license and the failure to do so may have consequences ranging from administrative citations up to the revocation of their Vacation Home Rental license. ENVIRONMENTAL: None ALTERNATIVES: The Planning Commission may request additional information to be added to the current database. Page 10 of 26  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR001 06/21/2023 VHR004 07/10/2023 VHR007 11/28/2023 VHR008 01/22/2024 VHR013 04/24/2023 VHR015 05/31/2023 VHR016 12/19/2023 VHR017 12/19/2023 22-003200 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee/Forced Comp Closed 12/22/22 VHR019 08/30/2023 22-002737 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Non-Actionable Closed 10/28/22 VHR022 01/02/2024 21-000219 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 06/26/21 21-000217 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Duplicate Closed 21-000221 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Warning Issued Closed 12/29/21 23-000073 Building Red/Tag Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Double Fee Closed 01/11/23 VHR025 11/27/2023 21-000218 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Duplicate Closed 21-000222 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Warning Issued Closed 07/08/22 VHR026 07/13/2023 VHR027 07/27/2023 VHR028 10/04/2023 22-003028 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee VHR029 08/03/2023 VHR033 01/03/2024 VHR034 05/03/2023 VHR035 02/28/2023 23-000397 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee VHR036 4/20/2023 23-000480 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee 23-000481 Building Red/Tag Outdoor Shower Double Fee VHR037 01/25/2024 VHR038 01/25/2024 VHR043 04/11/2023 23-000518 Building Red/Tag Water Heater Double Fee VHR046 09/13/2023 VHR052 11/08/2023 23-001762 Code Trash Cans on Curb Non-Actionable Closed 10/26/23 VHR053 09/11/2023 VHR054 07/06/2023 VHR056 09/05/2023 VHR057 05/25/2023 VHR060 01/03/2024 23-000201 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed 23-000182 Building Red/Tag Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Double Fee Closed VHR061 01/03/2024 VHR062 04/05/2023 23-000500 Building Red/Tag Shade Structure/Pergola Double Fee Closed 23-000277 Building Red/Tag Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Double Fee Closed VHR063 03/28/2023 VHR065 05/10/2023 VHR066 05/10/2023 VHR069 04/13/2023 VHR073 07/12/2023 VHR075 08/03/2023 21-000135 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Non-Actionable Closed 21-001002 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Duplicate Closed 21-001006 Code Noise Unapproved Fixtures Voluntary Compliance Closed 07/27/22 23-000567 Code Other Unapproved Fixtures Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR076 08/29/2023 VHR077 08/03/2023 VHR082 12/19/2022 VHR083 12/12/2023 VHR084 01/18/2024 VHR085 01/18/2024 VHR086 04/03/2023 VHR087 03/30/2023 VHR088 01/29/2024 VHR089 01/22/2024 VHR090 01/29/2024 VHR100 8/23/2023 21-000240 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number Voluntary Compliance Closed 07/14/21 Page 11 of 26 Page 1 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date 21-000535 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number Duplicate Closed 21-000547 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number Citation Closed 07/24/22 21-000792 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number Citation Closed 06/16/22 22-000793 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Non-Actionable Closed 08/25/22 22-000805 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Citation 22-001673 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Non-Actionable Closed 22-001672 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Non-Actionable Closed 22-002517 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Warning Issued Closed 10/06/22 22-002997 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Warning Issued Closed 11/29/22 23-001610 Code Other Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed VHR103 03/02/2023 VHR105 04/17/2023 VHR106 06/21/2023 VHR107 06/05/2023 VHR109 06/21/2023 VHR110 06/05/2023 VHR112 07/31/2023 VHR113 10/24/2023 VHR115 02/06/2023 20-000006 Code No License No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed VHR116 09/11/2023 VHR117 11/21/2023 20-000007 Code No License No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed 23-000261 Building Red/Tag Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Double Fee 23-000274 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee VHR118 08/31/2023 21-000120 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music Warning Issued Closed 21-000133 Code Noise Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Warning Issued Closed VHR119 09/12/2023 VHR121 11/28/2023 VHR122 12/14/2023 VHR123 01/29/2024 VHR126 11/02/2023 21-000747 Code Other Fencing Violation No-Violation Closed VHR127 10/10/2023 VHR131 02/01/2023 VHR132 10/10/2023 VHR134 01/08/2024 VHR135 01/10/2024 VHR136 04/12/2023 21-000111 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number No-Violation Closed 21-000449 Code Sign No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed VHR137 04/12/2023 VHR138 05/15/2023 VHR139 01/09/2024 21-000102 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed VHR140 12/19/2023 VHR143 01/02/2024 VHR144 01/31/2024 21-000233 Code Night Sky Unapproved Fixtures Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR145 03/28/2023 VHR147 02/23/2023 VHR148 08/14/2023 VHR150 02/23/2023 VHR151 01/16/2024 VHR152 02/22/2023 VHR153 03/29/2023 VHR154 06/28/2023 VHR156 07/10/2023 VHR157 02/21/2023 VHR158 06/26/2023 VHR160 06/28/2023 VHR161 03/27/2023 VHR162 04/05/2023 VHR163 07/10/2023 Page 12 of 26 Page 2 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR164 05/15/2023 20-27 PC Appeal Appeal - Failed Closed VHR165 04/12/2023 VHR166 09/13/2023 VHR167 06/13/2023 VHR168 04/19/2023 VHR169 04/18/2023 21-000099 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Non-Actionable Closed VHR174 04/26/2023 VHR175 09/13/2023 VHR176 05/25/2023 VHR177 05/30/2023 VHR181 07/03/2023 VHR182 08/14/2023 VHR183 04/25/2023 21-000868 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed 21-000879 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed 21-000897 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Warning Issued Closed 22-000181 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Citation Closed 23-000635 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Unverifiable Closed VHR184 06/12/2023 VHR185 07/12/2023 23-000018 Building Other OHV Non-Actionable Closed VHR186 10/24/2023 21-000088 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number/Location Voluntary Compliance Closed 21-000399 Code Vehicle RV/Motorhome Use Warning Issued Closed VHR187 05/31/2023 VHR188 06/06/2023 VHR189 06/20/2023 VHR190 07/31/2023 22-003088 Code Unpermitted Shade Structure/Pergola Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR191 09/25/2023 22-001928 Code Other Neighbor Disapproval of VHR Non-Actionable Closed VHR192 06/28/2023 VHR193 05/08/2023 VHR196 05/08/2023 VHR198 05/22/2023 VHR199 08/08/2023 22-001773 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 22-002291 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 22-002372 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-000531 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed VHR200 10/16/2023 VHR203 06/01/2023 VHR204 08/14/2023 VHR208 10/16/2023 VHR21-315 06/12/2023 VHR21-316 03/16/2023 VHR21-318 03/20/2023 VHR21-319 04/06/2023 VHR21-320 03/20/2023 22-001307 Code Unpermitted Outdoor Shower Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements VHR21-321 07/20/2023 23-001032 Code Unpermitted Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements VHR21-323 03/27/2023 VHR21-324 02/22/2023 VHR21-326 04/25/2023 VHR21-327 05/08/2023 VHR21-331 03/28/2023 VHR21-332 04/24/2023 VHR21-333 04/26/2023 VHR21-334 07/31/2023 VHR21-337 06/15/2023 Page 13 of 26 Page 3 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR21-338 04/12/2023 21-000263 Code Noise Duplicate Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 21-000344 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 21-000357 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises VHR21-339 10/16/2023 22-000541 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR21-340 06/08/2023 21-000682 Code Unpermitted Window Change out Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements VHR21-341 03/15/2023 VHR21-342 04/18/2023 VHR21-343 06/06/2023 VHR21-344 10/12/2023 21-000029 Code Trash Cans on Curb Unverifiable Closed VHR21-345 05/30/2023 VHR21-346 05/10/2023 VHR21-347 06/08/2023 VHR21-348 04/12/2023 VHR21-349 07/17/2023 22-002104 Code Sign Voluntary Compliance Closed No Sign/Wrong Number/Location 22-002645 Code Noise Duplicate Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 22-002649 Code Noise Non-Actionable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000290 Code Noise Duplicate Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000429 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000696 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000735 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000772 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-000836 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001023 Code Noise Unverifiable Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001047 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001149 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001449 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles No-Violation Closed 23-001452 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles No-Violation Closed 23-001499 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001581 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles No-Violation Closed 23-001687 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles No-Violation Closed 23-001694 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles No-Violation Closed Page 14 of 26 Page 4 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date 23-001738 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001874 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-002120 Code Noise SWS - Verified No Violation Closed Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises VHR21-350 07/19/2023 22-000275 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow No-Violation Closed 22-000355 Code Other Neighbor Disapproval of VHR Non-Actionable Closed 22-000448 Code Other Neighbor Disapproval of VHR Non-Actionable Closed 22-002750 Code Unpermitted Shade Structure/Pergola/Shed No-Violation Closed Improvements 23-000455 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number/Location Citation Closed 23-000660 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-000701 Code Other Occupancy/Room/People Voluntary Compliance Closed 23-000835 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 23-001498 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 23-001540 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises SWS - Verified No Violation Closed VHR21-351 06/12/2023 VHR21-355 04/13/2023 VHR21-357 09/18/2023 VHR21-361 05/17/2023 23-001213 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky SWS - Verified No Violation Closed VHR21-362 03/20/2023 22-000067 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate 22-000775 Code Other Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Rescinded 22-001865 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR21-363 04/12/2023 21-000771 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Non-Actionable Closed 22-002099 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Non-Actionable Closed VHR21-364 06/21/2023 23-000125 Code Vehicle Commercial Vehicles Voluntary Compliance Closed 23-000570 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed 23-000573 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed VHR21-365 07/31/2023 VHR21-366 05/23/2023 VHR21-367 10/24/2023 VHR210 9/18/2023 21-000204 Code Other RV/Motorhome Use No-Violation Closed 23-000542 Code Other Occupancy/Room/People Duplicate Closed 23-000546 Code Other Occupancy/Room/People Voluntary Compliance Closed 23-001146 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed 23-001147 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed 23-002078 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed VHR211 07/17/2023 23-001835 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 23-001839 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed VHR212 09/25/2023 VHR213 10/24/2023 21-000382 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Voluntary Compliance Closed 21-000434 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Duplicate Closed 21-000792 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number/Location Voluntary Compliance Closed 22-001386 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 22-001488 Code Other Occupancy/Room/People Voluntary Compliance Closed 23-001967 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed Page 15 of 26 Page 5 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR215 09/18/2023 VHR216 02/14/2023 VHR217 12/18/2023 23-001834 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises SWS - Verified No Violation Closed VHR218 12/18/2023 VHR219 07/11/2023 VHR22-001 06/26/2023 22-001811 Code Unpermitted Mini-Split Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements VHR22-002 05/11/2023 22-002229 Code Unpermitted Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements VHR22-003 06/12/2023 23-001204 Code Unpermitted Fire Pit Voluntary Compliance Closed Improvements 23-001428 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Non-Actionable Closed 23-001856 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Duplicate Closed 23-001857 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR22-008 05/15/2023 VHR22-009 09/12/2023 VHR22-010 05/18/2023 VHR22-011 06/26/2023 VHR22-012 05/15/2023 VHR22-013 07/12/2023 VHR22-017 08/08/2023 VHR22-018 06/14/2023 22-002768 Code Unpermitted Mini-Split Forced Compliance Closed Improvements VHR22-019 06/14/2023 VHR22-021 06/26/2023 22-002251 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Warning & Citation Closed VHR22-022 06/12/2023 VHR22-025 08/14/2023 VHR22-027 08/14/2023 VHR22-028 07/13/2023 VHR22-029 09/19/2023 VHR22-031 05/31/2023 VHR22-034 07/03/2023 VHR22-035 06/08/2023 22-001486 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Warning & Citation Closed 22-001515 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Warning & Citation Closed 22-001498 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Duplicate Closed 22-001496 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 22-001978 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Duplicate Closed 22-002252 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Duplicate Closed VHR22-036 08/21/2023 VHR22-037 05/31/2023 VHR22-038 05/30/2023 VHR22-039 04/26/2023 VHR22-040 09/05/2023 VHR22-043 08/08/2023 VHR22-044 06/08/2023 VHR22-045 10/16/2023 VHR22-046 10/16/2023 VHR22-047 07/31/2023 VHR22-049 06/12/2023 VHR22-050 06/26/2023 VHR22-051 10/23/2023 22-002416 Code Unpermitted Shade Structure/Pergola/Shed Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR22-052 08/14/2023 VHR22-053 07/11/2022 VHR22-054 08/15/2023 VHR22-055 12/11/2023 VHR22-056 05/23/2023 Page 16 of 26 Page 6 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR22-058 11/20/2023 21-000113 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Voluntary Compliance Closed 21-000124 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed 21-000126 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed 21-000131 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed 22-001306 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning & Citation Closed Improvements 23-000634 Code No License No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed VHR22-060 07/17/2023 VHR22-061 10/24/2023 VHR22-062 09/13/2023 VHR22-063 07/12/2023 VHR22-066 10/09/2023 22-000397 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Warning Issued Closed 22-000396 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Duplicate Closed VHR22-067 06/08/2023 VHR22-068 07/26/2023 VHR22-069 11/13/2023 VHR22-071 06/26/2023 22-002055 Code Sign No Sign/Wrong Number/Location Voluntary Compliance Closed VHR22-078 01/09/2023 VHR22-079 10/24/2023 VHR22-080 09/06/2023 VHR22-082 06/14/2023 VHR22-084 07/12/2023 VHR22-086 06/08/2023 VHR22-087 06/28/2023 VHR22-088 10/04/2023 VHR22-090 10/24/2023 VHR22-094 10/19/2023 VHR22-096 9/25/2023 23-000493 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-000597 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed VHR22-097 08/03/2023 VHR22-098 09/27/2022 VHR22-099 07/05/2023 VHR22-100 08/16/2023 VHR22-101 08/31/2023 VHR22-102 08/21/2023 VHR22-104 09/12/2023 VHR22-105 09/18/2023 VHR22-106 09/11/2023 VHR22-107 09/26/2023 VHR22-108 08/14/2023 VHR22-110 10/12/2022 VHR22-111 07/10/2023 VHR22-112 11/21/2023 VHR22-113 09/19/2023 MIN22-000883 Building Unpermitted Mini-Split Double Fee/Forced Comp Closed Improvements VHR22-114 10/02/2023 VHR22-115 02/16/2023 MIN23-000040 Building Unpermitted Mini-Split Double Fee Closed Improvements VHR22-116 09/11/2023 22-000036 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR22-117 10/04/2023 VHR22-118 09/06/2023 VHR22-120 09/12/2023 VHR22-121 10/12/2023 VHR22-122 09/27/2022 22-001099 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Warning Issued Closed VHR22-123 09/11/2023 22-002871 Code Vehicle OHV/Speeding/Tresspassing Non-Actionable Closed VHR22-125 10/25/2023 Building Unpermitted Mini-Split Double Fee Closed Improvements Page 17 of 26 Page 7 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR22-126 11/01/2023 20--000008 Code Other RV/Motorhome Use No-Violation Closed VHR22-128 09/18/2023 VHR22-129 01/08/2024 MIN22-001220 Building Unpermitted Water Heater Double Fee Closed Improvements MIN22-001139 Building Unpermitted Remodel Double Fee Closed Improvements MIN22-001136 Building Unpermitted Mini-Split Double Fee Closed Improvements VHR22-130 09/25/2023 VHR22-132 01/16/2024 MIN22-001131 Building Unpermitted Water Heater Double Fee Closed Improvements MAJ22-000457 Building Unpermitted Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Double Fee Closed Improvements 22-001308 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR22-133 10/05/2023 VHR22-134 10/04/2023 VHR22-135 12/20/2022 VHR22-136 11/13/2023 VHR22-141 10/25/2023 VHR22-142 10/12/2023 VHR22-143 12/07/2023 MIN22-001071 Building Red/Tag Window Change out Double Fee Closed VHR22-144 01/16/2024 VHR22-145 04/17/2023 VHR22-146 04/17/2023 VHR22-147 11/30/2023 VHR22-148 10/23/2023 MIN22-001081 Building Red/Tag HVAC Change Out Double Fee Closed VHR22-149 10/02/2023 VHR22-150 01/16/2024 MIN22-001158 Building Red/Tag Fire Pit Double Fee Closed MIN22-001130 Building Red/Tag Window Change out Double Fee Closed VHR22-151 12/11/2023 VHR22-154 10/12/2023 VHR22-155 09/21/2023 VHR22-156 12/12/2023 VHR22-157 01/19/2023 MIN23-000004 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-158 11/21/2023 VHR22-159 11/14/2023 MAJ22-000496 Building Red/Tag Demo Double Fee Closed VHR22-160 02/27/2023 VHR22-161 11/14/2023 VHR22-162 10/16/2023 VHR22-163 10/12/2023 MIN22-001080 Building Red/Tag HVAC Change Out Double Fee Closed VHR22-164 01/23/2024 VHR22-165 01/02/2024 VHR22-166 10/09/2023 VHR22-167 09/25/2023 VHR22-168 10/12/2023 VHR22-170 12/12/2022 MIN22-001103 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-171 10/09/2023 22-002491 Code rmitted Improvem Electrical Panel Upgrade Warning Issued Closed MIN22-000966 Building Red/Tag Water Heater Double Fee Closed MIN22-000967 Building Red/Tag Electrical Panel Upgrade Double Fee Closed VHR22-172 02/27/2023 MAJ22-000559 Building Red/Tag Remodel Double Fee Closed VHR22-173 12/07/2023 VHR22-174 10/12/2023 VHR22-175 12/11/2023 VHR22-176 10/23/2023 VHR22-177 10/10/2023 23-000787 Code Unpermitted Pool/Hot Tub/Spa Forced Compliance Closed Improvements Page 18 of 26 Page 8 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR22-178 03/20/2023 MIN23-000124 Building Red/Tag Remodel Double Fee Closed MIN23-000063 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-180 08/10/2023 VHR22-183 10/25/2023 VHR22-184 10/12/2023 VHR22-185 01/09/2023 22-000765 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR22-187 12/11/2023 VHR22-189 01/08/2024 MIN22-001173 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-190 10/02/2023 VHR22-191 11/13/2023 VHR22-192 12/04/2023 23-000070 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed VHR22-193 01/29/2024 VHR22-194 11/01/2023 VHR22-195 02/16/2023 23-000631 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed Illegal Activities(drugs, No-Violation Closed 23-000630 Code Other prostitution,etc.) Unverifiable Closed 23-001017 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed 23-001728 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises 23-001996 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed VHR22-196 12/01/2022 VHR22-198 01/25/2024 22-001016 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Warning Issued Closed VHR22-200 12/01/2022 VHR22-201 01/03/2023 VHR22-202 12/13/2023 VHR22-205 02/27/2023 VHR22-206 04/11/2023 VHR22-207 01/02/2024 VHR22-208 01/31/2023 22-001392 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Warning Issued Closed 22-002748 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Warning & Citation Closed MIN23-000027 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-209 01/23/2023 VHR22-210 10/17/2023 MIN22-001003 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-212 10/09/2023 VHR22-213 08/29/2023 VHR22-216 12/14/2023 MIN22-001070 Building Red/Tag Water Heater Double Fee Closed VHR22-217 10/02/2023 VHR22-218 01/02/2024 MIN22-001123 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed MIN22-001122 Building Red/Tag Water Heater Double Fee Closed VHR22-220 01/08/2024 MAJ23-000006 Building Red/Tag Shade Structure/Pergola/Shed Double Fee Closed VHR22-221 01/22/2024 22-002219 Code Unpermitted Shade Structure/Pergola/Shed Warning Issued Closed Improvements MAJ22-000389 Building Red/Tag Shade Structure/Pergola/Shed Double Fee Closed MIN23-000009 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-222 01/16/2024 VHR22-223 01/03/2024 VHR22-224 02/07/2023 VHR22-225 02/07/2023 VHR22-227 09/26/2023 21-001252 Code rmitted Improvem Remodel Warning Issued Closed VHR22-228 10/12/2023 VHR22-229 11/01/2023 VHR22-230 12/05/2023 VHR22-231 01/18/2024 23-001818 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed VHR22-233 01/25/2024 VHR22-234 11/01/2023 VHR22-236 03/06/2023 Page 19 of 26 Page 9 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR22-237 01/30/2024 23-000059 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning Issued Closed Improvements MAJ23-000019 Building Red/Tag Remodel Double Fee Closed MIN23-000091 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-238 01/02/2024 23-002096 Code Trash Cans on Curb VHR22-240 11/27/2023 VHR22-241 01/04/2023 VHR22-244 03/06/2023 VHR22-245 01/24/2023 23-001724 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow No-Violation Closed VHR22-246 02/07/2023 VHR22-248 03/07/2023 23-000202 Code Other Pool/Hot Tub/Spa No-Violation Closed 23-000320 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed 23-000383 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed 23-000431 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed 23-000616 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed VHR22-250 01/11/2024 MIN22-001175 Building Red/Tag Electrical Panel Upgrade Double Fee Closed MIN22-001170 Building Red/Tag Window Change out Double Fee Closed MAJ23-000082 Building Red/Tag Remodel Double Fee Closed VHR22-251 01/11/2024 22-000278 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Warning Issued Closed 22-000360 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky Warning Issued Closed 23-001191 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Courtesy Notice Closed 23-001518 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-001519 Code Night Sky Lights/Edison Lights/Dark Sky No-Violation Closed 23-001546 Code Unpermitted Remodel No-Violation Closed Improvements 23-001545 Code No License No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed 23-001691 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-001690 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Unverifiable Closed 23-001689 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed VHR22-252 02/27/2023 MIN23-000095 Building Red/Tag Mini-Split Double Fee Closed VHR22-253 01/30/2024 VHR22-254 03/28/2023 VHR22-257 01/30/2024 VHR22-258 02/28/2023 VHR22-259 05/22/2023 VHR22-261 10/03/2023 VHR22-262 04/25/2023 MIN23-000200 Building Red/Tag Outdoor Shower Double Fee Closed VHR22-263 05/02/2023 VHR22-264 03/28/2023 MIN23-000118 Building Red/Tag Water Heater Double Fee Closed VHR22-265 06/20/2023 VHR221 08/21/2023 VHR222 07/10/2023 VHR223 08/23/2023 VHR224 09/12/2023 VHR226 09/27/2023 VHR227 10/16/2023 VHR228 08/01/2023 VHR229 09/25/2023 21-000580 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Warning Issued Closed VHR23-002 03/13/2023 VHR23-004 05/09/2023 23-001031 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Warning Issued Closed VHR23-005 04/25/2023 VHR23-007 04/04/2023 VHR23-010 06/20/2023 VHR23-012 09/25/2023 VHR23-013 05/09/2023 VHR23-014 06/20/2023 VHR23-015 05/09/2023 VHR23-016 06/06/2023 Page 20 of 26 Page 10 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR23-017 06/13/2023 VHR23-019 08/15/2023 VHR23-020 11/14/2023 VHR23-022 09/26/2023 VHR23-023 10/24/2023 VHR23-030 11/01/2023 VHR23-031 01/23/2024 VHR23-032 12/11/2023 23-000620 Code Unpermitted Remodel Warning Issued Closed Improvements MIN23-000249 Building Red/Tag Remodel Double Fee Closed VHR23-033 12/12/2023 VHR230 10/04/2023 VHR232 09/18/2023 24-000067 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Ongoing VHR233 09/12/2023 VHR234 11/16/2023 22-000544 Code Vehicle Too many Vehicles Non-Actionable Closed 22-001777 Code Noise Parties/Loud Music/Loud Noises Non-Actionable Closed VHR239 07/31/2023 VHR241 10/12/2023 VHR242 10/12/2023 VHR244 08/31/2023 VHR245 10/09/2023 VHR246 08/30/2023 VHR247 01/25/2024 VHR248 10/16/2023 VHR249 11/16/2023 VHR252 11/01/2023 VHR255 08/29/2023 VHR256 09/25/2023 VHR257 10/19/2023 VHR258 01/31/2024 VHR260 05/16/2023 VHR262 11/15/2023 VHR263 11/02/2023 VHR264 11/14/2023 VHR265 11/14/2023 VHR270 06/01/2023 VHR271 01/24/2023 VHR272 02/09/2023 VHR273 11/16/2023 VHR277 04/12/2023 VHR279 04/24/2023 VHR281 04/24/2023 VHR282 02/13/2023 VHR283 11/01/2023 23-000633 Code Other Illegal Activities(drugs, Non-Actionable Closed prostitution,etc.) 23-000641 Code No License No VHR Permit/License No-Violation Closed VHR285 01/16/2024 VHR287 01/30/2024 VHR290 03/08/2023 VHR291 02/23/2023 22-000309 Code No License No VHR Permit/License Warning Issued Closed VHR292 01/22/2024 VHR293 10/23/2023 VHR295 02/09/2023 VHR296 06/15/2023 VHR298 01/22/2024 22-003015 Code Trash Trash/Trash Cans overflow Citation Closed VHR299 01/31/2024 VHR301 06/12/2023 VHR304 01/16/2024 Page 21 of 26 Page 11 of 12  Vacation Home Rental Violations Database 02/20/2024 License# Issue Date Case Number Type Violation Information Resolution Status Date VHR305 05/30/2023 22-002820 Code Unpermitted Mini-Split Warning Issued Closed Improvements VHR306 01/16/2024 VHR307 04/13/2023 VHR308 01/30/2024 VHR309 02/15/2023 VHR310 01/26/2023 VHR311 03/28/2023 VHR312 03/06/2023 VHR313 02/23/2023 VHR314 01/16/2024 VIOLATION TYPES Resolution CODE TOTAL: 183 No Violation 29 BUILDING TOTAL: 53 Non-actionable 34 Citation 6 VIOLATIONS Unverifiable 23 UNPERMITTED IMPROVEMENT: 30 NO LICENSE: 16 RED TAGS: 44 LIGHT: 22 TRASH: 22 NOISE: 59 VEHICLES: 15 SIGN: 11 OTHER: 17 Page 22 of 26 Page 12 of 12  VIOLATION CATEGORIES 53 183 CODE TOTAL: BUILDING TOTAL: Page 23 of 26  Violations Types OTHER: 17 SIGN: 11 VEHICLES: 15 NOISE: 59 TRASH: 22 LIGHT: 22 RED TAGS: 44 NO LICENSE: 16 UNPERMITTED IMPROVEMENT: 30 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Page 24 of 26  Resolutions 25% 31% No Violation Non-actionable Citation 7% Unverifiable 37% Page 25 of 26  Heirarchy of VHR License Violations and Punishments HOST CONTROL GUEST CONTROL REVOKE Advertising of illegal activities Repeated citation of illegal activities Repeated suspensions and/or suspendable activities Noncompliance with conditions (# of beds, occupancy, etc) Inaccurate advertising / advertising that contradicts permit Leasing activities that contradicts permit Unpermitted structures SUSPEND Construction / modification without permits More than three disturbance violations in 12-month period Repeated fineable activities Conduct of illegal activities (drug dealing, prostitution, etc) FINE Repeat offense on those items given warnings prior Disturbance violations WARNING Unverified, legitimate complaints Trash cans taken out on wrong day Sign not visible / modified Excessive parking Page 26 of 26