Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Regular MeetingMarco Island, FL · May 15, 2018
Minutes
51 Bald Eagle Drive
City of Marco Island Florida Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Meeting Minutes - Final
Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Chair: Carlos Portu
Vice-Chair: Michael Levine
Members: Meg Bonos, Rich Lutz, Jerra Minning, Allyson
Richards, Ron Rutledge
City Staff: Dan Smith, Samantha Malloy, Patty Mastronardi
Tuesday, May 15, 2018 3:00 PM Community Room
(1) CALL TO ORDER
Chair Portu called meeting to order at 3:00p.m.
(2) ROLL CALL
Present: 5- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Lutz, Member Rutledge and Member
Richards
Absent: 2- Member Bonos and Member Minning
(3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Led by Chair Portu.
(4) APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
All members agreed to approve agenda.
(5) APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
MOTION by Vice Chair Levine, seconded by Member Richards that these minutes
be approved. MOTION CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE:
Yes: 5- Chair Portu, Vice-Chair Levine, Member Lutz, Member Rutledge and Member
Richards
Not Present: 2- Member Bonos and Member Minning
ID 18-264 PRAC draft minutes for April 17, 2018
(6) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
a. Cancel June/July meetings
The next PRAC meeting will resume on August 21, 2018.
Ms. Malloy reported on the following:
Facilities:
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final May 15, 2018
Committee
Veterans' Community Park:
Ms. Malloy stated information getting out to residents through Kimley-Horn's meetings
until November 2018, they are creating graphs to help calculate public feedback. Our
park is receiving calls, emails and questionnaires daily helping communication to public.
Received input from VFW and American Legion.
Winterberry Park:
Closed for light repair. Contractor took down fencing near dugouts, backlog is taking
time. Looking for other solutions to replace fencing. Need protection from foul balls.
Little League area can be used getting 3 estimates (underground work). Night games are
challenging. Estimated time for repairs are on priority list, working diligently for solutions.
Contact Parks & Recreation to reserve use of field. Received estimate to install, and set
up scoreboard.
Vice Chair Levine - broadcast PRAC meetings on Facebook, Chamber of Commerce,
Twitter, and in newspapers.
Calusa Park:
Pathway has started. Vice Chair Levine checking with Director Pinter on options for
parking, and crosswalk from Library to Mackle Park (across Heathwood Drive).
Tommie Barfield Elementary:
Irrigation has been repaired, improving dry grass, will take some time due to years without
being maintained.
Leigh Plummer:
Watered with potable water per Al Benarroch, Affordable Landscaping three times per
week.
Mackle Park:
Camp Mackle registration (camp starts June 1st) started and will continue all summer for
1st - 5th grades, Camp Stellar 6th - 8th grade. Received many interested calls, proposing
approximately 80- 100 children daily.
Sailing Program:
Received lease for 5 years, need approval for dock repair due to hurricane damage
starting in 2 weeks in June (for 2 weeks). Possibly starting program in July 2018 after
construction is completed. Ms. Malloy stated an Open House for the program is yearly.
Received interest in Paddle Boarding program.
Member Richards will contact YMCA regarding discounted swimming lessons for Camp
Mackle.
Racquet Center:
Committee - 3 members pickleball and 3 members tennis, first meeting May 18th at 2:00
p.m. with staff.
Chair Portu reviewed courts with Ms. Malloy, his suggestion to resurface Court #1 (in
budget). Will add capacity for pickleball or tennis - solution to try to redo court #1 for
lessons, make court multi-purpose to use for tennis/pickleball. Take Court #2 make it
permanently pickleball court resulting in total of 9 pickleball courts. All clay courts will
be in tact as easy fix which will allow more pickleball players availability.
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT (TIME CERTAIN 4:00 P.M.)
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final May 15, 2018
Committee
Racquet Center input was at 3:33 p.m.:
David Shaggett - Collier County uses same vendor for fencing, could be another option. Parking is
concern, concept on pickleballer spending all day, is false. It is usually 60-90 minutes up to 2 hrs. There
is no cap on number of members allowed at facility. Court #8 - tennis not using anything, not trying to
take tennis courts away. If increase dues substantially, some players will not play, if only for 3 months,
look into a 3 month membership only for those playing pickleball many years. Relative dues - 9 courts for
pickleball - only occupying 27% of courts. Pickleball dues not cost same as tennis due to less
maintenance. Court #1 and Court #2 for pickleball with be ecstatic. Communication with staff, very
pleasant, thanked them for time.
PUBLIC COMMENT AT 4:02 PM: (TIME CERTAIN)
Dawn Kuhn, 505 Tigertail Court - surprised about survey and response. Not everyone on Facebook/Twitter.
Next discussion will be at next PRAC meeting in August 2018, other feedback will be up until November
2018.
Diane Shaggett - survey to taxpayer via postcard, direct mail to listed taxpayers on water bil. Make
available at Mackle Park or Library.
(8) PRESENTATIONS
None.
(9) OLD BUSINESS
a. FY19 Budget Update
Chair Portu inquired if members had modifications regarding the draft proposed FY19
budget memo as forwarded to PRAC.
Vice Chair Levine - donation of $1,000 for new bench at Mackle Park. Leigh Plummer
Park needs tree shade.
Chair Portu stated if budget approved for replacement of 50 trees, PRAC can schedule
workshop to find proper locations. Jane Hittler Park needs garbage cans. Ms. Malloy will
check into empty cans. Also, can use artwork under bridge, church property. Al
Benarroch stated there are no garbage cans at Jane Hittler Park due to vandalism.
Shoe cleaner at Racquet Center has been ordered.
b. Veterans' Community Park Update
Ms. Malloy stated some of the questionnaire feedback findings are:
Band shell, restrooms - open 24 hrs., nice walkway, and shading.
Questions on how park is being used, veterans do not want band shell, keep park calm,
not crowded.
Getting alot of feedback, more response from residents.
MICA's survey (few years ago) was 80% in favor of band shell. Kimley-Horn will create
report regarding percentages in favor of amenities. MICA sending survey to Parks &
Recreation, then sending to Kimley-Horn.
Chair Grifoni stated 6,400 residents voted for City Council. Use ad in newspapers,
Facebook, Twitter, and Chamber of Commerce, reached out to 3,000 residents.
City of Marco Island Florida Page 3
Parks and Recreation Advisory Meeting Minutes - Final May 15, 2018
Committee
.
c. MI Food Forest (vegetables/spices garden)
Member Richards - presented topics (emailed to PRAC):
Purpose
Definition
Samples of How Forest is Created
Objectives
FGCU Food Forest Plants
Landscape Architect
Chair Portu stated $5,000 in FY18 budget to help with project. Ms. Malloy will contact
City's Purchasing Manager to find out procedure for PRAC to move forward on project.
Member Richards will contact FGCU (and get estimate) on how to research project for
students and community.
(10) NEW BUSINESS
None.
(11) COMMITTEE COMMUNICATIONS
None.
(12) ADJOURNMENT
Meeting adjourned 4:17 p.m.
NOTE: TWO OR MORE CITY COUNCILORS OR OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT
City of Marco Island Florida Page 4
Agenda
51 Bald Eagle Drive
City of Marco Island Florida Marco Island, Florida
cityofmarcoisland.com
Summary Agenda - Final
Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee
Chair: Carlos Portu
Vice-Chair: Michael Levine
Members: Meg Bonos, Rich Lutz, Jerra Minning, Allyson
Richards, Ron Rutledge
City Staff: Dan Smith, Samantha Malloy, Patty Mastronardi
Tuesday, May 15, 2018 3:00 PM Community Room
(1) CALL TO ORDER
(2) ROLL CALL
(3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
(4) APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA
(5) APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
ID 18-264 PRAC draft minutes for April 17, 2018
Attachments: PRAC Draft Minutes for April 17.2018.pdf
(6) STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
a. Cancel June/July meetings
(7) PUBLIC COMMENT (TIME CERTAIN 4:00 P.M.)
(8) PRESENTATIONS
(9) OLD BUSINESS
a. FY19 Budget Update
b. Veterans' Community Park Update
c. MI Food Forest (vegetables/spices garden)
City of Marco Island Florida Page 1 Printed on 5/10/2018
Parks and Recreation Advisory Summary Agenda - Final May 15, 2018
Committee
(10) NEW BUSINESS
(11) COMMITTEE COMMUNICATIONS
(12) ADJOURNMENT
NOTE: TWO OR MORE CITY COUNCILORS OR OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT
City of Marco Island Florida Page 2 Printed on 5/10/2018
Get email alerts for Marco Island
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.