Citizen's Environmental Quality Committee
Regular MeetingWinona, MN · April 6, 2023
Minutes
CITIZENS ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE MEETING NOTES
DATE: Thursday April 6, 2023
TIME: Scheduled for 4:30 pm in the City Hall Council Chambers
PRESENT: Sadie Neuman, Madalyn Bollig, Paul Schmitt and Dan Hall
GUESTS:
STAFF: John Howard, Abby Wickboldt
1. Call to Order: Call to order at 4:38 PM by Dan Hall (Chair).
2. Review and Approval of March. 2023 Meeting Minutes: Motion by Paul, 2nd by Madalyn. Approved
unanimously.
3. Community Garden Update: John provided a brief update. The East Rec garden is fully subscribed and
should be opening soon. John intends to have a neighborhood meeting to discuss west side garden options,
and then hopefully build this spring. The Hiawatha Valley Mental health grant has not been awarded yet to
John’s knowledge. Abby had questions about a proposed rain garden there, and if it would supply the
garden’s water. John believes the rain garden would just be to filter stormwater for infiltration and not to
irrigate the garden.
4. Boulevard and Park Tree:
Abby began by describing the tree inventory efforts of earlier members, and shared her iTree Eco report
with members of the CEQC. Abby described that there are many interesting data points to capture and
display through the iTree program such as pollution captured and dollar values of ecological services. There
is even more data Abby could gather for a more robust and specific recommendations.
Abby asked the CEQC for input on what to focus on and what to share with the community and City Council.
She said dollar figures for every individual tree can be calculated.
Dan noted that the online Beacon website displays details on the public trees. Dan feels numbers add
weight to the argument for trees. Abby described the many benefits that trees can provide, and that large
trees are regularly being cut down for various reasons, such as street reconstruction. The overall outlook for
trees is bleak with many more ash trees to be removed in the years to come.
Paul said energy and carbon data would be useful – tons might be harder for people to understand. Dan
suggested focusing on tree deserts, and the benefits the trees would have in these areas. Dan referenced 8th
St. reconstruction. Sadie suggests using “Canopy scarce” in place of “tree desert”.
Sadie asked what resistance there is to tree planting in the City, or where that is coming from. Abby
described the tension between engineering projects removing boulevard trees and residents wanting them.
John relayed the budget for tree planting depends on grants. Sadie suggest a behavior change program
would be useful to get more people to support trees.
Maddi understands the value of a condensed report version, but also would like to see the full analysis.
Maddi suggests contacting the universities to reach passionate tree people and students. Abby wonders
how to best engage with other passionate people, and achieve change. The CEQC members suggest Friends
of Winona Parks, Healthy Lake Winona, Anne Conway and Winona Outdoor Collaborative. Abby described
some of her previous work with a non-profit tree planting, and concerns about making an impact with
university students.
5. Earth and Arbor Day Events: There will be an earth and arbor day event in Winona this year on April 22nd at
the Jaycee Pavilion. The City is again in the Tree City USA program. Abby is planning a tree give away at City
Hall on Arbor Day, April 28th.
6. Other Business: Conservation Minnesota is holding an environmental board game session later this month.
7. Adjournment: Motion to adjourn by Paul, second by Madalyn. Accepted by acclamation. Adjourned at 5:26.
Notes prepared by John Howard.
Agenda
April 3, 2023
Citizens Environmental Quality Committee
Winona, Minnesota 55987
Dear Committee Members:
The next meeting of the Citizens Environmental Quality Committee meeting will be held
on Thursday, April 6th, 2023 at 4:30 p.m. in the City Council Chambers at City Hall.
1. Call to Order
2. Review of March Meeting Minutes
3. Community Garden Update (5 minutes)
4. Boulevard and Park Tree Data (20 minutes)
5. Earth and Arbor Day Events (5 minutes)
6. Other Business (5 minutes)
7. Adjournment
Sincerely,
John Howard
Natural Resources Sustainability Coordinator
CITIZENS ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE MEETING NOTES
DATE: Thursday March 2, 2023
TIME: Scheduled for 4:30 pm in the City Hall Council Chambers
PRESENT: Sadie Neuman, Madalyn Bollig, and Dan Hall
GUESTS:
STAFF: John Howard
1. Call to Order: Call to order at 4:38 PM by Dan Hall (Chair).
2. Review and Approval of Jan. 2023 Meeting Minutes: Motion by Sadie, 2nd by Madalyn. Approved
unanimously.
3. Community Garden Update:
John stated the East Rec Garden is registering gardeners and scheduled to be open for use on April 1st. The
preliminary plan for the West side gardens is to split them between West Lake Park and Madison Park in
raised planters to trial the idea. There is still a plan to have a public meeting to discuss the West gardens.
4. Air Monitoring Information:
Dan attended an EPA webinar session on community multi-scale air monitoring stations. Their system is a
model based on data collected at monitoring site, and is rather complex. Parameters evaluated are ozone,
acidification, and pollution among others. A fun fact is that lightning is a large source of NOx. Trees and
plants produce isoprene and terpenes that can impact air quality negatively. The model is applicable to
almost any area. Industrial emissions and accidents are a major source of some air pollutants. Sadie has
looked into industrial releases, and some are serious in the Winona area, and would like to see the public
notified when this occurs. Dan said sometimes the community can observe a release before the company
even knows. Sadie has a number of other resources on air quality.
Sadie wondered about community sampling, and if that was part of the session? Dan did not recall that
coming up. Dan got the impression that it is more a general forecast rather than understanding the direct
conditions at a local point.
Dan said the webinar recording is online if others wanted to watch it, and see if it would be applicable to
Winona. He found it to be a worthwhile presentation.
5. Other Business: The City will be participating in an EV Smart program about electric vehicles. The CEQC is
welcome to attend in interested. Sadie asked about the focus of the trainings. John said the specifics need to
be determined, but generally it is about how a City can be involved in electric vehicles.
Dan asked how the City is doing with EV fleet vehicles? John stated that many City vehicles appear suitable
to be replaced with EVs, but none have been. Sadie asked how the City evaluated EV suitability. John
explained that using data trackers in the data port, they got data on 20 vehicles. Generally total miles
traveled was low, so well within the EV range. However, police cars are probably not a good fit since they
are always in use, so lack the downtime to recharge. Sadie wondered if the Police Dept. would use hybrids?
John said hybrids can be a 30% increase in miles per gallon.
6. Watershed Game: The members and staff participated in a watershed game practice round with Sadie
facilitating for the duration of the meeting.
7. Adjournment: Motion to adjourn by Dan, accepted by acclamation. Adjourned at 5:38.
Notes prepared by John Howard.
CITIZENS ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM: 4. Boulevard and Park Tree Data
PREPARED BY: John Howard
DATE: April 6, 2023
The Community Forestry Corps member, Abby W, will be presenting a summary of the urban
tree canopy and ecological value of City trees.
.
CITIZENS ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM: 5. Earth and Arbor Day Events
PREPARED BY: John Howard
DATE: April 6, 2023
On April 15th, there will be an environmental board game session hosted by local Climate
Action Corps AmeriCorps members at Jimmy Jam’s beginning at 5 pm. This will include the
watershed game.
The City will be hosting a booth at an Earth Day event sponsored by the Winona Arts Center
and Bluff Country Co-op on April 22nd. Any and all are welcome to attend. A flyer of the event
is attached.
Abby with Community Forestry Corps is planning a tree give away on Arbor Day, Friday April
28th.
.
EarthDay
Loremips u
m dolors itame t,
consect
eturadi
pis
cin
ge l
it
,se
ddoe iu
smodtempori
nci
di
dun
tutla
bor
eet
dol
orema gnaali
qu a.Qu si
i psumsuspendis
seulr
ti
cesgrav
ida
.Ri
suscommodoviv
err
amaece
nas
acc
He al
thyL akeWi non a
LSP(2t a
b l
esn exttoe achothe r
)
Winon aOu tdoorCol laborat
ive;
wilmos
l tl
ike
lyhaveanacti
vi
ty
Cel
ebrat
ion
Pra
iri
eMoonNu rs ery
Cit
iz
e n
sCl i
ma teL obby
ROAR
Greensted;the
ywi llhaveami crogreen
splanti
ngacti
vi
ty
Cit
yof Wi nona
Fri
endsofP arks&Re cr
e at
i
on
WS
S
Ut
WCF
re
es e
Apr
edl
l22 11AM -2PM
i
i
ng sgiv
ea waya ndeducati
onalmater
ia
l
WiseWa ter
’sBotan i
cal
s&S undry
umsanlacu J
a
svyee
c
elsPa
’
a
fc v
l
ii
l
l
i
s kePa
on,La
i
i
s. rk
Win onaOu t
doorCol l
aborat
i
ve
Ci
tizen’sCli
ma teL obby
Pr
airieMoonNu rsery
HealthyL a
keWi nona
Dri
ftlessKett
leCor n
TheGr eens
ted
J
aj
jaWe ll
ness
ROAR
SWCF
I
nfuzn
LSP
Ci
tyof Wi nona
HabitatArtS how
WACAr tProject
Bl
uffCou ntryCo- op
WS UT reeGi veawa y
Fr
iendsofP arks&Re creat
i
on
WiseWa ter’
sBota ni
cal
s&S undr
y
Ar
tpr
oje
cts
,Se
edpl
ant
i
ng,
Kit
efly
ing
,Foodt
ruc
ks,
Ven
dorBoot
hs
Atnoon,t
h eL
it
tleWarr
ior
sDrumli
newill
lea
dtheProce
ssi
onof
th
eS pe
ciesPa
rade.Chi
ldr
en12andundercanbri
ngacost
ume,puppe
t,
orama s
kofthei
rfav
ori
teani
malorpl
antspe
cie
stojoi
ninthepa
rade.
L
iveMu
sica
t1PM wi
t
hJa
ckRa
msl
and!
Pl
eas
ejoi
nusf
oragr
eatcel
ebr
ati
onofourEar
th.
Th
ise
ven
tisma
depos
si
bl
eth
rou
ghf
undi
ngf
r i
omWNBFna
nci
al
.Wet
hakt
n h
emf
ort
hei
rsu
ppor
t.
Get email alerts for Winona
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.