Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Regular MeetingMarco Island, FL · January 16, 2018
Minutes
City of Marco Island Florida
51 Bald Eagle Drive
Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Meeting Minutes - Final
Tuesday, January 16, 2018
3:00 PM
Community Room
Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Chair: Carlos Portu
Vice-Chair: Michael Levine
Members: Meg Bonos, Rich Lutz, Jerra Minning, Allyson Richards, Ron Rutledge
City Staff: Dan Smith, Lola Dial, Samantha Malloy, Patty Mastronardi
Martha Montgomery
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final January 16, 2018
Committee
(1) ROLL CALL
Present: 6- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Bonos, Member Rutledge, Member
Richards and Member Minning
Absent: 1- Member Lutz
(2) APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION by Chair Portu, seconded by Vice-Chair Levine, that this amended to
move item 5.a.1. after item 3. to be approved. MOTION CARRIED BY THE
FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 6- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Bonos, Member Rutledge, Member
Richards and Member Minning
Not Present: 1- Member Lutz
(3) APPROVAL OF MINUTES
MOTION by Vice-Chair Levine, seconded by Member Rutledge, that this be
approved. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 6- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Bonos, Member Rutledge, Member
Richards and Member Minning
Not Present: 1- Member Lutz
ID 18-020 Draft of PRAC Minutes December 19, 2017
Attachments: Draft of PRAC Minutes Dec.19.2017
a. 2009 Veterans' Community Park Master Plan Discussion
MOTION by Chair Portu, seconded by Vice-Chair Levine, to
recommend to City Council Kimley-Horn's Scope of Services
(dated Jan. 12th). MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 6- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Bonos, Member Rutledge,
Member Richards and Member Minning
Not Present: 1- Member Lutz
1. Kimley-Horn Scope of Services
James Pankonin - PRAC received revised draft of Scope of Services from last meeting -
sent out originally December 14, 2017.
Overview of general Scope of Services:
Changes addressed:
1. Eliminated data collection, previous planning document.
2. Need complete survey of entire site prior to construction in order to plan. Incur cost
later.
3. Provide levels of design images for community
4. Workshops: Staff, CM, PRAC, Parks & Rec -
b. changed to three (in one day) workshop meetings for input for park development
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final January 16, 2018
Committee
c. Provide same materials to PRAC
d. Handle with conference call instead of in person
e. Summary for process
Phase II Task - Master Development
Community wants to see:
5. Two (2) Master Plan Concepts showing ideas on paper for PRAC decision, updating
image boards, meeting with City with preferred alternate
6. Refine Draft Master Plan, Summary for review to City Council for draft Master Plan
7. Preparation of final Master Plan
Member Rutledge: Time frame for each Phase: page 11 - March 2018 start date 4-6
months usually ending July 2018.
Chair Portu stated budget proposal request is May 2018, Phase I, break ground 2019-
reduced cost by 25%.
(4) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
Had joint tree workshop with Beautification Advisory Committe regarding replacing trees in parks. Member
Richards will forward list of trees for PRAC to review.
a. Recreation Programs Discussion - Lola Dial
Ms. Malloy reported programs:
Winter Concert Series - every Sunday 2:00 p.m. - 4:00 p.m.
Tommie Barfield Elementary School celebrating Dr. Seuss week sponsored by Mackle
Park showing movie on Jan 26th
Souper Bowl - Saturday, February 3rd, 11:00 -1:00 pm
Parents Night Out - Feb. 9th, 6:00 p.m.-10:00 p.m.
b. Facilities Discussion - Martha Montgomery
Mackle Park:
Fields busy with soccer, lights on walking path repaired
Winterberry Park
Optimist - soccer
MI Academy - soccer
Men's softball - 5 days a week
Veterans' Community Park:
Lights rearranged
Racquet Center:
Under construction due to Irma, courts need new fencing, need to fill P/T position
Tommie Barfield Elementary School:
Insurance adjustor for City to replace facility fence, waiting for baseball field quote to redo
field
Use of fields - MI Academy pays by using volunteer hours, each hr. is $5.00 (limited
volunteer hrs. available)
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final January 16, 2018
Committee
Optimist - pays funds, Key Club - age restrictions
Member Levine: Add structure or fencing at Veterans' Community Park to prevent
accident at fountain.
Mr. Pankonin - no need for fencing around fountain.
Member Richards stated small dog park needs to fill in holes in ground. Ms. Montgomery
stated insurance adjustor and contractor, can set fence lower. Maintenance can add
something on bottom to prevent future issues of dogs getting through to other side.
Another answer next month.
c. Community Events - Samantha Malloy
Concert last Saturday turned out very well. Ended 8:30 p.m. (instead of 9:00 p.m. due to
cold weather)
Next possible concert date is April 28th. Farmers Market is full swing with 79 vendors.
ooking for one more vendors.
(5) OLD BUSINESS
b. Youth Council Update
Committee agreed not a good response, but to take three (3) kids applications received
to go forward.
(6) NEW BUSINESS
Meeting with BAC regarding replacement trees at Vets Park and parks. Member Richards took notes on
meeting will send to PRAC via Ms. Mastronardi. Types of trees were recommended by Affordable
Landscaping.
Citizens can take sampling tree donations. Can receive two trees every year (Miami project). Need costs
for losing other parks needing trees . Can have tree giveaway program. Adopt a tree, edible fruit tree.
Chair Portu: Can add tree in ROW, parks and residents homes. Can do many things,
Member Bonos will check on project for tree samplings, keep on agenda for next month. Give ideas and
move forward.
Chair Portu: Replace trees that were lost.
Al Benarroch, Affordable Landscaping - try to bring native trees to island to withstand salty air and winds.
He can help children with placing samplings, will take 5 years. Start at TBE with kids, find spot, fertilize,
grow, then place
Chair Portu: Can have an Adopt a Tree program community project- start at Mackle Park. Mold into a
plan to take back to BAC
a. Recommended Improvements for TBE - Meg Bonos
Ms. Bonos: Action Plan "Field of Dreams" belongs to Collier County Public School
District (school decision, not City) We maintain field only for usage.
Ms. Malloy: County is allowing us to use field. All equipment needs to be removed after
games.
City of Marco Island Florida Page 3
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final January 16, 2018
Committee
Need recommendation from baseball community and other members to build field as
baseball oriented. Met with Little League, Athletic Director, baseball players in
community with an overwhelming response of interest.
Recommendations:
Phase I: Field Repair (to make playable, fencing, landscaping, suspension nets)
Phase II: Requests or Field Improvements after 2018
Phase III: Additional to field to create unique MI community baseball field
Equipment Needs
Ms. Malloy stated field improvements need to be presented to TBE for approval prior to
work done. Repairing fencing, removing weeds, raking and mowing field by Feb. 22nd.
Itemize list, form committee to discuss costs by phase. Get fund raising residents.
Re-activate Island Parks & Recreation Foundation to start raising money.
Chair Portu: Make a better baseball plan, approach in different ways, need better
agreement with school, go with organized approach. Headed in right direction to make a
better facility. Get ready for baseball, have discussions a long term viable asset to City.
Member Bonos: Next step - put together committee to get right people starting with
Phase I to execute, then continue to Phase II.
Chair Portu - get field back to playable ready state for baseball, if need stuff to kick-off
baseball, come back and get some items done. Next step: Get committee names,
ultimate vision, formulate plan, take to County and school for approval, then get funds.
Reach out to Greg West for bi-laws.
Ms. Malloy - budget issue for new clay (no budget in past two years) cost is $1,200. to
level clay. Will look at previous years cost for clay, will email committee with cost for
small items.
b. Donations for Veterans' Community Park Trees
No discussion.
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT
Five people in audience.
(8) ADJOURN
Meeting was adjourned at 4:30 p.m.
NOTE: TWO OR MORE CITY COUNCILORS OR OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT
City of Marco Island Florida Page 4
Agenda
51 Bald Eagle Drive
City of Marco Island Florida Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Summary Agenda - Final
Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Chair: Carlos Portu
Vice-Chair: Michael Levine
Members: Meg Bonos, Rich Lutz, Jerra Minning, Allyson
Richards, Ron Rutledge
City Staff: Lola Dial, Samantha Malloy, Patty Mastronardi, Martha
Montgomery
Tuesday, January 16, 2018 3:00 PM Community Room
(1) ROLL CALL
(2) APPROVAL OF AGENDA
(3) APPROVAL OF MINUTES
ID 18-020 Draft of PRAC Minutes December 19, 2017
Attachments: Draft of PRAC Minutes Dec.19.2017
(4) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
a. Recreation Programs Discussion - Lola Dial
b. Facilities Discussion - Martha Montgomery
c. Community Events - Samantha Malloy
(5) OLD BUSINESS
a. 2009 Veterans' Community Park Master Plan Discussion
1. Kimley-Horn Scope of Services
b. Youth Council Update
(6) NEW BUSINESS
a. Recommended Improvements for TBE - Meg Bonos
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1 Printed on 1/9/2018
Parks and Recreation Advisory Summary Agenda - Final January 16, 2018
Committee
b. Donations for Veterans' Community Park Trees
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT
(8) ADJOURN
NOTE: TWO OR MORE CITY COUNCILORS OR OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2 Printed on 1/9/2018
Get email alerts for Marco Island
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.