Community Affairs Committee

7725 W. North Avenue Wauwatosa, WI Wauwatosa, WI 53213 Community Affairs Committee Meeting Minutes Tuesday, January 9, 2024 7:30 PM Zoom Only: https://servetosa.zoom.us/j/82923188685, Meeting ID: 829 2318 8685 Regular Meeting CALL TO ORDER Chairperson Wilke called the meeting to order at 7:32 PM. ROLL CALL Present 8 Alderperson District 8 Chair Jason Wilke Alderperson District 4 Vice Chair Ernst Franzen Alderperson District 2 John Dubinski Alderperson District 5 Sean Lowe Alderperson District 3 Joseph Makhlouf II Alderperson District 2 Andrew Meindl Alderperson District 7 Mike Morgan Alderperson District 6 Meagan O'Reilly ORDINANCES FOR ADOPTION CONSIDERATION 1. Ordinance amending the Official Zoning Map of the City of Wauwatosa 23-1055 from Special Purpose - Public Facilities District (SP-PUB) to Special Purpose - Parks and Open Space District (SP-POS) at the southeast corner of 116th Street and Gilbert Avenue for the west side park Recommendation: Introduced December 19, 2023, for adoption consideration Tamara Szudy, Planning & Zoning Manager, and Dave Simpson, Public Works Director, presented the item. RESULT: RECOMMENDED FOR ADOPTION MOVER: Mike Morgan SECONDER: Sean Lowe Aye: 8 Ald Wilke, Ald Franzen, Ald Dubinski, Ald Lowe, Ald Makhlouf II, Ald Meindl, Ald Morgan, and Ald O'Reilly 2. Ordinance amending Secs. 24.03.030, 24.03.040 and 24.07.030 of the 23-1306 Wauwatosa Municipal Code related to building height for C2 zoned properties Recommendation: Introduced December 19, 2023, for adoption consideration Tamara Szudy, Planning & Zoning Manager, presented the item . Page 1 of 3 Community Affairs Committee Meeting Minutes January 9, 2024 Discussion was had regarding the item. Public Comments Erika Sanders, Metro Fair Housing Council, supports the item Indy Stluka, 746 N 112th St, made a comment on the item to keep /increase unit density and supports the height limit in C2 zone Brian Randall, 204 N 86th St, is opposed Ann Kammerer, 728 N 113th St, made a few comments on the item Five amendments were proposed. 1. Motion by Ald Makhlouf, seconded by Ald Meindl, to amend Part II, subsection J .2.a. to change 80% to 40%. Motion failed 3-5 (Dubinski, Franzen, Lowe, Morgan and Wilke voted no). 2. Motion by Ald Makhlouf, seconded by Ald Meindl, to amend Part III to change " P" to "C". Motion failed 4-4 (Dubinski, Lowe, Morgan and Wilke voted no). 3. Motion by Ald Makhlouf, seconded by Ald Meindl, to amend Part I to amend minimum lot area per unit in the table in 24.03.030 B. to 726 sq. ft.(60 units per acre). Motion failed 2-6 (Dubinski, Franzen, Lowe, Morgan, O'Reilly, and Wilke voted no). 4. Motion by Ald Lowe, seconded by Ald Morgan, to eliminate Part II . Motion failed 2-6 (Dubinski, Franzen, Makhlouf, Meindl, O'Reilly and Wilke voted no). 5. Motion by Ald Meindl, seconded by Ald Franzen, to amend Part II, subsection J .2.a to strike "20% or more" and replace it with "a specified percentage of", strike "80 % or below the" and replace it with "the corresponding", and add at the end of the sentence "as shown in the table below: % of units to qualify AMI % Level 25% 80% 15% 50% 10% 30% Motion failed 4-4 (Dubinski, Lowe, Morgan and Wilke voted no). RESULT: RECOMMENDED FOR ADOPTION MOVER: Joseph Makhlouf II SECONDER: Meagan O'Reilly Aye: 6 Ald Wilke, Ald Franzen, Ald Makhlouf II, Ald Meindl, Ald Morgan, and Ald O'Reilly Nay: 2 Ald Dubinski, and Ald Lowe COMMUNITY AFFAIRS COMMITTEE ITEMS 1. Request by Chris Geiger, Cardinal Capital Management, for a Planned 23-1261 Unit Development (PUD) Approval Extension for a senior residential apartment development at the northwest corner of 74th Street and Wright Street Tamara Szudy, Planning & Zoning Manager, and Katie Hampel, 111 E Kilbourn Ave, presented the item . RESULT: RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL Page 2 of 3 Community Affairs Committee Meeting Minutes January 9, 2024 MOVER: Meagan O'Reilly SECONDER: Sean Lowe Aye: 8 Ald Wilke, Ald Franzen, Ald Dubinski, Ald Lowe, Ald Makhlouf II, Ald Meindl, Ald Morgan, and Ald O'Reilly 2. Request by Gabriela Prewitt, The Architects Partnership, LTD., for a 23-1359 Major Planned Unit Development (PUD) Amendment at 11111 W. Burleigh Street to construct a bank with drive through (Chase Bank) Tamara Szudy, Planning & Zoning Manager, and Henry Amegatcher, 200 S Michigan Ave, presented the item. RESULT: RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL MOVER: Mike Morgan SECONDER: Ernst Franzen Aye: 7 Ald Wilke, Ald Franzen, Ald Dubinski, Ald Lowe, Ald Makhlouf II, Ald Meindl, and Ald Morgan Nay: 1 Ald O'Reilly 3. Request by Ad Hoc Community Land Trust Formation Committee to 24-0007 increase Committee membership from 8 (eight) to 9 (nine) voting members Paulette Enders, Development Director, presented the item. RESULT: RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL MOVER: Mike Morgan SECONDER: Ernst Franzen Aye: 8 Ald Wilke, Ald Franzen, Ald Dubinski, Ald Lowe, Ald Makhlouf II, Ald Meindl, Ald Morgan, and Ald O'Reilly ADJOURNMENT Meeting was adjourned at 9:16 PM. Page 3 of 3